9 ms·
The bosses who silently nudge out workers
- cultofmetatron 4y agoso what happens when a boss quiet fires someone who quiet quits at the same time?
- ebiester 4y agoYou get phantom payroll until the next layoff. The truth is that often when you see a large company with a 5-10% layoff, it's a cleanup of phantom payroll and otherwise low performers.
- pryelluw 4y agoSilence of the lambs.
- StevePerkins 4y agoIf an employee drags ass, but doesn't want to quit... and an employer tries to manage them out, but doesn't want to fire them... then I would say that it's a draw. And in this case, the employee generally "wins" in the event of a draw.
- francisofascii 4y agoI once worked for a company that transferred low performing engineers to customer service over the phone support rather than firing them. That way they could say they never lay off employees. Which you could argue is better that firing. But working customer support was the worst. They did have excellent phone support though.
- DelightOne 4y agoIn some countries this might be illegal, with having their work defined in their employment contract?
- marcus_holmes 4y agoIn the UK/Australia, this would definitely qualify as constructive dismissal just for the role change. If they changed the salary then even more so. Of course, if they didn't change the salary then it could turn out interesting; the customer support folks could demand equal pay as the ex-engineers.
- badpun 4y agoThat's what happened in Poland in 1990s when France Telecom took bought the local telco monopoly (Telekomunikacja Polska) from the Polish state. FT wanted to get rid of lots of relatively well-paid office workers (largely due to automation making them no longer necessary), but were unable to do so, as keeping employment was part of the sales contract. However, they were allowed to move people around the company, provided they still pay them the same salaries. The FT's "solution" was to move hundreds (probably even thousands) of people into call centers and subject them to what today would definitely be recognized as mobbing. A family member went through that - she said that, whoever could quit quickly did, and people who had no alternatives stayed on the job largely only thanks to tranquilizers and other psych meds.
- hikingsimulator 4y agoThis is a very common practice at French telecom companies, and beyond. A massive lawsuit occured when a string of suicides at Orange Telecom in France happened. Managers would systematically psychologically harass workers till they quit, or die. All in order to meet "headcount reduction targets." Call that practice the good, old Roman decimation. The French managing practice of moving someone in a spot where they will get bored out, if not killed out is called "placardisation," or "to put someone in a cupboard." Demeaning and morally unacceptable, but something that business majors at French grandes écoles are taught is "une normalité," a given, a fact of business life. [a] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orange_S.A._suicides https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orange_S.A._suicides
- gowld 4y agoIt's only legal if employer refuses to file the proper paperwork (firing / layoff) if they leave and it is ruled constructive dismissal.
- kennend3 4y agoDepending on your country, this could be against the labour laws. here (Canada) what you outline is a violation. https://www.canada.ca/en/employment-social-development/programs/laws-regulations/labour/interpretations-policies/constructive-dismissal.html https://www.canada.ca/en/employment-social-development/progr... Changes in Powers or Duties The most common cases of constructive dismissal are where the employee leaves as a result of material changes in powers or duties. Usually, a main area of responsibility is removed or the employee's duties are decreased; for example, a plant superintendent whose duties are confined to those of yard foreman. Such actions are in fact a dismissal in disguise, whether or not they are accompanied by changes in salary or job title. Commonly, this form of constructive dismissal involves a significant loss of prestige and status as a result of a corporate reorganization or change in reporting arrangements.
- azalemeth 4y agoIsn't the word for this "constructive dismissal"?
- Brian-Puccio 4y agoThe first line of the fifth paragraph reads: > In overt cases, this is known as ‘constructive dismissal’: when an employee is forced to leave because the employer created a hostile work environment.
- halostatue 4y agoYes. And it’s generally considered something for which any employee could win at a labour board, if they wanted to take it there. Strictly speaking, constructive dismissal could be seen as a form of fraud (many unemployment schemes do not cover someone who has quit their job, only those who have lost their job without cause). It’s going to be harder for the employer in the UK (for now, until the shambles of a conservative government finalizes the gutting of rights) and Europe, but it’s far more humane and effective to figure out where the employee can fit within the organization, and if there is nowhere to fit, to give the employee a generous termination package. Employees who have been constructively dismissed like this need to remember to not sign any NDAs or arbitration agreements on the way out and to document the experience to take it to a labour board.
- teddyh 4y agoIsn’t this frequently reported as being very common in Japan?
- protomyth 4y agoI remember a documentary about Sony doing this. [edit] https://www.nytimes.com/2013/08/17/business/global/layoffs-illegal-japan-workers-are-sent-to-the-boredom-room.html https://www.nytimes.com/2013/08/17/business/global/layoffs-i... [/edit]
- goodpoint 4y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20220704071443/https://www.nytimes.com/2013/08/17/business/global/layoffs-illegal-japan-workers-are-sent-to-the-boredom-room.html https://web.archive.org/web/20220704071443/https://www.nytim...
- omgmajk 4y agoFrom what I hear it's almost impossible to get fired in Japan so it seems likely, I have no sources other than: "I heard it somewhere" for this however.
- fomine3 4y agoFiring is hard for big japanese company so this is alternative way.
- not_the_fda 4y agoYep, I did some integration with a large firm in Japan in the mid 2000's. They had a whole room of people that just sat at their desks and napped or read a book during the day.
- iamdbtoo 4y agoThis was one of the most cowardly acts I ever experienced at an organization. And the organization is run by people who call themselves "leadership coaches" and who do "management consulting" and it frustrates me to no end they are teaching other people this is effective management.
- club_tropical 4y agoHave some mercy on the employers; they didn’t want it this way. This is all downstream of law. Nobody wants to play Russian Roulette by being direct with people and risking a lawsuit or, more likely, a complaint at the EEOC. Even if everything is above board, just the existence of the case can harm your reputation in the future, like someone who has been arrested and cleared.
- Loughla 4y agoI get what you're saying - in that people will sue over anything. But. If you being "direct" with an employee about their performance rises to an EEOC complaint, you absolutely need to think about what you're doing and why you're doing it. >Even if everything is above board, just the existence of the case can harm your reputation in the future, like someone who has been arrested and cleared. I have had several EEOC complaints files against me for BS reasons (I work in a field that works with folks with disabilities, and it can be difficult to separate disability and job performance for some folks). None of them have had findings, and none of them have ruined my career. I'm confused by your statement here.
- lr4444lr 4y agoI get that this may feel demeaning, but come on, we're trying in the modern world to do something better than the inhumanity of locking the factory doors 100 years ago or yanking a guy's union book, and now people are complaining about how psychologically scarring it is to be treated with enough decency to receive a paycheck and be given a low enough stress role to find a new one? Jeez... recognize this for the progress that it is!
- kemiller2002 4y agoNot to mention in the U.S. health insurance is tied to employment. Firing someone not only stops income from coming in, but also doubles the cost (in a lot of cases) of insurance. On top of this, firing someone allows the company to dispute unemployment. Giving someone to find a new job would be an amazing gift.
- JauntyHatAngle 4y agoI don't see why past progress should be an impediment to future progress.
- Broken_Hippo 4y agoExactly this. Just because things were worse in the past doesn't mean they are good enough now - just not as bad as yesteryear.
- kennend3 4y agoI take it you did not read the article? The individual stated they would rather have been fired instead of having to undergo that process. "Eliza had effectively been frozen out by her employer. Barely a month later, she quit. “It was humiliating – I was made to feel worthless,” she says. “It was the worst experience of my career: I’d rather have been just fired on the spot and paid off than have to go through that.”"
- whiddershins 4y agoFired and paid off.
- michaelt 4y agoFor an extreme example of this, look up 'rubber rooms' for teachers [1] - > It’s a June morning, and there are fifteen people in the room, four of them fast asleep, their heads lying on a card table. Three are playing a board game. [...] > These fifteen teachers, along with about six hundred others, in six larger Rubber Rooms in the city’s five boroughs, have been accused of misconduct, [...] or, in some cases, of incompetence [...] > The teachers have been in the Rubber Room for an average of about three years, doing the same thing every day—which is pretty much nothing at all. [1] https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2009/08/31/the-rubber-room https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2009/08/31/the-rubber-roo...
- JackFr 4y agoWith respect to NYC teachers thank the union for that. The rubber rooms are because of contracts and processes which make teachers extremely difficult to fire. The issue that happens is that teachers who might be unsafe to have in the classroom with children, will have a years long arbitration and appeal process before they can be fired.
- yourapostasy 4y ago> ...will have a years long arbitration and appeal process before they can be fired. For the US, I read that as "it will be so expensive in attorney time to secure a litigation-proof post-firing outcome it is cheaper to simply pay them to sit and do nothing for the remainder of their contract". Above some amount of money thrown at these arrangements, it might come with consequences: future teachers unions might find long-term contracts or contracts at all rather problematic to negotiate. I wonder what the union side of the picture looks like for these allegedly problematic teachers?
- cool_dude85 4y ago>For the US, I read that as "it will be so expensive in attorney time to secure a litigation-proof post-firing outcome it is cheaper to simply pay them to sit and do nothing for the remainder of their contract" It's all done through arbitration, so much lower cost than the regular US court system. >I wonder what the union side of the picture looks like for these allegedly problematic teachers? I'll bite: why should management just be able to fire people unilaterally? All the union is asking is for the case for firing be proven in arbitration. It's management's choice to take these teachers out of the classroom while the case against them is pending and pay them to do nothing. Just look at some of the cases cited in the actual article: a lady they spoke to got bad perf reviews for two years from a new principal after 20 years of good ones. The writer spoke to 5 unnamed parents from the teacher's school who said that the new principal was good. Is it so obvious that the lady needs to be fired from her job?
- dkjaudyeqooe 4y ago"her main duties now consisted of simply being available between 0900 and 1800, sending the occasional email and completing the odd routine task from home." Sounds like heaven, finally I could get some work done on my side project.
- thefz 4y agoYeah, beat them at their own game. Collect one paycheck, while doing what you want, or even collect more than one paycheck.
- sleepymoose 4y ago>her main duties now consisted of simply being available between 0900 and 1800, sending the occasional email and completing the odd routine task from home. This sounds like a perfect opportunity to be paid while searching for a new job. I honestly don't see how employers still see this as a good idea. Please, by all means, stick me at home with nothing to do but collect a paycheck. I'll gladly clock in while filling out applications for a better role.
- jbirer 4y agoIt seems like she invested herself and her ego too much into the job, almost caring more about the "position" than the money, which is very weird. I would just take the paycheck and the easy work.
- Spivak 4y ago> I'll gladly clock in while filling out applications for a better role. I would assume that's the point. You can turn over employees without the political headaches of firing. If you fire enough employees nobody will want to work for you (in the case of specific managers) and risk triggering an exodus as people lose faith in the company (and the best most employable employees leave first).
- falcolas 4y agoNot that I'd enjoy the process, but it also sounds like a pretty good retirement plan. I'd keep my resume up to date for when they'd give up on me quitting, but I'd also not be adverse to doing things I want to do in exchange for being available for the occasional email.
- ryandrake 4y agoI would love to semi-retire with a role like that. It's not like I'm going to instantly turn off my Internet and forget how to do software when I'm 60. But, I'm also not going to be interested in running at full throttle grinding and chasing promotions, either. I would love to wind down my career with a role like "Grow a beard, answer E-mail questions, be available to help with emergencies, and mentor junior employees." I'd probably only ask for 25% pay for a job like that.
- mmcgaha 4y agoI don't know, but this sounds OK to me. Hey you are not working out for me in this position. How about I keep your paycheck rolling in while you find another job?
- dec0dedab0de 4y agoI had this happen to me at best buy when I was 19. The assistant GM didn't like that I had purple hair so he would essentially bully me every day. To the point that other co-workers noticed, and were telling me that I should say something to HR or OSHA[1]. As someone who made it through catholic grade school I prided myself on being able to take shit from authority with a smile, so I put up with it. Until one day I overslept and the thought of having to call in and say I was going to be 15 minutes late was too scary and I just didn't go back. Only time I ever no call/no showed anywhere. More recently I had an "architect" on a team who felt threatened that I knew more about our tech stack than he did. He would constantly go against my recommendations without giving a reason, and would assign me boring things. If something broke he would spend the whole time trying to figure out how to blame me, instead of how to fix it. In return, I would just say it probably is my fault let's fix it, even when I knew it was someone else's fault, because who cares. I would also be very public about my technical opinions. The result was that management decided our team didn't need an "architect" and we now have a few Sr. engineers instead. If I didn't have that awful experience at best buy 20 years before, I don't think I would have had the courage to stand up. [1] This is a funny story that I still tell. One day it was slow, he assigned me to wash the walls with a brush and bucket. One co-worker just kept saying "I've never heard of washing the walls. you paint the walls." Another said they would refuse do it unless they had all the appropriate OSHA safety gear. But the best part was that I was just spot washing the dirt and stuff, and the manager came over to me like an annoyed parent and said I was doing it wrong and showed me the right way. He grabbed the brush soaked in soapy water and used big aggressive strokes water dripping down, and so I followed his example. Within 10 minutes he had me stop because the carpet was stained from the paint dripping off the wall, because you don't wash walls, you paint them.
- conductr 4y ago> If I didn't have that awful experience at best buy 20 years before, I don't think I would have had the courage to stand up. Too me this is a key takeaway. Business is shitty in lots of ways. There’s a million ways the fit could be wrong. Our process of couple interviews and job offer doesn’t always allow for proper due diligence as both parties are trying to sell something. The goal for everyone is should be to make sure you have enough cushions in your finances and other parts of your life that you can politely say “fuck off” whenever or whyever you feel like you’re being treated poorly. Just don’t put up with it. It doesn’t mean walking off is the best solution, but sometimes you try to fix with communication and other things and this is your only option. I have an expectation that people treat me professionally in work. If people are being conniving, twofaced, or yelling and screaming it’s time to go. (I tend to experience yelling a lot. I think the stress/deadlines gets to certain people to where they just like to yell.)
- monkeydust 4y agoIf someone gets assigned to something that is called 'special project' or similar it nearly always means this is happening.
- Neil44 4y agoWhy would 'the bosses' not simply let her go, if she was still in her probation period? What would they stand to gain by this approach?
- dusted 4y ago> her main duties now consisted of simply being available between 0900 and 1800 Where can I apply for a job like this?
- omgmajk 4y agoHonestly this seems good to me, I get that some person might feel that this is bad and I get the article but free money while searching for a new job just can't be bad.
- motohagiography 4y agoOne of my early bootstrapped startup failures was a site for anonymously referring colleagues' cv's, linkedin and other profiles to a pool of recruiters with the intent that the person would get recruited away. The premise was that these neutral referals were higher quality leads for recruiters than reaching out via cold emails, and just because one of your co-workers would prefer to see you somewhere else doesn't mean you can't be great at what you do in a new role with new relationships. I spoke to one manager who had to do layoffs and said he would have loved to be able to get some of them recruited away, as it would have been a net-positive for everyone involved. It was in the time when Tinder and other taboo breaking apps were coming to market, but it's better than the alternative. If it sounds mean spirited, consider it against the alternative of "managing-out" or "pip'ing out" people, which is a terrible artifact of labor law where instead of setting clear expectations and outcomes, it incentivises gaslighting people for months, sabotaging their mental health and relationships with their colleagues, and with knock-on effects for bringing that home to their families. Firing someone with clarity and closure sucks, but the band-aid comes off. Managers who avoid difficult conversations and use passive gaslighting instead can wreck the families and homes of people who are accountable to them. Referring out someone who isn't a fit to external recruiters (outrefer'ing) seemed like a relatively humane solution. Free to out-referers, subscription fee for recruiters to get the warm leads by city/role and skills. Maybe the time for it will eventually come.
- User23 4y agoBack in the day at Kodak it was a common trick to give a bad employee a stellar review and put them up for internal transfer in the hopes that sone sucker would take the underperformer.
- chasd00 4y agoin the US bad teachers get managed the in a similar way. It's very hard to fire a teacher due to the union but you they can get moved around to different schools. They call it the "turkey shuffle".
- mintysoap 4y ago
- billsmithaustin 4y agoI talked to someone who had a similar experience in New Zealand. As I understand it, this kind of treatment is more common in countries where the employment laws make it hard to fire someone. It is also more common when the employee's severance package is large and the employer is not just disappointed but upset with the employee.
- User23 4y agoThis reminds me of the classsic story of the Boredom Room[1]. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2013/08/17/business/global/layoffs-illegal-japan-workers-are-sent-to-the-boredom-room.html https://www.nytimes.com/2013/08/17/business/global/layoffs-i...
- susanasj 4y agoI understand feeling psychologically hurt by this as a young ambitious person but as someone that has 10+ years of tech experience my ego wouldn't be hurt by this and I would gladly take a role where I send a few emails a day and keep my salary. I would be killing it with my hobbies during the day.
- debacle 4y agoIn the UK this could be for very different reasons than in the US. It is particularly hard to fire there, this may have been seen as a cheaper and easier route.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 4y ago> her main duties now consisted of simply being available between 0900 and 1800, sending the occasional email and completing the odd routine task from home That's just asking for her to get a second WFH job... or enjoy the time off.
- roschdal 4y agoThis corporate capitalism system is evil, on the same level as gulags in the Soviet Union and concentration camps in Nazi Germany. Workers can't perform according to the system? Then silently terminate them and nudge them into poverty. "Freedom" in the Western world? No.
- AlmostAnyone 4y agoWhat's your alternative?
- roschdal 4y agoThe alternate is to treat people fairly in accordance with basic human rights.
- AlmostAnyone 4y agoThat's not really saying anything at all. Every alternative to the corporate capitalism system that has been ever tried ended with millions of dead people.
- roschdal 4y agoThe alternate is to treat people fairly in accordance with basic human rights. -Fair treatment. -Human rights.
- AlmostAnyone 4y agoAs I said, this means nothing. It's already the case.