9 ms·
> It's a statement about each party's (dis)satisfaction with the current success of their party. This requires clarification. If our government was elected bas
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
> It's a statement about each party's (dis)satisfaction with the current success of their party.
This requires clarification. If our government was elected based on a "one person one vote" principle, Republicans would be nearly guaranteed to lose the presidency and Congress. Since 1992 there have been 8 presidential elections. Republicans only won the popular vote once (2004) but also won the presidency in 2000 and 2016. Similarly, if you look at Congress, especially the Senate, Republicans have outsized power due to the additional votes that those in less populated/rural areas get.
The fact is that our Constitution reduces voting rights for those that live in populous urban areas and gives outsized voting rights to those that live in rural/sparsely populated areas. California has nearly 70 times the number of people as Wyoming, but they both get 2 senators. Even looking at the Electoral College, California only has 18 times as many electors as Wyoming, despite having 70x the people.
This rationale/compromise may have made sense in the late 1800s, but it's difficult for me to see how this is a good thing now. I wonder how many presidential elections we can go where the "winner" receives fewer votes than the "loser" before people seriously question what the purpose of our democracy is.
One other note, the equal-number-of-senators-per-state is the one thing that the Constitution explicitly forbids changing by amendment, the last clause of Article V.
- 627467 4y agoWhy is it odd that in a federalized country 1 person is not necessarily 1 vote? Look at the UN general assembly: votes of island nations with few thousand people are worth the same as another nation with 1B people.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoIf the UN could make decisions with the sorts of impact on ordinary people's lives that the US Senate can, I think we'd see the problems with the UN structure too. The UN, however, is primarily a venue for the airing of grievances, the distribution of aid, and occasionally the finding of common purpose. It's not much like the US Senate, which consistently blocks legislation supported by a majority of the population.
- amanaplanacanal 4y agoIf you ignore the security council, where a small number of powerful nations rule over everyone else.
- prottog 4y agoThe cap on the size of the House should be lifted, so that an approximately equal number of people are represented by each representative, no matter what state you live in. I don't see the problem in both California and Wyoming getting two senators, since that's (as you mention) precisely the point of the Senate. It's very deliberately built in to the American political system that the will of the half-plus-one majority does not dictate the direction of the whole country. If anything, the ever-increasing Federalization of laws and policies is the real problem: Californians living like Californians is fine, and Wyomingites living like Wyomingites is also fine, but there is a problem when one tries to make the other live more like them. Let's have fifty vibrant laboratories of democracy. > how many presidential elections we can go where the "winner" receives fewer votes than the "loser" before people seriously question what the purpose of our democracy is. I'm already questioning that myself, considering roughly half of all eligible voters don't even bother to show up for presidential elections -- let alone midterms, which is more like two thirds. If we consider that chunk that does not vote as being OK with the status quo, then I think we have a lot of room left before American democracy is really imperiled.
- colinmhayes 4y ago
- prottog 4y agoThat's glib. Do you know much about Mississippi? Do you live there, or have close friends who do? I live in a neighboring state and it's unthinkable that the people of this state would bring back slavery or segregation. In fact, a much bigger portion of the population here lives amidst people of other races -- break bread with them, celebrate each others' big life events -- compared to certain other states where an attitude like yours about Mississippi is common.
- jessaustin 4y agoWhen will Jackson have drinkable water?
- 4y ago
- johnthuss 4y agoClearly Republicans have benefited greatly from the electoral college lately. Whether that is good or bad depends on your political leaning. As a centrist I appreciate that the USA <> California. I don’t know that it is possible to judge this issue in an unbiased way.
- lupire 4y agoWhy do you appreciate that the US = the rural parts? That is the current alternative to "California". Ronald Reagan, patron saint of the right wing, was governor of California.
- _-david-_ 4y agoThe US does not equal the rural parts. Did the rural parts of America vote for Biden or support what he is doing? California from decades ago is hardly comparable to modern day California.
- UncleMeat 4y agoDirect election of the president would not make the USA = California. California would have about 13% of the impact on the presidential election, matching their percentage of the overall population.
- justin66 4y ago> Clearly Republicans have benefited greatly from the electoral college lately. Whether that is good or bad depends on your political leaning. It actually is possible to have an opinion about the electoral college that is grounded in principal, rather than how your favored political party is benefiting.
- tastyfreeze 4y agoSenators were meant to represent each state's government not the people directly. The Senate, by being once removed from the people, was supposed to take a longer more measured view on issues. The 17th Amendment[1] broke that and made senators elected by the people. The people have the House. The House has also been broken over time. In 1929 the House was capped at 435 members. Since then the number of people that a given representative represents has increased dramatically from 209,447 people in 1910 to 747,184 in 2018.[2] I agree that the Electoral College needs reform but I am sure that we will not agree on the solution. I think that each state, being an equal member in the union, should have an equal number of electoral votes. Equal votes per state reinforces the purpose of the republic. The republic is supposed to ensure that each state can live the way they want and have military protection. Having one state with more say in the executive is antithetical to a republic. The president is supposed to represent the union, not the people, on the international stage. Doing away with the Electoral College and going for a direct democracy is a recipe for disaster. Direct democracy does not work on a large scale. The answer to much of the contention we have today is to return to the limited government that was originally described in the Constitution. Power has become too concentrated in DC and now everybody is playing the game of thrones. [1] https://constitution.congress.gov/constitution/amendment-17/ https://constitution.congress.gov/constitution/amendment-17/ [2] https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2018/05/31/u-s-population-keeps-growing-but-house-of-representatives-is-same-size-as-in-taft-era/ https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2018/05/31/u-s-populat...
- colinmhayes 4y agoliterally no one is suggesting a direct democracy. The question is whether the constituents of this country are people or states, and I suppose the answer probably depends on whether you live in a populated or unpopulated state.
- tastyfreeze 4y agoThe Constitution is an agreement between the states, not individuals. When ratifying the Constitution the people of a state voted to join the union as the unit of a state not as individuals. That makes the states the constituents not the people.
- dahdum 4y ago> If our government was elected based on a "one person one vote" principle, Republicans would be nearly guaranteed to lose the presidency and Congress. True in the very short term, but that's only because neither party really targets the popular vote. Both would realign their platform and bases accordingly, and we'd just end up with a new system with new flaws. However, if you are correct, that would mean a de facto one-party state. That's downright frightening to me, even if I am a member of that party.
- midoridensha 4y agoYou wouldn't get a one-party state. The US did this before: back in the 1800s, there were 2 parties, the Whigs and the Democratic-Republicans. The Whigs imploded, so the other party broke in 2, yielding the two present-day parties. If the GOP were to collapse and die out (as it should), the Democratic Party would simply break in 2, creating two new parties: the left-wing/progressive party and the center-right party. The former would champion all kinds of social causes and the latter would be the pro-business party.
- jquery 4y ago>Both would realign their platform and bases accordingly Don’t threaten me with a good time.
- sokoloff 4y agoThe Constitution doesn't explicitly forbid changing the Senate composition by amendment. It does require consent from states whose representation would be reduced by such a change.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 4y ago> One other note, the equal-number-of-senators-per-state is the one thing that the Constitution explicitly forbids changing by amendment, the last clause of Article V. It doesn't forbid it, it just requires states losing equal representation to consent to the change. Of course, it also doesn’t limit, say, reducing the powers of the Senate, including transferring them entirely to either the House of Representatives or a new third house of Congress, leaving Senators as purely decorative fixtures.
- dllthomas 4y agoAnd you could maybe get away with changing it with two amendments, one that removed the restriction and another that changed the Senate.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y ago> It doesn't forbid it, it just requires states losing equal representation to consent to the change. Ok, fine, it forbids it in this Universe then.
- rayiner 4y ago> If our government was elected based on a "one person one vote" principle, Republicans would be nearly guaranteed to lose the presidency and Congress. Not at all. Republicans have won the Congressional popular vote more times than democrats since 1992, and are about to win it again. There has only been one election since 1992 where Republicans won more House seats while losing the Congressional popular vote. They’re 2% ahead in the generic Congressional ballot right now. You can’t blame that on gerrymandering or whatever. Republicans consistently lose the Presidential popular vote because their incentive is to run the most right-wing person who can win the vote that actually counts, the Electoral College vote. For Congress, republicans have to contest at least some seats in New York and California. But for the Presidency they don’t care if a single person in those states votes for them. If we used a nationwide popular vote, the GOP would just run someone closer to the median of their House delegation, which consistently does win the popular vote. To get an idea of what things might look like in a counter-factual world, look at this three-way poll in a Cheney/Trump/Biden matchup: https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/the-premise-poll-liz-cheney-receives-nearly-20-support-in-three-way-contest-with-biden-trump-301623817.html https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/the-premise-poll-li.... Biden would get 36%, Cheney 20%, and Trump 45%. Shifting to a popular vote would move the coalitions around a bit: Republicans would have to care a little more about holding onto Romney/Biden suburbs. But it doesn’t mean consistent democratic majorities.
- tptacek 4y agoIf we used a nationwide popular vote, the GOP would just run someone closer to the median of their House delegation, which consistently does win the popular vote. Sounds pretty great to me.
- zhoujianfu 4y agoYeah! As long as we have fptp elections there will be two parties each getting about 50% of the vote, because they will evolve to be competitive. The question is just should that 50% line be about the middle of all citizens, or should that “middle” be randomly skewed towards people who happen to live nearer to farms.
- edmcnulty101 4y agoThe framers of the constitution did not intend for presidential election by popular vote. The intention was for state legislatures to nominate electors who would then vote for president. It wasn't until mid 1800's that states started elections (of electors) by popular vote. Note: still through an elector proxy. Also this is not a government run by popular vote, it is a mixture of state and population based government and also representation democracy not direct democracy. In The Federalist Papers, James Madison explained his views on the selection of the president and the Constitution. In Federalist No. 39, Madison argued that the Constitution was designed to be a mixture of state-based and population-based government. Congress would have two houses: the state-based Senate and the population-based House of Representatives. Meanwhile, the president would be elected by a mixture of the two modes. The fact that people feel that states shouldn't have equal say and equal power is to me a huge breakdown of society. Having California run the entire country would be a nightmare.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoCalifornia could not win any popular vote about any matter whatsoever on its own. The only thing that wins popular votes is ... having a majority of voters voting for it. Doesn't sound so bad does it? At least until you start to introduce the petty tribalism of "I don't want those folks who ain't from round here telling us what we can and can't do". The real question is: there are obviously different "ideal sized bodies" for a popular vote controlled democracy, depending on the issue at hand. It probably is right that "folks from round here" get to decide a bunch of issues, without having to convince the whole country. And there are issues where you really should only be able to move forward with a popular vote across the whole country. So the question is: what's the right scale/scope of the voting entities for different kinds of issues? I don't know the right answer, but I'm fairly sure that the states we have right now are not the correct choice for a lot of issues.
- edmcnulty101 4y agoDirect democracy is two wolves and a sheep voting on what's for dinner. tyranny of the masses is equally as bad as tyranny of the one especially considering how tribalistic people are. That's why the framers of the Constitution decided against what you're proposing. as to the right size question. there is no right size. it's totally arbitrary. States are what we have and that's fine.
- rg2004 4y ago> If our government was elected based on a "one person one vote" principle, Republicans would be nearly guaranteed to lose the presidency and Congress. They are playing a game to win the electoral college, expect if it were popular vote they would play a different game with different policies
- ninkendo 4y ago> expect if it were popular vote they would play a different game with different policies Right, and that different game would look nothing like the current Republican Party, hence why it’s a totally fair statement to say that the Republican Party as we know it today would never stay in power in such a system. They’d have to change, and that change would probably make them look a lot more like Democrats. Put differently, the current politics and policies of the Republican Party only yield electable candidates in a country that gives outsized power to rural voters.
- WalterBright 4y agoThe answer is, it is a Republic, not a Democracy. It's set up to make it difficult for the majority to trample on the rights of the minority. More colorfully, having two wolves and a sheep vote on what's for dinner. It's still a good thing.
- scarface74 4y ago> It's set up to make it difficult for the majority to trample on the rights of the minority Two words: Jim Crow
- lupire 4y agoIn context, he meant the rights of the minority that was 18th Century slave owners.
- scarface74 4y agoSaying slave owners rights were being protected is not exactly a rousing endorsement about the constitution protecting the rights of the minority.
- UncleMeat 4y agoYeah. The idea that our system somehow successfully prevents a majority from outright extreme oppression of a minority is laughable given our history. This is just a talking point made with nearly zero intellectual honesty to continue to support a system that benefits one political faction. When they say "trample on the rights of the minority" they mean "enact legislation unpopular among conservatives."
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoPeople keep saying this (the republic vs direct democracy part), and it literally doesn't make any sense, to the point that I have difficulty believing people aren't being deliberately obtuse. Having people directly elect their representatives is still very much a republic and in no definition I've ever seen considered direct democracy. We're talking about people electing their representatives, not their laws.
- Georgelemental 4y ago> the equal-number-of-senators-per-state is the one thing that the Constitution explicitly forbids changing by amendment, the last clause of Article V. Nit: "no State, without its Consent, shall be deprived of its equal Suffrage in the Senate."
- lp0_on_fire 4y agoI'm curious what scenarios were discussed in Philadelphia that they thought a state would willingly give up equal suffrage in the Senate?
- parineum 4y agoSenator dies in office and the State chooses to withhold appointing a replacement because there is an impending election.
- selimthegrim 4y agoDoes this impact the part of 14th amendment that reduces representation for noncompliance after readmission?
- johnnyanmac 4y ago>The fact is that our Constitution reduces voting rights for those that live in populous urban areas and gives outsized voting rights to those that live in rural/sparsely populated area yup, that was by intention. That's also exactly why the senate was erected; they didn't want smaller states to be ignored by campaigns that could ultimately just focus on enough electoral votes to win the election. >This rationale/compromise may have made sense in the late 1800s, but it's difficult for me to see how this is a good thing now. I wonder how many presidential elections we can go where the "winner" receives fewer votes than the "loser" before people seriously question what the purpose of our democracy is. I'm not sure. the exact same gaming would work today if we aboloished the Electoral College tomorrow. The same gaming could happen today; you focus on CA, NY, TX, and FL and you have a large chunk of the population talked to in one swoop. But that leaves 40+ states de-prioritized. figuring out how to solve that without putting the fate of the country in Ohio's hands is a delicate balance to seek. I'd personal prefer for spillover voting to help ease off the polarization of it all, but that would be an even more uphill battle. Obviously both parties would not want to lose any potential power.
- lupire 4y agoNo, it was because the slave states didn't want to lose slavery in a Senate vote. If you think CA is too populous for it's people deserve an equal vote, CA should be 6 states. But the slavers fought that too (Missouri Compromise). State boundaries are legal constructs inherited from obsolete aristocracy, not meaningful cultural boundaries. It makes no sense to solve a hypothetical tyranny of large states by replacing it with an actual tyranny of small states. The Constitution is We the People, not the We the States.
- jquery 4y agoWell said. Thank you. As a disenfranchised Californian I will bang this gavel until I die. The loss of the SALT deduction hit our finances tremendously. 1. Direct impact via higher taxes. 2. People fleeing the state for lower tax states because without the SALT deduction, we have a race to the bottom infrastructure-wise (not that we didn’t already, but the SALT deduction dampened the effect somewhat). This is the kind of BS law that can only pass when small states get to run roughshod over large ones.
- anon291 4y agoIt's a great thing because where you live matters. I have no idea what's going on in the wilds of Wyoming. Wyomingites do. If Californians were represented by population, these lands would be managed by people who do not live there. That is terrible. IMO, the main thing wrong with us federalism is that the western states ought to be broken up
- HWR_14 4y ago> I have no idea what's going on in the wilds of Wyoming. Wyomingites do. If Californians were represented by population, these lands would be managed by people who do not live there. Given how few people live year-round in Wyoming, but how many Californians own vacation ranches there, that actually might make sense.
- anon291 4y agoPeople living in a place should have the sole right to determine what happens to that place. Vacation homes don't give you a right to vote, and they shouldn't. This is nuts.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoThis is a nonsensical idea, at least as stated. The people who live within 500' of you do not have exclusive control over what happens in that 500' radius circle. Control is ceded to entities like your town, or county, or state, or federal government, in no particular way. The federal government controls, for example, what happens in the air above where you live; your state probably controls the building code for where you live; your town likely controls where you can take a dog for a walk or the intensity of outdoor lighting. There's no smooth gradient of control dropping off as you get further from where you live. It's messy and it's complicated. In addition, your stated view of who should have control also acts as a major barrier to people who do not live in a place from ever doing so. I suspect you may have no problem with that, but it's not technically "the American way" (aspirationally, anyway).
- 4y ago
- pyuser583 4y ago> If our government was elected based on a "one person one vote" principle, Republicans would be nearly guaranteed to lose the presidency and Congress. The Republicans are competing under the rules that exist - and they’re very, very good at it. Do you think they would blindly wander from defeat to defeat without seriously changing tactics?
- friend_and_foe 4y agoA note on the electoral college: the size of it is determined by the number of senators and number of representatives per state. The house of representatives can easily change it's size and reapportion seats more fairly, and therefore reapportion electoral college votes more in line with the population. States like California could easily outweigh states like Wyoming in such an endeavor and make it happen, but still they don't. Why? They should want to increase the power of their state in the house, no? Perhaps it has something to do with their power as an individual representative in the house, but whatever the reason, it isn't a problem strictly caused by the constitution, it is a problem that congress refuses to solve that they could very easily.
- naasking 4y ago> This requires clarification. If our government was elected based on a "one person one vote" principle, Republicans would be nearly guaranteed to lose the presidency and Congress. That's a meaningless observation. If the rules were different such that the popular vote mattered more, then Republicans would play a different game. Roughly the same equilibrium would be achieved in the end.