19 ms·
Experiments spell doom for physical-collapse explanation of quantum weirdness
- gus_massa 4y agoNote that this was not the "mainstream" explanation. It was not even the most popular explanation. Everyone agree about the math, but there are a few interpretations of quantum mechanics. All are weird and equivalente, so it's not possible to make an experiment to decide which one is the correct one. There are a few attempt like this to extend QM and get a less weird theory, but it looks like this failed, at least with the more simple model for the extension. Anyway, most people just use "Shut up and calculate".
- bowsamic 4y agoI have a PhD in theoretical quantum optics and I can assure you that it absolutely was (and still is) a mainstream explanation EDIT: I misread the article, I thought it was about whether collapse occurs in general, not about physical explanations for collapse
- lupire 4y agoPlease explain the mistake in the article. > The experiments find no evidence of the effects predicted by at least the simplest varieties of these collapse models.
- pfortuny 4y agoYep: the article seems to say "there is no collapse" (in the title) but then it turns out to say "collapse as explained by these models may not be". Two very different things. I was caught as you by the title.
- gus_massa 4y agoI was initially confused too.
- Comevius 4y agoLooking out for quantum consciousness in articles about quantum physics would be a good drinking game, though here it is handled with a proper amount of scepticism. The pressure is enormous for writers to include mumbo-jumbo, because people click on these articles expecting to find out that it's possible to alter the Universe with psyhic abilities, which is how quantum physics is represented in social media, especially TikTok.
- ThalesX 4y agoHaving been passionate about this for awhile, I have a layman’s surface overview of the state of physics, or I like to believe so. It amused me to no end when my elderly aunt came to ask me for a tl;dr; on Quantum Physics. She stopped me shortly asking how she can control the universe with her mind. I tried to explain a bit about the famous interpretation (Copenhagen, not Von Neumann–Wigner) but she would have none of it because the business course she just attended had a segment on how to control the universe and proceeded to disregard and mock me.
- wongarsu 4y agoTo be fair, the Copenhagen interpretation doesn't really fit today's world view. We have largely moved away from viewing humans or "consciousness" as something special, so the notion that an observer collapses the wave function just seems weird now. "Many worlds" or "the wave function never collapses, you are in a superposition" both make much more sense with how we currently view the world
- ericmay 4y agoI’d say a good heuristic would be to include all mammals in any theory about consciousness, wave function collapse, quantum consciousness, etc. and then see if the theory still holds up. If it does, you are probably on to something. I think scientifically we will look back on “humans are uniquely conscious” as a categorical differentiation instead of a gradient with other mammals to be as absurd as believing the earth is the center of the universe. “Unique consciousness” is a quasi-religious mechanism we use at a societal level to not run around all the time terrified of death.
- dzdt 4y agoThere is an often-repeated statement that different quantum mechanical theories are equivalent. This is an over-simplification. Is wave function collapse is a real thing or just an approximation of what happens when a large system is entangled? Some smart people have tried to make theories where wave function collapse is a real thing. These new experiments are working to rule out those ideas. My feeling is that Everett's "many worlds" interpretation is the clear favorite: there is no wave function collapse.
- rubidium 4y agoMany worlds is just some peoples favorite because they get too weirded out but indeterminism. They prefer a billiard ball universe and so invented the hairbrained many worlds theory.
- ravi-delia 4y agoOr- and hear me out with this one- they prefer an explanation which follows naturally from existing experiments and doesn't require a hacked together non-linear irreversible operation which occurs only under bizarre conditions exactly when needed to patch over experimental results. No one in the whole world cares if the universe is deterministic or not, but collapse is embedded in an entirely deterministic system. MWI may not be right, but collapse is wrong.
- shadowfox 4y ago> MWI may not be right, but collapse is wrong. Such confidence ... I envy that.
- nil-sec 4y agoIt’s quite nice to have something irreversible though. It gives you time. Also nobody really thinks QM is the end of it, assuming semi classical physics under the hood is just odd to me. There is something below QM that we don’t understand yet (AdS/CFT looks like a good start to me) and personally I think the whole interpretation of QM debate will look stupid in retrospect. Yeah collapse is odd, but it just shows us this isn’t it. Reality is much weirder than we thought and giving up on realism is just the beginning.
- im3w1l 4y agoIn true collapse-of-the-gaps style, what if collapse happens when an entangled system becomes so large that the edges of it are outside of each others event horizons due to cosmic inflation?
- bowsamic 4y agoI think you mean expansion rather than inflation (inflation is something that happened very briefly at the beginning of the universe). In models with collapse, the collapse happens instantaneously, no matter what
- cb321 4y agoAs with any unsettled questions there are pros & cons to the various takes on quantum reality. Part of the appeal of MWI (intrication of observer into observed system as part of the measurement process) to me was always that the instantaneousness you mention here is a very "ordinary" kind of "fastness by synchronization". It's basically just a kind of causal wavefront hitting. There are plenty of "infinitely fast" synchronization effects like this..some perhaps less obvious than others, but many pretty pedestrian and accessible to lay people. Neither the junction of a scissors or the "spot light" on clouds need be constrained by light speed, for example. People routinely abuse "nothing" (or maybe "go") in the " 'nothing' can 'go' faster than light" saying. :-)
- kgwgk 4y ago> intrication of observer into observed system as part of the measurement process That was already part of von Neumann’s model of measurement over 90 years ago.
- cb321 4y agoYeah. Perhaps most charmingly treated here: https://arxiv.org/abs/2011.12671 https://arxiv.org/abs/2011.12671 { EDIT: though surely many other places! There are also YouTube videos of this one, though, and Sidney Coleman was really a Feynman-class edutainer, perhaps as under-recognized as von Neumann is relative to say Everett on this topic :-) }. I should perhaps have used the word "entanglement" rather than "intrication". Oops.
- bottlepalm 4y agoI remember something about super determinism being a possible answer to this. Do these results increase the likelihood of that?
- kryptiskt 4y agoNo, none of the other explanations predicts anything like this. The theories that fell here predicted physical effects that went beyond standard quantum mechanics. The others are playing it safe and staying unfalsifiable.
- astrange 4y agoSome superdeterministic theories are testable. Some of them aren't, or say things like experiments aren't capable of proving anything in the first place because the universe doesn't obey rules.
- vpfaulkner 4y agoFrom a layman’s point of view, it seems like we grasping at straws when it comes to these thorny quantum questions. Is fair to say, for example, that we are about as clueless as our ancestors were with the bubonic plague? To a non-expert it can be difficult to separate which theories lay on solid ground and which theories are highly speculative.
- resoluteteeth 4y ago> From a layman’s point of view, it seems like we grasping at straws when it comes to these thorny quantum questions. Is fair to say, for example, that we are about as clueless as our ancestors were with the bubonic plague? > To a non-expert it can be difficult to separate which theories lay on solid ground and which theories are highly speculative. Sure, but isn't that the point of doing these experiments?
- vpfaulkner 4y agoI'm all for trying to understand these phenomena and running these experiments. Just trying to get a sense for how much of a grasp we have on these phenomena. Based on the other responses, it seems like we can mathematically model these phenomena very well and make very good predictions. However, when it comes to explaining why these phenomena exist in the first place, we are like a medieval doctor trying to explain why antibiotics work.
- ravi-delia 4y agoThat would not be fair, though it's understandable why a layman might feel that way. The fact is, most physicists don't particularly feel the need to have an explanation for that kind of thing. We have the math, and most people agree on how to use it to make very accurate predictions. Collapse was always a little silly, but there are other possibilities as to why you'd get that kind of effect just from wavefunctions.
- bee_rider 4y ago"It's only a model" Patsy says, but then they cut to a whole big song and dance routine, so it must be a pretty good model. Or course it is unsurprising that Monty Python's Holy Grail would provide deep physics insights, they were a pretty clever bunch.
- iainmerrick 4y agoFalsification is hard work, and rarely reaches a tidy end point. Even now, according to Curceanu, Roger Penrose — who was awarded the 2020 Nobel Prize in Physics for his work on general relativity — is working on a version of the Diósi-Penrose model in which there’s no spontaneous radiation at all. It's incredible how influential Penrose has been for such a long time, and continues to be. As far as I can tell (I'm interested but far from an expert) very few theorists are coming up with genuinely testable ideas in this area.
- lamontcg 4y agoMost scientists either blindly accept collapse as a mechanism and then happily use the highly accurate math and don't care it isn't testable, or if they think about it at all they adopt something untestable like MWI and then happily use the highly accurate math and don't care it isn't testable. Thinking hard about testable theories in this area is incredibly slow progress and doesn't pay a lot of bills (https://www.theguardian.com/science/2013/dec/06/peter-higgs-boson-academic-system https://www.theguardian.com/science/2013/dec/06/peter-higgs-...)
- lebuffon 4y agoDon't tell anyone, but in the back of my mind I wonder if what we call quantum mechanics has something to do with the rendering engine in this simulation we find ourselves in. Is quantum collapse just us "catching" the engine deciding what to render when we observe something? :-)
- macrolocal 4y agoMaybe, but it would be a highly non-classical computer. Probably it could cheaply render the most physically plausible paths to specified outcomes, and quickly factor large primes. Nb. quantum also highlights assumptions made by our brain's rendering engine.
- licnep 4y agoI have very little knowledge of quantum physics, but in my mind there is some similarity between quantum phenomena and backward raytracing in computer graphics. In forward raytracing, images are rendered by "shooting" photons from all lightsources and seeing which ones end up hitting the player's camera. This is similar to what we think happens in nature, but the calculation is extremely inefficient, because the vast majority of photons never hit the player's viewpoint. In backward raytracing, we only shoot "photons" backwards from the player's camera, and see which rays end up hitting a light source. This computation is much more efficient. It makes me wonder if our "simulation" uses a similar shortcut
- phailhaus 4y agoThat's my interpretation as well, except I'd go a step further and say it's time-independent based on what we've seen of quantum entanglement. There's no reason to resolve a particle's state if it's not interacting with anything, but once you do you can safely define the entangled pair's state retroactively because it hasn't interacted with anything either. So what we end up seeing is that after you measure one particle, the other behaves as if it always had the complementary value. It's not faster-than-light spooky action at a distance, it's more akin to reality "resolving" to a consistent time-independent state.
- astrange 4y agoThe tricky part with using quantum physics as evidence for a simulation is that it's weird, but it's only a specific amount of weird. A simulated universe could easily be weirder; why isn't P=NP obviously true?
- royaltheartist 4y agoOh great, now they've got Doom running at the Quantum level
- BirAdam 4y agoI was hoping the article would be about someone experimentally porting Doom to a quantum computer, but… of course not.
- ccvannorman 4y agoNot yet.
- _hcuq 4y agoQuantum mechanics is a useful model in some contexts. It is not reality. Other models are useful in other contexts. Reality is unknownable. But we can always use better models.
- iNic 4y ago"The map is not the territory" - Korzybski
- axilmar 4y agoPerhaps the collapse happens when all the quantum fields are activated at a particular point in their coordinate system. I.e. if we have 3 fields, with respective coordinates [0, 1, 2], [1, 2, 3] and [2, 3, 4], a particle emerges only when the 3rd point of field A, the 2nd point of field B and the 1st point of field C, all with value = 2, are activated. If the quantum field activations happen periodically, but their periods do not match, or the fields have different granularity when they are activated, then we may get a wave-like outcome for particles, since the interactions of all the fields happen only when the fields are synchronized at specific points in their history. EDIT: Writing the above made me realize that the underlying fabrique of the universe may work like a neural net, where each possible point in the universe is actually a node in a neural net, and each node has multiple fields connected to each node, and values flowing into the fields excite the nodes based on a function, for example accumulation. When a limit is exceeded in a node, a particle is created, or a particle disappears (for black holes). A neural net of such proportions could be called ...God (yeah, I said it, sorry...I don't believe in a God but the parallelism is interesting, at least to me, from a philosophical perspective).
- markisus 4y agoThis tidbit about a prodigious undergraduate struck me. He double majored in math and physics and was about to start his PhD at Harvard. And in a sudden freak accident he was gone from existence. The universe will always remain unfathomable in some ways. > In 1996, Qijia Fu of Hamilton College in New York — then just an undergraduate — proposed using germanium-based neutrino experiments to detect a CSL signature of X-ray emission. (Weeks after he submitted his paper, he was struck by lightning on a hiking trip in Utah and killed.)
- addaon 4y agoReminds me of a golden age (?) science fiction short story -- no idea the author or name -- about a spate of suicides and mysterious deaths among physicists who got too close to "the truth," externally caused by an alien force trying to keep humans in their petri dish.
- cbruns 4y agoSounds like Three Body Problem. Not golden age though.
- abecedarius 4y agoIt's an Asimov story whose title I forget. The truth in question was a defense against nuclear bombs.
- HALtheWise 4y agoBreeds There a Man...? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breeds_There_a_Man...%3F https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breeds_There_a_Man...%3F
- addaon 4y agoThat's it! Thanks! Clearly left a mark on my memory.
- 4y ago
- Nihilartikel 4y agoI wasn't expecting them to be able to run Doom on a quantum computer for at least another decade!
- immmmmm 4y agoas a former physicist and quake engine modder, your joke is very nice:) more seriously, having spent countless nights thinking of QM, it feels a bit like Nature is playing w you and your nerves.
- mkaic 4y agoLooking forward to the PBS Spacetime coverage of these experiments in about 2 weeks time, I'm sure they'll do an excellent job explaining them.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sillysaurusx 4y agoReplying to a now-deleted comment: > Is there a good ... idiots guide to interpretation of quantum weirdness ? I am more than a little lost I’ve got you covered. And believe it or not, you’ll be joining Tiktok University today: https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZTRHqk6MP/ https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZTRHqk6MP/ Tiktok has been quietly amassing a huge library of educational content, and I’ve been diligently sorting those into collections. I’ll post several more related to physics. https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZTRHqLx2k/ https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZTRHqLx2k/ https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZTRHqBn2L/ https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZTRHqBn2L/ Why entangled electrons can’t communicate information: https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZTRHqBCLq/ https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZTRHqBCLq/ Heisenberg uncertainty principle: https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZTRHq8XN3/ https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZTRHq8XN3/ https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZTRHqY49j/ https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZTRHqY49j/ A more advanced one: https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZTRHq2pYS/ https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZTRHq2pYS/ And a break from quantum weirdness, just ‘cause I like it: https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZTRHqBQHE https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZTRHqBQHE I have pages and pages of videos, so I probably shouldn’t spam them here. I can post more if there’s any interest.
- macintux 4y agoPerhaps a GitHub gist? I have a few collections that I share here that way.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dmix 4y agoI often post on HN that TikTok offers much more to the world than videos of girls dancing and silly pranks. It gives people what they want (for better or worse) and adapts very very quickly to tastes. Once it learns you're a science nerd it fills your feed with some high quality educational content like this. The chemistry stuff they have is also A+.
- awinter-py 4y agough the actual news event being covered in this article is a 2022 result[1] confirming a 2020 result[2] both of which 'set a lower bound' on this theory by penrose. 'set a lower bound' means they didn't find it. this article is credulous -- yes, this may exist and semi-serious people are looking for it, but pls don't confuse 'we haven't found it yet' with 'current science suggests this is very small'. how small?! at least admit that your theory doesn't predict an energy level. 'Current science suggests that bigfoot dwells in the places we have not yet looked'. Also put the newest paper in the first paragraph, don't make me dig through recirc links, ugh. 1. https://journals.aps.org/prl/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevLett.129.080401 https://journals.aps.org/prl/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevLett.12... 2. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41567-020-1008-4 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41567-020-1008-4
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- masteranza 4y agoThis article is a perfect example how science is getting led into dark areas by people who didn't learn quantum mechanics right or people who pretend to understand it, but can only blindly follow the formalism without much understanding of what they actually do. Every such article continuous to mysticize the whole subject by quoting famous scientists who were either puzzled by it at the time or scientists like John von Neumann who clearly gave a dumbed down view of the now called collapse (perhaps on request to skip the math). I really appreciate this forum - as it is one of the last places that I know of where one can have a civil discussion - and therefore I will take the effort to show that pure quantum mechanics - with no additions - essentially explains the process of measurement which is not at all sudden as the name "collapse" would suggest. The reasoning comes from von Neumann himself, but now sometimes it's attributed also to Wojciech Żurek. TLDR of below: All processes in nature, including the measuring process are unitary, the "collapse" is just an artifact of our ignorance about the exact state of the measuring aparatus. Here it goes: For simplicity, let's assume that psi describing our particle is a superposition of two eigenstates: |psi> = c1 |1> + c2 |2>, i.e., |c1|^2 + |c2|^2 = 1. Without loss of generality we can pick: c1 = x and c2 = sqrt(1-x^2) exp(i phi), where x is a real number smaller than 1. The density matrix of this pure state can then be written as rho = |psi><psi| and one by writing the explicit form of this density matrix one can see that the diagonal terms are: x^2 and 1-x^2, while the non-diagonal terms are: xsqrt(1-x^2) exp(i phi) and xsqrt(1-x^2) exp(-i phi). In the most complete scenario of a measurement, the density matrix of the system can change change in many ways including the diagonal terms of the density matrix. However in this simplistic example, a measurement will by necessity, bring only the non-diagonal terms to zero (I hope most of the interested readers will have enough background to understand why). Now, the measuring device, as a macroscopic object, will have the number of degrees of freedom far greater than the simple particle which's state we're about to measure. This number will be the order of the Avogadro number (~ 10^23) - even the smallest human visible indicator will be this big. The measurement, by necessity, includes an interaction of our small system with the enormous measuring device. Before the interaction the whole system (the particle and the measuring device) can be written as a tensor product of the two wavefunctions: |Omega_before> = |Psi> ⊗ |Xsi> = ( c1 |1> + c2 |2> ) ⊗ |Xsi> where |Xsi> represents the wavefunction of the measuring device and everything it interacts with before the measurement. When the interaction occurs the state of our measuring device changes unitarily (as everything in nature) according to the full Hamiltonian of the system, and with some regrouping of the terms, we can write the state after the interaction as: |Omega_after> = c1 |1> ⊗ |Xsi_1> + c2 |2> ⊗ |Xsi_2> This is the true state of the system as performed by nature. The individual subsystems are no longer in pure states, but the whole system |Omega_after> (if we're able to completely describe it) - is. Now, comes the final part, which some call the "collapse", but in reality it is just "an average" over all possible states of the bigger (measurement) system *which we declared apriori to not be the system of interest and states of which not able to follow because we measure with it*: Tr_{over the degrees of freedom of Xsi} |Omega_after><Omega_after| In result we obtain a matrix after the measurement which is just formed with the diagonal elements x^2 and 1-x^2, i.e., the probabilities of the two measurement results and non-diagonal terms being equal to zero. Why are they zero? Let's inspect one of the non-diagonal elements over which the above trace is taken: x*sqrt(1-x^2)exp(i phi) <Xsi_1|Xsi_2> It is effectively zero, because the trace over the degrees of freedom of Xsi is a mutliple integral, again of the multiplicity of order of Avogardo number and a similar number functions which change in various ways. It is enough that only a fraction of such integrals will have a value lesser than 1 to guarantee that the product will be equal to zero. And this is all. Any attempt to change this fact would need to reject quantum mechanics completely, because probability calculus is at the heart of it.
- EGreg 4y agoI like PWT because other theories don’t rule out FTL propagation of things, either, and PWT just assumes it. It is far less weird than for example the many worlds explanation.
- hilbert42 4y ago"If there is indeed a background perturbation that provokes quantum collapse — whether it comes from gravitational effects or something else — then all particles will be continuously interacting with this perturbation, whether they are in a superposition or not." This makes eminent sense to me. I have a notion that I'll try to present in its simplest form which is that a quantum system exists in background 'sea' or 'substrate' akin to random noise whose maximum fluctuations are of themselves insufficient to disturb or perturb said quantum system. Without this noise an 'event' such as a particle, photon etc. would perturb the quantum system in a predictable way thus it would 'collapse' into a predictable outcome (according to understood physics). As the noisy substrate permeates and superimposes on everything it randomizes the 'collapse'. Of course, we'd have to invoke notions such as virtual particles zero point energy, Casimir-like effects—even then, saying that is a gross oversimplification without much additional amplification. Perhaps it's best just to say that essentially a noisy fluctuating background environment would perturb and randomize an otherwise predictable quantum system. Again, like many of these theories, I've little to support my idea except intuition—and with quantum mechanics relying on it is a very dangerous thing to do.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pjdorrell 4y agoThe results of these experiments indirectly tell us something about our chances of ever meeting aliens: * No physical collapse => Everett interpretation AKA "many worlds" * Many worlds gives us the Anthropic Principle for free * The Anthropic Principle explains the origin of the first living organism, or, to put it another way, the observed existence of the origin of our first living ancestor does _not_ set any lower bound on the probability of the first living organism developing from non-living molecules. * A very low probability of the origin of life implies the non-existence of any other life in the observable universe. * Therefore, no aliens. (The aliens do of course exist in other parts of the total Universal Wave Function, but we never get to meet them.)
- ummonk 4y agoIt should be noted that the Everett many worlds model is impossible due to the nonlinearity of gravity - different worlds cannot exist independently of each other without interacting gravitationally - you’d get the kind of collapse that Penrose’s theory predicted. Given these experiments, there isn’t any obvious theory that squares the kind of wavefunction collapse we observe with the nonlinearity of gravity.
- richardfey 4y ago> If there is indeed a background perturbation that provokes quantum collapse [...] then all particles will be continuously interacting with this perturbation, whether they are in a superposition or not. This reminds me of how our own heart's peacemaker works.
- guerby 4y agoWhile reading about the various QM experiments I've always wondered why people use the word "measurement" for what looks more like to me as "particle collision with large enough macroscopic effect to be seen by human". A few QM experiments: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double-slit_experiment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double-slit_experiment Little dots on the screen are some collision with a macroscopic visible effect. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stern%E2%80%93Gerlach_experiment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stern%E2%80%93Gerlach_experime... Silver atoms going one way or another again on a screen and little dots. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aspect%27s_experiment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aspect%27s_experiment Detectors probably some collision again and counting or imaging apparatus. And of course a collision is a physically mostly discrete event so no one would question wether there's a need for an "observer" for it. Would love to be pointed at some QM where there's no collision or similar discrete event for "measurement" as I'm a total noob in QM :).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]