3 ms·
It's also just the wrong place in the stack to add these features. It's not a language concern, it's a platform concern. If I'm running a program in a web brows
by kibwen 4y ago
It's also just the wrong place in the stack to add these features. It's not a language concern, it's a platform concern. If I'm running a program in a web browser, it doesn't matter what language it's written in, I can pause the program and interactively explore it via the browser console. We should have the same thing for native apps on operating systems in general, and they should be native to the OS (provided by the OS vendor themselves) and not require any modification to the program (or any special programming language) in order to use.
- mwcampbell 4y agoTo what extent can native-code debuggers, like lldb, fill this need?
- jmartin2683 4y agoI agree this would be very cool. I can’t count the number of times I wish I had runtime interactive debugging in a repl along the lines of pry in Ruby in just about every language that doesn’t have it. That said, gdb etc are pretty awesome too if it’s an option
- none_to_remain 4y agoThis pretty much means debugging a running process' assembly code You can already do this but it is a difficult way to play
- pjmlp 4y agoHistory has proven it only works on language platforms, and as Dan Ingals asserts, the OS shouldn't be there. Anyway a modern OS where this is partially there, is Android.
- kibwen 4y agoHistory has proven the exact opposite, as the failure of Smalltalk and the ascendancy of the web browser demonstrate. And as I assert, Dan Ingals is incorrect.
- pjmlp 4y agoLast time I looked into it, the Web browser is a OS agnostic platform and JavaScript influence in tooling traces back to Smalltalk via SELF influence. There are even two Smalltalk like development experiences Web browser based, Amber Smalltalk and Lively Kernel, the latter from Dan Ingals. The OS should be an implementation detail of language runtimes, as proven by serveless computing and cloud native development, who cares if those runtimes run on top of an OS, bare metal or a type-1 hypervisor.