8 ms·
Differential mosquito attraction to humans is associated with skin acid levels
- remarkEon 4y ago> Chemical analysis revealed that highly attractive people produce significantly more carboxylic acids in their skin emanations. Mutant mosquitoes lacking the chemosensory co-receptors Ir8a, Ir25a, or Ir76b were severely impaired in attraction to human scent, but retained the ability to differentiate highly and weakly attractive people. The link between elevated carboxylic acids in “mosquito-magnet” human skin odor and phenotypes of genetic mutations in carboxylic acid receptors suggests that such compounds contribute to differential mosquito attraction. I wonder if diet has any impact on this. Anecdotally one of my childhood friends in boy scouts was a vegetarian and my goodness was he a mosquito magnet. I’ve always wondered if there was some relationship with what protein you eat and how attractive you are to these insects. Edit: keep the anecdotes coming. I mean no judgement on any diet. I really just want to understand what makes these horrible insects bite people because, while I was born in Iowa, I spent most of my young adult life in Minnesota and wew that state has a lot of mosquitoes.
- GenerocUsername 4y agolikewise, isn't carboxylic acid in all the carbonated sodas we drink?
- andy_ppp 4y agoI think carbolic acid found in soft drinks and carboxylic acids (there are many of them) are found in all sorts of things (coconuts, goat fat, fragrances, pheromones, etc) but not carbonated drinks, according to Wikipedia. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carboxylic_acid https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carboxylic_acid
- stochastimus 4y agoNot sure why you got downvoted for asking a good faith question, but you’re thinking of carbonic acid, which is responsible for the fizz when the pressure lowers as you pop the top and it creates carbon dioxide.
- dustedcodes 4y agoPersonal anecdote: I am a massive mosquito magnet, and I was initially a proper t-rex eating meat every day for 25 years but in the last ten years I’ve been 99% Pescatarian (mostly just veggie but sometimes fish or seafood) and I’m still the same massive mosquito magnet. My wife was her whole life Vegetarian and she is the opposite of me, not a mosquito magnet.
- tluyben2 4y agoAlso personal anecdote; my wife and myself are longtime vegetarians and we never get stung. We generally don’t notice that there is anything bitey around us until magnets asking us if we can go inside because they are getting eaten alive (we have been in Florida for instance where a friend got 10+ bites in a very short time while we were sitting there outside long before him and noticed nothing until he ran inside; this friend is a real magnet as anti moz spray doesn’t help at all for him). It’s not only mosquitos though; things like flees, gnats, midges etc are also not interested in us; we always have to hear from others if there is something that bites. But no idea if it’s diet related as I cannot remember how it was before I switched diet; too long ago.
- withinboredom 4y agoI wonder if this is also applicable to bees. When I was a kid, we got caught up in a swarm (there were five of us hiking in the woods). I was walking through the swarm as though I wasn’t even there. I think I had maybe a handful on me the entire hour, while my friends were literally covered in them, even under their clothes and underwear. I never get bitten by insects, ever. I can count on one hand how many mosquitoes have bitten me in the last decade.
- cglace 4y agoI eat tons of meat and my wife eats mostly vegetables. Mosquitoes never bite me and she gets eaten alive.
- ReptileMan 4y ago>My wife was her whole life Vegetarian and she is the opposite of me, not a mosquito magnet. A friend of mine was in the same situation - he was a magnet, his wife not. His explanation was - "She is so toxic, that they die if they bite her". Brave guy.
- jvm___ 4y agoAnother article I read said they did multiple samples from people and the attractive people were always attractive. They said it rules out soaps and recently eaten food, but I guess "extreme" diets of vegan or carnivore wouldn't change much over a few months. The study did try to rule diet out though.
- pavon 4y agoMy wife and I eat nearly identical diets. When we are outside together she can be bit over a dozen times and I won’t be bit once. Furthermore, she has been highly attractive to mosquitoes her entire life spanning radically different diets.
- iamben 4y agoI wonder whether puberty has an effect? I was bitten to death as a kid, as an adult it's far, far less frequent (to the point where a single bite is 'a thing'). But that might also be because kid me played outside in the park in the evening/went camping etc., and if adult me is out in the evening it's usually sitting outside a bar.
- tchaffee 4y agoAnecdotal: Both my wife and I have varied our diets in significant ways for long periods. I've never attracted mosquitoes, she always does.
- anon400232 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jader201 4y agoI’ve always wondered this, so will ask here since it’s relevant: How certain are we that it’s a difference in whether or not someone is bit by mosquitos vs. whether or not (or how) someone’s body reacts to a mosquito bite? I am a mosquito magnet, but my skin also deals with other oddness on occasion, plus I’m moderately allergic to a number of things. So part of me feels that may have some (more?) to do with it vs. that I’m bitten more. E.g. I’ll often find myself riddled with mosquito bites without even having realized I was being bitten. So I imagine it’s possible for non-magnets to also be bitten but just not have the same reaction.
- disillusioned 4y agoThis specific study used samples of fabric rubbed in the skin oils of various people and then indexed which fabrics attracted the most mosquitos, most reliably, so while it may not be a guarantee that all mosquitos feed at the site they're most attracted to, I wouldn't think it's quite that big a leap... I imagine that they feed at the first known-good-human, generally speaking. They also specifically call out that there are "low attractor" humans who simply don't generate as much of the carboxylic acid compounds that the mosquitos were attracted to, and who may still be bitten, but were not he preference. People definitely react different to bites, though. I know plenty of people who don't really feel much of an itch, vs others for whom it's awful.
- tlb 4y agoIn the paper, they’re counting mosquitoes that fly into a chamber containing odor collected from skin. They calibrated that against people sticking their arms in a mosquito box and counting bites as they happened. So bite response shouldn’t affect the result.
- cookie_monsta 4y agoI have had maybe 3 mosquito bites in my life, despite having lived large stretches in the tropics. Mostly they don't even land on me, but I have watched when they do - the closest they get to biting is lowering their proboscis until it touches skin. Then they fly off. I always assumed it had to do with skin odour, probably diet related. It's surprising that the science isn't more advanced on this considering how harmful/annoying mosquitos can be and how primitive the current countermeasures are.
- Flatcircle 4y agoSomeone in Southern California needs to figure out how to get rid of the recent explosion in Asian tiger mosquitos that have invaded the region. It’s crazy how fast it’s happened. Once the mosquitos start spreading one of the many terrible diseases they can carry the government officials will finally act, after it’s too late to save the first victims of an avoidable problem. Horrible quality of life issue that should be fixable if the government officials can get their act together soon!
- danielheath 4y agoYou can protect a small area (like a patio) reasonably well by stretching a mesh bag over the front of a box fan (the mosquitos get blown into the bag and can't escape).
- stavros 4y agoHm really? They get sucked into the fan? I'd imagine that a bag a fair distance from the fan would be better, as there more volume for them to get caught in the draft.
- soggylaundry 4y agoget a electric mosquito swatter
- mvid 4y agoThey barely work
- stavros 4y agoI don't know how you're using them, but they're the best $3 I've ever spent. Swat in the general vicinity of the mosquito, it's gone. They're amazing.
- kelnos 4y agoIn cases where you can't actually see the mosquito, sure, but in cases where I've caught a glimpse of it and the swatter was nearby, I've had great success with them.
- taleinat 4y agoI'm very skeptical of these results: The sample size is much too small! They started with only 64 individuals. Of those only ONE was found to be especially attractive to mosquitoes, and only TWO especially unattractive. They then used the scents from these three individuals, and 5 others who did not participate in the initial testing, for the following phases of research. Also, of the 5 additional people, two were found to be especially attractive, and one unattractive. This is extremely inconsistent with the results from the first phase. Now, they did a ton of work and show very interesting results. But these problems make all of their results very questionable in my mind. Yes, followup research could shine more light on this to validate their results (or not), but I wish they would make less grand declarations about the meaningfulness of their results. I bet this is going to make the news around the world... and if it later turns out to be inaccurate, it's only going to further reduce the public's trust in science.
- moffkalast 4y agoIf the professor from my statistics class is anything to go by, you just need a sample of more than 32 and you can assume it's a normal distribution /s
- anon400232 4y agoStatistical literacy is stupidly low. Without that, what is reasonable to expect for scientific literacy?
- MauranKilom 4y agoI don't understand what exactly you are complaining about. Can you elaborate on which specific statistical claim you think they should not make? This is not an analysis of "what fraction of people are attractive to mosquitoes", it is about how mosquito attraction differs between people. You can make meaningful statistical claims about this with just two subjects (and lots of measurements, which they did - see e.g. Fig 1G). I also don't understand how you complain about the insufficient sample size and then go on to claim the difference between two cohorts is "extremely inconsistent".
- 4y ago
- TEP_Kim_Il_Sung 4y agoMosquitoes used to prefer me, but after switching to a keto dietmostly ignored me. Now back to a regular diet and I am a mosquito magnet again.
- sethammons 4y agoMy friend, along with his father, are completely ignored by mosquitoes. I've seen him walk through clouds of them as they seek out anyone else and just ignore him.
- zagrebian 4y agoReminded me of World War Z.
- deepzn 4y agoReminds of me this video I watched years ago by Veritaseum. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=38gVZgE39K8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=38gVZgE39K8 Really interesting, again super small sample size. It's just his girlfriend and him testing out who's more attractive using a lab experiment. I don't believe they were able to conclusively answer the question, even with the mosquitoes biting one person more than the other. I had been thinking for a while, mosquitoes prefer certain smells, and use their olfactory senses to find targets. Anecdotally, like others on the thread, I get bitten all the time in areas with mosquitoes, where my parents, others never did.
- sparker72678 4y agoWhile reading this paper I went off the trail to two other papers and learned that alcohol consumption increases attractiveness to mosquitos. TIL https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20209056/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20209056/ and https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12083361/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12083361/
- zvr 4y agoAlso discussed yesterday, by a reporting of the same paper by Scientific American https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33299023 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33299023
- amai 4y agoSince my wife often has low levels of iron and never gets biten by mosquitos and for me the opposite my theory is that mosquitos also like iron rich blood. But I have never seen a study about this connection: https://www.verywellhealth.com/reason-mosquitoes-bite-some-people-more-others-4858811 https://www.verywellhealth.com/reason-mosquitoes-bite-some-p...