3 ms·
I think when people ask "why are you doing this" what they are really asking is: Why are you showing this to me? Especially for things that are really common
by bawolff 4y ago
I think when people ask "why are you doing this" what they are really asking is:
Why are you showing this to me?
Especially for things that are really common or totally undocumented. E.g. i'm glad you are having fun making a commandline calculator in python, but im not sure why you posted it to show hn. Or alternatively - im glad you are having fun making whatever you are, but if you cant even write 1 paragraph describing what your program is intended to do, i dont know why you are showing it off.
Alternatively, occassionally people are asking "why do you find this fun?". Everyone gets joy out of different things, but if you show something off and then give no context, its a bit weird. Most people expect an explanation on why whatever you are doing is interesting or meaningful to you.
- Meekro 4y agoI think those people might be looking for a community of creators who enjoy showing things off to each other. Ideally, the command line calculator in python would be accompanied by a blog post explaining either why the project is important, or what the creator learned by making it.
- Barrin92 4y ago>i dont know why you are showing it off it may be as simple as them just being excited. I sure was when I wrote my first program and many people don't have anyone else to show it to. The world is so full of things to passively consume that someone building anything, no matter how scuffed or with little explanation does in my opinion not really deserved to be treated abrasively.
- kasajian 4y agoAgreed, but a pet peeve is when you ask a question on StackOverflow, and get asked why you're doing it, the answer to which isn't need to respond to the post at all. But they want to know. Fine. Fair enough. So you tell them, and then they proceed to tell you that that's not what you should do, and instead should do something else. So now you have multiple comments in your post that has nothing to do with anything. It's just noise and a waste of time. Also, maybe I have a very good reason for why I want to do something and I'm not really willing to tell the world because proprietary in nature. People are just overly nosey, or as usual, they understand that your domain is their domain, so we have have the same problems :)
- bmn__ 4y agoThe motivations you ascribe to the SO respondents and the description of the nature of comments are not congruent with reality. If you cannot fathom where you went wrong in your assumptions, then I have a small psychological experiment for you: try being a respondent for some time instead of only a supplicant.
- mgfist 4y agoI think there's a third reason, which is insecurity. "Why is it that you find coding so fun". "Why can you spend all your free time coding when I can't muster 20 minutes without getting bored". etc.. I have this sometimes. It feels like if only I loved to code all the time I'd be much better at my job and be more respected / better paid / higher titled etc.. Truth is it's ok to not love coding and not want to do it on the side. It's also ok to love to code and do it 24/7. We need to be empathetic with our own selves and our own passions/interests :)
- bawolff 4y agoI love to code, but pretty much only when i am unemployed. There is just only so much coding i can do in a day before becoming a crazy person. If it helps, i dont think my love of coding has really helped me at work. It just makes work seem more boring compared to the coding i would actually like to do, and makes work/life balance more challenging. :)
- muzani 4y agoFrequently it's to find someone with the same excitement for the same things.
- quickthrower2 4y agoOften the blog post / program / whatever was not shared by the author. It was discovered by someone else. It was public, but not intended to have a big HN conversation.
- bawolff 4y agoSure, although i think that just means the question is better directed to the person who shared it rather than the person who wrote it. And its not neccesarily a negative question either - i might actually want to know what part of this project sparked excitement so i can share in that excitement.