8 ms·
5.1 Magnitude Earthquake Near San Jose, CA
- jmathai 4y agoI grabbed my phone a few seconds after feeling the quake and Googled "earthquake in california today". I'm amazed that the earthquake showed up as the top result with an exact coordinate and magnitude.
- tsunamifury 4y agoThose with pixel phones got notifications 10 seconds before the earthquake wave hit them.
- floydian10 4y agoObligatory XKCD: https://xkcd.com/723/ https://xkcd.com/723/
- elihu 4y agoAlso relevant: https://xkcd.com/937/ https://xkcd.com/937/ (In this case it seems like the app worked.)
- baggy_trough 4y agoThat would depend on where they were.
- jedberg 4y agoI'm guessing you're in SF or Oakland?
- mentat 4y agoSeemed even a bit longer before that on the peninsula coastside. The whole thing felt magical, to even know that much beforehand.
- rbolla 4y agoIs it true?
- Fatnino 4y agoYes indeed. Earthquakes move through the ground at the speed of sound. Once earthquake detectors on the ground near the epicenter detect it they send the information out at the speed of light, so even factoring in a little bit of delay for calculations, advance warning on the order of several seconds is possible depending on how far away the recipient is.
- tjohns 4y agoDepends on where in the Bay Area you were: https://earthquake.usgs.gov/earthquakes/eventpage/nc73799091/shake-alert https://earthquake.usgs.gov/earthquakes/eventpage/nc73799091... Santa Clara had 2 seconds of advance warning, and Sunnyvale had 4 seconds. San Francisco got 18 seconds of warning, though was outside the "ground motion" zone.
- rconti 4y agomyshake pinged my apple watch while i was recording a cat. Cat definitely did not detect it before myshake, I don't think he even noticed it until the actual shaking.
- eins1234 4y agoMy Samsung got the notification from Google too, so probably not a Pixel exclusive thing. Though I wish it would have overridden silent mode. 10s of advanced warning isn't all that helpful if I only find out about the notification 10 minutes later.
- modeless 4y agoYou just reminded me to go into my notification history and turn on "Override Do Not Disturb" for the earthquake early warning notification. I really like the notification history for that; you can go back to a notification you dismissed hours ago and edit its settings.
- eins1234 4y agoWas this under the "Crisis Alerts" category for Google? Going to set it for my phone too, even though this kind of thing really should be set to override do not disturb by default. Apparently my phone supports notification history, but it was also turned off by default... Bad defaults strikes twice in a row.
- anarazel 4y agoMy notification arrived minutes late, interestingly.
- sosodev 4y agoI believe can actually just type "earthquake" and it will show the same result!
- samstave 4y agoLoma Prieta in ~1989 was NUTS. I lived in lake tahoe at the time and was a freshman in HS and was at football practivce at 5:04 PM when it happened, and my dad was waiting in the car and it car shook so much he got out because he thought us kids were pranking him by jumping on his bumper.... This 5.1 is a good thing, as it has relieved geo-stress... (I hope!) but as a california native, I think of earthquakes like I do california poppies (which I just planted a bunch of) they are magnificent, just dont pick any... EDIT: The 1989 earthquake was also in october.... October 11 I think... but I wonder if the seasonal shift in temperatures affect earthquakes. As October is generally the best month in the bay area weather-wise...
- mc32 4y agoYou'd need like a hundred 5.1s to "relieve the geo-stress".
- macintux 4y agoI caught a much smaller one when I was young and had the exact same reaction your dad did, sitting in a parking lot with no one around. I had a better excuse than him: I was in central Indiana, and who ever heard of a quake there? (No, not looking forward to another New Madrid quake.)
- russellbeattie 4y agoThe stories of the New Madrid quakes are insane. The earth was literally rolling, fissures opened up spewing enough gases to block out the light and more. And the aftershocks went on for months. Hard to imagine.
- 0xB31B1B 4y ago5.x earthquakes are not “stress relievers”, that is a common fallacy.
- kirubakaran 4y agohttps://earthquake.usgs.gov/research/eqproc/grdmotion.php https://earthquake.usgs.gov/research/eqproc/grdmotion.php Especially: https://histre.com/highlights/kirubakaran/5b7c1756 https://histre.com/highlights/kirubakaran/5b7c1756
- baggy_trough 4y agoLoma Prieta was preceded by two 5.x foreshocks within a year.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Sakos 4y agoOne in June, one in August, then Loma Proeta in October. Is seasonal weather ever a relevant factor for quakes?
- baggy_trough 4y agoSeismologists believe not.
- jofer 4y agoPut simply, no. The details are messier because groundwater flow very much does affect earthquakes (poroelasticity), but by and large, seasons don't affect groundwater flow significantly at the depths involved. E.g. wet vs dry weather doesn't matter. But on the other hand, a lake filling up or draining can, especially in terms of triggering very small earthquakes.
- MPSimmons 4y agoNot at the scale of quakes like this. Frost quakes are a thing, but very localized: https://www.accuweather.com/en/winter-weather/what-is-a-frost-quake-and-where-do-they-occur/670762 https://www.accuweather.com/en/winter-weather/what-is-a-fros...
- guenthert 4y agoFirst time I noticed vertical, not just lateral movement. 5.1 isn't all that big, but this one was close to me. Good that the building is a wood structure, otherwise I'd be looking for damage now ...
- benlivengood 4y agoI got an Android alert before the waves arrived in the East Bay (Oakland-ish) which is neat from an SRE perspective.
- mayli 4y agoGot that too, but almost at the same time when I feed it.
- anontrot 4y agoStop feeding the Earth quake god damnit!
- baggsie 4y agoThat must be quite terrifying given the location - does the alert indicate the strength of the quake?
- outworlder 4y agoIt does not. Not even sure it's possible.
- jofer 4y agoIt's highly imprecise, but not impossible. The alerts are already "this is over some threshold of ground acceleration", so there's an inherent severity estimate in the alert going out at all. But expected intensity information isn't included because: 1) it's still a very imprecise estimate at that time, 2) actual intensity of ground motion (what you care about) will vary dramatically by location, and 3) people don't deal well with that kind of information in an alert that is really meant to be "hey, take cover".
- celdon25 4y agoWhen I was working in SF (Near Montgomery BART), there was an earthquake, but I was at the dentist at the time. The dentist was nearby on a hill near Union Square. The earthquake was not felt at all there, but it was apparently rather strong at the office down the hill.
- jedberg 4y agoIf you felt it please fill out the USGS report: https://earthquake.usgs.gov/earthquakes/eventpage/nc73799091/tellus https://earthquake.usgs.gov/earthquakes/eventpage/nc73799091... Even if you didn't feel but live in the Bay Area please fill it out, they need that data too!
- Justin_K 4y agoDo you know what the do with the data? Genuinely curious.
- samstave 4y agoThey likely analyze it
- namrog84 4y agoHaving more data points can help give more insights into the quakes propagation. I'm no expert but I'd imagine it's not perfectly circular an is influenced by a variety of factor that with more data points makes it easier to learn things about under ground and quakes.
- eddsh 4y agoDidn’t feel it in Palo Alto but my wife did in Stanford. I’ve yet to experience one!
- mdon 4y agofelt it mildly on California Ave, in Palo Alto.
- gnicholas 4y agoInteresting, we definitely felt it in Menlo Park. Perhaps being on the second floor made it more noticeable? What stood out to me was how long it was — it felt like we were moving for 15-20 seconds, though it could have been shorter.
- andirk 4y agoCity workers digging up the street today in front of my house in Berkeley. I thought they hit a pipe! Glad it was just a huge earthquake
- yumraj 4y agoYou felt it in Berkeley?
- kstrauser 4y agoI felt it in Alameda. It wasn't strong, but was very noticeable.
- jorts 4y agoWeird. I am also in Alameda and didn't feel it but my kitchen cabinet door was slightly tapping against the cabinet which caught my attention. This is on the east end.
- yumraj 4y agoThe quake was on Calaveras fault, near SE San Jose. So, I guess it traveled along the East Bay fault lines all the way to Alameda and Berkeley. I am just surprised it was felt so far for a 5.1
- josuepeq 4y agoGot the ShakeAlert notification; but felt no quake. Nothing noticeable at all in San Francisco/Twin Peaks. It’s all bedrock up here.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Teknoman117 4y agoI didn't really feel it in San Mateo, but the blinds were swinging in the office so it was definitely moving some stuff up here.
- delabay 4y agodidn't feel in san mateo either
- vincentriemer 4y agoWeird, I'm in Foster City and felt the strongest shaking I've ever felt in my time in the Bay Area.
- Kina 4y agoFoster City will amplify any shaking since the entire city was built on compacted fill and reclaimed earth.
- alanwreath 4y agoI came here only to question why this news even registers on HN news.
- karaterobot 4y agoHN works on a voting system, so that people can register what they feel is important, and if enough people do that then things show up on the front page. There's a bit more information available here: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoBecause it interests us.
- sophacles 4y agoAre you asking: "why does the site with 'news' in it's name report news?" Or are you asking: "how does this earthquake in the place where much tech is centered and a large number of HN users live pertain to HN?" The answer turns out to be the same: it's relevant to a lot of people here and they upvoted it.
- alanwreath 4y agoThese are all obvious answers. Still begs the question of what's the value of having these discussions here. There are plenty of discussions that are not permitted on HN (even if they would garner useful discussion). I only posit that this type of news also lends no value to this forum (SV locals don't or shouldn't depend on HN for local emergency news), and so should be removed/banned. Just my 2¢ - downvote away.
- temp_praneshp 4y agoIt enabled this comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33335391 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33335391 which, I would argue, adds a lot of value.
- 4y ago
- shriphani 4y agoMy garage door shook for a bit but I got none of these alerts. I'm on tTmobile, do I need to sign up somewhere ?
- redwood 4y agoI didn't feel it at SJC
- manofmanysmiles 4y agoI barely felt it in Berkeley, and thought I was imagining it.
- nonrandomstring 4y agoHow far are we from decent prediction? Many years ago ago I looked quite deeply at stick-slip friction models, the mathematics, dynamics and signals. I'd wager, in the time since 2005, there's a lot we could do with machine learning, predictive signal analysis and good historical data. Even 5 minutes warning could save a lot of lives. Any ML + geo-scientists on the case?
- daveaiello 4y agoA seismologist from Berkeley said on KCBS that the ShakeAlert system worked in the case of this earthquake. So many people in the area were warned. I heard this on Audacy from the Philadelphia area.
- daveaiello 4y agoInfo on how ShakeAlert works: https://twitter.com/USGS_ShakeAlert/status/1584983600378032128 https://twitter.com/USGS_ShakeAlert/status/15849836003780321...
- jofer 4y agoShakeAlert and similar systems are awesome, but not exactly what most folks mean by a prediction, FWIW. They're meant for warnings of seconds, but not for things on the scale of minutes or hours or days. Not to take away from ShakeAlert in any way though! Just clarifying that in terms of another comment I made about earthquake precursor signals. ShakeAlert and similar aren't about precursors, but instead are about "the earthquake has happened, let's tell folks before the damaging surface waves reach them".
- daok 4y agoSouth-East San Jose and I felt it. Received a notification on my Pixel phone as the house was shaking. Nothing broken, but for the 5-6 seconds it lasted I had the reflect to hold my monitors (on arms) because they were shaking.
- raggi 4y agoWas very disappointed that my iOS device had no alerting.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoAndroid is partnered with Shakealert but Apple has not. There are third-party apps that you can get for iPhone. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/ShakeAlert https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/ShakeAlert
- raggi 4y agoWhile I understand this in some sense, the efficacy of these systems going through the regular push message queue is going to be poor.
- tanseydavid 4y agoFelt the first one in Central Marin. Today is actually the 33 year anniversary of the Loma Prieta quake -- weird.
- ChrisCinelli 4y agohttps://www.britannica.com/event/San-Francisco-earthquake-of-1989 https://www.britannica.com/event/San-Francisco-earthquake-of... - It was Oct 17, 1989
- etrautmann 4y agoThat was one of my first memories and a totally wild experience as a young child in a hotel room on market st. I got to eat nothing but strawberry milk for about three days since since that was about all we could easily get, or so I remember.
- dumpHero2 4y agoSlightly off. That was on Oct 17, 1989.
- Exuma 4y ago
- smcin 4y agoIt was not in the least terrifying and actually a big yawn; no known damage or injuries; "near San Jose" is inaccurate, it was 14km east of San Jose up the (fairly sparsely-populated) foothills near Alum Rock, 6.9 km depth, 37.311°N 121.677°W, inside Joseph D. Grant Park, zipcode 95140, total population only a tiny 191. So, remote, not urban and nothing like all those San Andreas movies. We felt the floor ripple for a couple of seconds and that was all. All transit is still running, just at reduced speeds (standard practice just in case there's a big aftershock, which there almost never is). You want to worry about something that's actually broken, then worry about whether the US MNT will get it together to call up leading goalscorer Jordan Pefok by 13 Nov deadline for the World Cup. Now that's worth losing sleep over. Or worry about Cuba, Haiti, Puerto Rico reconstruction from Hurricane Ian; Cuba got it bad. USGS.gov has a page up near-instantaneously with the details including crowdsourced reports of perceived intensity by location, as they always do: https://earthquake.usgs.gov/earthquakes/eventpage/nc73799091/executive https://earthquake.usgs.gov/earthquakes/eventpage/nc73799091... PPS: in that area, Mt Hamilton (4265') and Lick Mill Observatory are worth a visit. And over west in Menlo Park visitors can visit the USGS station for free, that's a very fun and educational thing to do.
- mint2 4y agoThis comes off a bit as minimizing/dismissing concern of the next big one, and also seems to be expressing disappoint that this one wasn’t more exciting instead of being “a big yawn; no known damage or injuries.”
- smcin 4y agoNonsense, I live in Silicon Valley for 23 years now, this has nothing whatsoever to do with "the next big one", today's one was purely a 5.1 in a remote sparsely-populated area up the hills inside a county park with no reported damage or injuries, population only 191 and they hardly even have any two-storey buildings inside the entire park, not that those were reported damaged either. By the way, IIUC from geologists it's actually good and healthy to have frequent small earthquakes to blow off pressure and avoid becoming the "next big one", hence today's non-event is good news not bad news. I actually showed you multiple ways to instantly read the USGS data (coords, intensity, depth, population, total lack of buildings higher than two stories) to understand that this was a non-event not the "next big one", not even in the neighborhood. Technical literacy matters, sensationalism seriously doesn't. Today's non-event was actually a Good Thing in that it also gives us yet another occasion to calibrate earthquake early-warning sensors, to stay prepared for any actual serious earthquake, which this wasn't. I also said nothing whatsoever about "excitement" or "disappointed", so do not misrepresent me. I did imply that media is increasingly sensational (which it is) and lazily skewed towards merely collating cellphone "eyewitness reports" from places with 4G coverage, without making any semi-objective comparison to the rest of the planet; and I correctly pointed out that zero people were affected here in SJ today whereas 11 million Cubans were affected by Hurricane Ian [0], to pick one obvious example. I also know some friends-of-friends whose house was severely damaged by the 11/2020 Marikina, Manila floods/Typhoon Vamco/Ulysses [1] (98 deaths, 19 missing, 360K rescued, ~43000 houses damaged). Also, a magnitude 6.2-6.5 struck rural northern Luzon, Philippines earlier today [2], no reported damage or injuries [3], but noone's mentioning that. [0]: https://www.state.gov/u-s-support-for-hurricane-ian-recovery-efforts-in-cuba/ https://www.state.gov/u-s-support-for-hurricane-ian-recovery... [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Typhoon_Vamco#Philippines_2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Typhoon_Vamco#Philippines_2 [2]: https://earthquake.usgs.gov/earthquakes/eventpage/us6000iwds/executive https://earthquake.usgs.gov/earthquakes/eventpage/us6000iwds... [3]: https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1684866/magnitude-6-7-rocks-abra-felt-as-far-as-ncr https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1684866/magnitude-6-7-rocks-ab...
- not2b 4y agoMy home office in Campbell (just south of SJ) is on the second floor so I got more of a shake than my wife downstairs got, though her MyShake app gave her a few seconds warning. For those not in earthquake country, this was a moderate quake, not big enough to cause damage other than maybe knocking something over right near the center. The epicenter was in Joseph Grant Park to the east of San Jose, near Mount Hamilton.
- ipnon 4y agoIf you want early earthquake alerts, the Governor’s office sponsors UC Berkeley to make the MyShake app. This app could save your life! https://myshake.berkeley.edu/ https://myshake.berkeley.edu/
- yumraj 4y agotried installing it on iPhone and set the HomeBase - keeps on crashing.. :(
- hujun 4y agosimilar experience here, the UI design is confusing, tell you to select an area but apparently you can't select/drag on the map, you can only typing the address then many times the auto complete doesn't work, and it seems you have to use the incorrect auto completed address...
- brewdad 4y agoI was getting those errors too a few days ago when I tried. However, the app does show my correct location. It either actually went through despite the error or is getting location in some other way as a backup. Probably the latter since I think I did grant location privileges to the app.
- yodon 4y agoTheir servers are probably getting hammered. Try again tomorrow or in a few days.
- lucb1e 4y agoI didn't get any notification on my phone. How does it try to figure out whether you should get one? Do you need to turn on location services, have a cell tower connected, or is it detecting pre-waves (I really know nothing about earthquakes) using the accelerometer?
- s1artibartfast 4y agoDo you have iPhone or Android? If iPhone, you need to download an app
- lucb1e 4y agoI'm on Android but in Europe. Was just curious how it tries to determine this as I turned off automatic location uploading to google.
- raggi 4y agoThere are different systems. The more critical system in the USA, WEA is a mandatory (FCC rules) central system that most consumer devices and consumer networks take part in. The "last mile" technology varies by network type and version. The GSM lineage (including 4G, LTE, 5G) is implemented using cell broadcast which is a protocol data unit that solves for the one to many problem. Extensions added geo-fencing & geo-targeting on the client devices (device compares its idea of location to the incoming message), and also cell based routing optimizations network side. The cell broadcast part is technologically available ~everywhere as a result of broad GSM deployment, but whether it is integrated into an alert system is a jurisdiction issue. Sadly few countries (in the global scope) have the kind of power of the US or the EU to gain access to things like extended on device features. The app based systems are largely based on some form of location reporting and push messages which are far less reliable - one to one messaging systems (like Apple/Google push notifications) are physically impossible to scale for real time sub-second alerting in dense populations, given the bandwidth constraints of radio. CB is expensive at the radio tower, and can disrupt normal communications (potentially including emergency services communications) as such it's use is more limited than other solutions, for example in todays event it was only used in an area of about a 25km radius. To put this in some context, many folks commenting here, including myself still in the "felt it" areas were within a ~90km radius (SF is about 85km away from the center).
- sbuttgereit 4y agoI felt in San Francisco. I was on the sixth floor of one of the buildings in Civic Center. The shaking was pretty mild (which I'd expect given facts of what happened), but the duration was rather longer than many of the smaller nearby quakes you're likely to feel.
- s1mon 4y agoI live in SF on bedrock, but on the 5th floor of a ~100 year old steel framed apartment building. Definitely felt it, but nothing like the 5.1 in 2001, when I was on the 11th floor of the old Hamm brewery building in SF. That swayed back and forth way too much for my taste. For the first few minutes a Google search for "earthquake" initially had it located some distance from "San Hose". Clearly someone was typing that it in manually.
- tjohns 4y agoYou can view a map here of how much advance warning people with ShakeAlert-enabled phones (like Pixel) got before the earthquake: https://earthquake.usgs.gov/earthquakes/eventpage/nc73799091/shake-alert https://earthquake.usgs.gov/earthquakes/eventpage/nc73799091... Santa Clara had 2 seconds of advance warning, and Sunnyvale had 4 seconds. San Francisco got 18 seconds of warning, though was outside the "ground motion" zone.
- lazide 4y agoI honestly thought it was someone rolling a big cart across the floor above mine. I was really surprised when I saw 5ish magnitude. Definitely worth checking the earthquake kit though!
- andrewinardeer 4y agoLet's hope this is not a foreshock.
- sizzzzlerz 4y agoWas at lunch when it hit. I felt it sitting down at a table. I looked at others in the store and I didn't see anyone reacting to it at all. It was kind of subtle but it lasted for 5 or 6 seconds. Just a little bit later, the earthquake reporting apps on my iPhone and iPad show a notification. Nearly 15 minutes after it happened, I get an alert on my phone from the state emergency services department reporting the shake. Quite useless, I'm afraid. A 5.1 is the largest we've had around here in sometime.
- yodon 4y agoIf you're close to the epicenter there's no way for any app to give you advance warning. Any app is going to make use of the fact that internet messages travel faster than earthquakes, so the farther you are from the epicenter the more warning you'll get. Close to the epicenter is going to be no warning regardless of whose app you use.
- ksaj 4y agoIn Canada, we have mandatory Amber Alert notifications that affect all modern cell phones. It is loud so you aren't likely to miss it. These alerts cannot be muted, and require the user to acknowledge receipt or another alert will come shortly thereafter. This helps to catch people during alert time in case their phones are not on, or they're in the shower, or whatever. I am surprised California and other wobbly places don't use the same system, with the addition of quake and forest fire alerts. Everybody here knows the alert sound instinctively now, so even if you're in public and hear someone else's phone go off, we all know what it is.
- subarctic 4y agoAs other commenters have mentioned, they do have the same system in the US, but they actually use the proper alert types, unlike in Canada where they're all just thrown under the highest alert level that can't be ignored or silenced. See also https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20720587 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20720587
- dry_soup 4y agoJapan has had this for years, but California's app for this is still in beta IIRC. It's funny to me that one of the world's tech capitals has taken so long to get this rolling. To be fair, California doesn't have earthquakes as regularly as Japan (at least not of the same magnitude). I guess this is another symptom of our crumbling institutions in the US, we only get services quickly if there's a profit to be made. In the popular imagination, innovation is only the domain of private companies.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI for one hope they never make the obnoxious amber alerts impossible to disable.
- hot_gril 4y agoTechnical detail, amber alerts refer specifically to missing children. The other ones aren't amber alerts. But seemingly all of them trigger a loud sound.
- beefman 4y agoHandy calculator to convert between magnitude and energy: https://earthalabama.com/energy.html https://earthalabama.com/energy.html
- yumraj 4y agoAnother one, 3.6 , few minutes ago
- aaroninsf 4y agoPer https://t.co/WJdzMWgZSY https://t.co/WJdzMWgZSY (USGS), the modeling for an aftershock in the coming week predicts: 64% chance of a 3+ 16% chance of a 4+ 2% chance of another 5+ and today's quake being a foreshock is also possible, with the model's predictions being 0.2% (1 in 500) chance of a 6+ 0.02% (1 in 5000) chance of a 7+