4 ms·
That's right: the "collapse" interpretation is an approximation. You can derive if from the MWI. We already know that the "worlds" separate and almost complete
by jfengel 4y ago
That's right: the "collapse" interpretation is an approximation.
You can derive if from the MWI. We already know that the "worlds" separate and almost completely cease interacting. The interactions decrease to the order of "two to the power of Avogadro's number" almost immediately. The collapse interpretation rounds that to zero (at some arbitrary point).
To make that more concrete you have to add a term to the equations, making it theoretically testable, but it's remarkable that anybody could manage to test it in practice. It's clever to use a neutrino detector -- something designed to measure ludicrously small amounts of interactions.
I don't think anybody is surprised by the results, just that they could get any. The un-physical arbitrariness of the cutoff caused problems from the get-go.
I was going to say that it doesn't make MWI any more palatable, though I suppose it does. They've detected the other branches, albeit in a very indirect way. They're real. But they're just as inaccessible as they ever were.
You still need the concept of decoherence to make it work. The unstable equilibrium can't hold for large objects. That's both mathematically and physically sound.
- pdonis 4y ago> You can derive if from the MWI. Not as an actual physical process, no. "Collapse" in the MWI just means that, once the "worlds" have decohered, within each "world" the wave function can be collapsed to the one that describes the measurement result observed in that "world", for purposes of predicting future results. But in the MWI this is just a mathematical convenience and doesn't correspond to anything physically happening. In the theories being tested by the experiments described in this article, though, collapse is an actual physical process: there is only one "world". This contradicts the MWI. > They've detected the other branches, albeit in a very indirect way. What experiments are you referring to here?
- whimsicalism 4y ago> doesn't correspond to anything physically happening It corresponds to the inner product of the two branches of the wavefunction going to 0 due to physical phenomenon.
- pdonis 4y agoThat is decoherence, not collapse. Collapse, as a physical process, would be all of the branches but one ceasing to exist.
- whimsicalism 4y agoOh I misread your comment - I thought you were referring to decoherence as the mathematical convenience. Now that I see that it was collapse, definitely agree.
- dchichkov 4y agoIf quantum computers would work, it would be very difficult to explain "where" the computation happens without having some sort of MWI into picture. But if, somehow, quantum computers keep their noise levels up without producing any interesting acceleration I'll expect that a theory would emerge at some point explaining that. And it may disambiguate which interpretation is the one.
- tsimionescu 4y agoQuantum computers are easy to explain in CI as well: they simply exploit certain numerical properties of complex-valued probabilities (unlike the real-valued probabilities of classical probabilistic Turing machines).
- mjan22640 4y agoCould the other branches be our dark matter?
- jfengel 4y agoNo. They don't behave at all like dark matter. Among other things, there's no reason for them to be distributed in a halo, nor for some galaxies to lack them.
- plutonorm 4y agoBroad statements, do you have the time to elaborate?
- simonh 4y agoDark matter affects some galaxies, but the rotation of others is completely explained by the observable matter. Why would one galaxy be influenced by its many worlds twins, but not another?
- jameshart 4y agoSci-fi plot concept answer: because one galaxy is populated by sentient life, and the other isn’t.
- tremon 4y agoQuarantine by Greg Egan explores this concept (the many-worlds theory, without the dark matter).
- plutonorm 4y agoWell because that galaxy in that position might be a low probability event - not many universes have that galaxy at that position. So therefore that galaxy appears to have less dark matter.
- gus_massa 4y ago
- poopnugget 4y ago
- infogulch 4y agoIf other 'branches' are still detectable, then they're probably detectable by more than one means; say, gravitationally. Could this be an explanation of dark matter? That is, dark matter is the sum of tiny gravitational interactions between many mostly-split branches of the wave function.
- cwillu 4y agohttps://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/34993/reversing-gravitational-decoherence https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/34993/reversing-... “What actually happens in an experiment with electrons is kind of interesting. Since photons are massless they are easy to excite if they have long wavelength and hence low energy. Whenever an electron gets accelerated many "soft" (i.e., long wavelength) photons get emitted. But if the acceleration is weak, the photons have such long wavelength that they provide little information concerning which path, and interference is possible. It is the same with gravitons. Except the probability of emitting a "hard" graviton (with short enough wavelength to distinguish the paths) is far, far smaller than for photons, and therefore gravitational decoherence is extremely weak.”
- jamiek88 4y ago> two to the power of Avogadro's number" So you’re saying… theres a chance…? :)