13 ms·
New study suggests people with dark personalities weaponize victimhood (2021)
- AndrewKemendo 4y agoNarcissists have completely invaded and taken over every “safe space” as the predators they are. This has been my going thesis for a while now. Most humans have natural empathy for each other. There is a natural sense of fairness, desire for equanimity and caring for others that is built in to our social systems. This was recently experimentally shown that all humans share two social traits: a sense of fairness and that unprovoked violence is unjust Over the last 70-80 years society has made huge strides (though nowhere near "done") in supporting entire classes of people who have been systematically oppressed or otherwise victims of marginalization. More importantly though, we as a society have decided to give more grace and patience to victims because they need healing and support - something that non-victims and non-protected people don't get because they simply don't need it as much. Further we have systematically expanded the definition of what a victim looks like. I recall as a child that physical abuse was the only thing we would consider “abuse” but now we know better. Mental and emotional abuse can be as devastating if not more than physical, so we give grace to those who are struggling mentally – and usually in ways that do not present obviously. As a species, we have righteously determined that it is traumatic, crude and uncouth to interrogate someone on their victim credentials in order to prove they are actual victims. So the barrier to entry for being part of a marginalized group is simply telling your story. To people who aren't victims, this looks like a power shift but also a "break" from having to be a good person. Specifically there is a sense that political/social power is being systematically transferred from non-protected groups that have traditionally held power, to marginalized or protected classes of people. Whether the above shift in political power is true or not is irrelevant - as the true nature of who holds power hasn't shifted in any significant way from what I can tell. Malignant narcissists want to play life on easy and if throwing up a victim card just works then they will lie and do whatever it takes to be part of that group. So what can a malignant narcissist to do if they aren't truly a victim, that will confer on them the most prized status, that of victim? The answer is simple: Join a traditionally oppressed community by lying about your experience, exploiting the inclusive nature of the community so you can claim the moral high ground as a victim, usurp the organization for your own ends and continue to keep marginalized people oppressed. Rachel Dolezal [1] is the poster child of this. So, how do you spot it? At least for me, the most obvious cases are when a person from a non-protected class, identifies strongly and loudly as someone from a marginalized or protected group - especially if that marginalization is subtle and/or non-verifiable. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rachel_Dolezal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rachel_Dolezal
- cloutchaser 4y ago[flagged]
- standardUser 4y agoJust because bad actors can take advantage of a more expansive idea of privilege and victimhood does not mean it's a bad thing. If anything, it exposes those who take advantage as exactly the type of people the article is talking about. Although some people may successfully use the queer label, or any other label, disingenuously as a shield or a weapon, I'd consider that most of the time those abuses are transparent and draw ire from people who more genuinely align with a stigmatized label. In other words, it's a somewhat self-correcting problem. There will always be people who take advantage. Let's not let them ruin it for the rest of us.
- mistrial9 4y agoor this one: https://www.the-sun.com/entertainment/tv/3414502/woman-killed-nazi-hid-in-forest-with-wolves-lies/ https://www.the-sun.com/entertainment/tv/3414502/woman-kille...
- BlargMcLarg 4y ago>At least for me, the most obvious cases are when a person from a non-protected class That only works for the very obvious cases. Plenty of 'protected class' individuals exist who in reality live far more privileged than those not in a 'protected class'. The basis being people are trying to substitute empathy and common sense with catch-all rules. Which in the context of humans has worked out a grand total of 0 times across our entire existence.
- AndrewKemendo 4y agoIndeed - hence my caveat
- MichaelZuo 4y ago> As a species, we have righteously determined that it is traumatic, crude and uncouth to interrogate someone on their victim credentials in order to prove they are actual victims. So the barrier to entry for being part of a marginalized group is simply telling your story. No? If this is a joke it seems like an odd place to put it. Otherwise you really need to get out more and talk with ordinary folks anywhere in the world, especially in the construction trades, because the vast majority of them don't ascribe to this at all. This kind of catastrophic virtue signalling spiral simply doesn't occur among large segments of the working population.
- bannedbybros 4y ago
- hjkl0 4y agoThe title sounded like a joke at first. But the term “dark personality” is explained inside: > New research provides evidence that narcissism, psychopathy, and Machiavellianism — maladaptive personality traits known as the “Dark Triad” — are associated with overt displays of virtue and victimhood I feel like the title could also have been: “people with dark personalities suck”
- onecommentman 4y agoThis discussion in the comments involves a lot of talk about “victimhood”, “narcissism”, “privilege”, etc. without a formal definition of these terms. A lot of the heat in the discussion would disappear if a common definition of these terms were proposed and agreed to. Even more would disappear if those definitions were measurable in some objective sense. Otherwise I find discussions like this devolve into an unnecessary and unpleasant exercise in semantics and a waste of good photons. It seems like a generational malady. As a side note, I find it is more rhetorically and psychologically powerful to simply describe a disadvantaged situation you (or someone else) are in, rather than adding “and I’m/they are a victim”. When you add the word “victim”, you leave yourself open to bickering about what a “victim” is and how you/they should respond as such, which is distracting from the main point of effectuating change. Allowing the reader/listener themselves to complete the thought “wow, you/they really got screwed over” in their own mind takes advantage of their natural psychological need for closure. Since the reader/listener themselves will be making that closure, your/their disadvantaged situation will make a more powerful impact on them and the description would be more likely to lead to positive action. If you are simply looking for an enabler to help feed your psychological need for being perceived as a victim, well, call yourself a “victim” all you want, and good luck in finding someone to complete that folie à deux.
- random314 4y agoI have never met anyone who doesn't think of themselves as a victim. I include myself. It is almost like a fundamental human trait. I think Dale Carnegies "7 habits" book should have made this concept well known.
- FooBarBizBazz 4y agoThis seems related to David Graeber's idea that money was originally a moral instrument more associated with temples, than a purely secular phenomenon emerging from trade. To have-been-wronged becomes a fact of accounting. I think of -- -- sacrifices that people make. Mortifications of the flesh and so on. "Wrong yourself so the universe owes you something." -- blood money paid in the Islamic and old Germanic worlds. -- a brokerage account, with assets and liabilities. -- how much of the New Testament is full of financial metaphors. The rich man accumulates his fortune on earth, but the righteous man accumulates his fortune in heaven. But then I also think of -- central bankers, who magic money into existence -- Bitcoin, Ethereum, and the rest. Which brings me back to the observation -- -- Bitcoin is structured like a cult, in which you make a sacrifice to join (exchanging money for it, or wasting electricity), after which you then have an incentive for membership in the tribe (ownership of Bitcoin) to confer benefits (i.e., for the price to appreciate faster than other assets). You really want to be able to say "to hell with it" and escape the game. To stop accumulating karma and live perched up on a cliff face.
- throwaway0asd 4y ago[flagged]
- kayodelycaon 4y agoNew study, the sky is blue the majority of the time. Anyone with a "dark personality" will use any means of manipulation they can. This includes playing on people's sympathy. Slight tangent to the article which is more generic: The sad fact is things like acceptance of mental health and acknowledgement that sexual assault is far more common than people want to amit, will result in more people claiming these things falsely. Which causes further harm to the people this would help.
- denton-scratch 4y agoYeah, I gave up after a few paras. Manipulative folk gonna manipulate.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- anxiously 4y agoThe article talks about signals of virtue and victimhood being exploited by people high in the dark triad to get what they want. I don't think it is tied specifically to the dark triad at all.. but maybe people high in any of the triad have learned to exploit the technique to get what they want. You could make the case that virtue signaling and victimhood was always a conscious or unconscious act to extract something of value from people.
- mjburgess 4y agoSure, under a kinda evo-psych/behavioural-eco analysis of why evolution, over a long span, has made us responsive to these signals.. yes. But that's a radically different kind of analysis than intention, which is under-determined by evolution. ie., say we're all subject to the same evo forces, but we all intend different things. To say that narcissists exploit a "victim-compassion" response is very different than saying genuine victims do. They "give off" the "genuine victim" signal with with good reasons and intending to act on those reasons, people help. Narcissists exploit the same signal but with the wrong reasons.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoThis actually an interesting question. I would counter that the narcissists also have the same reasons as "true" victims. They seek to personally benefit from the compassion of others. What sets them apart is not the motive or reason, but the execution. Narcissists are more apt to use deception to cultivate compassion.
- mjburgess 4y agoThat is what I would dispute. A victim who signals victimhood isnt necessary, indeed perhaps often, looking for help. Which is why so many victims arent helped, of course. If you're punched by a bully, you may just want to run away in shame -- yet, and onlooker may strongly desire to help you. By seeing help as something a victim intentionally seeks for the sake of their own benefit, we reduce them to selfish actors and eliminate psychology from the picture. This is often the trap evo-psych falls into: its adhearnts mistake an explanation of how X could evolve, for an explanation of why a given person in a given situation Xs. These are radically different. Evolution is a blind machine with no intention; if you perform this elimination you will mistakenly assume the same of people.
- sharkbird2 4y agoIs anybody surprised by this? Manipulative people will always use whatever is the popular/dominant ideology of their time and location to get any sort of benefit they can. It might be manifested as being the most fervent communist, fascist, pious/religious, or whatever it is the the society at the time holds high and dear. In our times it just happens to be victimhood and social justice things.
- icare_1er 4y agoIt takes around 1 or 2 years for the current LGBT flag to become outdated until a new minority in the minority wants its own colors and its own letter.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kayodelycaon 4y agoAs a member of an LGBT minority not on the flag, I wish we would just stick with the six-color flag. I feel like the constant bickering over who should be included on the flag distracts from the real problems.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dnissley 4y agoNo. But we are often told to always believe those claiming victimhood.
- Karellen 4y agoJust because a bunch of dark triad types have a propensity for lying about having been victimised, does not mean that most people who say they've been victimised are dark triad types lying about it. Yes, you should keep in the back of your mind that it's possible that someone who claims to be victimised might not be telling the truth, but your first instinct should be a presumption that they're telling the truth, and to act with compassion as if they are. Especially if you're not familiar with the ways in which they claim to have been victimised - your instincts about how you think that plays out might not be great if you've not actually been through it yourself.
- tareqak 4y agoThis article is from February 26, 2021.
- icare_1er 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- terminatornet 4y agowhat is the woke phenomenon?
- throw123123123 4y agohttps://www.econlib.org/wokism-in-the-developing-world/ https://www.econlib.org/wokism-in-the-developing-world/
- terminatornet 4y agooh thanks, turns out i'm a wokist, maybe even a wokaholic. I'm addicted to wokahol.
- ttpphd 4y agoHahahaha so it's illustrated by a triangle with three points of "maoists" (how dated, people are really showing their age), "Nazis", and "liberation" This is John Birch Society schizotypal stuff, not a definition of "woke".
- SuoDuanDao 4y agoAKA 'cancel culture' or 'political correctness gone mad'. I would glibly define it as 'high-stakes competitive virtue signaling by expressing empathy or acknowledging historic injustices harder than your rivals'.
- terminatornet 4y ago
- dandanua 4y ago
- photochemsyn 4y agoThis quote is a bit odd, it could easily be interpreted as a justification for authoritarian rule by entitled criminals: > "“Fortune and human imperfection assure that at some point in life everyone will experience suffering, disadvantage, or mistreatment,” wrote the authors of the new study. “When this happens, there will be some who face their burdens in silence, treating it as a private matter they must work out for themselves..." So, if one is a victim of a crime, or repression, or some other injustice, and one makes it a public issue (by, for example, seeking redress in a court of law), one is engaging in 'narcissisim, psychopathy and Machiavellianism'? What does the US Constitution have to say about this? > "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the government for a redress of grievances." Yes there are those who abuse the courts (and the court of public opinion) in the manner the authors describe, but I think the vast majority of cases don't fall into that category.
- thegrimmest 4y agoI think the problem is that we're constantly expanding the definition of "social injustice". Can you propose a bounded definition for the term?
- kypro 4y agoI feel there's a big difference between people who say something like, "here's why I think I'm a victim of [x]" and "I'm a victim, so I deserve [y]". I know when kids say they "deserve" anything I try to shut it down because while it may be true in some cases I think to embrace that kind of perspective can be damaging. In my opinion you shouldn't expect anything from the world, you should simply seek to be understood. If people understand your struggles then they most of the time they'll treat you well instinctively. Simply demanding that your understood and that you should be given what you deserve isn't a good way to approach things. That said, I'll be honest and admit that I 100% weaponise victimhood if I feel I'm being attacked unfairly. When people start accusing me of being x, y or z, then I'll happily twist that back around on them by playing my own victim cards.
- rayiner 4y ago> In my opinion you shouldn't expect anything from the world, you should simply seek to be understood. That’s expecting something, isn’t it? I much prefer the convention in Asia: don’t make yourself a burden; seek to make things easier for the people around you.
- musicale 4y ago> don’t make yourself a burden; seek to make things easier for the people around you It helps to stay young, rich, beautiful, healthy and free of any disability.
- 9wzYQbTYsAIc 4y ago> If people understand your struggles then they most of the time they'll treat you well instinctively That’s the crux of all social issues, isn’t it? Understanding the other means allowing yourself to be stood over and to stand under the other. Of course, it is quite difficult to determine and come to a consensus on the limits of understanding. Godwin’s Law, etc.
- xtiansimon 4y ago“Understanding the other means allowing yourself to be stood over and to stand under the other.” What does that mean? Is this some kind of post-modern critique of meaning?
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI think that there is something profoundly wrong when people aspire to be the victim rather than their hero in their own personal narrative. It is a form of stunted emotional growth. Virtue arises from overcoming challenges, not just suffering. Ascribing virtue to suffering itself leads to a race to the bottom, where the most noble society is that which suffers the most
- jimmyjazz14 4y agoIts easier to be a victim than a hero even in peoples minds.
- PartiallyTyped 4y agoSometimes you get tired of everything being a constant fight from the moment you were born. Sometimes you are tired of grinding endlessly with little if anything to show for it, all because we threw a bad dice at birth.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoIt absolutely is tiring! Still there is nothing virtuous or noble about suffering itself.
- lo_zamoyski 4y agoAs Marcus Aurelius once wrote, all men suffer, but not all men pity themselves. Somewhat tangentially: Thomas Aquinas once wrote that if we experience a loss, we may allow ourselves to grieve for a while, and then stop. The danger of sadness is that we may indulge it indefinitely and sink into despair. A person who wallows in such despair and self-pity would be well served by considering whether he is poisoned by envy, perhaps the envy of egalitarianism. To paraphrase Chesterton, at least the aristocrats of old had the satisfaction of feeling superior than others. The egalitarian man cuts down all those he fears are better than he is (typically by denying the qualities of others)! The majority of our suffering, especially the spiritual and psychological variety, is our own doing. There are plenty of people born with all sorts of conditions who live happy lives because they've accepted the immutable and made the best of the cards they were dealt. If self-pity deserves anything, it is not compassion, but contempt.
- bvoq 4y agoIn my experience the people who need the most help are those that don't ask for it but are still looking around helpless or grumble. It's a nice social cue to pick up on and feels great to help people like this. Grumbling is a nice signal of: If you can spare a hand, I will be happy.
- jmnicolas 4y agoOn the other hand when I'm grumbling it's because I want to be left alone.
- labrador 4y ago[flagged]
- PartiallyTyped 4y ago
- labrador 4y agoI was more offended by his Space Jews jokes than anything else. I am not Jewish but I think he went too far, but that's what comedians do. Nobody except grandma wants to go see a politically correct comedian. I think you along with many other people are missing his point. He has a problem with how black people are treated in this country, rightly so, and he has a problem with transgenders who want to say they have suffered more than his community and he is "punching down" on them. Like he said, some transgenders are victims until they need to white, then they call the cops. He signs off the special asking transgender community to stop "punching down" on black people. He's pretty clear about this but psychopaths will often deliberately misunderstand to make their case.
- PartiallyTyped 4y agoYes, because punching on an even smaller minority is a good way to make a point about how black people are treated /s instead of punching up to the majority. In fact, he cares so much about his community, that he is against affordable housing because of course he is a NIMBY [1]. The transgender people (not transgenders), do not claim they have suffered more than his community, that's a strawman. Let's ask black trans people how their community has treated them. This is a disgusting degree of mental gymnastics to excuse outright reprehensible behaviour. [1] https://reason.com/2022/02/10/dave-chappelle-is-a-nimby/ https://reason.com/2022/02/10/dave-chappelle-is-a-nimby/
- labrador 4y ago> punching on an even smaller minority I don't see it. He told some jokes. That's his job. > of course he is a NIMBY When you drag in issues not related to the discussion you might as well admit your main argument is weak
- throwaway290 4y agoIs this related to the problem of teenagers glorifying mental illness? Awareness and tolerance is good, but receiving attention by simply claiming you have it is addictive especially for those who are not getting enough attention e.g. from parents. I wonder if this is orthogonal to the topic or how it starts...
- chatterhead 4y agoYes, you are thinking down the correct thread. It gets scarier the further you go. Not because what it implies people are willing to do, but what people can be made to become.
- fallingfrog 4y agoOn a macro scale, the Christian right and certain specific politicians do appear to have an unwarranted persecution complex.
- IceHegel 4y agoWhy would we need a study to tell us this?
- jmyeet 4y agoSo what you see in the US political landscape is that there are people who, at least by global standards and even by domestic standards, have incredible privilege who love nothing more than to adopt an oppression aesthetic (eg the Great Replacement [1]). We also have seen the stratospheric rise of narcisism. I've wondered if this is a new phenomenon. If so, why now? If not, why was it seemingly less prevalent historically? Things like "hyper-individualism as a virtue", a core tenet of many modern American cultures, raiise the question: is this because of narcisism or the cause of it? Culturally we seem to celebrate what are (literally) psychopathic behaviors (eg CEOs of large companies). But here's another thought: maybe the attraction of a sense of oppression is closely related to the human need for a sense of purpose, to be part of something. Organized religion in the West is in decline but it usually provided this structure. It's scary for many to think that everything is just random and when you die, that's it. There's a certain comfort and structure in being part of soemthing, even if that something is (or is construed as) oppression. I believe this is a strong motivator for the resilience of conspiracy theories. As for weaponizing victimhood, here's a good rule to live by: from a narcissist, every accusation is a confession. It tends to work in reverse too, meaning if you find someone making really hpocritical and logically inconsistent statements or accusations, which they themselves don't abide by or are guilty of, it tends to be fairly strong evidence of narcissism. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Replacement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Replacement
- trgn 4y ago> We also have seen the stratospheric rise of narcisism. > I've wondered if this is a new phenomenon Christopher Lasch in the 70s has a very precise answer to your question. Narcissism is the inevitable defense mechanism to navigate a society in which all organization of civic and family life are increasingly bureaucratic, state-governed, and transactional, a defense mechanism in a society in which all models and ideals are mediated by imagery and advertisement. In such a society, man cannot but end up with a personality that's hesitant to make close bonds of affection or develop personal loyalty. It is inevitable to nurture insecurities about one's own station in life or one's role in the power structure, about one's physical appearance. To thrive in such a society of impersonal bureaucracy and cult of youth, one almost has, by necessity, to be low key manipulative, congenial on the surface, effortless "cool", preoccupied with projection of identity and youthful vigor. His are two important insights imho: His analysis precedes internet-era, the preconditions are more fundamental than just social media-fueled victim culture. Also, current epidemic of absorption is at its core a survival strategy for a bureaucratic, technisized world; we cannot expect any change unless the relations between labor, family, and state do not fundamentally become less bureaucratic.
- PuppyTailWags 4y agoBefore we go runaway with this, I think it's reasonable to also ask: how many people who are displaying victimhood are victims? Maybe people who desire to manipulate others may use victimhood to do so, but are they statistically significant in population to all victims?
- BlargMcLarg 4y agoFor what it's worth, these questions have been asked in the context of women/men and sexual conduct. The pendulum swung from "women are ridiculed for being victims" to "men can't be victims and women are always victims". Research is now coming out that a lot of male victims go unnoticed and quite a few women are misusing the status quo. Now the pendulum threatens to swing back to "women are ridiculed" again. The question itself only matters if no method exists where the pendulum can be dampened more quickly. Given history, there is reason to believe such a method exists.
- PuppyTailWags 4y agoYes, in the context of sexual misconduct what is the percentage of victims who are actually victims? Like if narcissists lying about sexual misconduct is statistically a rounding error, that's really important to know.
- BlargMcLarg 4y agoThis is changing all the time due to the way it is reported, extrapolation, etc. But let's be extreme and pretend half are false. Of the half that are false, only a portion has a narcissist false flagging. All the cases are man on woman. Now I don't believe the number of false accussations is close to half (yet, anyway), but even if it were, ask yourself: Would you want to ignore the half of true victims, Would you utilize an aggressive method (e.g. Duluth model) or utilize a safer method, if you know one exists, and Does any of this mean woman on man sexual misconduct should be downplayed? Sure, the actual statistics matter once trade offs come into play. But people are already failing the basic litmus test of answering the questions above. And that's how the pendulum of grief swings on.
- Borrible 4y agoFind your niche and exceed at it! Predators, parasites, mimikry. There must be some social-ecological equivalent. Don't be envious, it's natural.
- xkcd1963 4y agoOne does not need to call himself a scientist in order to arrive to these obvious observations
- 9wzYQbTYsAIc 4y agoThe art of science could be described as making that which is elusive, obvious, and to doubt that which is obvious, as elusive.
- xkcd1963 4y agoIt probably doesn't help that I believe that social science is not a science.
- 9wzYQbTYsAIc 4y agoNo, it probably doesn’t help - it could be a source of cognitive dissonance for you.
- xkcd1963 4y agoYou mean that I don't agree? Thanks sherlock.
- 9wzYQbTYsAIc 4y agoNo, my dear watson - I mean that your disbelief in that particular sub-discipline of science may cause you a headache someday.
- xkcd1963 4y agoOr it causes societal damage already by people taking it too seriously. Like people used to believe that graphology was a serious thing and that using your left hand might cause brain damage. Those things got replaced by psychology
- pressurefree 4y ago