10 ms·
IDA cybersecurity software provider Hex-Rays acquired
- Thaxll 4y agoNot sure why Hex-Rays spends so much time fighting piracy and making the purchase a very complicated process, it's a lost battle, there will always be pirated copy of IDA, stop fighting it and embrace it to make a better offering.
- kurisufag 4y agoFor reference, I downloaded a cracked copy off TPB (or some such place) when I was in high school for reversing video games, and I've never seen a legitimate reason to upgrade or get a real license. It's really a testament to the robustness of the software.
- hirvi74 4y agoThe people who worked on IDA should be teaching classes on development. I do not think I have ever encountered a single bug in my usage (obviously they exist as with almost any system of moderate complexity). It's just a rock solid application.
- arsome 4y agoTheir debugger used to be pretty buggy, just after the 5.0 or 5.1 release I'd crash it on a regular basis. More recent versions have improved this though and they offer some really slick features in the debugger than other tools can't even do.
- hirvi74 4y agoI forget what version I started with, but I believe it was after 6.
- self_awareness 4y agoStructure editor sometimes bugs out and removes all items from the view, together with comments that serve as help text. The window is completely empty. Also this Python detection tool that needs to be executed prior the first run didn't support python 3.10 at some point -- they've did version detection based on the filename that detected 3.10 as 3.1 (windows9-style version detection). Not sure what's the case with recent IDA versions, because I'm using Ghidra since a long time now. But overall I agree, I would never suggest IDA when being asked about an example of a buggy software.
- hirvi74 4y agoThose are just mere test. You must use IDA to RE itself to fix those bugs. Then you have truly earned the right to use IDA bug free. ;)
- luma 4y agoIt seems like a completely senseless waste of their efforts, given the nature of the product they are selling and the user community who knows how to use such a thing.
- userbinator 4y agoIndeed, I still remember when it was a "rite of passage" to crack IDA yourself.
- Beached 4y agothey need to go the binja route and just give away a minimal version for free, stopped of the fancy features and scripting. we use binja at work, which means a dozen enterprise licenses, because binja was easily usable legally for free. we all love ida, but licensing is a pita with them. so we never bothered.
- arsome 4y agoThey do have a free version of IDA, the problem is most people who use it want the decompiler these days and that costs big. Looks like they've actually added the "cloud-based x64 decompiler" to the free offering now, so maybe if you're not working with 32-bit code and not working with anything too sensitive that could be of use.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- IYasha 4y agoI've heard rumors of Ilfack's level of anality being legendary, but seeing so many confirmations!..
- willk 4y agoI hope this doesn't lead to stagnation in the product with ever increasing licensing costs. IDA is expensive enough as it is.
- userbinator 4y agoI think they lost a lot of potential customers after NSA released Ghidra.
- Beached 4y agobinja had more to do with loss of enterprise customers than ghidra. I know maybe 100 professional sres and none of them use ghidra on a daily basis. most use binja now, and others admit they only use ida, because they already have it and know how to use it. they also admit if they have to move to a place without ida licenses, they would be happy to go binja full time if that's what their teammates use
- vsnf 4y agoI hope it does. It may direct more attention to Ghidra instead.
- EMIRELADERO 4y agoI think things can only get better. Right now it's hard enough to be allowed to buy the damn thing in the first place!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- stolen_biscuit 4y agoDoes anyone know what impact if any the release of Ghidra had on Hex-Rays? IDA never really accommodated to the hobbyist, so I wonder did it have any impact on the commercial side of things apart from the IDA Home release?
- fragmede 4y agoThey accommodated them by it not being too hard to crack using itself, which must have had a commercial impact.
- mike_d 4y agoVery little. Everyone who was passing around pirated copies of IDA continued to do so before and after the release of Ghidra. More than anything I think binary.ninja started to eat their lunch because it was a far superior experience and up front reasonable pricing. Hex-Rays did ultimately release IDA Home, but you have to sign up for an account to even find out what their hobbyist license costs. I cannot underscore how much Hex Rays never wanted to have customers or sell products. Maybe this restructuring will fix that?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 4y agoThey were, according to this, doing 20MM in 2020, which is surprisingly high for something like IDA. I think they mostly just don't want people like us as clients.
- ylk 4y agoIf you translate this article you’ll see that they didn’t just do 20 million in revenue, they made 18 million in profit with 18 employees, 11 of them being devs: https://archive.ph/Abxqp https://archive.ph/Abxqp
- bri3d 4y agoI disagree with this for a non-direct sales reason: before, you learned IDA, cracked or not. If you learned to reverse software of any kind, you acquired IDA. Now, more and more tutorials and introductions use Ghidra. Is it better than IDA? In some cases yes, in most not yet, but it’s easier to get. If I were Hex-Rays, I’d be very concerned with a generational shift as people stop bothering to pirate IDA and those who learned on Ghidra enter the industry and don’t demand an IDA license.
- pseudo0 4y agoHopefully this works out for Hex-Rays, allowing them to invest more into developing IDA and expanding their low-cost product offerings. The general sentiment I have seen among people doing SRE is that IDA is rapidly losing market share to Ghidra. While it excels in some areas, the licenses are pricy even for tech employers, and entirely out of reach for students or colleges. It's hard to convince an employer to fork out cash for IDA licenses when new employees are asking to use Ghidra, because that's what they use at home and at school.
- rjzzleep 4y agoFor me I got the Company I was contracting for to buy me an IDA license and as I was trying to take over from there Hexrays never responded to any requests. I'm guessing that I'm on the same pirate blacklist that a lot of people landed. I guess I should have expensed it instead of having the Company buy it. I was the only person doing RE work, it was a single user person license and I was also the only linux user out of that 300 people org. I think there are a lot of people that would like to pay for IDA but can't get it. On the other hand I really don't like the Ghidra user experience. Is there something similar to FLIRT in r2 or ghidra?
- pseudo0 4y agoI don't think Ghidra has a proper FLIRT equivalent yet. That's one of those bells and whistles that may (or may not) be worth the license fee, along with in my opinion a more polished UI. Just to clarify, if I wasn't concerned with budget and had to pick a product today, I'd still go with IDA, but the mindshare among new hires and interns is swinging pretty rapidly towards Ghidra. If they are able to continue adding features (with US government funding, and open source development), IDA is right to be worried about whether they will still be the best choice in 5 years.
- ylk 4y agoIt’s not r2 or ghidra, but binary ninja has signature libraries: “The matching algorithm is inspired by FLIRT, which was designed with similar requirements in mind.” https://binary.ninja/2020/03/11/signature-libraries.html https://binary.ninja/2020/03/11/signature-libraries.html
- tptacek 4y agoThis seems like "acquired" in a different sense than we normally mean; it's more like an announcement of an investment round than an acquisition, right?
- WirelessGigabit 4y agoHe sold majority share to an investment group. So every button will now become an in-app purchase. Function decompilations will cost in-app currencies. And today they’re offering the pro-pack. 10,000 decomp units for $1,200 bucks. Of course now they can devalue the value of a unit at will.
- sam_lowry_ 4y agoAFAIU Ilfak is planning retirement. Retirement and tired have the same root. He got in this business pretty much accidentally and never wanted to become the most hated person in wannabe cracker circles.
- gjm11 4y ago> Retirement and tired have the same root. This does not appear to be true. "retire" is from French retirer, to pull (something) back -- as e.g. a general might do with troops that need to stop an attack. "tire" (verb) goes back to Old English tiorian, and its etymology before that is not known and in particular doesn't seem to come from French "tirer" or its Latin antecedents.
- ylk 4y agoMore details here, but the article is in Dutch: https://archive.ph/Abxqp https://archive.ph/Abxqp
- tux3 4y agoQuoting from the translation: """ With the new shareholders on board, Hex-Rays must evolve from an engineering company to a commercial company. “After the takeover, we want to structure the company, develop a commercial team and a management team and continue internationalization,” say Ingels and Luyten. The intention is to transform the current commercial model of perpetual licenses into a recurring model. In the first model, customers pay a large amount at the start and then annually for updates and maintenance. The other includes an annual payment for the license and all associated services. Hex-Rays' next growth phase will be led by a new CEO, who will take over from Guilfanov. He will eventually become chief technology officer (CTO) of the Liège company and chairman of the board of directors. """
- WirelessGigabit 4y agoWhat’s the current best tool to reverse engineer C++ exe’s? I want to reverse engineer an old game!
- jnk345u8dfg9hjk 4y agoI think you're looking at it in this thread
- Demonsult 4y agohttps://github.com/radareorg/iaito https://github.com/radareorg/iaito
- throwaway24424 4y agoI personally gave up on this product a long time ago. The only way I see this panning out is via extremely aggressive enterprise sales schemes and a further reduction of hobbyist accessibility. Good riddance from the hobbyist perspective...
- rychco 4y agoThis makes me hopeful that users will switch to Binary Ninja. I picked up Binja a while ago (because it’s actually affordable for an individual) & haven’t felt any need to return to IDA. There’s also Rizin which seems pretty robust from what I’ve seen (haven’t tried it myself), & of course there’s also Ghidra. IDA isn’t the only effective disassembler in town anymore.
- Beached 4y agoI see people going to binja in waves. not only is it easier to acquire, but it's freaking good and intuitive to use. they cater to the hobbiest market to, with a free version that will honestly work for soooo many things. I don't understand why people use ghidra honestly. but hey, nsa has some good pr people
- saagarjha 4y agoGhidra’s decompiler is far better, and it’s free.
- arsome 4y agoDid they ever fix the debugger situation in Binja? Looks like it's still in beta. I really hated using Ghidra and Binja compared to IDA as I'm a bit reliant on dynamic RE for some purposes, while IDA is able to bridge the gap between static and dynamic without the need to break out x64dbg or similar.
- psifertex 4y agoIt's been on the dev builds enabled by default for several months now and no longer labelled beta, but we're in the middle of a release process right now so at some point soon this week the current stable will have a full debugger release (though you can try that version now if you switch to dev)
- jpleger 4y agoI was a heavy ida pro user from 2008-2012. I have probably been responsible for or directly approved giving them 35-40k at different places over the years. I wanted to do some pic disassembly a while back and out of curiosity asked if they had a low cost personal license for non commercial use and basically got told to pound sand. They said the price for the full version was what it was, no discounts. Then they came out with their ‘home’ edition which is an insult at $365 per architecture and not all architectures are available. I don’t care how much better it is than open source stuff, until they have a full featured personal version and lower their price, they won’t be getting a dime of my (or my companies) money. It isn’t 2008 anymore.
- brokenmachine 4y agoCan one of the experts commenting here let me know a good process to get started with learning to decompile/reverse engineer/modify Windows programs? Is it worth doing any of those online ctf thingys? Any recommended resources or books I should check out?
- ylk 4y agoPlease don’t take this the wrong way, but googling is a very important skill to have. There’s quite a bit of information out there and I’ll basically just repeat what you can find online already. You’re additionally not very specific about your goals, which makes it hard to give specific advice. Practical Malware Analysis is a really great book, even if you don’t intend to reverse malware. It has labs after every chapter, along with solutions. It teaches you about windows, how to approach reversing a program and what to focus on to not waste too much time. Once you worked through that CTFs should be much more approachable. Reverse Engineering: Secrets of Reverse Engineering and Practical Reverse Engineering are also often mentioned as good books, but I personally haven’t read them. Aside from that, the books from nostarch.com are great. If you want to learn more about windows itself, there are the “windows internals” books. It’s also a good idea to find a community with similar interests, learning together is often more fun. And when you ask for help try to properly state your problem and what approaches you already tried to solve it, along with their outcomes. Good luck!
- brokenmachine 4y ago>There’s quite a bit of information out there and I’ll basically just repeat what you can find online already. Yeah, too much information. Maybe I'm just not finding the precise search words to find what I want. Your reply was very helpful so thanks for that. >You’re additionally not very specific about your goals I'd like to be able to do very basic audits of how programs work and precisely what they're doing, and also modify their behavior in simple ways (change hardcoded servers, change program execution flow, disable or enable certain functionality). Reverse engineering with basic modifications. I'd also like to have a go at modifying firmware of embedded devices, eg a car head unit with a stupid splash screen on startup that I'd like to disable. For example I have a camera with wifi functionality, and you can control it from a phone app. It would be cool if I could somehow control that from the command line, or create my own basic app for the PC to control it. On top of that it would be good if I could modify the firmware to make it automatically start up in that remote control mode. Mostly just for adding to my box of tools and general understanding though.