8 ms·
Asbestos encapsulates a problem with society at large. We, unfortunately, are simply too binary in our thinking "Oh, asbestos causes cancer? We better purge i
by cogman10 4y ago
Asbestos encapsulates a problem with society at large. We, unfortunately, are simply too binary in our thinking "Oh, asbestos causes cancer? We better purge it from everything everywhere".
The context of when and why (and to who) asbestos causes cancer is simply ignored.
This sort of problem exists everywhere. If something bad happens or is caused by something (politics, economics, etc) we are simply too quick to throw the baby out with the bathwater.
From a tech standpoint, I see this a lot. Postgres at my current company got banned because one team one time had a bad experience with it (after they misused it).
- Retric 4y agoManaging complexity is important even if it results in suboptimal solutions. Imagine if when building a house you needed to shape every single brick for it’s actual load. Sure you end up using less materials, but you lost economies of scale and suddenly need vast quantities of computing power for minimal gain. Using uniform bricks and banning stuff may seem wasteful, but it enables efficiency elsewhere.
- cogman10 4y agoThat's not what's happening in terms of asbestos. Rather, it's more like "Electricity has caused buildings to burn down, so lets ban electricity". Rather than focusing on the safe use of a material, we instead lean towards removing it all together. Older materials with known faults (such as wood being flammable) are deemed acceptable simply due to having known weaknesses in a period where we didn't care about safety. If we found out wood causes cancer, we'd still use it in building and furniture because we've always used it in building and furniture. It's not an economies of scale problem. When you get right down to it, the people that got mesothelioma from asbestos pretty much universally directly worked with it (usually in the form of doing things like blowing it in loose form for insulation). Yet we spent an ungodly amount of money and time stripping asbestos from buildings that had been there for decades not causing any problems. Ironically, directly exposing people to asbestos in the process (more than you'd ever be exposed to it was left undisturbed).
- foobarian 4y ago> If we found out wood causes cancer, If the rate was high enough I bet we'd phase it out. Don't underestimate the importance of the size of the effect.
- cogman10 4y agoSmoke from burning wood causes lung cancer at roughly the same rate as cigarettes. Have we banned wood stoves/ovens/or fire pits? I dare say, wood smoke has caused more cancer than asbestos ever did. [1] [1] http://www.familiesforcleanair.org/wood-smoke-pollution-kills-more-than-two-million-people-a-year/ http://www.familiesforcleanair.org/wood-smoke-pollution-kill...
- darkarmani 4y ago> Dr. Smith has spent decades studying the health effects of indoor air pollution due to biomass burning on women and children in developing countries. Your link is talking about indoor fires. Outdoor fire pits wouldn't concentrate the smoke in the living area. I have no idea what the total effect would be for outdoor fires, but it isnt' the same as the indoor burning biomass stoves
- schwartzworld 4y agoIn my area fire pits are absolutely illegal. It's densely populated and people don't want to breathe their neighbors smoke.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lazide 4y agoThey’re largely phased out in large swathes of Californa due to ‘spare the air’ days lining up almost perfectly with days you’d ever want to use them.
- crazygringo 4y agoYes they are absolutely banned in lots of places. And there are whole programs designed to reduce worldwide deaths from smoke, precisely because it is a major problem. It's something we're actively working on because it's so serious and plausibly fixable. So what on earth are you trying to say?
- jollyllama 4y agoA lot of this is a result of culpability/liability/blame. Intelligent use of aesbestos will be precluded by extreme legal risk. Your coworkers probably avoided repercussions for their experiences by shifting the blame to Postgres.
- pixl97 4y agoOne way to look at this is when process and policy is not followed. In IT we see this when information is lost (no backup policy), or information is leaked (no security policy). Using technology with no policy/process is almost always a risk factor for business. If said posts team had created a policy and process it's very likely the incident would not have occurred in the first place. With products control is very rarely tightly held. There is a supply chain from where it's mined out of the ground all the way to destruction of the product which may be decades or even centuries away. Trying to ensure that your customer use a product intelligently over that long of time frame is too risky for most businesses.
- permo-w 4y agothe problem there is that if you don’t entirely ban asbestos and ensure that everyone knows asbestos = cancer, then like a cancer, corporate interests and the profit motive will ensure that it slips and slides back into usage to the point where it becomes a problem again with public health risks, strong reaction is absolutely fine, and I wish we had more tendency towards it, not less. let’s do something drastic about micro-plastics!
- cogman10 4y agoWell, this is exactly the problem, it's completely arbitrary and based on public outrage what gets banned and what doesn't. If we can't motivate enough people to care about something, it won't be banned. That's not a way to run health policy. I'd certainly like more action against PFAS, for example. At very least, more science done to know exactly how harmful it is (especially given how it's permeated so much of the public drinking water). But, would I ban PFAS all together? Heck no. Rather I'd want to have a better understanding of where they should and shouldn't be used and how we should treat PFAS chemical outputs.
- CHB0403085482 4y agoYes, ban/restrict PFAS https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32980712 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32980712
- acdha 4y agoI think you’re overestimating the degree to which these decisions are made logically based in a desire to avoid problems, and overly quick to dismiss different opinions on acceptable levels of risk as arbitrary or outrage-driven. There’s a long history of companies claiming to be doing the smart thing but cutting corners ruthlessly - for example, here’s a story I read last week contrasting how they told regulators they worked versus the actual plant conditions: https://www.propublica.org/article/asbestos-poisoning-chemical-plant-niagara-falls https://www.propublica.org/article/asbestos-poisoning-chemic...
- hwillis 4y agoTo illustrate this: Asbestos is only banned in spray-on insulation, pipe insulation, paper, flooring, and new uses. The actual reason its not used as much (and it certainly is still used) is because of the public opinion and threat of lawsuits. https://web.archive.org/web/20121022215630/http://www.epa.gov/asbestos/pubs/asbbans2.pdf https://web.archive.org/web/20121022215630/http://www.epa.go... > EPA does NOT track the manufacture, processing, or distribution in commerce of asbestos-containing products. It would be prudent for a consumer or other buyer to inquire as to the presence of asbestos in particular products.
- reedf1 4y agoInterested to know how one can misuse postgres enough to ban it!
- cogman10 4y agoThey stored data in the array and then did a bunch of queries against that array. Queries like "select * from foo where array contains value". Shocker, that's slow.
- marcosdumay 4y agoFunny that this is a query where Postgres can famously and singularly be very fast.
- dragonelite 4y agonuclear energy is also good example i think.
- WalterBright 4y agoIf gasoline cars were invented today, they would never be allowed to be sold to consumers, because gas is too toxic and too flammable to allow ordinary people to use it.
- amluto 4y agoLike how hydrogen cars are in development but are waaay too dangerous to sell, so you can’t buy one. Except you can. The Toyota Mirai is available and quite heavily subsidized. Whether buying one is a good idea is a different question, although the main issues with owning one don’t involve safety as far as I know.
- Gigachad 4y agoCars in general are extremely dangerous. I can’t think of anything else we allow that’s as bad.
- johnflan 4y agoAlcohol perhaps
- highwaylights 4y agoWell, OK, except that there’s an infinitely long-lived bystander risk to not purging asbestos from all use. You could (for instance) argue that once the product exists, and is in place, it poses no further risk to anyone - this is a common suggestion but is demonstrably, dangerously false. It’s a rock, it never breaks down. Its state never changes over mortal timescales. Eventually a building, or a rocket, or a train will be refurbished or scrapped - and when that happens people in the area are at no less risk than they ever were.
- iseanstevens 4y agoI think in the case of a non-reusable rocket being launched into space there could be an argument for it, assuming extreme precautions at installation and some calculation/precaution in case the rocket fails in atmosphere. It could even lower the net asbestos on earth :) (not /s, though I attempting to add humor)
- areoform 4y agoAuthor here, while I agree with some of your points, phasing out technologies is less of a problem as much as forgetting them. For example, we have far better insulators than asbestos now that can serve as thermal protection systems if we ever build a rocket of this scale again. One example of these new technologies are aerogels. In 2012, NASA showed off the HIAD, Hypersonic Inflatable Aerodynamic Decelerator, it's a flexible heat shield that's made out of aerogel, https://www.nasa.gov/directorates/spacetech/game_changing_development/HIAD/index.html https://www.nasa.gov/directorates/spacetech/game_changing_de... Plus toxic materials are very much still in use in the space industry, including asbestos. They're used as separators in fuel cells, insulation for missiles, etc Asbestos was banned for buildings not for the space industry. https://www.pbs.org/newshour/show/decades-after-proof-of-its-carcinogenic-properties-asbestos-still-surrounds-us https://www.pbs.org/newshour/show/decades-after-proof-of-its... It will be replaced slowly as better materials become available.
- cogman10 4y ago> One example of these new technologies are aerogels. And, to be fair, if you could use aerogels, you should use aerogels. They are way better at insulation than asbestos. They are simply cost prohibitive in most cases. Despite what it may look like, I'm not trying to shill for asbestos :D. I just think it's a microcosm of a problem with society.
- schlauerfox 4y agoI think more to your point, specific government secrets get forgotton because they are closely kept under punishment, open access science, by letter or by journal has been going well for 600+ recorded years. Trades even longer by apprenticeship. Clockmakers and any other as well.
- bad_alloc 4y agoIronically we might have also forgotten the massive cleanup that was needed for or buildings to either remove or permanently bind asbestos. How do you drill a hole into a wall, do maintenance on cables and pipes or tear down a building when it might emit enough asbestos needles to give you cancer at any disturbance? It is not sustainable.
- CorrectHorseBat 4y agoForgotten? We have just started doing that
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> We, unfortunately, are simply too binary in our thinking "Oh, asbestos causes cancer? We better purge it from everything everywhere". The author's point being we not only purge it physically, but also culturally and thus intellectually. (I feel like there's a meta point around this thread being de-railed by discussions about how bad asbestos is.)
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> We, unfortunately, are simply too binary in our thinking "Oh, asbestos causes cancer? We better purge it from everything everywhere". I don't think this has anything to do with the OP. It is focused on the process of knowledge being lost simply through the raw fact that nobody remembers it. This is applied to everything: > We have lost more than 50% of all feature films made before the 1950s The message of the piece is that we've forgotten the asbestos because, when you go to look at the preserved rockets today, it isn't there.
- userbinator 4y agowhen you go to look at the preserved rockets today, it isn't there. ...probably because it was removed for aesthetic and health reasons.
- alerighi 4y agoThe thing is that it poses a risk that can be avoided, since there are alternative materials with the same (or better) properties that doesn't cause cancer. Asbestos was widely adopted because it was a very cheap material, they did know that it was dangerous but that fact was hidden by the companies selling asbestos containing materials for profit. There is no reason to use it. Not only asbestos, for example in the past they used to put radioactive material in daily life object, such as clocks, dials, etc to illuminate them in the dark. Obviously it was not a good idea, since the risk it poses didn't justify the purpose. Same thing with smoke detectors, now we are no longer using radioactive particles in them, basically because we have better electronics that not only can replace radioactive material but can be more effective in detecting a fire.
- nostrademons 4y agoMost professionals who work with asbestos don't recommend "purge it from everything everywhere." Rather, the usual recommendation is to leave it intact and don't touch it, unless it's going to be disturbed in a way that'll release the fibers anyway (eg. imminent renovation or demolition, accessible to small children). Even then, oftentimes abatement consists of encapsulation, i.e. just wrap it in some physical barrier that will prevent it from being disturbed. It's banned in new construction, but choosing to use something different when building anew is a lot less expensive than ripping it out of existing construction.
- himinlomax 4y ago> Asbestos encapsulates a problem with society at large. We, unfortunately, are simply too binary in our thinking "Oh, asbestos causes cancer? We better purge it from everything everywhere". There is actually a good reason for this: the slippery slope is not always a fallacy.
- taneq 4y agoI worked with a guy like that once, anything he’d tried and it didn’t work perfectly was forever forbidden as “tried that, didn’t work.” Nobody else was allowed to attempt it.