7 ms·
Parents of overweight children don't know their children are overweight
- patio11 15y agoQuick guess: "How can little Timmy be overweight if half the kids in the neighborhood are chubbier than him?" (Psst: not that difficult, actually.)
- JonnieCache 15y agoIndeed. I would say that because of various inherent cognitive biases, people are likely to interpret terms such as "overweight" as a comparison to their local average, rather than a medically-established ideal weight range. Such abstract thinking just doesn't come naturally. We are incredibly biased here because our jobs often require little else except abstract thinking. This is massively atypical.
- seunosewa 15y agoI think the parents are right to interpret the terms that way. They are not misinterpreting the weight of their children, they are just answering survey questions based on their own points of view and relative observations.
- paulhauggis 15y agoThis seems to happen a lot. I've seen many surveys where group x is seen as "uninformed" when in reality, it's because the group has a differing opinion than the person giving the survey.
- ErrantX 15y agoI guess it depends on how the studies were conducted (I haven't looked). They may well take steps to eradicate this problem. However, I suspect you are right and - in actual fact - this may really be what the studies are concluding: that parents of overweight children do not see the problem because the average they see around them is not medically-healthy normal. It would be interesting to see the average weights of children in the study areas to see how much the theory stands. It would also be interesting to see a similar survey that asked whether they thought their child was within the healthy bounds (i.e. no classifications like "overweight" where they could draw comparisons).
- ErrantX 15y agoI think you have hit the nail on the head. This brings to mind one rather long and tedious "discussion" I had on Wikipedia last year that revolved around whether "above average" was an adequate way to summarise "Overweight and Obese". Getting across the concept that the latter terms were - in the context of the source - medical definitions and not going to change with the (ill-defined) average, was difficult at best. There was a lot of "but obviously being overweight means you are above average". I'm not surprised to see others observing the same issue in different contexts.
- masklinn 15y ago> There was a lot of "but obviously being overweight means you are above average". Which obviously makes no sense whatsoever: the one person who gets enough food during a famine is not overweight (could be, but that's independent).
- rapala 15y agoBy my observation, this is pretty common logical fallacy. If from A follows B, many will deduce that from B follows A. This often happens in math, when a lemma says that A => B is true. Many will use the lemma "the wrong way around".
- cookiecaper 15y ago>rather than a medically-established ideal weight range Is it really "abstract thinking" to accept an arbitrary "medically-established ideal weight range"? Shouldn't we evaluate the criterion set by the medical community too before we accept it? I hear constant criticism of the BMI system for determining healthy weights, yet I've never really known another standard system. While I agree that it's bad to compare your chubby kid to the obese kids and write off the weight problem because fatter children exist, I'm not sure how far we should run with the insistence on conformity to numbers like BMIs. If my children are in the "overweight" BMI range (which isn't applicable to them yet as both are under two) but I still feel that they've been exercising, eating well, etc., and are generally healthy, I'm not going to sweat it.
- JonnieCache 15y ago>Is it really "abstract thinking" to accept an arbitrary "medically-established ideal weight range"? It is abstract thinking as opposed to concrete thinking, because you are imagining a hypothetical child with a certain build, (or is it a set of children with a range of healthy builds?) and comparing your child to that, as opposed to simply comparing your child to the other children you see in front of you every day when collecting your child from school. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abstract_object http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abstract_object
- cookiecaper 15y agoWell, your link lists concepts like "Five" or "Justice" as abstract, so the entire concept of "overweightness" instead of just "overweight child" is "abstract" by that measure. I guess I assumed you meant something more meaningful and less pedantic. And I don't think there's much of a leap in terms of abstraction if you just jump from "compared to the other kids, my kid is ok" to "compared to this number on a chart, my kid is ok". That is just a change in what data point you prefer to reference, not a change in thought patterns.
- king_jester 15y agoThis is a key point. BMI by itself is not an accurate indication of a person's health. I often see discussions freely interchange being overweight with being unhealthly, even though we only have data for some types of health conditions correlating with higher body weight. To my knowledge, there is no single score or data point that can be used to accurately assess an individual's health.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- ufo 15y agoI can see you point but the kids mentioned in the survey are from the most obese 15% of the population so they really are chubbier then their neighbors.
- deliciouscoffee 15y agoThere's an interesting study in the New England journal of medicine related to this. The authors found that having social ties to an obese person significantly increased an individuals chance of becoming obese. From the study: A person's chances of becoming obese increased by 57% (95% confidence interval [CI], 6 to 123) if he or she had a friend who became obese in a given interval.[0] One of the authors is quoted as saying: “You change your idea of what is an acceptable body type by looking at the people around you,” Dr. Christakis said.[1] [0]http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMsa066082 http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMsa066082 [1]http://www.nytimes.com/2007/07/25/health/25cnd-fat.html http://www.nytimes.com/2007/07/25/health/25cnd-fat.html
- tdfx 15y agoAnd going out to eat with them probably doesn't help, either.
- Someone 15y agoBe surprised (I was). http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/117/3/681 http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/117/3/681: "Respondents were grouped by child body mass index (BMI) percentile (<5th, 5–84th, 85–94th [at risk for overweight (AROW)], and ≥95th [overweight])." Apparently, those parents are not alone in thinking 'overweight' is a relative term.
- rmassie 15y agoI see so frequently that when a child is overweight, their parents are overweight as well. I wonder what their perception of their own weight is.
- firefoxman1 15y agoIt's really crazy how your eating habits are influenced by your parents. My mother is really into eating really healthy and both I and my sister eat healthier by choice now. I remember when I was really young my mom's friends were impressed that I willingly ate vegetables...they were actually impressed by that! I would always notice the look on my mom's face like "...uh why wouldn't he?" It's really kind of sad that eating your vegetables nowadays is impressive.
- JonnieCache 15y agoPeoples' perception of various tastes vary dramatically, partially through genetic factors (some people are even termed "supertasters,") but also with age. There is research showing that children perceive bitterness especially strongly, and that this attenuates with age. See: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3087510/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3087510/ Age modifies the genotype-phenotype relationship for the bitter receptor TAS2R38 So when some children say they don't like vegetables, it may not be such an illegitimate claim after all. I personally still cannot stand brussel sprouts, into my mid 20s.
- firefoxman1 15y agoYeah I've seen a study that showed a gene is traced to a 50/50 of people liking cilantro.
- dgordon 15y agoI never had them until my mid-20s, but apparently a lot of people's only experience of brussels sprouts is boiled to death, which allegedly increases their bitterness. I've had them roasted, and they were reasonably good.
- deleted 15y ago
- niels_olson 15y agoHere's my experience in primary care: obese parents bring in their obese child with a complaint of some minor illness. My sense is they tend to be less confident in themselves than leaner folk, so they tend to resort more frequently to more physical positioning to get an antibiotic for their kid's viral URI. It probably doesn't help that they had to endure more stress at home before rising to the necessary motivation to move, then moving itself is more of an effort. By the time they've been sitting in the waiting room for an hour and the clinic room for 10-15 minutes, they're just in a foul mood. Being in a closed room with large, physically unhappy people can be intimidating, never mind that there's a waiting room full of other patients. Rather than addressing ancillary issues head on, it's infinitely more convenient to focus on customer service for their immediate issue. The issue needs to be addressed in a more benign setting.
- utyhretyudyt 15y agoIt's unlikely - statistically - to be a physical thing, but either way it don't explain why you, are in the queue, at Burger King... - Tim Minchin
- SNK 15y agoSince so-called overweight - BMI 25-30 - is the longest-lived cohort, I'd say parents aren't the only ones with distorted perceptions.
- drblue 15y agoCitations please. If that was true, I've learned a new fact that conflicts with most of what I know about obesity having an effect on, for example, heart disease. The first link when googling for "lifespan by bmi" is: http://wehrintheworld.blogspot.com/2009/05/bmi-and-life-expectancy-results.html http://wehrintheworld.blogspot.com/2009/05/bmi-and-life-expe... Which cites two metareviews. The first is a collaboration between the UK Medical Research Council, several British organizations including one out of Oxford, and the US National Institute on Aging (which is under the NIH umbrella). It was published in _The Lancet_ (Impact factor: 33). I will quote the quoted part from said blogpost: > BMI is in itself a strong predictor of overall mortality both above and below the apparent optimum of about 22·5–25 kg/m2. The progressive excess mortality above this range is due mainly to vascular disease and is probably largely causal. At 30–35 kg/m2, median survival is reduced by 2–4 years; at 40–45 kg/m2, it is reduced by 8–10 years (which is comparable with the effects of smoking). The definite excess mortality below 22·5 kg/m2 is due mainly to smoking-related diseases, and is not fully explained. While I found a few studies that didn't find a correlation (including one in AMA), I can't actually find an academic source for the claim that people with a BMI of 25-30 have the longest lifespan and see lots of claims that the optimal BMI is in the low 20s. Do you have any citations handy?
- blahedo 15y agoIf you run a search for '"slightly overweight" live longer', you'll turn up links to a number of different studies in a number of different jurisdictions that have shown this. For instance: http://lifehacker.com/5303009/being-slightly-overweight-could-lead-to-longer-life http://lifehacker.com/5303009/being-slightly-overweight-coul...
- Cass 15y agoI'd be interested in the link to that study, if you have it.
- redfiche 15y agoI don't understand this, it's such a routine part of the doctor visit for my two sons for them to tell us what percentile the boys are in for both height and weight. At one point one boy went above the 75% in weight and we immediately made changes. Are pediatricians really not giving out this data on a routine basis?
- uncr3ative 15y agobut being 75% in weight amongst 1 year olds isn't necessarily indication that he should lose weight. S/he might be 98% in height.
- civilian 15y agoThey do comparisons between the height & weight percentiles.
- Someone 15y agoAs another reply said, being heavier than the average kid need not be a problem, e.g. When your kid also is taller than normal. Your logic is broken (or you do not present all of it) in a different way: a quick google gives me the impression that for kids in the USA, the 75th percentile is about the edge case, but you need extra data to convert percentiles to 'being too heavy'. In the extreme, if everybody is overweight, even the lightest percent of kids will be overweight).
- redfiche 15y agoMy only intent was to say that in my experience some data has been quite readily available. In our case it was enough data to understand our son's weight was trending in an unhealthy direction. We made small changes to the quantity and quality of food available to him and reversed the trend. The 75th percentile just happened to be the trigger in our personal case. I make no suggestion that it is an appropriate trigger in general, or that it equates to 'being too heavy.'
- billybob 15y agoA lovely interchange my wife overheard in a medical office: Parent: "He needs to gain weight, right?" Doctor: "Why do you think that?" Parent: "You can see some of his bones!" Doctor: "You're SUPPOSED to be able to see SOME of them."
- robododo 15y agoI found it really interesting that someone piped up in the blog comments disagreeing with the measure for overweight: "Since so-called overweight – BMI 25-30 – is the longest-lived cohort, parents aren’t the only ones with screwed up perceptions, IMO." Denial's everywhere, I guess. Tangentially related: I was buying a coat as a gift for my mother, and was perplexed by the sizes. So I went to my local expert: Me: "What's up with all the women's sizes? They're all 1-X, 2-X, etc." Wife: "Oh, 'woman' sizes mean fat. Misses means normal." Me: DOES NOT COMPUTE So even sizes in stores work to make people feel they're ok. 1X isn't "extra large" It's "woman sized". WTF?
- Dylan16807 15y agoBringing up conflicting evidence in a scientific discussion is denial?
- mikeash 15y agoBringing up a single piece of conflicting evidence and using it to declare the other side to be completely wrong is definitely denial.
- Dylan16807 15y agoI don't read that as declaring the other side completely wrong. That study was for people a little bit overweight, while the apparent delusion of parents extends into the very overweight. Even the phrasing of "aren't the only ones with distorted perceptions" suggests that both sides have their failures.
- mikeash 15y agoThis may just be a pessimal interpretation of humanity, but I definitely read that sort of flip response as a quick way to dismiss the entire side's merits, attempting to show that they have an obvious agenda, are ignoring something obvious that shows they're wrong, etc. I certainly could be misinterpreting.
- 15y ago
- tokenadult 15y ago"Does Weight Matter?" by Steven Novella of Science-Based Medicine http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/index.php/does-weight-matter/ http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/index.php/does-weight-ma... has a good discussion of the definitional issues. The article links to pro and con sources about whether excessive weight can lead to health problems, with discussion of logical fallacies related to arguments on the issue.
- blahedo 15y agoOh, where to start. - BMI is a poor measure of obesity. Among other things, bone and muscle are both significantly denser than fat. People, including children, with thicker bones and/or more muscle will have higher BMI regardless of fatness. So it's at best a poor proxy for fatness, not the One True Measurement that so many people use it for. - BMI is an especially poor measure for children. The ideal BMI (to the extent that means anything) varies according to developmental stage. Which is why you'll get tables and graphs for BMI that are indexed by age---except that age and developmental stage are themselves only roughly correlated, and a child at an earlier or later stage than is typical for their age will not be well-described by such a chart, and the "ideal BMI" that the chart lists for that child's age will actually be a non-ideal BMI for that child. - BMI percentile is an even poorer measure, because it provides only a comparison against the population; if the population is skinny, even a high percentile might not be overweight, and if the population is fat, even a low percentile might be overweight. And that's modulo all the concerns in the previous two paragraphs. - Even after taking all of that into account, we still have the problem that our conventional idea of "overweight" meaning "more weight/fat than is healthy" is likely inaccurate, in that some amount of certain kinds of fat actually make one healthier, and (as cited elsewhere in this thread) people who fall into the range often called "slightly overweight" actually live longer. So evaluating kids' health (or their parents' assessment thereof) with reference to their BMI percentage is fraught in four different ways with inherent, systemic problems.