5 ms·
Western media in most western countries isn’t state controlled, and so heavily influenced by public sentiment, not the other way around. Russia never really had
by seanmcdirmid 4y ago
Western media in most western countries isn’t state controlled, and so heavily influenced by public sentiment, not the other way around. Russia never really had a chance in the war of public opinion in the west: whenever they attack other countries they are just assumed to be the bad guys. But really, being the aggressor in most of their incidents is not a good look.
- logicalmonster 4y ago
- jonnybgood 4y ago“The algorithms that decide…” You’re sounding conspiratorial. You need to provide some evidence for your claims.
- logicalmonster 4y agoThat is literally what algorithms do: they decide what items are selected or not based on whatever criteria are selected.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoI get it, Russians really believe as you do about western societies, that somehow Biden controls FoxNews from behind the shadows, or that somehow Trump banned himself on Twitter. But if you think about the cases where government, social media, and traditional media have come into conflict, centralized government control really doesn’t add up.
- pydry 4y agoBeing run by two dueling oligarchical camps (US) vying for control and imperial expansion is arguably not much better than being run by one (Russia). In spite of your sly misimplication, both systems are far more alike than they are similar to, say, an egalitarian swiss style direct democracy.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoBut which one runs which? Democrats get as angry at twitter as much as republicans do. It seems like Twitter is run for…profit alone rather than catering to either one of those parties. > Either way neither one runs an egalitarian swiss style direct democracy. Having lived in Switzerland before, that sounds like a bit of an exaggeration.
- patrick451 4y ago
- fooblaster 4y agoThe Biden administration is not involved with censorship of social media.
- nomel 4y agoThere’s evidence, and a lawsuit, about the White House pressuring Twitter with Alex Berenson [1]. It appears the FBI manipulated Facebook [2]. There are probably more. 1. https://www.wsj.com/articles/biden-and-twitter-censorship-alex-berenson-covid-vaccines-white-house-social-media-11660335186 https://www.wsj.com/articles/biden-and-twitter-censorship-al... 2. https://news.yahoo.com/mark-zuckerberg-tells-joe-rogan-205738193.html https://news.yahoo.com/mark-zuckerberg-tells-joe-rogan-20573...
- nomel 4y agoIs this somehow wrong? Let's hope the outcome of the lawsuits are widely known, reported fairly by the media, and taken seriously.
- pydry 4y ago>being the aggressor in most of their incidents is not a good look Aggression is very much narrative based. There are very few conflicts in real life that didnt involve an extremely long chain of provocations and counter provocations with each side playing down their own provocations and playing up the other's. In this sense nobody is 'truly' an aggressor when they tell their own story. In the case of America's unbridled aggression against Afghanistan there was 90% public support & 55% in iraq so apparently sometimes the look of unbridled aggression is good. I dont know why we'd expect the Russian public to be full of hippy peaceniks when our aggressive imperialism can enjoy such widespread support. Western media might not be state controlled but it is all essentially controlled by a very limited number set of oligarchic power centers vying for power. The net effect is pretty similar. The example given here, is, in any case state controlled - the BBC is essentially little more than a western RT since david kelly.
- nyokodo 4y ago> America's unbridled aggression against Afghanistan there was 90% public support To characterize the US invasion of Afghanistan as “unbridled aggression” is a gross misrepresentation to the point of being a sign of unreasonable partisanship at the very least. The reason it had 90% public support as well as participation from NATO and other US allies is because there was proof that Afghanistan was a state sponsor of the 9/11 attacks on US soil. A military response was warranted which precludes “unbridled aggression” as a description by any good faith commentary. Criticism of the strategy of occupation and regime change as containing aspects of aggression, that is definitely reasonable.
- pydry 4y ago>To characterize the US invasion of Afghanistan as “unbridled aggression” is a gross misrepresentation to the point of being a sign of unreasonable partisanship Americans are not typically aware of it (this is relevant to what I said about our provocations being downplayed), but the Taliban offered to hand UBL over if we supplied evidence of his guilt and put him on trial in a neutral country. Meanwhile, if you take your righteous indignation about what I said about Afghanistan you will have a template of a rough idea of how the average Russian feels about Ukraine. Were you born in Russia your views would probably align.
- hulitu 4y ago> Western media in most western countries isn’t state controlled Officially, you are right.
- illiac786 4y agoinnuendos without elaborating? Really? Even a 6 year old kid can do that.
- mysecretaccount 4y agoIf you're genuinely curious: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propaganda_model https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propaganda_model
- illiac786 4y agoI am curious about what your arguments are, but you refuse to name them. Sending me the definition of propaganda seems to indicate you think I don't know what propaganda is, I find this assumption very audacious on HN.
- mysecretaccount 4y agoThat is not a link to the definition of propaganda. Did you click the link?
- illiac786 4y agoThis a link to the Wikipedia article on propaganda. It's the definition and more. Again, not answering my question.
- mysecretaccount 4y ago> This a link to the Wikipedia article on propaganda. It is not. It is a link to a Wikipedia article summarizing Herman and Chomsky's propaganda model. If you are genuinely curious why people argue that US mass media is state controlled, you would be hard pressed to find a better starting point than that page. You are not genuinely curious though, so feel free to move on.
- wefarrell 4y agoIn the last 20 years the US government has exerted more control over the press by denying access to outlets that are more critical. The department of justice has been more aggressive in going after outlets that publish confidential information. Many government officials and politicians go on to work for outlets, compromising their independence.
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoDenying access? Well, they quit allowing them into presidential press conferences. That's a very very minor "denying access". They didn't deport them all. They didn't arrest them all. They didn't prohibit those outlets operating in the US. They restricted their access to official government sources (executive branch only, so far as I have seen). Well, if you want the truth about what's going on, a presidential press conference might not be the most trustworthy source anyway...
- globalreset 4y agoIn West we have a superior system where the interests of elites naturally align, so there is less need of forceful control. The effect however is exactly the same. Msm always just toots the elite aporoved narrative. There's not even a pretense of and disagreement in any meaningful subject. The whole purpose of NATO is being anti Russia and we've been expanding it despite our initial promises toward Russia. It's a basic tactic of "keep kicking the dog until it finally bites you, which is a perfect excuse to shoot it dead". But a typical western msm watcher is too distracted and dumb to notice as it is being used over and over again in different situations.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoIt’s not that simple: in the west we lack authoritarian leaders that stifle all the competition so that one viewpoint prevails. Instead, their are multiple “MSM”s with competing narratives, to the point that there is no unified narrative at all. Disagreement is simply the norm, and it is the lack of agreement that makes our media look weird to Russians, Chinese, and so on. I missed the point when Ukraine was inducted into NATO, making the Russian invasion completely valid and understandable. Ok, that’s sarcastic, but it makes my point that the Russian reasoning for this war was simply never going to fly, even if western media presents them exactly as Russian media does, they are still going to sound distasteful.
- globalreset 4y agoDisagreement? A norm? Hahahaha.
- wrp 4y ago> Western media in most western countries isn’t state controlled... Have to disagree. Western media and big tech have been very willing to control information flow to suit the desires of politicians if they are from the right political party. Considering how effective internet companies are at blocking things, I suspect that low-effort information searches online are more censored for Americans than they are for Russians.