5 ms·
Every single highly individualistic society seems to be in population decline (more so if you factor out immigrants from “anti-progressive” Muslim or Catholic c
by rayiner 4y ago
Every single highly individualistic society seems to be in population decline (more so if you factor out immigrants from “anti-progressive” Muslim or Catholic countries). Individualism seems to be a self-limiting feature of society: it’s unpleasant to raise children in highly individualistic societies, which makes such societies inherently transitory.[1]
Is societal self-obsolescence how you define “progress?” How successful can your society really be if your people don’t seem to want to raise kids in it and perpetuate it? If you have to import people from collectivist societies just to take care of your elderly?
[1] The inverse is not true—many collectivist societies are also facing population walls—but for quite different reasons.
- BlargMcLarg 4y agoBirth rates dropped to below replacement rate in the 70s near universally among developed countries, far before many of them became increasingly more individualistic. American culture and attitude seeping into most of those countries kicked into overdrive the 21st century, but birthrates were already low by then.
- CPLX 4y agoThe hidden variable here is the newly available innovation of birth control pills.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- klipt 4y agoIt's just nature's way of filtering out people who like sex but don't want kids. Prior to birth control, having a genetic predisposition toward liking sex was enough. In the future, most people will also have a genetic or cultural disposition towards wanting kids.
- CPLX 4y ago> It's just nature's way of filtering out people who like sex but don't want kids. More like: It's just nature's way of filtering out people who like sex but don't want [more] kids [right now]. That’s a lot of people, and thus, less kids.
- taneq 4y agoTaking it to its logical conclusion, it’s nature’s way of filtering out people who either (a) have good short term but poor long term planning, or (b) have good impulse control. Uhoh.
- trashtester 4y agoExactly this. A couple of centuries from now, people will laugh about that time people thought that the population will collapse. Most likely, there is an enormous selection pressure right now for any genes that predispose people (and in particular women) to want to have (many) kids. If those genes are as common as I believe, they should be dominant within about 10 generations (counting from approximately 1970).
- jkhdigital 4y agoAnd that selection pressure hasn't existed for the entire history of life? I don't think genetics have nearly as much to do with it because we are not living in a "state of nature" where genetics are the dominant factor in reproductive fitness. Even Richard Dawkins recognized this many decades ago when he coined the term "meme" to refer to the units of cultural lineage that clearly influence evolutionary fitness by altering the behavior of the people who hold them. edit: I mean, you're not wrong, but I'd posit that there is enormous selection pressure for memes that promote fertility.
- trashtester 4y ago> And that selection pressure hasn't existed for the entire history of life? Not at all. For most of evolutionary time, organisms didn't even have any kind of cognitive capacity at all (being single celled organisms). Even after brains started to develop, mating behavior was primarily instinctual. And even up until this day in humans, the sexual drive may easily overpower any desire to prevent pregnancy if people (and women in particular) doesn't have access to birth control. Arguably, the sexual drive may have been so strong that there may have been a selection pressure favoring INHIBATION of reproductive behavior (K selection). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/R/K_selection_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/R/K_selection_theory Especially so in females, as under some conditions, having fewer offspring and investing more in each may provide a higher number of surviving offspring than giving birth to more, but with less investment in each. Without birth control, even K-selection strategies ended up with 5 or so offspring per woman, on average, with about 2-3 surviving children on average. With child survival rates near 100%, K-selection strategies are now strongly disfavored compared to r-selection strategies, even without birth control. (So r-selection has probably been selected for at some level for the past 150 years or so in the West). Birth control simply multiplies this effect. > because we are not living in a "state of nature" This, I'm sure, is a fallacy. The rate of genetic adaptation is directly linked to the strength of selection pressures, where "selection pressures" are not just survival rates, but rather the number of surviving offspring. To quote wikipedia: "Contrary to popular belief, not only are humans still evolving, their evolution since the dawn of agriculture is faster than ever before" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recent_human_evolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recent_human_evolution > "meme" to refer to the units of cultural lineage that clearly influence evolutionary fitness by altering the behavior of the people who hold them. Memes (as coined by Dawkins, not the pop culture use) are their own replicators. They code for the replication of thoughts and ideas. Memes are not very tightly coupled to the physical fleshbags they inhabit. Like regular viruses, they often pass from host to host laterally, even though some forms are often transferred to children. But there is no reason to think that this has limited genetic evolution (meaning adaptation, not necessarily "improvement"). This is basically orthogonal to whatever the memes are doing. (Though there is an interaction term where genes and memes form part of the natural environment of each other as replicators). Genes may not be the dominant factor in reproductive fitness right now, but unlike for memes, the relative frequency of genes depend directly on reproductive fitness, meaning whatever variance DOES ALREADY exist in the genome for reproductive fitness are under a massive selection pressure right now. For many, if not most memes, reproductive the reproductive fitness of the hosts has little impact on the ability of the meme to replicate. For some memes (or meme-plexes) like religions, one _could_ argue that they attach themselves strongly enough to families that they are inherited in a way similar to genes. However, I would argue that memes can lose this power much more quickly than genes can. Just consider how quickly Christianity have been losing power over most Western linages lately. Meanwhile, genes will continue to build up momentum for as long as the selection pressure remains. Currently, that pressure is for women to WANT to have children. While cultural effects may come and go, any genes coding directly for that will be reinforced. If these genes already exist, this will take a few hundred years. If mutations are needed, it could take 10x longer. Eventually, though, if the selection pressure persists, having babies will have the same pull on female brains as sugar, sex or serotonin-inducing social affirmation. At some point, though, REAL overpopulation is likely to be a limiting factor. Real, as in famine or disease will place a hard cap and re-introduce child mortality rates of 50%+.
- seydor 4y ago> in population decline So? It's not the most populous groups that dominate, quite the contrary. The world had half the population just 50 years ago.
- godelski 4y agoYeah I find the conversations about population decline quite odd. We've seen the results of population explosion, and I don't think many agree that the results were great. But they also weren't that bad. I think people miss the point that (if you're a fellow Millennial) that when your parents were born there were less than half the number of people on the planet than there are today. I don't think rapid decline will be a good thing (just like rapid increase wasn't) but I don't think it is an existential crisis either. World population: (1804) 1 billion, (1927: 123yrs) 2 billion, (1960: 33 yrs) 3 billion, (1974: 14 yrs) 4 billion, (1987: 13 yrs) 5 billion, (1999: 12 yrs) 6 billion, (2011: 12yrs) 7 billion, (2023: 12 yrs) 8 billion.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoI think the reason for it is that those conversations tend to focus on local community as it relates to society's ability to support its existing retirement model. This conversation is then repeated across multiple countries with varying degrees of intensity, urgency and political backing. In the old country ( Poland ) for example, in 2016 ruling party introduced a stipend for each kid[1]. The official results don't seem to support the approach though[2]. I guess my point is that it may be existential crisis for some communities more than others. Naturally, it does not help that discussion of it almost invariably brings a question of overpopulation and all the baggage that brings. [1]https://ec.europa.eu/social/main.jsp?langId=en&catId=1246&newsId=9104&furtherNews=yes https://ec.europa.eu/social/main.jsp?langId=en&catId=1246&ne... [2]https://worldpopulationreview.com/countries/poland-population https://worldpopulationreview.com/countries/poland-populatio...
- oneoff786 4y agoWhen the population is growing quickly the ratio of young:old people is high. When the population is shrinking, the ratio becomes very small. A society with many old people and few young people will suck
- Der_Einzige 4y agoThe collectivist societies, like South Korea and Japan, are experiencing stronger and worse populations declines than highly individualistic societies.
- hotpotamus 4y agoWhich societies are even still growing? I thought that even developing countries were falling off in birthrates. I assume the world in 2100 will be mostly Amish people and Israelis at this rate (and the oceans will be a couple meters higher too).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- luckylion 4y agoAre they, if you factor out immigration? As far as I know, in Europe, the recent-ish immigrants are propping up birth rates, but they adapt to the average in two or three generations.
- Barrin92 4y agoThey're not collectivist societies. South Korea in particular is effectively more American than America. From shopping-mall centric kpop to double eyelid surgery, no country has so thoroughly absorbed Western standards as SK has, and then some. Japan slightly less so, but not by much. Even China today is ruggedly individualistic with much less social trust than you'd find in Europe or the US. If anything funnily enough as some people have pointed out, countries like Britain now look like Japan did 20 years ago, they've if anything leapfrogged us at our own game. I've traveled a lot, in particular Asia and I would struggle to name one country that actually deserves to be called collectivist.
- jkhdigital 4y agoI think the real issue is that "collectivist" and "individualist" are very crude terms that attempt to summarize a whole litany of cultural nuances. My son just started 2nd grade here in Japan after being born and raised in the US (spouse is Japanese). It's really clear that here, children are socialized to think of the group to which they belong before themselves when contemplating their actions. Stated differently, people are socialized to identify strongly with the groups to which they belong. Does this mean the society is "collectivist"? I don't really know. I do observe that many of the social activities involved in group cohesion here are viewed as somewhat burdensome obligations. I believe it was de Tocqueville who first observed the seemingly novel and unique way in which Americans viewed social association: "When citizens can associate only in certain cases, they regard association as a rare and singular process, and they hardly think of it. When you allow them to associate freely in everything, they end up seeing in association the universal and, so to speak, unique means that men can use to attain the various ends that they propose. Each new need immediately awakens the idea of association. The art of association then becomes, as I said above, the mother science; everyone studies it and applies it." https://oll.libertyfund.org/quote/tocqueville-on-the-spirit-of-association-1835 https://oll.libertyfund.org/quote/tocqueville-on-the-spirit-...
- godelski 4y agoBut many collective societies are also facing similar issues of loneliness and isolation. This isn't just a western problem. We also see this same problem all across Asia: India, Japan, China, Korea. Some of these countries even had a rise in isolation before the US. I don't think it is a individualism vs collectivism issue, though I'm not going to dismiss it from the equation. I think it is that humans have just gotten comfortable as our lives have all tremendously benefited. We have little day to day problems. The problems we face now are much more abstract and existential than before, which tend to not be as motivating for adopting risky behavior.
- rayiner 4y agoAs I noted, the inverse is not true--some collectivist societies are also declining. But the reasons are different. Some Asian societies really socialized an anti-natal mindset in the mid-20th century as a means of population control. China's one-child policy was the most brutal manifestation of that mentality. In the short run this was helpful to development. But unless they can break out of that cultural trap, in the long run it will destroy those societies.
- godelski 4y agoI disagree. The issues Japan is facing look very similar to what the west is facing: loneliness. Here's a 12 year old article stating the same thing about Japanese men having no friends[0]. We see similar trends in Korea and even China. Yes, there are other contributions to the population declines. The parameters have different values, but I'm arguing that the same parameters exist. That the models are actually quite similar. In China we are seeing the Lay Flat movement as a response to 996[1]. One could argue that the loneliness is forced upon these people because of their working hours, but I don't think that as different as you make it out to be. There definitely is a linkage to higher work hours and lower number of friends. [0] https://japantoday.com/category/features/kuchikomi/growing-number-of-men-have-no-close-friends https://japantoday.com/category/features/kuchikomi/growing-n... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/996_working_hour_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/996_working_hour_system
- donw 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ulfw 4y ago