4 ms·
I don't think the article's argument justifies the idea that fewer cars will be sold. Cars wear out primarily through driving. If you simply switched to automa
by joe_the_user 15y ago
I don't think the article's argument justifies the idea that fewer cars will be sold.
Cars wear out primarily through driving. If you simply switched to automatic driving, what you would have is fewer cars being driven more often and so being worn more quickly. If car-mile consumption stays the same, new-car production would stay the same.
On the other hand, if the auto-drive cars increased carpooling, then you'd see a decrease in car-miles consumed and so a decrease in production. But if auto-drive cars drove around empty more, you might have even more car-miles being consumed.
Moreover, you'd have a "big bang" where people decide to mostly stop driving the old, non-automatically-driving cars and so there'd a huge spike in consumption at that point.
The space saved by avoiding parking could be really large, still.
A nice thing would be that at the start, a person might be able to finance their self-driving car by renting in out when they didn't need it. Those economies might make the phenomena spread really quickly.
- prophetjohn 15y agoIf you simply switched to automatic driving, what you would have is fewer cars being driven more often and so being worn more quickly At the very least, I expect that would be offset by some amount by the fact that automatic cars are going to be driven in a much more efficient and car-friendly manner than they are when a human is operating it with their imperfect motor skills, their ego, their laziness, etc. The way the cars operate would be (or at least could be) algorithmically optimized so that all those little things you're encouraged to do (like pretend there is a glass of water on the dash when you're driving, etc.), actually happen.
- fragsworth 15y agoAlso, once Jiffy Lube starts accepting driverless cars, you would see oil changes and maintenance done on a more regular basis since you wouldn't have to drive it to the shop, further extending the lifespan of the vehicles.
- toomuchtodo 15y agoOil changes can easily be automated. Electric vehicles? All they need is a parking spot to automatically pull into and charge at until required to move to their next waypoint.
- jacques_chester 15y agoThe passenger-mile invariance would be offset by the selection of different design tradeoffs. For example, most driver cars have far more performance "on tap" than will be used in the entire lifetime of the car. Such performance is not free. It causes engineering tradeoffs that increase maintenance costs, complexity and of course reduced fuel efficiency. But it's easier to sell a driver car with some oomph than not. There will be other design tradeoffs you and I have not thought of (and could not think of) that will add up to further efficiencies.
- kkowalczyk 15y agoThe article might not but I think that it would totally happen. My assumption here is that there would emerge a big car provider who would provide those cars, similar to how there's only few major car rentals, or how ZipCar is leading in its category or even how Uber emerges as a single taxi-like provider. The economies of scale are very big here. Given that, some things you have not accounted for: Higher average utilization per car. I don't know how much commute traffic accounts for total traffic, but by judging rush traffic on 580, it's quite a lot. Most of those people go from the same location (e.g. SF) to the same location (e.g. Mountain View) and today most of them drive alone. Today 4 or 5 of them would be scheduled by an algorithm to use the same car. Because of that the cars would get re-designed for a higher capacity (at least 8-10 people) or even straight up buses. A big provider would have so much data that they could optimize the hell out of sharing cars. Similarly, the cars would utilized, on average, much better. Again, a company with enough data could really optimize for a lifetime of a car and they would have economic incentives to do so (unlike a single customer for whom even gathering the necessary data would be cost prohibitive). Our cars are, without a question, utilized very inefficiently. Someone operating a fleet of tens of thousands of cars would have not only economic incentive but also necessary data and necessary transaction volume to optimize per-car utilization, because for them it would translate directly into large savings.
- learc83 15y agoI can't upvote this enough, people seem stuck in their concept of what a car is. Without a driver we are free to redesign cars in so many ways. We no longer need to worry about designing it so that the driver can see every angle, so we can design more efficient seating layouts. We can even add partitions so the 10 passengers don't have to see each other. Long distance deliver vehicles can operate at lower fuel efficient speeds. We can combine delivery and passenger vehicles. The list is endless.
- wcarss 15y agoIn fact, many transit systems do combine delivery and passenger vehicles -- greyhound has a package delivery service. To your other point: I think that assuming we'll go off the wall and design wacky new vehicles is too optimistic, akin to the "cities of the future" envisioned during the past hundred years. People's sensibilities of "what makes a car look nice" and "what is a metal box I'd like to sit in" seem to be pretty set, and we don't have a very different experience in a train or on a bus today than in a car. Face forward or backward in a seat with big windows and high visibility. Part of that is for your senses to not freak out, part of it is just that it's cheap and easy, and part of it is that experiments in the form-factor don't need to be done, so they aren't done. I expect the same trend will continue unless flukes occur.