13 ms·
Jessica Wade made more than 1k Wikipedia bios for unknown women scientists
- jonnycomputer 4y ago[fixed, so please disregard this comment now] Cool. But "BIOS"? Seems sort of a misleading headline (especially since its not in the headline in the linked article).
- rany_ 4y agoIt's probably some Hacker News rename rule.
- Brajeshwar 4y agoEdited. Sorry, I realize HN does some edits for the title when we submit articles.
- jonnycomputer 4y agoI didn't know that either!
- oboes 4y agoYou can look at Jessica Wade's contributions to Wikipedia there: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/Jesswade88 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/Jesswade...
- biztos 4y agoI picked one at random and the subject didn’t seem like someone I’d expect to have a bio on Wikipedia — some awards but no big achievements in her field were cited, much less linked to. Random Professor Earning Tenure, Watch This Space! That said, I’m in favor of everyone on the planet having a Wikipedia entry if anyone wants to make it for them. I’d love to do the same thing for lesser-known artists, but I’m lazy and I assume the WikiLords would erase everything. But maybe not, based on this… maybe I’m just lazy!
- smt88 4y ago> That said, I’m in favor of everyone on the planet having a Wikipedia entry if anyone wants to make it for them. I can't imagine a worse idea for some many reasons. - Wikipedia isn't supposed to have original research, and most people haven't been researched. - I don't want to search for composer John Williams and then see 300,000 other random people that fewer than 10 people want to read anything about. - Moderation is hard already.
- Panoramix 4y agoI clicked through 5 of them. All were professors with no substantial achievement mentioned. Are we going to make a Wikipedia page for all university professors on Earth? Surely they are smart and accomplished, but at least tell me what separates them from the crowd. What was their major breakthrough? the big invention? the novel technique? Otherwise this is just bloat IMO.
- civilized 4y agoLast I heard, Wikipedia doesn't want to carry an article for every university professor or scientist who has published some papers. In glancing through Wade's entries, it seems like many of them are just published scholars without any additional notability. I wonder if Wikipedia's notability rules are being uniformly respected here, or are they being selectively applied based on the gender of the person? I think it's great that Wade is bringing more visibility to lesser-known female scientists, but if we are valuing that, I think we should do so regardless of the subject's identity. Maybe Wikipedia should relax its notability rules a bit for scholars. If you are inspired to downvote this, I would be curious to know if you disagree with my proposal, or just dislike that I brought up the issue at all.
- robswc 4y agoI was curious about this very thing. At first I thought this was a really cool thing she was doing. I think everyone should be rewarded for their hard work, research or discoveries. I guess I can't say I'm a fan of the way she went about this though, after reading some of what she's written: Her comment: "The problem is not that she’s not notable, or that @Wikipedia editors are a bunch of sexist trolls waiting to jump on the bio of an impressive scientist" Seems to be in reply to this comment: "There is a lack of significant independent coverage. Getting an award from the local YWCA does not help her meet any notability criteria. As a for notability as a scientist, my search in Google Scholar found a grand total of 1 citation of papers she has authored or co-authored. Just because she works for the government doesn't mean she can't publish papers (and she has), the only restriction is if her work is classified. Her participation in the discovery of element 117 appears to have been very minor. Her name does not appear in the Oak Ridge publication "The Discovery of Element 117". Her Oak Ridge autobio says her part of the discovery of the new element was to "contribute ... to the purification of the Bk-249 used to help discover Z=117". Sounds like a very minor role in an undertaking involving a large number of people. I don't see convincing evidence that she is notable as a scientist or meets WP:GNG. I agree with the others who cited WP:TOOSOON as an issue." This is all found on the wikipage that was part of the original article: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Clarice_Phelps https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletio... Which I honestly find pretty reasonable. If you were to make a Wikipedia article for every college professor, we'd have a pretty bloated Wikipedia, lol. That said, I really do hope that maybe we could focus on quality vs quantity. I don't doubt that there are 1000 people out there deserving of a Wikipedia page... I also don't doubt that perhaps some of her examples don't really qualify, given Wikipedia's guidelines.
- jackmott 4y ago
- MisterSandman 4y ago> However, not all of Wiki-world was happy with her. Several of her entries were deleted by other Wikimedians, as the most influential contributors and editors are called. She told TODAY.com that they said a handful of the women she wrote up were not all that well-known. > Wade said that’s right, that’s the problem: they should be better known. This is my biggest problem with Wikipedia, it sees itself too much as an encyclopedia, when it's clearly more than that. Wikipedia is already full of boring and random stubs, I don't see the obsession editors have with making sure that a person is "important enough" to have an article. I feel like the bar should be lowered - not too low, obviously. Important is fairly subjective, and you're limiting yourself to things people in the past have written about. Original research shouldn't be discouraged to the extent it is, as long as it is backed up with valid sources.
- robswc 4y agoLooks like these are their guidelines on notability. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Notability#General_notability_guideline https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Notability#General_n... Here is why they claim to have them: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Notability#Why_we_have_these_requirements https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Notability#Why_we_ha... Honestly, looks pretty reasonable to me. Looks like its less to do with "we don't want less-known people to have wiki bios" and more to do with "many wiki bios of less-known people typically don't uphold the standards needed to create an entry." I do agree they should be more lax on some of the rules... but I say that as someone that hardly uses wikipedia, so maybe not the best person to consult, lol.
- jl6 4y agoLowering the standard of notability starts to create problems for the even more fundamental policy of verifiability. If articles are allowed without having even a couple of independent sources discussing the subject, it’s harder to weed out the self-promoters, spammers, and hoaxes.
- robswc 4y ago
- aaaaaaaaaaaaab 4y ago
- louwrentius 4y ago
- bakugo 4y ago>This is a positive effort, and that’s it. Why is creating hundreds of articles of zero substance a positive effort?
- louwrentius 4y agoWho said they are of zero substance?
- 30amxn30 4y ago
- dvt 4y agoIt's a Very Bad Thing™ that Wikipedia has become such a centralized funnel for information: (a) it's governed by gatekeepers with agendas, for better or worse; (b) an article's quality is often inversely proportional to its talk page archive length—i.e. articles on controversial topics are basically worthless if you're trying to get a balanced viewpoint; (c) Wikipedia has become a bureaucratic behemoth sucking up donations; (d) it implicitly kills other competition (Wikipedia universally ranks above all other pages); (e) in many cases, sources are either fabricated outright or the source does not support the article or the source is itself more nuanced than the article (editors rarely check sources, let alone that sources themselves may be biased); (f) Wikipedia rules are enforced arbitrarily and in an ad-hoc manner (some Wiki editor communities are more hard-line than others); etc. I think Wikipedia is going to end up being a net-negative in the long run. In the 90s, Wade would've started a website/wiki called "Female Scientists" and she would've ranked just fine on search engines. But these days, Wikipedia itself has become a cultural battleground.
- jl6 4y ago(b) is something that needs to be taught in media literacy courses: for any controversial subject, always read the talk page as well as the article. Easier said than done when there are 300+ pages of archives, but there are often FAQs present to cover the biggest issues, and at any rate, who said understanding controversial topics would be easy? But for controversial battleground subjects, I think (e) is actually not so common, because the opposing sides of edit wars do actually ruthlessly check each others’ sources, looking for any excuse to disqualify them.
- londons_explore 4y agoIf everyone read the talk page, then edit battles would happen on the talk page itself, with people removing comments that 'weren't in the right spirit'.
- jl6 4y agoThis totally already happens. Well, it does for off-topic trash and personal attacks. If you go in with suggestions for improving the article (even misguided ones), your comment won’t get deleted.
- bergenty 4y ago
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoWikipedia's credibility is not based on gatekeeping. Gender issues aside, Wikipedia could give a biography page to every homeless person and their credibility would only improve.
- inglor_cz 4y agoBut its usability would go down. How many people named Smith, Li or Gonzales are out there? Good luck finding the right one if the count of entries go into hundreds of thousands. Also, why limit yourself to living people only? And once you add, say, everybody whose name has been recorded in writing, you are probably looking at 15 billion or so.
- hbrn 4y agoHow exactly would it improve? Right now any person in the world can contribute to Wikipedia because of their notable sources policy. Any person in the world can validate and correct mistakes. Would homeless people write their own biography? Noone will be able to verify this information. How in the world this improves credibility?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- aaron695 4y ago
- 34675904565 4y agoAre women (in science or other areas) underrepresented as subjects of Wikipedia articles relative to their notability (as defined by Wikipedia)?
- dig1 4y ago> “People assume girls don’t choose science because they’re not inspired,” Wade, 33, said in a recent interview. “Girls are already interested. When I worked in the math department, most scientists were male. However, the biology and chemistry departments had way more female scientists than male. So how does this correlate that "the science does not inspire girls"? TBH, I'm happy we have listed lesser-known scientists on Wikipedia, no matter what gender they are, but there should be some line. In the science community, a number of citations or h-index show how productive you are, and those above some X value should have a place in Wikipedia. Gender neutral, of course. Also, the article dabbles between girls and students of color - is this about women scientists, a clickbait article, or does the author have some identity crisis? As someone said here, she is hurting Wikipedia's credibility. Recently I spoke with some high schoolers about "how they are lucky to have Wikipedia these days" and they mentioned that their teachers are actively dropping Wikipedia as an information source for being too unreliable. So I'm guessing, inflating numbers to prove something doesn't benefit anyone in the long run.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- zozbot234 4y ago> TBH, I'm happy we have listed lesser-known scientists on Wikipedia, no matter what gender they are, but there should be some line. Wiki has notability guidelines for scientists, regardless of the gender. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Notability_(academics) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Notability_(academic... Generally, if someone has a Wikipedia article as an academic it means that they're known for their clearly above-average achievement and/or impact, as reflected in available sources.
- louwrentius 4y ago
- MichaelCollins 4y ago> Wikipedia these days" and they mentioned that their teachers are actively dropping Wikipedia as an information source for being too unreliable. The original stance from teachers back in the 00s when Wikipedia was new was "Never cite wikipedia". If the message is now "No longer cite wikipedia", does that mean there was a period between then and now in which teachers thought highly of wikipedia?
- swayvil 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rajin444 4y agoNo, it's the definition of sexist. Her criteria for submitting these women / minorities is that "they should be noticed but aren't" and this criteria applies to all humans. Choosing to only help out selective groups purely because they're female or minority (not because they were passed over) is the definition of sexism / racism / etc.
- jmull 4y ago(Wish I'd read this before my sibling reply, I probably would have replied to this since it goes directly to my point... but I guess it doesn't hurt to clarify) According to the definition, there would have to be "prejudice, stereotyping, or discrimination". (I realized that's three more words to look up, but believe me, it's worthwhile to understand these powerful words if you want to use them without harm.)
- swayvil 4y agoListen closely for I illuminate a mystery. There is a reality deeper than words. A substance that makes words look like mere windblown fartgas in comparison. Penetrate the floofy fartgas, touch the substance.
- swayvil 4y agoFlagged and censored. These people. I swear.
- jmull 4y agoHere's the definition I got when googling it: > characterized by or showing prejudice, stereotyping, or discrimination, typically against women, on the basis of sex.
- goethes_kind 4y ago> “Ultimately, we don’t only need to increase the number of girls choosing science, we need to increase the proportion of women who stay in science,” We need to do neither of those things. Women who are smart enough to contribute to science are also smart enough to make their own mind about whether or not they want to contribute to science.
- reocha 4y agoDo you not think people are less likely to go into fields where they don't see themselves represented?
- version_five 4y agoI think most people don't consider identity politics when choosing a field. Anyway, equating "seeing themselves represented" to some shallow race and gender stuff reflects reality for very few.
- gspencley 4y agoI usually shy away from these conversations because of how politically toxic they are, and how easily people can twist and manipulate words to fit any meaning they want to ascribe. But you've just echoed a sentiment that I've had for quite some time relating to the "representation matters" claims. I grew up loving Star Trek. DS9 is one of my favourite of the series and I considered the character of Benjamin Sisko to be a huge role model and influence on me. I felt similar sentiment towards the characters Katherine Janeway and Seven of Nine on Voyager. Seven of Nine was particularly relatable to me as a nerdy outcast trying to fit in with "normal society." More recently, I felt a powerful attachment and kinship to the character of Elizabeth Harmon in The Queen's Gambit. To the point where I have never felt so personally represented by any fictional character in my life. The obsession, drive, ambition, social awkwardness, the anger issues, being ruthlessly self-critical and even the drug abuse (was stimulants for me as a teenager) were all characteristics that felt like they were taken directly from my own life. But according to many, that shouldn't be possible because those characters have different skin pigmentation and genitals than me. What a racist and sexist proposition that is. Almost as if ideas, character, personality and morals don't matter. We just need to go back to assuming those things based on little more than superficial irrelevancies.
- caramelcream 4y agoThis serves as a great illustration of the "women are wonderful" effect, which was featured on HN the other day: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33175754 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33175754
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hunglee2 4y agoGood and bad together here. On the one hand Jessica Wade's commitment elevates the under appreciated achievements of these women scientists, in so doing exposing the bias in how we record history and attribute credit. On the other, it also reveals the vulnerability of open edit repositories where the 'truth' can be determined by those with the most time and motivation. What is to stop politicisation of the content? Nothing at all. Indeed, seeing as Wikipedia has become the de facto source of truth for many, it would be surprising if government does not already have a program to ensure edits and articles support designed narratives and justify domestic and foreign policy behaviours
- jmull 4y ago> Nothing at all. I think you could look up how wikipedia is moderated. I wouldn't say it's perfect or anything close, but you'll quickly find that "nothing at all" is very wrong.
- ALittleLight 4y agoSeems like this would have the opposite effect - increase the proportion of sub-notable women on Wikipedia makes it look like male researchers standout and female researchers are mediocre. It also discounts the prestige of any Wikipedia article about a woman that deserves to have one - since people will know there is a much lower bar for women.
- crazygringo 4y ago100% no. You're assuming that these pages are all for "sub-notable" women, which is flat-out wrong. The ones that don't meet notability standards get deleted (as the article describes), just as happens with "sub-notable" men who people try to create pages for. Jessica Wade is simply filling in the gaps. Nobody is lowering the bar for women. And even if that were the case, nobody is randomly browsing thousands of Wikipedia researcher pages where they could even make a judgment like that. It's an entirely fantastical concern.
- nnopepe 4y agoI randomly picked one of her contributions and it reads like a travel blog of a random canadian[1], a second pick brought me to a dead french woman[2] whos claim to fame is being "one of the first" to do something By the sound of it Jess's reputation is so obnoxious people simply can't be arsed to contest her article creations anymore https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delphine_Farmer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delphine_Farmer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genevieve_Hidden https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genevieve_Hidden
- crazygringo 4y agoI'm sorry but I just can't take your comment seriously. You think... "dead French women" don't belong on Wikipedia? Do you have any idea how many dead French men are on Wikipedia? I cannot fathom what leads you to describe someone as a "dead French woman"... or even as a "random Canadian", as if any Canadian that nnopepe has never heard of sure doesn't belong in Wikipedia...! I have no idea if these two meet the standards for notability or not. But I do know that being obnoxious never stopped deletionist editors before. I'm not sure there's anyone in the world more stubborn than Wikipedia deletionist editors.
- brap 4y agoHow many people are actually searching for and reading these bios? Is this effort at all useful?
- brosinante 4y agoIs read count the metric we're using?
- brap 4y agoI don't know, but surely there should be a metric, and I don't think number of entries is a good one.
- freebreakfast 4y agoI cannot answer your questions directly, but page view information is available for all Wikipedia articles. https://pageviews.wmcloud.org/ https://pageviews.wmcloud.org/
- lucb1e 4y agoIt is also an effect that drives itself. If you look for someone and they essentially don't exist online, you are less likely to tell a friend about this person because you don't learn as much about them, which then drives even fewer views to the page. Now that they exist, it might take years before one can tell something based on views. Searches are hard to map, because searching for POTUS 2008 might get you to Barack's article... but only if it exists. Wouldn't know that someone was looking for this person if they don't type the name exactly and correctly.
- onos 4y agoIt got this woman some publicity.
- Nifty3929 4y agoDoes an unworthy Wikipedia bio page somehow harm anybody (aside from the hosting cost itself)? Honest question - I don't see how. On the flipside, does adding these pages do anything to increase visibility for these women? Honest question here as well, but again I don't see how it would. I would only end up on one of these if I specifically searched for it, which implies she was already known to me. Really this seems like a no-op to me. Maybe I can grant some tiny positive value in that if I have an interest in one of these women, I can now go get a tiny amount of additional information about them.
- totoglazer 4y agoIf they were involved in discovering X, now they are much more like to be mentioned and linked in the article about X. So I think that would boost visibility slightly.
- LatteLazy 4y agoSooner or later you get down to billions of stub articles. I wrote a research paper once, it even got published in a fairly large journal. But I am not noteworthy and don't need an article on wikipedia. You need to have some lower bound to stop egomaniacs like me from writing our own 10k world biographies...
- Nifty3929 4y agoI don't really see how B's of stub articles hurt though. I don't even see them, if I'm not looking for them. Maybe if they share a name with a more note-worthy person, and then clutter search results for that person and cause confusion.
- Vt71fcAqt7 4y agoBecause the credibility of articles on wikipedia rests on having multiple editors. Having one (likley biased) writer for billions of entries means that most of the info on wikipedia would be false. It's better to have less info and be more accurate than become a glorified ad space.
- secondcoming 4y agoIt's Wikipedia, not LinkedIn
- yegle 4y agoI'd like to ask a couple questions for me to form my own conclusions: 1. What's the gender ratio of scientists with h-index >100? >50? >10? 2. What's the ratio of scientists with missing wikipedia pages breakdown by gender, with h-index>100? >50? >10? 3. What's the gender ratio of scientists of first/second/third authors, on papers with citation >500, >200, >100.
- renewiltord 4y agoI suspect you will need to do the research to answer these questions yourself. Sadly you can't even just run a name join because humans don't have primary key uniqueness.
- z7 4y agoWhat conclusions would it offer? Among the top 100 chess players I think there are three women. Most people seem to think it's due to some cultural factors or gender discrimination. This could be applied to any asymmetries you might find.
- yegle 4y agoI can ask follow up questions if the answer is known. But mainly, I want to know if the ratios from my questions don't match the gender ratio in the general population, at which point does the ratio start to diverge? Was it when a student needs to choose a major? Or when a professor interviews a PhD candidate? Or when assigning tasks and someone getting a less impactful part? Or when deciding the ordering of the authors based on (very subjectively) the contribution?
- Ferrotin 4y agoRight now it’s zero women. Hou Yifan just dropped out of the top 100.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- slooonz 4y agoSo, the flagship of the article is the wikipedia entry for "Clarice Phelps", notably for "her work on a team that discovered a new periodic-table element at the Oak Ridge National Laboratory". The article (heavily) implies that Clarice Phleps not having a wikipedia entry is her "not having her dues" because she’s a woman. However, if we look at the authors of the original article, there is no mention of her : https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Synthesis-of-a-new-element-with-atomic-number-Z-%3D-Oganessian-Abdullin/ec9412add23e66f34b6bf51ebd7332278af413fc https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Synthesis-of-a-new-ele.... Of the 30 authors of the article, only two have a wikipedia entry (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yuri_Oganessian https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yuri_Oganessian and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_H._Hamilton https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_H._Hamilton).
- ineedasername 4y agoThen perhaps that’s a failing of the linked article to adequately convey her contribution, not an indication of anything else. Same for the other authors without a Wikipedia entry. Their absences don’t indicate that Phelps too shouldn’t have an entry. Instead, for a significant discovery, it perhaps means that other people are similarly lacking in recognition. Is your point that she shouldn’t have a Wikipedia entry, or that it’s absence was not necessarily related to her being a woman, or something else entirely?
- belorn 4y agoThe written goal of Wikipedia is to be a recording of what other sources in the world are stating, and explicitly not to be a primary source. Wikipedia is not a substitute when there is a lack of original sources reporting on a subject. Because of this, there are a lot of experts and advocates that simultaneously dislike Wikipedia, want to fix it, and have a terrible experience while doing so. They want Wikipedia to represent the truth, and if there is a lack of original sources they want Wikipedia to fix that so people can access the truth. This in turn makes other people suspicious when advocates or experts edits Wikipedia, furthering the conflict.
- 4y ago
- slibhb 4y agoIt's somewhat ironic that Wade has received many honors for her activism -- but not for her science -- which involves promoting the science of other women.
- zeroimpl 4y agoHow's that ironic or relevant? Most scientists do not receive awards.
- soheil 4y agoOK this is just annoying and borderline spamming Wikipedia. She is creating new wiki pages for people with their primary qualification being a woman/minority group in academia [0]. Again and again from history we learn fundamentalism doesn't work yet here we are showing its ugly head even in sciences, not only she's getting away with it she's even being praised for this. Wikipedia has very clear notability guidelines [1]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/Jesswade88 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/Jesswade... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Notability_(academics) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Notability_(academic...
- rexreed 4y agoAnd of course, here's her Wikipedia entry: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jess_Wade https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jess_Wade
- 5555624 4y agoMaybe someone will edit it and get her birthday narrowed down. Even one year, instead of two, would be an improvement. An article written in 2018, with a heading saying she was 29, doesn't seem reliable.
- z7 4y agoI notice these unknown male Fields Medalists have much sparser entries: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jean-Christophe_Yoccoz https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jean-Christophe_Yoccoz https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanislav_Smirnov https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanislav_Smirnov https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Scholze https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Scholze https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elon_Lindenstrauss https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elon_Lindenstrauss https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/June_Huh https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/June_Huh ;)
- faeriechangling 4y agoThen flesh them out. We're all rooting for you!
- z7 4y agoIt's actually not that difficult in the case of someone like Peter Scholze. There's a good deal of scientific journalism available and some more accessible meta publications. But I guess public interest in crystalline cohomology isn't very distinct. Turns out a scientist's lack of visibility in the public eye via publications like Wikipedia is shaped by more than their gender.
- RugnirViking 4y agothe previous commenter wasn't entirely being sarcastic. You are correct, a big part of the reason that certain topics are covered more than others is literally just interest by authors. There are many many more people interested in writing about video games etc than there are interested in writing about field's medalists. The best way to solve that problem is to either get writing yourself or encourage others to write.
- mantas 4y ago
- lifeisstillgood 4y ago>>> Girls are already interested. It’s more about making students aware of the different careers in science and getting parents and teachers on board.” This rings so true - even in my career, good mentorship (at the right time) would have very different outcomes. I think of all the productivity statistics we worry about, and yes when productivity was lifting heavier piles of earth, capital investment mattered. Today's productivity comes from better organisation and better capabilities- either do more with less or invent new things to do. And those are deep educational and social issues. As an example I suspect YC itself is good proof that there is not a fixed pool of entrepreneurs but that by improving the fertility of the VC soil more people fall over that weird line of risk-taking. Imagine there was a pill that would turn regular folks into people willing to stop at nothing to make their idea a success. Now with a million fired up entrepreneurs do we have enough early stage funds? Enough lawyers with startup experience, enough HR Saas accounts? If inspired entrepreneurs were not a limiting factor (which seems to be what VCs say when they look for a great founder) what else is broken about our eco-system? And if we could fix that, what else is broken about the eco-system for getting young girls (and boys) into scientific productive careers?
- JamesianP 4y agoTo me science as a field is somehow more primitive and backward in that it's still first and foremost about building one's CV, like an explorer putting their name on places before the other guy gets there. This doesn't generally match the current environment where everyone is pursuing the same incremental advances and will get there sooner or later. Yet we pretend the one person who's paper got past reviewers first deserves all the credit for that increment plus the increments that follow. The first implementations often don't even work. Presumably the reason it works this way is because the funding process in research rewards this approach. Elsewhere like in engineering, results are what matter. Science will probably evolve in this direction as we need more and more of it, and results are produced in more shared-credit environments like big labs instead of academia. Then it won't be so much about the Matthew effect which favors those who got started the earliest (which tends to be boys).
- justshowpost 4y agoYet another A Bored Chinese Housewife Spent Years Falsifying Russian History on Wikipedia She “single-handedly invented a new way to undermine Wikipedia,” says a Wikipedian.*
- hinkley 4y agoI recall taking a class from an author who had some pretty cool ideas. But he had one of those vanilla names with a disambiguating page but he wasn’t on it. So I made him a link and a page and put what I knew down. It got deleted instantly. I am not sure how I feel about that but I remember thinking I bet this pisses people off.
- errantmind 4y agoSNR is important for information sources. If people don't meet the notability standards of Wikipedia they need to be removed.
- mctt 4y agoSNR Signal to Noise (ratio). In this case the comparison would be; Citation to Citation needed (ratio). https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Citation_needed https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Citation_needed
- pavon 4y agoHow does non-notability decrease SNR? Does the existence of articles for non-notable people decrease the likelihood that people will find articles for notable ones? Does it lower the quality of other articles? As long as the articles for "non-notable" people are well-sourced and accurate, I see no reason why their existence lowers the SNR of Wikipedia. And if they are of low quality then there are more justifiable reasons for removing them than notability.
- errantmind 4y agoYes, non-notability decreases SNR because it ends up crowding articles into disambiguation pages which makes it more difficult to traverse related articles on the site. It is generally preferable not to stumble across non-notable articles when browsing Wikipedia. It is also more work for editors to 'maintain' non-notable articles over time. Having notability standards significantly reduces this burdain.
- nullc 4y agoHaving a Wikipedia article about you is not doing you a service. Unless you're high enough profile that people will actually care to remove bullshit (and have non-bullshit to replace it with) it'll just end up a random magnet for random innuendo, any random controversy you were even peripherally involved in, and other such highly unrepresentative coverage (if not outright defamation).
- dandare 4y ago> In the early years of our sample, women were less likely to be selected as members [of AAAS and NAS] than men with similar records. By the 1990s, the selection process at both academies was approximately gender-neutral, conditional on publications and citations. In the past 20 years, however, a positive preference for female members has emerged and strengthened in all three fields. Currently, women are 3-15 times more likely to be selected as members of the AAAS and NAS than men with similar publication and citation records. https://www.nber.org/papers/w30510 https://www.nber.org/papers/w30510 The paper is not peer reviewed.
- klipt 4y agoIntuitively, it makes sense that decades of Diversity Training could ultimately change people's biases. That means it succeeded.
- WastingMyTime89 4y agoThe point was correcting the factors which lead to women avoiding or not succeeding in STEM not creating an opposite bias. Maybe a positive bias is still needed to tip the scale but we have to be careful of not drastically overshooting.
- iampims 4y agoWomen have “centuries” of not being treated as equals before we can talk about “overshooting”.
- WastingMyTime89 4y agoThis take doesn’t make sense. The goal never was to make up for centuries of inequality (as if we could - that’s going to be of little help to the disadvantaged women, they are dead now) or punish modern men for a past they had nothing to do with. The goal is equality, period. Creating a world where men are disadvantaged in a mirror situation would be an abject failure. Positive bias is good as a bootstrap because feminine role models are a necessity for young girls to be able to identify with someone in the field and the situation was so unbalanced something had to be done to seed the field. But in an equal playfield, women don’t need help to stand for themselves. At some point, we will have to stop artificially advantaging them and recognising this point is important.
- faeriechangling 4y agoThat's a very nice story, it makes me happy.
- pvaldes 4y agoThe idea that women don't do science because they are dumb is correctly dismissed. But let me introduce a different, more interesting, idea. What if most women don't do science because they are smart? Young people don't care about the numbers, they are impressed by success, and bios of most obscure figures doing science, lets face the ugly truth... aren't good models of success. We are fixing the wrong problem here, with too simplistic premises (the problem is that people is ignorant / that we don't have exactly the same number of people in each demographic category doing science / That everybody should have the same interests and goals and think in the same way) When the real problem to address is that working conditions in science are, often, terrible and that our society punish people in many different ways for wanting to be scientists
- wrp 4y agoThere is/was an MIT computer scientist who argued that the reason why fewer female students stay with CS is that they take a more pragmatic view of the career prospects.
- tenpies 4y ago> When the real problem to address is that working conditions in science are, often, terrible and that our society punish people in many different ways for wanting to be scientists Part of that problem was that the tenuous professional environment meant that very few scientists were willing to speak up when the science becomes politicized. With good reason, we saw the few that did get absolutely obliterated and their careers-ended - often going as far as then tarnishing them at a personal level. As far as societal trust, scientists are not as bad as journalists yet, but they're going to get there[1]. The replication crisis was the backdrop of this, but the COVID pandemic made it very clear to anyone paying attention that the government dictates scientific consensus and any disagreement is squelched both by fellow scientists, and the prestige organizations in each field. Now that this is being compounded with Woke-testing hires and publications, you've effectively ended the legitimacy of most publications, institutions, and papers. --- [1] https://www.pewresearch.org/science/2022/02/15/americans-trust-in-scientists-other-groups-declines/ps_22-02-15_trust-declines_00-01/ https://www.pewresearch.org/science/2022/02/15/americans-tru...
- 4y ago
- hoseja 4y agoSuddenly, "notability" takes a back seat.