8 ms·
Oblivious Supreme Court poised to legalize medical patents
- Mediocrity 15y agoAt this point I might just change careers. Lawyer sounds like a pretty good gig right now.
- wtn 15y agoYou might be interested to hear about the Ticketmaster class action settlement I learned I was a party to in my email this morning. Lawyers get $16 million, members of the class get coupons on future Ticketmaster purchases.
- xxpor 15y agoNot just a coupon, but a coupon for $1.50
- Mediocrity 15y agoI guess I'll have to reconsider then; the lawyers definitely got the short end of the stick. (; More seriously, I would have no qualms of going into the legal profession specifically to defend against this sort of brand of crazy where possible. (And of course more mundane cases as the majority.) I'd wake up each morning feeling MUCH better than if I became something like say, a firefighter.
- leot 15y agoIt's amazing that so many entrepreneurs seem to hate the large payments that class action lawyers are awarded. Class action lawyers perform the same kind of high-risk high-reward gamble that startups engage in. While tech startups create value by making something useful, these lawyers create value by keeping powerful interests honest. The idea that they are unnecessary or should be capped because consumers will just "in the long run" "vote with their feet" has been shown to be (patently) false: corporations can take advantage of huge economies of scale when they breach millions of contracts in small, hidden ways. The only real recourse of an individual is to participate in a class action. Perhaps the biggest part of the individual's reward is that the corporation will stop its bad behavior. I can understand distrust of the judicial system because it shows a bias in favor of the deep-pocketed. What I don't understand is why there's a distrust of class-action verdicts, where both parties compete on a relatively even playing field.
- _delirium 15y agoI think the main source of dislike is that the lawyers appear to be the only ones profiting: they receive substantial payouts, the lead plaintiffs they talk to receive payments, but the bulk of the class they supposedly represent receives worthless coupons. The suspicion is that they're negotiating primarily for themselves, willing to sell out the class with a shitty settlement, as long as they themselves get a good payout from it. I've been reasonably happy with class-action lawyers when they've negotiated actual, non-trivial cash-money payments for their class. But Ticketmaster store credit, so they can take home money while failing to get anything for the class they supposedly represent? Fuck off. I filed an objection to the proposed settlement when I received that offensive proposal. If all they can negotiate is $1.50 in store credit, then I think we can safely say that they failed in their lawsuit, and shouldn't get any payment.
- leot 15y agoSounds like a problem of the selection of legal representation. It seems there needs to be some, ah, website that helps to put together groups of plaintiffs and organizes the process of selecting a good legal team to represent them ... ... if the website got 0.25% of every settlement, it could be pretty lucrative.
- drewcrawford 15y agoAs I understand it (IANAL) the vast majority of members of the class find out during the settlement process, i.e. well AFTER the lawyers have been picked. You can technically "opt out" and go sue the company yourself, but you're not going to get people who realistically, upon receiving notice that they are getting an unexpected settlement in-between two utility bills, decide to form their own class.
- leot 15y agoRight. The point would to allow this kind of thing to happen more organically. Those with a grievance would aggregate before the legal team was chosen.
- beedogs 15y agoIt's even funnier than that. The coupons are for $1.50 each, and you're allowed a maximum of 17 of them, no matter how many tickets you actually purchased over the years. Thanks, Ticketmaster!
- marshray 15y agoI wonder if they would consider CPR to be patentable. Truly Dr. Heimlich missed an opportunity when he failed to patent his "trademark" maneuver. In the future, perhaps we'll be expected to wear bracelets (or microchips) that tell the paramedics on which life-saving techniques we're up-to-date on our licensing payments.
- joshAg 15y agoI think it's more reasonable that doctors or health care providers or health insurance companies will be the ones that actually have to license any patents because that's where the money is. It's not like consumers need to keep a bracelet or file of all the patents they've licensed so they know which software and hardware they can buy. Can you imagine not being able to get a cast because your hmo didn't license the patent for "applying gauze soaked in plaster to a broken or fractured limb to prevent the bone from moving while it heals"? crap.
- einhverfr 15y agoHere's a good example though. Serafem is basically prosac, but it's approved for treating severe PMS basically. They license the patent for that correlation from MIT. A doctor prescribing generic prosac instead would then be violating MIT's patent. Unfortunately here medical patents are already here. I don't think the Supreme Court is going to switch course either. What we really need is for Congress to act and impose compulsatory licensing on all patents if the end technology is a medical one. This is also what is needed to bring medical costs down in this country. Unfortunately Congress is in the hands of big business so they will probably run the other direction....
- alexholehouse 15y agoWould this not fundamentally break healthcare?
- JamesBlair 15y agoMuch like software, it will limp along.
- cynest 15y agoProbably only increase the costs.
- mindcrime 15y agoIs healthcare not already fundamentally broken?
- acslater00 15y agoHonestly, this is probably the best possible thing. The reality is that under the Patent Act, things which are not fundamentally "inventions" -- such as software algorithms, genes, and in this case, data correlations -- can legally be granted patents. This is a problem with the Act, not with any given court's interpretation of it, and that is what needs to change. I can think of no better way to build political support for a major patent reform initiative than a constant stream of human-interest pieces on 60 Minutes where a handsome doctor earnestly explains that he couldn't save Bobby because of a patent claim from some faceless corporate troll. Software is abstract and complicated. Saving Bobby is emotional and simple. If patents start to impact medicine the way they've impacted software development, they're not going to last very long in their current form.
- Mediocrity 15y agoThis is true. And because of the implications of what you just said above. I'll leave it at that. EDIT: In retrospect, I probably shouldn't have ended the post in that way. Instead, I'll acknowledge that this solution to silly patents is certainly viable. But that at the same time calling it "The best possible thing" seems somewhat narrow in the grand scheme of things. After all, it DOES require people to die to be workable.
- gwright 15y agoThank you for pointing out the primary culprit here--Congress and its lame legislation in this area. The headline's use of 'legalize' only perpetuates the confusion surrounding Supreme Court decisions. It is the underlying legislation that gives life to the patent claim not the fact that the Court upholds patents that succesfully adhere to a misguided law. Ambiguous or otherwise weak legislation leaves the court in a no-win situation of shaping public policy via judicial opinions.
- wnoise 15y agoOne problem is that even unambiguous legislation gets twisted by agency interpretations and case law to no longer mean what it originally said.
- 15y ago
- shadowfiend 15y agoThis is an extremely foolish title, and the tone of the article is likewise foolish. It's highly unlikely the Supreme Court has not read the amicus briefs, and almost impossible that they will not before passing judgement. These are not 9 people picked off the street and thrown on the bench to judge what the application of law is, and they don't mess around. Reading pretty much any Supreme Court decision will show you how intelligent these nine justices are. It's popular to condemn the Supreme Court's decisions if you disagree with them, and it seems equally popular to blame them on the Supreme Court's fundamental misunderstanding of <x>. I'm not saying the SCotUS is flawless—hardly, they are made up of people—but it would behoove authors and readers if you started from the base assumption that you are dealing with brilliant jurists. Indeed, that is how lawyers have to prepare. The lawyers arguing against the patent were likely aware both of the justices' intelligence and their general interpretations of patent law, therefore chose not to tread the path of invalidating medical patents in general. The questions asked by the justices were fair. Not expressing skepticism does not mean there is no skepticism, for one. We don't find that out until the decisions are written. Whether this was a case where someone should have gone after medical patents in general is up for debate. In particular, it seems unlikely that the Mayo clinic, which probably has its own medical patents, would try to invalidate the concept itself. If you read some more of the questions and interactions, you'll see that the Supreme Court seems anything but oblivious: they're trying to probe what should and should not be patentable in a field that involves actions and reactions that are all based in chemical fact. If neither they nor the lawyers can provide a satisfactory test to determine this, then all they can do is decide the specifics of this case. True change in this area really is something where the Court can only do so much. The definitions of patents in general are determined by Congress and its laws. If we want to change them, we have to focus there. SCotUS has merely become our backup because it's been relatively difficult, particularly in the last 40 years or so, to convince Congress to pass laws that are potentially damaging in any way to the bottom lines of businesses.
- ireadzalot 15y agoTo add to your point about the justices, Chief Justice Roberts is on the record for saying that it is not unusual for him to go through 20-25 drafts before he signs off his opinion on a case. You can watch him saying that here: http://www.c-spanvideo.org/program/286078-1 http://www.c-spanvideo.org/program/286078-1 His says this around 42:45 min into the video.
- sycren 15y agoI hope they don't try to include something like this in ACTA to bring it across to the EU
- jacques_chester 15y agoCountries with universal health systems might be more resistant due to the immediate and visible cost to the respective Treasuries.
- jm4 15y agoThe Supreme Court does not "legalize" anything. They interpret existing laws and decide on their legality. They can't shoot it down just because it sucks. Their decision is based on whether or not the law runs afoul of the Constitution. Don't like the law? Blame the a-holes who wrote it. Better yet, try to get it changed.
- scarmig 15y agoIt's very... sanguine of you to think the Supreme Court is full of bloodless rationalists, computers that read statutes and, via sheer force of deductive reasoning, come to a conclusion. In reality, the Supreme Court is supremely political, and they regularly do shoot down a law because they think it sucks or approve a law because shooting it down would make people angry.
- waterlesscloud 15y agoPlease provide examples of both assertions.
- scarmig 15y agoIt's not striking down a law, but you can see the process at work most clearly in Bush v. Gore. It was, on the face of it, a horrible decision, and the court itself said it shouldn't be used for any precedent; it's not been cited once since then. But it isn't merely a matter of disagreeing with the decision. It's the crass politicization of it. If you look at the breakdown of the vote, the Justices who supported Bush supported Bush, and those who supported Gore supported Gore. (Thomas's wife was heavily involved in Bush's campaign, and O'Conner had said the evening before the election that she'd find Gore's election personally disastrous.) Nor can ideology account for the decision: the same justices who are pretty stingy when it comes to applying Fourteenth Amendment rights generally suddenly found it imperative to extend it to a radically new situation in an usurpation of state rights with federal judicial might. The converse was also true, as the Justices usually distrustful of states running their own elections suddenly thought that sacrosanct. Edited to add a particularly damning quote: "The counting of votes that are of questionable legality does in my view threaten irreparable harm to petitioner Bush, and to the country, by casting a cloud upon what he claims to be the legitimacy of his election. Count first, and rule upon legality afterwards, is not a recipe for producing election results that have the public acceptance democratic stability requires." IOW, Scalia is banning the recounting of the votes of undecided legality because it might make Bush's election look less legitimate and cause political turmoil.
- austenallred 15y agoI just hope medical patents are as easy to patent as some technical patents. That way I'll snake the "cure for cancer" patent right now and then troll anyone who tries to use it later. I have no problem with patents if you are patenting an actual, working, viable product, when when you can patent an "idea" the entire purpose of a patent turns into a market full of arbitrage.