4 ms·
Competent Elites (2008)
- chmaynard 4y ago> Large amounts of money seem to attract smart people. I wonder if the author meant the converse, that smart people seem to attract large amounts of money.
- bell-cot 4y agoMy kinda-cynical read is closer to "just as powerful kings of old attracted a clever-sounding crowd of courtiers, counselors, priests, philosophers, and such, so do large quantities of money today attract a clever-sounding crowd...".
- BizarroLand 4y agoYou would think that universities would be the richest places on the planet then. There area few that are in the running but most of the money in the world is not in academics, so raw intelligence cannot be the only money attracting factor.
- jacknews 4y agoThere's no doubt I think that some people are smarter than others. And that some people appear much smarter, more confident, charismatic, etc than others, in person, in conversation, even in debate. They're not necessarily the same set of people though.
- bo1024 4y agoGreat point. I find a theme in this essay of confidence, speaking quickly, and perhaps charisma being associated with intelligence or depth of thought. I've met enough brilliant people (often women) who speak softly, slowly, or without firmness or definiteness. This also varies by culture.
- jackcosgrove 4y agoIn my own life, I've found charisma flowed from confidence. And confidence flowed both from knowing what I knew, and not knowing what I don't know. Now that I know a lot more of what I don't know, I'm kind of a schlub.
- bo1024 4y ago- That smart people manage to find their ways into positions of wealth and power, doesn't necessarily imply that you need to be smart to occupy those positions effectively. In other words, they might be wasting their brains on those positions, as compared to being a scientist or engineer or something. - When it comes to the qualities mentioned - deep, quick, vibrant, etc. - I feel people overestimate how innate these qualities must be, versus learned or developed in an environment.
- yamtaddle 4y ago> - When it comes to the qualities mentioned - deep, quick, vibrant, etc. - I feel people overestimate how innate these qualities must be, versus learned or developed in an environment. I'm sure it's far from the only way it happens, but I've noticed a type, and my suspicion is it's largely attributable to small-class discussion-heavy (possible because of the small class sizes) prep schools. I'm sure some of it's the quality of the material those schools are working with, if you will, but I think that kind of an education also tends to build exactly that kind of ability to seem commanding and sharp in social situations.
- mhb 4y agoSome previous discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=316662 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=316662
- sillysaurusx 4y agoI miss 2008’s mindset. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=316847 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=316847
- photochemsyn 4y agoPeople's perception's of others is an interesting subject. Let's take this snippet as an example: > "Even so, these people of the Power Elite were visibly much smarter than average mortals. In conversation they spoke quickly, sensibly, and by and large intelligently. When talk turned to deep and difficult topics, they understood faster, made fewer mistakes, were readier to adopt others' suggestions." First, there's the issue of inherent bias to deal with. When one is entering a gathering of 'the power elite', one will tend to expect brilliance (if that's were one's biases lie, at least) and that will color one's perception of what's actually being said. Putting that aside, if one sees an exceptional 15-min presentation at a power elite gathering, is that just some kind of natural phenomenon? Did that person just pop out of the womb spouting clear, well-organized thoughts to the world? No - it's a skill developed through practice. This is really one of the most irritating things to encounter, the assumption that a person's skills are somehow innate and not the result of hours of hard work and concentrated effort. In almost all cases, an unprepared, unpracticed talk or presentation is a disaster, and the decision to 'wing it' is always a bad one. Similarly, someone who powers through difficult math and science courses in college is not 'naturally intelligent' - no, they're the ones who spend four hours a night solving problems and reading, while missing out on the fun social party scene. So when people say "oh, you're just naturally gifted, and I can't keep up with you because of that", the best response is, "are you sure it's just not because your a bit lazy and not willing to put in the required hours of effort?" [edit] P.S. for a nice short sci-fi send-up of 'power elite' worship, I recommend "Ironclads" by Adrian Tchaikovsky: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/34466691-ironclads https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/34466691-ironclads
- hirundo 4y agoIt's both. I've worked harder then fellow students who had much better results and less hard for better results than other students who failed, and seen the same capacity follow students across classes. It's the same with physical talents, where I had a particularly vivid example. I golfed almost obsessively for about three years, and then introduced a friend to the game ... who beat me on the back nine of his first round.
- 4y ago
- pinewurst 4y agoHow soon we forget that the Wonder of Biological Knowledge, Steve Jurvetson, was the 1st Theranos backer and a huge defender all the way down. Yudkowsky merely admires those who project an admiration for him, mostly IMHO in an attempt - like Jurvetson - to themselves seem like intellectuals. Turtles all the way down…
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 4y agoThis definitely has the whole "I am so smart, therefore people who think like me are also smart" vibe to to it.
- justin66 4y agoThat's the LessWrong motto. It sounds more dignified in the original Latin.
- magusdei 4y ago"Ego sophos, ergo et qui mihi similiter cogitant sophi sunt"?
- codeflo 4y agoThere’s also a whole “the really smart among the rich people are actually smart enough to recognize the importance of my work” marketing pitch, if you know that (AFAIK at least) he actually lives off of donations to his research project.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoThis is the literal plot of the Emperor's New Clothes Fairytale.
- ido 4y agoThe actual article notwithstanding, upon reading it two thoughts occured to me: 1. I knew and know plenty of CEOs (some of them were my bosses at some point) and quite a few of them are...Not that impressive? I can think of at least a couple that we (the people under them in the corporate hierarchy) actually thought were idiots 2. As a developer turned founder...Being a CEO is a lot harder than I realized. The part about how not everyone can be an executive - even a bad executive - rings true to my subjective experience. I just don't think "lack of intelligence" is what's preventing a lot of people from being able to perform as executives.
- xnx 4y agoI think this article from 2008 might be circulating because John Carmack shared it recently: https://twitter.com/ID_AA_Carmack/status/1582578735965868033 https://twitter.com/ID_AA_Carmack/status/1582578735965868033
- dsr_ 4y agoAssuming that Eliezer's observations are correct, we must still consider: - survivor bias - successorship issues, especially regression to the mean - the role of luck - advantages from inherited wealth
- MichaelZuo 4y agoWhen I first read this as a teenager I didn't see what the big shocking secret was supposed to be, after all very above average people appearing to be significantly better than the average seems like a tautology. And then, as I grew up, I realized many folks don't like admitting that someone else could be better in a general sense, maybe out of stubborn pride, or mistaken beliefs in literal equality of outcomes. Or maybe because they're afraid of putting in the effort to improve themselves, preferring the easy way out as a crab in the bucket. In any case, it made me reflect on how many other 'obvious things that cannot be said' appear everywhere as one grows older.
- masterof0 4y agoI think people are OK to admitting others are better, for example, I admit Hussain Bolt runs way faster than me. What people don't like is those "elites" telling us how to live our lives, or how to think, or what to accept as normal and what not, while coming from an extremely privileged background that most people don't have, where their "achievement" are more of a consequence of their upbringing and less of a personal success story.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoThat seems to be a different issue. Recognizing the fact that very above average people exist does not mean recognizing any group as the final arbiters of the human condition.
- Godel_unicode 4y agoThat’s certainly one group, but there’s also a very loud group of people who insist that elites are just normal humans who were allowed to bloom. I think there are several reasons here; some are ideologically opposed to the existence of outliers, some are worried about the chilling effect of telling people that no matter how hard they work they’ll never be at Gausses level as a mathematician, and some are comforted that their lack of success isn’t their fault because they weren’t given opportunities.
- ldjkfkdsjnv 4y agoI've long noticed this. I used to hang out with a group of Stanford graduates, two of them started extremely successful companies, one of which has a valuation > 5B. I think they were just simply better, and in many facets. Height over 6'2, BS/MS in CS from Stanford, played sports at a near professional level, while still being sociable. In my head I wanted to say it was their network that lead to the success, and it no doubt did, but when it came down to it, they were just able to build companies and see market opportunities that others cannot. And they weren't working around the clock. I will add one more point. Most people have simply never come into contact with truly elite people. Work at any large company and probably zero actual elites work there below the highest levels. VP at Google is not elite. This is where the confusion comes from
- PuppyTailWags 4y agoI think you might have to consider how "simply better" is actually circumstances beyond their control. Their height cannot happen without nutrition. Their sports proficiency cannot happen without early exposure, which often requires parental resources(money for equipment, time to commute to games...) . The ability to get an education is heavily dependent on health, parental investment, lack of childhood trauma, et al. (For example, the burden to get a BS/MS from Stanford increases if your parents commit a hate crime against you for being gay.) If anything this is a group of comparatively highly successful people and discussing nuances between their success. But statistically much of that is opportunity and luck.
- ldjkfkdsjnv 4y agoSure, there are all sorts of life circumstances that could stop them. Luck is involved. But the degree of raw talent was shockingly high.
- CptFribble 4y agoThe point being made here is that "raw talent" is frequently the removal of barriers via socioeconomic factors. The best predictor of whether a child will graduate college is whether their parents also graduated college. Most "naturally talented" people are "simply" people allowed to reach full human potential due to circumstances of birth, where "less talented" people frequently could have reached similar potential, but for: - lower socioeconomic status - less- or un-educated parents who don't know what opportunities to put their children into for maximum growth - parents who themselves experienced significant trauma as children and didn't have the opportunity to process it due to lack of money or access to mental healthcare, and then subsequently inflict similar trauma on their own children The lower socioeconomic status one in particular contains a host of other potential potential-limiters: - less money for healthy food (or enough food at all) means less growth potential and worse overall health for the rest of your life - if your parents don't have money for the equipment, you likely won't be allowed to participate in sports (happened to my wife) which means your brain will miss critical early wiring opportunities with the sport-specific mechanical tasks, which will result in lower potential skill ceiling later in life - no money for travel means less exposure to world cultures, and unless living a in large city less exposure to foreign languages, and exposure to foreign languages as an infant is critical for later foreign language success due to pruning of connections for unused phonemes during early development. There are many, many more things that go into the development of "raw talent" I haven't even touched on beyond "just" parent socioeconomic status, like poor people being more likely to have to live near major roadways and its influence on the rate of asthma in children. The takeaway here is that very often people with "raw talent" weren't born that way, they were simply allowed to grow.
- ForgotIdAgain 4y agoFollowing John carmack on twitter? ;)
- gampleman 4y agoThis should be unsurprising in a well functioning (i.e. meritocratic) hierarchy. Power laws indicate that the differences in the top percentile can be huge, and as such one would expect these large differences in ability to be reasonably easy to recognise and promote. If this does become surprising, then the social system has become dysfunctional and needs some serious adjustment, as it likely no longer serves its purpose.
- helen___keller 4y agoThe thesis is that these “elites” were not the generic suits that the author expected, but > Even so, these people of the Power Elite were visibly much smarter than average mortals. In conversation they spoke quickly, sensibly, and by and large intelligently. When talk turned to deep and difficult topics, they understood faster, made fewer mistakes, were readier to adopt others' suggestions. > No, even worse than that, much worse than that: these CEOs and CTOs and hedge-fund traders, these folk of the mid-level power elite, seemed happier and more alive. In my view, all this data is still consistent with being a generic suit, maybe under the “yuppie” subset Appearing competent, engaged, happy, and intelligent is different from actually being. I’ve worked directly with executives (technical founders) who prides themselves on being able to dive in and diagnose issues, acting like they’re the best engineer in the room but only hiring people because they’re too busy doing executive things to continue building the product by themselves. And you know what? Those people will seem really intelligent until you come in one day, learn that they pushed a change to prod at 2 am, and it caused a ton of damage because they know nothing about engineering practices, and then half the team wastes a week trying to fix things without hurting the executives’ ego.
- SilverBirch 4y agoI think this is a serious case of not understanding different types of roles and intelligence. Yes, a VC is going to be able to make great small-talk about emerging tech ideas. Why? Because they're constantly bombarded with new ideas and people trying to persuade them to invest in different new projects, and in order to gain access to those deals it is table stakes today for them to manage their brand. So yes, they'll have some insightful things to say - most of which they'll likely have picked up somewhere and else and are just laundering. This isn't indicative of them being some kind of ubermensch the likes of which mere scientists could never hope to be. A research scientist spends years working away at incredibly difficult problems and if they're super smart, and quite lucky they might push their chosen area of research forwards significantly. But this focus is not going to make them interesting to make small-talk with, because to really understand the issues that they're interested in you'll need a huge amount of existing knowledge. I think funnily enough, we've had a real piece of evidence about whether these CEOs and VCs really are galaxy-brain individuals. We got the release of the Musk texts for the Twitter deal. What did it show? These guys are mediocre. They're sycophantic, group-think bros who know that the primary way to play the game is to suck up to each other and never criticise. If you're going to define intelligence as someone's ability to entertain you at a cocktail party then yes, slightly behind Paris Hilton, Jurvetson is your guy. If you want interesting insights, you can go and listen to people like Scott Galloway, but he's not a genius, he's just a rich guy who has enough money to have a team researching stuff so that he can provide interesting insights. A resource a researcher neither has nor needs.
- pragmatic 4y agoI have not been paying attention but has Yudkowsky done anything noteable since these writings from 10+ years ago?