4 ms·
First of all, "biometric data" is a scary-sounding term that sounds like iris or fingerprint scans, when it's just... what people's faces and voices look and so
by crazygringo 4y ago
First of all, "biometric data" is a scary-sounding term that sounds like iris or fingerprint scans, when it's just... what people's faces and voices look and sound like. By this measure, my own brain is "collecting biometric data" on thousands of people a day while I walk down the street.
Second, in cases like the Nest camera or Google photos, presumably most of the people it's scanning don't match anything. It sure doesn't feel like a violation of privacy or consent for a computer to say, "I tried, but nope, face/voice not recognized".
Third, everyone being recognized has previously been identified by the user, whether someone tagging their friends in Photos, family members on Nest, or household members for Assistant. If I'm OK with a friend uploading an image of me to their own Google Photos, I don't see why I shouldn't allow them to run a facial detection algorithm to organize all the photos that contain me.
Now if Google were using all of this to build up a database of all the faces in the world matched to identities (as other sketchy companies have already done), then this would all be a problem. But there's zero evidence of anything like that, and that's not what this case is about. This isn't about misusing Street View or anything.
So it's hard to see this as anything but a political stunt? What's Texas's goal here -- to remove the helpful features that alert us when a stranger (as opposed to family member) is at our door, to distinguish voices in Assistant, and find photos of a particular friend in our photo library...? These are all genuinely useful features.
- AnonCoward42 4y agoIt is always a matter of scale. You can get the fingerprint of anyone (relatively) easily, but not everyone. So the problem only arises when it is done in mass or more generally when it can be used by centralized entities of any sort. The wider question is, if this can be avoided at all. But I think we should at least try, because this kind of data can so easily be misused and at one point in time we were already aware of that, but forgot in recent times.
- VWWHFSfQ 4y agoPeople always come in here with the same comment like "my brain memorizes people's faces too! Should that be illegal???" Your brain isn't memorizing billions of people's faces on the scale that Google is. There's a difference. It's a false equivalency.
- nova22033 4y agoYour brain isn't memorizing billions of people's faces on the scale that Google is. There's a difference. It's a false equivalency. Doing things at scale isn't a crime. Can you point out which law google broke?
- weberer 4y ago>Google had violated a state consumer protection law that requires companies to inform citizens and get their consent before capturing their biometric identifiers, including fingerprints, voiceprints and a “record of hand or face geometry.” The law in question: https://archive.ph/w9gtb https://archive.ph/w9gtb
- shadowgovt 4y agoIt's going to be an interesting case because it can easily be argued that Google captured nothing; they ran post-capture analysis on data captured by individuals for private use. Whether that's relevant to the law is what the courts will have to decide.
- crazygringo 4y agoAs long as the data Google is collecting is segregated per-user, then no -- it's not any different. If Google is learning about 10-20 people per account, and that data never gets combined, then what's the problem? Google also processes billions of people's e-mails. But they're segregated per-account. So there's no problem. What makes someone's face any different from an e-mail they send? Again, this lawsuit is not about Google aggregating anything. It's entirely about information that users voluntarily choose to supply, that is used for features desired by those users, and that remains segregated per-account.
- jeremyjh 4y agoDo you seriously believe that until the end of time no court can sign a warrant demanding Google search it’s database of photos across all accounts?
- dkarl 4y ago> sounds like iris or fingerprint scans, when it's just... what people's faces and voices look and sound like It's important to point out the important difference, which is that fingerprints are considered uniquely identifying for practical purposes, and are commonly used to identify individuals by automated security mechanisms and by law enforcement, whereas faces are considered uniquely identifying for practical purposes, and are commonly used to identify individuals by automated security mechanisms and by law enforcement.
- bbojan 4y agoI see what you did there.
- residentcoder 4y agoFrom the article: >Mr. Paxton said in a statement. “I will continue to fight Big Tech to ensure the privacy and security of all Texans.” It's obvious pandering to the masses. This is about Mr.Paxton trying to get some attention.
- cvwright 4y agoBig Tech keeps winning because we all hate our political opponents more than we hate the abuse of our privacy.
- manuelabeledo 4y agoAlso because people like Paxton aren't really doing their jobs. He targeted Google, when Amazon, Facebook, etc. are doing the same. Also, less known companies like Palantir, roam free, just because they don't have the political baggage like Google do. Worst of all, Paxton doesn't seem to have any issues with police departments having access to Nest or Ring accounts.
- bedast 4y agoHe's on the ballot next month. So of course he is. Not a fan of mass surveillance, but my gut says this is the wrong person to fight this fight. His motives are questionable, and it shows in specifically targeting private business and not working to "ensure the privacy and security of all Texans" from government and law enforcement.
- Bhilai 4y agoYep, this sounds like Ken Paxton trying to get some limelight a week before early voting begins in Texas. Its supposed to be a close election for Paxton who has basically abused his office in all sorts of ethical violations[1] He also been under indictment for securities fraud[2] and recently decided to literally run and drive away in his car to avoid being served[3]. This is Paxton's incompetence for those unaware: > Six of the people indicted last year on allegations that they were involved in a scheme to force teenage girls to “exchange sexual contact for crystal methamphetamine” are now free. [1] https://apnews.com/article/elections-texas-presidential-election-2020-ken-paxton-a1bdcfd0a9d25bd6aa3666b70f74f2b2 https://apnews.com/article/elections-texas-presidential-elec... [2] https://www.texastribune.org/2022/09/15/ken-paxton-securities-fraud-deposition/ https://www.texastribune.org/2022/09/15/ken-paxton-securitie... [3]https://www.texastribune.org/2022/09/26/texas-attorney-general-ken-paxton-subpoena-abortion-lawsuit/ https://www.texastribune.org/2022/09/26/texas-attorney-gener...
- advisedwang 4y agoGoogle Photos recognizes EVERY face even if you don't tag someone. It can show you a big array of every person in every photo you've ever taken. Tagging just puts a name underneath the picture and allows you to search them by name. https://support.google.com/photos/answer/6128838 https://support.google.com/photos/answer/6128838 My google photos has a "photo group" for every person I studied in college with (from a series of photos I took at a dinner with everyone present). It even has barack obama, which it recognized off a shirt a friend was wearing. I tagged none of these poeple.
- cromwellian 4y agoSo it’s a clustering algorithm that just clusters photos with like features together. Let’s say it was done without any kind of special face recognition but was done purely by some funky nearest neighbor algorithm in high dimensional space. Would you still object? The end result is the same, grouping things by commonality on different axes, one of them being faces. If the underlying algorithm didn’t even know what faces were, would it may a difference?
- amf12 4y ago> Google Photos recognizes EVERY face No. It does not "recognize" a face. If you take a few pictures of another Google user, it won't say - "Hey, here are all the pics of John". It will just allow you to lookup all pictures that match a face. Its clustering and not recognition.
- nova22033 4y agoThe texas AG is under indictment for security fraud. This is red meat to trumpers who feel the social media companies are biased against them.