4 ms·
Why should the employer be required to show all their cards, but the candidate not?
by WalterBright 4y ago
Why should the employer be required to show all their cards, but the candidate not?
- googlryas 4y agoCandidates do essentially have to show their cards - employers verify your salary history with products like "the work number". Most people don't even know their salary is being reported by their company to a third party, which then packages and sells that data.
- WalterBright 4y agoI thought there was a law in some states preventing that.
- googlryas 4y agoYes, but it is less than half of the states(though I'm not sure what percent of the population are covered), and even then, many of the bans are phrased such that pay history questions are only banned before an offer is made, or it is voluntary but employees may not know their rights. It is still legal to rescind or modify an offer after you discover salary history in most states with a "pay history" ban in place. https://fitsmallbusiness.com/salary-history-ban https://fitsmallbusiness.com/salary-history-ban
- 1991g 4y agoTo answer your question as posed: to fix the power/information imbalance that is used to pay people less than they are worth. To answer your question the way I wish to: thanks to Equifax's TWN, candidate resumes, reference checks, background checks etc - the candidate is already showing all their cards.
- WalterBright 4y ago> the power/information imbalance that is used to pay people less than they are worth Candidates often pad their resumes with skills they don't have. They'll pad their salary history. They'll hide things like stretches in jail. They'll list degrees they don't have. All to get a higher salary. The employer often doesn't realize for months that the employee wasn't as represented, and way overpaid. It goes both ways. I know you likely don't believe me, but I've been employer and employee, at min wage and professional wages. If you ever become an employer, you'll find out real fast how little power you have over employees. Anecdotally, I know employees with million dollar salaries. Is it credible that if corporations really had all this power, they'd be paid that much?
- WalterBright 4y agoBTW, I have a friend who, when he interviews candidates for professional positions like accounting and such, asks them "how much is 20% of $20,000?" A significant fraction, even those with masters degrees, even those who claim to be accountants, are flummoxed by it. There's a lot of resume inflation going on.
- ghaff 4y agoDoing that sort of mental arithmetic in a high pressure situation has very little to do with an accounting degree. Yes, it should be easy but I imagine I could make a lot of people flail at questions that they could answer easily sitting around a coffee table.
- WalterBright 4y ago> Doing that sort of mental arithmetic in a high pressure situation has very little to do with an accounting degree. Yeah, it does. Accountants work with percentages all the time. And if they can't do literally trivial arithmetic, they aren't fit to be accountants. He'd give them an hour. So let's see. What's 10% of $20,000? Then double it? (There are many other shortcuts to the answer.)
- ghaff 4y agoYes. Give someone an hour, of course. I'd expect any minimally educated white collar professional to be able to that without a calculator. As a verbal problem to answer in ten seconds? I'm more sympathetic with people freezing even if I certainly expect I'd be able to do it absent extreme pressure.
- WalterBright 4y agoIf someone regards an interview question as extreme pressure, I don't know what to say. Except advise the person to do more job interviews until they get used to it.
- JamesianP 4y agoYou can gather info on companies just as well.
- WalterBright 4y agoAs a bonus, you're more likely to get an offer by researching the company beforehand and demonstrating familiarity with it.