6 ms·
Proposal: have every US adult pay a flat $52 extra in taxes a year. This amounts to $1 a week. Let's say this collects $150 million a week, assuming 150 million
by kibwen 4y ago
Proposal: have every US adult pay a flat $52 extra in taxes a year. This amounts to $1 a week. Let's say this collects $150 million a week, assuming 150 million taxpaying adults. Have the government hold a nationwide lottery where, every week, this $150 million pot gets split into 500 parts and handed out to 500 different people. That's 500 random people a week receiving $300,000 dollars, a life-changing amount of money for most people, and all it cost them was $1 to enter. Then, abolish all other lotteries (EDIT: referring to the state-run lotteries).
Obviously this doesn't change the fundamental probability of lotteries, but most people are happy to pay $1 for a remote chance of winning $300,000 (and you can even let people opt out if they don't want to participate). It preserves the entertainment aspect (broadcast the pulls and make a weekly event out of it), creates a shared cultural touchstone (maybe dectuple the pot for the week of Christmas or something), while also eliminating the weird perversity of our current state-run lotteries that prey on gambling addicts.
EDIT: Can I ask the downvoters to elaborate?
- nerdponx 4y agoI'm curious why this was downvoted myself, I actually like the idea.
- djbusby 4y agoSeems not-downvoted to me. I like the idea of more winners rather than more money for fewer winners. I don't like the national aspect. Nobody should be obligated to play.
- kibwen 4y agoAs I mention in the comment, it's fine to let people opt out. And you don't need to tell anybody that you opted out, so you can still participate in the spectacle even if your chance of winning is now literally 0% (as opposed to "vanishingly close to 0%").
- cercatrova 4y agoInteresting proposal. However, will it stop the compulsive gamblers? Maybe they'll just find somewhere else to gamble. This already happens in countries where gambling is illegal like China. This reminds me of the No-Lose Lottery concept by Freakonomics as well: https://freakonomics.com/podcast/is-america-ready-for-a-no-lose-lottery/ https://freakonomics.com/podcast/is-america-ready-for-a-no-l...
- kibwen 4y agoI'm not suggesting to make lotteries illegal at the federal level, only to abolish the for-profit lotteries run by the states.
- sicp-enjoyer 4y agoEvery initiative is just "another $1 a week". You add a few thousand of those taxes and pretty soon it's real money.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoIf we add enough $1 a week, everyone can win the lottery every week.
- hackeraccount 4y agoEvery week there's a $100 dollar lottery that everyone wins! Everyone is forced to play. Tickets are $100 each. Buy as many tickets as you like.
- jason-phillips 4y agoThat won't address compulsive gamblers and therefore won't address the problems identified in a material way. As someone who worked in a very popular convenience store north of the University of Texas campus for four years during college, I watched them gamble obscene amounts while obviously living in poverty. I believe the compulsive gamblers will still be driven to gamble away as much of their available cash as they possibly can. (I didn't downvote you)
- Dylan16807 4y agoBanning other lotteries should make it much harder for those people to get hooked in the first place, shouldn't it?
- jason-phillips 4y agoI believe they'll still find a way, as the article describes. There will be an unmet need and potential market that will be satisfied, outside the bounds of what's lawful.
- parineum 4y agoLotteries were originally run by organized crime. Legalizing state run lotteries was essentially the cure for that.
- chucksta 4y agoYou think lotteries are only 100 years old? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lottery#Early_United_States_1612%E2%80%931900 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lottery#Early_United_States_16... >Lotteries in colonial America played a significant part in the financing of both private and public ventures. It has been recorded that more than 200 lotteries were sanctioned between 1744 and 1776, and played a major role in financing roads, libraries, churches, colleges, canals, bridges, etc.[5] In the 1740s, the foundation of Princeton and Columbia Universities was financed by lotteries, as was the University of Pennsylvania by the Academy Lottery in 1755.
- moistly 4y ago
- zzleeper 4y agoUnder what argument should it be reasonable to force people to play the lottery and pay $1/week for it? I don't play the lottery, feel it's stupid and just a tax on impossibly optimistic people (or those good at math), and would be quite annoyed at having to play this lottery and pay money for it.
- nerdponx 4y agoThe point is to offset the loss in tax revenue. Very few people will notice a $52 increase in taxes, and you can set an income minimum for it if you prefer (scaling up the amount as needed to hit the revenue target).
- BrianOnHN 4y ago> Under what argument should it be reasonable To narrow the gap luck currently plays in life outcomes. Currently, you are either born lucky, trust funds and generational real estate, or not. More chances to be "lucky" would enable more opportunities for more people. And the OP suggests a negligible cost to make that happen.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoIt seems like this would do the opposite. It simply increases the role that luck plays in life outcomes. If you take luck to be bad, this is not an improvement. If you disagree, Why don't we just increase the number of people born with trust funds and generational wealth, at the cost to the rest of society. This would have much the same effect as instituting the lottery. Being lucky and winning a lottery is just as "unfair" as being lucky and being born to the right household.
- sokoloff 4y agoEverything you describe seems to be increasing the role that luck plays, by giving 52 more chances per year to be lucky enough to win a helpful amount [but not trust fund/generational real estate level] of money.
- 4y ago
- jareklupinski 4y ago...have every *willing US adult pay...
- reducesuffering 4y agoThis is just inequality-increasing wealth redistribution, the opposite of taxes, that does nothing to prevent compulsive gamblers from still playing shady criminal underground gambling. You're taking a bit from the poorest, responsible non-gamblers, and enriching just a few who will mostly irresponsibly spend it into smithereens.
- kibwen 4y agoIt's less inequality-increasing than the current Powerball lottery.
- reducesuffering 4y agoI don't see how. Currently, it's optional for everyone. You would be mandatory increasing inequality for 99.9% of people, as opposed to what, the current 5% of lotto ticket buyers?
- bequanna 4y agoI think you don’t quite understand why people participate in lotteries and gamble. Lottery scratch off tickets are especially popular because of the possibility of many plays in a short period with intermittent rewards. Also, in your scheme participating in the nation lottery is compulsory? That doesn’t sit well with me
- kibwen 4y agoTo reiterate my comment, participation does not need to be compulsory for this scheme to work.
- HarryHirsch 4y agomost people are happy to pay $1 for a remote chance of winning $300,000 The wealthy class is of course happy to pay a small amount in lotto lobbying to ward off larger proportional tax increases to fund infrastructure. Hence we are stuck with lotto 4 times a week.
- Dylan16807 4y agoDo you have evidence for that? I would have expected the lottery to pay for its own pushing.
- beebmam 4y agoWhat is your evidence, beyond an apriori argument, that this would lead to something helpful? Why should I be compelled by the state to give my money to something that isn't clearly helpful to society?
- kibwen 4y agoAs I mention in my comment, there's no problem with letting people opt out.
- BitwiseFool 4y agoIs this something akin to that checkbox on your tax return indicating you want to donate $3 to the Presidential Election Campaign fund? I think the main difference is that it would be an extra amount you'd pay, rather than having the government allocate that $3 from the total amount that was going to the treasury. https://www.fec.gov/introduction-campaign-finance/understanding-ways-support-federal-candidates/presidential-elections/public-funding-presidential-elections/ https://www.fec.gov/introduction-campaign-finance/understand...
- aamoscodes 4y agoExcept the PEC goes to political candidates and this money would materially help someone each year. Every person in the country could use the PEC and candidates would still need to court donations from PACs and other groups. $300k to a set number of families? We could write articles about them each year to see how this changed their lives. Even if the recipients are already wealthy it would turn into an interesting story.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- msla 4y agoBelieve it or not, some people honestly have moral scruples against gambling. Sine those scruples don't really hurt anyone else, forcing them to violate those scruples is just mean.
- kibwen 4y agoNobody is being forced to participate. As I mention, you can let people opt out. I wonder if anyone is reading my comment at all?
- Maxburn 4y agoCompulsory enrolment in a lottery? This isn't remotely legal. Also I view lotteries as taxes on those that don't understand probability and money investing.
- Dylan16807 4y agoThe government can tax you. The government can give out money to random people. What do you mean not legal? Especially because the government writes the laws...
- Maxburn 4y agoSo just change the words and suddenly it looks like all the other taxation theft they are already doing. Got it.
- Dylan16807 4y agoOh if you think taxes in general are illegal, go for it, but you should state that upfront instead of making it sound like you think this one is special.
- gspencley 4y ago1) Don't force me into a scheme that I don't want to participate in. Maybe "most people" are willing to gamble a small amount of their hard-earned income. I am not. I choose not to buy lottery tickets because such systems do not appeal to me and I have better things to spend $52 on. Like buying a pair of shoes for my child for the school year. 2) Your math doesn't account for the administration costs of such a system. 3) Not to get us into a libertarian "taxes are theft" debate, but if we can agree on the necessity of government services and the funding thereof, then I don't see why it should be controversial to try and find optional alternatives to taxation whenever possible. Lotteries might have their drawbacks, and we can debate whether lotteries are a good way to go about getting funding, but at least they are an opt-in / voluntary way to raise funding for those services. No one has gone to jail or had their assets seized for failing to buy a lottery ticket.
- kibwen 4y ago> Don't force me into a scheme that I don't want to participate in. As I've typed four times so far, my comment mentions that there's no problem letting people opt out.
- anjc 4y agoThat's essentially what lottery/prize/premium bonds are, albeit they're optional https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lottery_bond https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lottery_bond
- Dylan16807 4y ago> most people are happy to pay $1 for a remote chance of winning $300,000 Sure, as a novelty. Not hundreds of times every few years.
- sokoloff 4y agoJust over 57% of US households are already paying zero or negative federal income tax. This scheme amounts to a giveaway of an extra sum to them, rather than an increase in taxes to them (except for the tiny sliver who are between $0 and -$52 per adult per year in federal income taxes).
- hackeraccount 4y agoTrue... up to a point. I'm not a fan of the parent so this isn't a defense of the idea but saying "income taxes" is a bit of a cheat. Taxes are taxes. So, what percent of of households pay taxes? If you look at not just income but sales taxes, sin taxes,payroll taxes and pass-through taxes I'd bet the answer is 100% or close to it. And it's probably more then $1 a week. That said, the idea of adding an optional poll tax lottery seems dopey.
- kibwen 4y agoDopey or not, the question I'm attempting to raise is whether it has desirable properties compared to our current state-run lotteries. In a just world, perhaps this wouldn't be necessary. But I don't know how to make the world a just one, sadly.
- aamoscodes 4y agoCorrect, most of the US does not make enough money to need to pay taxes. This proposal would actually decrease that number, because receiving $300k in one year (if we tax it as income) means you will need to contribute taxes that year...maybe they can even use part of their net earnings to contribute $60 to the fund, so someone else will have enough money to pay taxes the following year.
- sokoloff 4y agoOne positive aspect of this is that, assuming we taxed these payments as income, it would reduce the deficit by around $2.5B/yr, or around 0.1% of the deficit.