17 ms·
Google is forcing us to make our open source VoIP app worse
- mvletter 4y agoThe power they have vs the responsibility they take is completely out of balance.
- SpaceL10n 4y agoThat can be good thing, imo. Young people have little power to change the world around them, yet they take responsibility for "making the world a better place". I find it inspiring when companies do this too.
- yuvalr1 4y agoAlas Google does the exact opposite - they have a lot of power (they essentially verdict an app to life or death, which sometimes means the death of the business), but take very little responsibility for their actions towards app developers.
- encryptluks2 4y agoLOL... I can see Apple developers saying something like this while theu write about it on their even more limited and lockdowned devices.
- user3939382 4y agoYou can agree that company X does Y thing wrong without deciding that you will make unlimited practical sacrifices in your life to support that position. If I cut my relationship with every institution I have an ethical problem with, I'd be living in the middle of the woods in a hut.
- BlueTemplar 4y agoThankfully it's nowhere that radical, and we can avoid both Android and iOS and build towards a better future, thanks to the recent revival of "real" Linux smartphones.
- dspillett 4y agoThis sort of thing is why I intend to never write a mobile app for Google/Apple/other devices. Though as I never get around to writing my many desktop or web-based app ideas, maybe this isn't much of a problem for Google/Apple/other!
- webmobdev 4y agoYeah. I bought a Mac, an iPad and an iPhone to do mobile development for ios. And then I realised how screwed up and exploitive the whole Apple ecosystem is for developers - they not only want us to pay them annually for the "privilege" of developing on their platform (even though we add value to their platform by creating software for it), but they also want to charge us a commission on each sale (with the bar that we can't tell our customers that the price is higher because of the "Apple Tax"). I decided not to support their platform. And after reading many tales of developers struggle with the illogical bureaucracy of the "app stores", I feel that I made the right decision. I understand the Google ecosystem is similar, but slightly more bearable because Android allows side-loading. Waiting for the day when legislation / regulation upholds our consumer and computing rights to develop, install and run software on our own devices without ever needing permission from the device makers.
- pedro2 4y agoNever? Unless you give up on NFC, banking apps and all those goodies.
- arsome 4y agoWe've had NFC, banking, etc on rooted phones and even on windows desktops loaded with malware for decades now. Clearly there's a tradeoff that can be made here and the banks still find it worthwhile to offer the extra features and save money on staff even if it occasionally causes fraud.
- pedro2 4y agoYes but it is troublesome and AFAIK getting more difficult each year.
- ziddoap 4y agoI'm not familiar with mobile app review process, would any change in code require a re-review/re-submit? If Google approved it as-is, could the developers add a few lines as an "update" and skip over the full review process? Seems like the ruling is being made on what can be done with the current permissions, rather than what is being done. If that's the case, I sympathize with the devs but I think I support the position Google is taking there. Off-topic comment: I use NoScript, and the entire text of the article renders for a half second before disappearing and for some inexplicable reason requiring JS to be enabled. If you can render it for that half second, why hide it? Why force me to use JS when you just proved that you can render it without?
- Marsymars 4y ago> I'm not familiar with mobile app review process, would any change in code require a re-review/re-submit? Yes.
- jsnell 4y agoIt does sound like they're batch-copying the entire contact book into their app at startup, rather than using the Android contact picker. The static analysis problem of determining whether there is / isn't a batch import seems a lot easier than determining with certainty what happens with the contacts after they were saved to disk. Though the article doesn't actually show any screenshots from the review emails, but just paraphrases them, so we don't even know that their interpretation of the rejection reason is correct.
- TheNorthman 4y agoThis could, of course, be an explanation. Except for the _stated fact_ that after they removed the batch import, they were still rejected.
- jefftk 4y agoI don't see where they say they removed batch import? Just that they removed caching. I don't think they're using the default contact picker?
- squarefoot 4y agoThe mobile ecosystem has been built with the sole intent of milking users through targeted advertising, media consumption and unnecessary services subscription, so I find normal that corporations behind the OSes fight hard to maintain the platform as closed as possible (proprietary or seemingly open OSes, closed drivers, locked bootloaders etc). Their deepest fear is seeing their ecosystem conquered by Open Source, or for that matter any other kind of scenario (shareware, donationware, etc) in which users and developers are directly in contact and no middleman is necessary anymore.
- Andrex 4y agoOh man, you should have seen the mobile sphere before Android...
- naikrovek 4y agono joke. what a hellhole that was.
- acdha 4y agoBefore iOS, to be fair. Touchscreens got the attention but the use of the iPod’s popularity to negotiate a non-terrible cellular market was equally transformative. The carriers used to charge something on the order of $50k each to be listed in their app stores and their percentage of revenue was high and negotiated based on your perceived ability to pay: we had several clients bail on J2ME projects because they were being asked to take home less than half of each sale and making 6-7 figure minimum profit commitments to each carrier! The sales person would look at their total corporate revenue to base their first offer on, and they were not quick to negotiate down to our actual budget.
- Traubenfuchs 4y ago> Analytics cookies are installed on this website to enhance your browsing experience. Such cookies are only used to optimise this website’s performance and enhance user experience. It is not possible to disable analytics cookies on this website. Now that's just a lie and you know it. Is this legal?
- Marsymars 4y ago“It is not possible” isn’t used by companies to mean “it isn’t physically possible”, it’s used to mean “it isn’t supported by our processes”. (I’ve been in a frustrating back-and-forth over the past couple days with a company who’s quoting me an outrageous shipping fee, and keeps telling me it’s “impossible” to ship with a different delivery service.)
- earleybird 4y agoCan't vs won't.
- MaxikCZ 4y agoIIRC: At least in Europe, they needn't ask for essential cookies. They need to ask for cookies used for tracking, profiling, fingerprinting and consent to share collected info with third parties. The rules also state that the path to reject those cookies must be as easy as it is to accept them, so if they have "accept all" button, they are required to also provide "reject all" button, that has similar visibility and accessibility to the "accept" button. IIRC At least in EU, what they do is illegal and dark pattern, and hence personally I have no reason to believe their side of story on any topic.
- dwaite 4y ago> The rules also state that the path to reject those cookies must be as easy as it is to accept them, so if they have "accept all" button, they are required to also provide "reject all" button, that has similar visibility and accessibility to the "accept" button. The rules also say that you have to be able to _withdraw_ your consent as easily as you provided it, which IMHO 99% of cookie banners fail to provide for.
- AlexandrB 4y agoWith the exception of Signal, I never give apps access to my contacts. If you think that's paranoid, remember how apps like LinkedIn used this kind of information in the past[1]. Thankfully on iOS apps almost always work without contact access (is this mandated by App Store rules?). It's not clear from the article if the app just asks for access to contacts or requires it, but if you can't make your Voip app work without accessing my contact list, I don't want to use it. [1] https://www.theverge.com/2013/9/21/4756212/linkedin-accused-of-hacking-user-email-lawsuit https://www.theverge.com/2013/9/21/4756212/linkedin-accused-...
- thebeardisred 4y agoWhile I don't doubt that you never give apps access to your contacts, how many apps do you use as _dialers_?
- londons_explore 4y agoiOS doesn't even let you change the dialer.
- avisser 4y agoI have Google voice on my iPhone. Google voice calls show up in my "Recents" in the Phone app. When I click them, the call is started in Google Voice. That feels like changing the dialer, even if it's technically not.
- scarface74 4y agoThird party dialing apps integrate with contacts, the dialer, your call history etc.
- cmsj 4y agoAbsolutely the same here. WhatsApp is a nightmare to use without contacts, but I don't care, they are not having my contacts.
- 4y ago
- grishka 4y agoThankfully the use of Google Play is not mandatory. You could as well distribute your app from your website and make it update itself — you know, just like people did for ages with desktop software.
- turminal 4y agoYeah, good luck with that. Nearly nobody installs apps from outside Google Play.
- naikrovek 4y agothat's not exactly true, though of course I don't have numbers. maybe that is something you just don't see a lot, but that happens often?
- mixedCase 4y agoLook up the Epic/Fortnite situation and the only conclusion from its development and Epic's decisions is that it almost never happens and unless your market is exclusively techies you'd be foolish to consider it viable as your sole release channel.
- naikrovek 4y agois that why Epic required you to sideload the game for the first couple of years of its life? because no one sideloads?
- mixedCase 4y agoThey tried to make it its main distribution channel to avoid having to pay Play Store fees. They ceased doing it because it was much harder to acquire customers via sideloading despite the product being motherhugging Fortnite than it was to pay the tax on every "micro" transaction.
- grishka 4y ago
- pomatic 4y agoI was intrigued by the prospect of a foss voip phone app that's cross platform - but was unable to find the repo. for the app (libary repos are available and obvious, just not the app as a whole). Anyone know where it lives?
- captainzidgel 4y agoThe website calls it the Voys app but I think it's actually called Vialer: https://github.com/open-voip-alliance/vialer https://github.com/open-voip-alliance/vialer It's the only full app in their repo and it fits the description they gave on the website.
- csdvrx 4y agoDoes it work with twilio sip trunking?
- chooma 4y agoIndeed, the Voys app is a white-label version of Vialer. See: https://github.com/open-voip-alliance/vialer/blob/9e81baffc3086d84ac83d1ecabb8df87fd25b454/lib/domain/user/brand.dart#L75 https://github.com/open-voip-alliance/vialer/blob/9e81baffc3...
- pwg 4y agoDoes Linphone (https://linphone.org/ https://linphone.org/) not meet that need of cross platform (website claims versions for all major OS'es) and open source (https://gitlab.linphone.org/BC/public/linphone-desktop https://gitlab.linphone.org/BC/public/linphone-desktop)?
- chunk_waffle 4y agoIf this is at all like the Chrome Extension review process, having a privacy policy that is clearly written and describes that you don't upload any contact info (as well as what info you do upload) might go a long way.
- secretsatan 4y agoI kinda sorta see google’s side. There are just too many shady operators out there who will swear blind they’re completely honest, and maybe they are, but they also employed a third party to write code or maybe just imported a 3rd party lib (i am in no way saying this is the case) As to, why don’t they look at the code? bugger that being standard practise, i’m not handing over my code to google or apple. Even if they did, how to check final the uploaded binary? I’m not doubting the article, but the mobile app world is flooded with shady operators at all levels, and i don’t really buy the real paranoid arguments here
- smeagull 4y agoYou're right, Google have long been incompetent at managing user generated anything. They should probably stop building things that depend on it, because they're so bad at it.
- asdff 4y agoAt the same time, why not just release at least one phone that is developer friendly? People can handle it. All these issues are present on computers that are able to run unsigned code, have sensitive personal info stored on them, etc. Yet the sky is not falling with all this going on with everyone's computer on earth, like how people fear the sky will fall if we opened up the mobile phone.
- jtvjan 4y agoIt's easy to install unsigned apps on Android, but not being on the Play Store severely limits your reach, since many people only check there for apps instead of searching on the open web.
- ericlnu 4y agoFDroid
- secretsatan 4y agoThey keep making them but they keep failing, because people want phones that work without needing a computer science degree to understand what is safe and what isn’t. And myself being an apple guy with a dev account, i can install pretty much what i want
- shadowgovt 4y agoInteresting (and disquieting). I can see this from Google's standpoint also... I don't expect them to shoulder the cost of interpreting a binary blob by decompiling it, so they're left with the problem that the trust calculus is that they're observing a user doing something with very sensitive user information in a binary blob they can't introspect. Hypothetically, one possible workaround (that definitely wouldn't work for all companies and requires more trust of Google than many will be comfortable with) would be to offer a feature where the package uploaded to Google for hosting on the Play Store includes source code and they compile it to native... But then you have the problem that a company will have to exfiltrate source code to a third party (even though the third party is the one with total control over their app's existence in the largest Android store).
- saagarjha 4y agoSource code can be just as difficult to analyze as compiled code, especially if you’re trying to do automated analysis on it.
- jasonjayr 4y agoIIRC, if they attempt to 'hack' this by falsely claiming they are uploading the contacts, they might be on the hook in the future if Google expands the scope of their mandatory pentests: https://cloud.google.com/blog/products/g-suite/elevating-user-trust-in-our-api-ecosystems https://cloud.google.com/blog/products/g-suite/elevating-use...
- donmcronald 4y ago> We even sue governments for protecting the privacy of our users. Lost in translation?
- lhobas 4y agoNo: Voys is a Dutch company with a South African counterpart. Their Dutch entity sued the Dutch government for not providing enough clarity on how mandatory call logs get processed on the government side.
- zerocrates 4y agoI think they meant that the text "We even sue governments for protecting the privacy of our users" probably should have been "We even sue governments to protect the privacy of our users," or "...for not protecting the privacy...," etc.
- chooma 4y agoThat's indeed what they tried to say, but they translated it very Dunglish. [1] blog story: https://www.voys.nl/blog/voys-wint-rechtszaak-van-agentschap-telecom-en-eerste-eindklanten-maken-melding-van-schending-privacy-bij-autoriteit-persoonsgegevens/ https://www.voys.nl/blog/voys-wint-rechtszaak-van-agentschap...
- outworlder 4y agoProbably not a translation, confusing for/to is pretty common for non-native speakers. (Native speakers on the other hand will say 'loose' vs 'lose', 'rouge' vs 'rogue', or even 'could/should of')
- bombcar 4y agoFun fact, almost all VOIP in the USA comes through Bandwidth.com https://www.bandwidth.com/voice/voip-origination/ https://www.bandwidth.com/voice/voip-origination/
- betwixthewires 4y agoSo put it in f-droid.
- mixedCase 4y agoAnd nobody will use it because third party stores are discouraged by the operating system's UX.
- betwixthewires 4y agoLots of people use f-droid. It's as easy as installing f-droid from browser and then checking a box in settings.
- mixedCase 4y agoI am aware. I'm one of them. Unfortunately us "lots of people" are still probably <0.1% of Android users.
- betwixthewires 4y agoBut that's not "discouraged by the system UX" and what better way to get people to use f-droid than offering incentives to use it? Like your favorite app having better features when installed from there?
- mixedCase 4y agoSorry, but if you do not believe getting security warnings, having to go into the settings and mangle with configuration, just to be able to install a store downloaded from a website, sometimes go through additional configuration depending on your phone's modifications (looking at you Xiaomi) to then install the actual program you wanted is not "discouraged by the system UX", despite the real world experiences of companies who have tried even simpler things and failed, I'm not sure we can agree on what's viable or not.
- j45 4y agoWith Rust and WA emerging it will be interesting to see how long it takes to get a voip client as a PWA that just runs in the browser. WebOS when with Palm was ahead of it's time from a software perspective and couldn't get the hardware out. The ability for all apps to be JS/HTML only with WebOS would be super interesting.
- jeroenhd 4y agoTo get that to work, you'd need to run some kind of WebRTC-to-SIP proxy which would be abused to hell and back. There seems to be an abandoned open source project that you can use to do this: https://github.com/saycel/Saycel.Phone https://github.com/saycel/Saycel.Phone 3cx also seems to have built a web app for their SIP product: https://www.3cx.com/blog/releases/web-client-pwa/ https://www.3cx.com/blog/releases/web-client-pwa/ No need to get Rust or WASM involved. Built-in browser support should allow you to do this stuff with just Javascript.
- j45 4y agoThere’s def web clients already out there. I’ve seen satchel, just haven’t come across an actively developed one. Jssip is a neat library but not a client: https://jssip.net/ https://jssip.net/ Twilio also has a web client. Taking a cursory search of WebAssembly for voip shows some activity: Webrtc is a little old and using webassembly to introduce other codecs isn’t entirely new or novel: https://cloudtweaks.com/2020/08/deep-customization-webrtc/ https://cloudtweaks.com/2020/08/deep-customization-webrtc/ Blazer allows using webassembly to make calls from twilio: https://www.twilio.com/blog/making-phone-calls-from-blazor-webassembly-with-twilio-voice https://www.twilio.com/blog/making-phone-calls-from-blazor-w... Another neat use for webassembly and audio is audio production say for podcasts with multiple callers that makes editing a bit easier. https://superpowered.com/js-wasm-overview https://superpowered.com/js-wasm-overview Noise cancellation and other dsp effects are something webassembly can meaningfully help with. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30568164 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30568164
- r_hoods_ghost 4y agoAhh a privacy oriented company, that won't allow you to opt out of their analytic cookies this breaking the law in the EU. Or in other words, not privacy oriented at all.
- enriquec 4y agoeurope's cookie fiasco is so idiotic - why don't you just disable them in your browser if you care?
- Nextgrid 4y agoBecause the EU knows that you don't need cookies or client cooperation to track people as there is enough information the client sends (and has to send for functional purposes - think IP address, user-agent, browser fingerprint) to reidentify it down the line even without a persistent identifier. If you think clearing cookies will defuse industrial-scale spyware from the likes of Facebook, Google or the various data brokers: 1) Don't waste your time clearing them; modern browsers already heavily restrict third-party cookie access and clear them on their own 2) I have a bridge to sell you
- atriix 4y agothe irony of that, is that all to many times, one must enable cookies to be able to dismiss the, often full screen takeover, cookie notice to "disable" cookies
- Nextgrid 4y agoNon-compliant & dumb implementations doesn't mean the law itself is bad. The problem is a major lack of enforcement.
- gunapologist99 4y agoA lack of enforcement is definitely not the problem. Stated as the inverse, what would more enforcement solve? And, even if it was a solution, what would this additional enforcement actually enforce? A poorly written law, apparently designed to introduce additional friction into simple web browsing, with porous and easily-evaded definitions and vague goals that only apply to a tiny fraction of planetary inhabitants? (Because that seems to be the actual problem.)
- Nifty3929 4y agoAt the risk of stating the obvious, developers are not the customers. Android has millions of customers who benefit from Google's attempt to prevent misuse and abuse. It is far from perfect - but a bias toward protecting the end-user and their data is the correct choice. In this case, there is a "false positive" where Google thinks something bad is happening when it isn't. They see that contacts are being touched, but they don't know what is being done with that data and assume the worst (as they should). It would be nice if the accuracy could be dialed-up by inspecting code or other manual processes, but this is labor intensive and therefore expensive for society as a whole, regardless of who pays the price (devs, Google, or users). Question for Voys: If there was a service where for $10k/yr you had a white-glove app-approval service from Google/Android/Play where they do actually inspect your code, would you pay for it? Maybe you would, and maybe there's a good market there. I don't know.
- gg82 4y agoOf course having Google preventing misuse and abuse is a bit like having a fox guard the henhouse!
- godshatter 4y agoCan they put it on f-droid and point their users there? Downside is that users don't know what f-droid is and have to install it, upside is they find a new "app store" that has some new techy things on it. Not sure if f-droid gets around having to tell your phone it can run third-party apps, but if it does that would be a win as well. I didn't see in the post if they sell this or give it away.
- danuker 4y agoCompletely open source means no place for supposedly secret Firebase Messaging credentials, which requires developers to bend over backwards, if they want reasonably quick notifications: https://github.com/deltachat/deltachat-android/issues/82 https://github.com/deltachat/deltachat-android/issues/82
- indrora 4y agoAll this makes me yearn for the days of Windows 10 Mobile again. I built a very simple websocket based app and there was not only support for "you need a long lived TCP connection and occasionally might need to read from it" but "you need background services that might depend on the state of the radio" and more. Honestly it was an absolute dream to develop for, and it's a damn shame upper management seems to have had a fit that they weren't winning out of the gate.
- dna_polymerase 4y agoWhy do they need to cache contacts ‘locally’. Are they usually stored in the cloud?
- nnopepe 4y agoGiven that their site thinks itself above GDPR I'm inclined to believe google
- zbuf 4y agoCan you be more specific?
- z3t4 4y agoJust release the apk from your website
- rasz 4y agoI was with you all the way to >We are now decrypting network traffic to show that we are not doing anything with the contacts, what network traffic? You said its a local phone dialer ...
- kyelewis 4y agoIt’s a VoIP app, network traffic is likely.
- yazzku 4y agoTwo companies should not decide what goes in and out of the mobile ecosystem, or we need to stop non-standard and proprietary ecosystems from becoming a social norm and building infrastructure on top of them.
- duxup 4y agoPersonally I would associate access to my contacts with the ability to just upload it. No reason version 2 can’t do the thing after they upgrade and I already gave permission in version 1.
- hedora 4y agoWell, the app review people could do their jobs and approve version 1, then check version 2. It is open source, giving them even fewer excuses.
- duxup 4y agoI don’t think that is how the permissions work and to as the app review people to validate every other promise seems absurd. If the app can see the data, it’s over already.
- dima_vm 4y agoFrom my past experience, both Google and Apple fervently defend their built-in caller app, and really-really don't like any other app making regular voice calls. Part of that is that they don't want cloning (they clearly state that your caller app must look obviously different from default system one), which is understandable, but even when it clearly not a clone, they make take it pretty hard, it feels like they would rather just ban it.
- sophacles 4y ago> Dear Google. We are one of the most privacy-conscious companies you can find. I think I found the reason Google is rejecting your app.
- savy91 4y agoWe develop a banking app for families (parents and kids). 2 weeks ago we had to remove the possibility to pick phone contacts to invite other family members because Google claimed we were uploading contacts to our servers (which we did not). We appealed and it did not work. We then complied with their request and added to the privacy policy they we have access to the contacts and we might process them, and yet Google still rejected our app. In the end we just decided to completely remove every code from the app that would allow us to read the contacts on the phone. This has now made our app UX worse for the 60% of users who used this feature. Also, mind that we of course offered the option to never grant this permission so nobody was ever forced to give access to their address book.
- davidhyde 4y ago
- veeti 4y agoThe parent comment literally says that their users always had the choice, but don't let me interrupt your knee jerk reaction. > A win win for everyone is if Google allowed the user to turn this feature on manually in settings post app install but they don’t do that. That is exactly how the Android permission model already works. But now Google/Play Store is enforcing additional restrictions on developers that use these permissions.
- davidhyde 4y agoOh, I wasn’t aware of this. Call it an uninformed reaction, oops. Thanks for pointing out my mistake! Maybe this post will be helpful for iPhone users who think that android users have no control until it’s already too late (I thought that, by default, contacts could already be uploaded before permissions could be revoked by the user)
- striking 4y agoUsers can decline the permission. Additionally it sounds like this was an optional part of the flow ("possibility")
- psykus 4y agoIs Google seriously just run by AI at this point? I imagine at some point up the middle management chain it’s just a layer of AI making decisions that no one has the authority to override. Similar to how Amazon warehouse workers say that they’re working for an algorithm at this point making hiring/firing decisions.
- kaushikc 4y agoAmazon runs on hire quickly and fire quickly policy (many other businesses have already copied this style of recruitment), which is why they are finding themselves running out of massive pools of workers.
- clcaev 4y agoPerhaps phones need an API so an application may request a single contact's information as selected by the user, without exposing the entire phone book?
- binkHN 4y agoThis API exists in Android.
- savy91 4y agoIn many phone brands using the PICK_CONTACT intent still requires the READ_CONTACTS permission, which allows to read all contacts. There is also an issue opened for this [1] [1] https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/118400813?pli=1 https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/118400813?pli=1
- binkHN 4y agoDo you have a list of the affected brands?
- savy91 4y agoI do not. I can tell you that a Xiaomi device I tested was not affected. All Samsung devices I tested as well as Realme (and therefore I assume also Oneplus and Oppo) are affected. This issues also hints that at least 4 years ago it was an Android issue and therefore all phones were affected. A lot of users still use phones from 4 years ago that have not been updated to the latest Android version by the manufacturer. Also, in the issue comments some commenters say that it still happens in Android 11 and Android 10 which at this point are the Android versions that the majority of users have on their phones. So, to answer your questions in short: all brands who released phones 4 years ago and have not updated the OS with an Android version with the fix can be considered "affected brands". It is a "best case scenario" because it appears also devices with the latest updates still show the same bug (the Realme and Samsung devices I tested were all running on at least Android 10).
- qwerty456127 4y agoThe problem is the same as always - automated bullshit black-holing instead of thoughtful review and constructive communication a human could do. Perhaps the latter is impossible (or maybe this is another bullshit) for companies with userbases this huge but do we really need such in the first place?
- taneq 4y agoIt’s very difficult to convince a marketing behemoth that their automated systems are harmful when those automated systems’ errors drive users towards said behemoth’s own offerings.
- r2sk5t 4y agoWe had this issue and went back and forth with Google for weeks with no progress. It was infuriating, since the peeps on the other end just cut and pasted responses. Then, we hashed the Contacts before uploading them and our app was immediately approved. Subsequently, they decided to ding us on this permission "QUERY_ALL_PACKAGES", which we needed for inviting people you know to our app. Since we were so beaten down, we removed that feature. Congrats Google!
- esprehn 4y agoWhy do you need to know every app installed on the device to invite people you know?
- r2sk5t 4y agoBecause we were using this: https://github.com/EddyVerbruggen/SocialSharing-PhoneGap-Plugin https://github.com/EddyVerbruggen/SocialSharing-PhoneGap-Plu... ...and didn't want to invest in this feature.
- Firmwarrior 4y agoGood news, my friend: https://github.com/EddyVerbruggen/SocialSharing-PhoneGap-Plugin/issues/1150#issuecomment-1113006784 https://github.com/EddyVerbruggen/SocialSharing-PhoneGap-Plu...
- saagarjha 4y agoNot to channel the usual Hacker News acid at you but have you considered the optics of “we are using code that requests fairly broad permissions because we couldn’t be bothered to invest in doing a better job that didn’t have to do this”? I don’t see this explanation as being particularly comforting.
- waqf 4y agoI don't want you to query my packages and I don't want your help to invite people I know to your app. That sounds like a feature that was made for your benefit, not for mine. So it seems that Google made your app better for me as a user. Congrats Google indeed.
- alerighi 4y agoEven if the app uploads contacts to a server, is that a big deal? A lot of apps do that: WhatsApp, Telegram, Facebook, Instagram, Microsoft Teams, basically any messaging application. Of curse the app should ask permission to do so in accordance to local laws (such as GDPR if we are in Europe), but it shouldn't be a concern of Google.
- saagarjha 4y agoJust because someone else does it doesn’t mean it’s the right thing to do.
- kazinator 4y agoOf course Google isn't going to look at the code. Most Google App Store apps are not open source, so why would that be a workflow at all? You have to evaluate those same deliverables that are downloaded to the user. To be able to infer properties of the build application from the source code review, it has to be shown that the two correspond; the shipped, built version comes from the code that was reviewed. Poring over someone's source code is a fool's errand. You will never catch everything; people find 25 year old bugs in code that have evaded all previous pairs of eyes. Google's approach here is poor though; they created these API's and permission model and now have to backpedal on it randomly. If you want untrusted applications to have access to Contacts, it should be done with abstract tokens that do not reveal any contact details. Each contact is represented by an object handle that provides every imaginable operation you might want to do to, with or by-means-of a contact. It's possible to design a system whereby some contact properties (e.g. mobilePhoneNumber) are accessible, but the result of the access is an abstract object that doesn't actually reveal the content, only represents its existence. The user interface could be priviled so that, say, a text field widget can be given one of these opaque objects, and then display the actual phone number. The only way to get at it would be to have permission to take a screenshot, and then OCR it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jeremyjh 4y agoIt’s a VOIP phone - it has to actually have the number.
- 6510 4y agoSorry if this is a dumb question but how does it use the number if it isn't uploaded?
- pjerem 4y agoOf course you need to tell the server the number you want to call. That’s the basis of any VoIP application. But you don’t have to upload every contact neither you have to send any information associated with the number.
- hedora 4y agoWhy not put it on f droid, and make it really, really clear that the play store version is defeatured?
- jaimex2 4y agoOffer a side-load option for performance till Google pull their heads out their rears. Lottery apps had to do this for years.
- Brian_K_White 4y agoWhy does the api and the permission exist if there is no such thing as a legitimate use of it? Oh right, Google Maps and Gmail and who knows what else can have full access to those same contacts.
- jakeogh 4y agoor... dont use the walled garden... fdroid, and aurora (for closed apps)
- codazoda 4y agoI’d rather add new contacts to an app like this than use share my existing ones. There’s just too much info there.
- Too 4y agoOne possibility is that Google Play runs the app in a sandbox, monkey test it by clicking on everything, trace the outgoing connections and sees that one request contains PII from the sandboxed contacts. It could be a third party library that does it. Play is surprisingly sophisticated, and with Google focusing only on automation, i wouldn't be surprised to see them have this level of testing. This particular test wouldn't even be hard to write.