3 ms·
Temporarily overshooting 2°C would cause permanent damage to Earth’s species
- LatteLazy 4y agoWe're on course for 4+. 1.5 is locked in. Nothing short of a nuclear war will stop 2-3.
- Moissanite 4y agoIf people truly care about the humanitarian elements of climate change, they should be looking into how to relocate somewhere north of a billion people from Bangladesh and the surrounding area to land which isn't doomed to be underwater relatively soon. Of course, you can't make money selling refugees (yet), so this remains a secondary consideration.
- junofan 4y ago> Relying on carbon dioxide removal and so-called negative emissions technologies to lower greenhouse gases in the atmosphere over several decades is too risky to contemplate. Author is saying to not even think about all solutions? Unprompted, on a post ostensibly sharing research findings? Sounds a bit dogmatic and politically motivated. I don’t trust their results.
- thrown_22 4y agoThe energy budget needed for CO2 removal makes all our energy consumption done to this point a rounding error.
- twawaaay 4y agoThere are possibilities for removal mechanisms that do not require proportionate input in energy directly. For example, you could perfect growing algae and let the algae extract energy from sunlight on its own. We would just have to ensure good transfer of CO2 from atmosphere to water. Another I have seen is crushing rock -- as silicate is weathering it will naturally extract CO2 and the question is how efficiently you can powder rock. Another possible solution would be finding a process that will remove CO2 as a byproduct. If you have to put a lot of energy into it, at least get some part of it back.
- mjhay 4y agoYou're describing small systems being scaled up millions of times. It reminds me of the doomed and misguided Ocean Cleanup Project. Where would you grow all this algae? It would take a great deal of area (easily multiple thousands of square miles) because it relies on photosynthesis. You can't build it at sea, because it would be destroyed be storms. The crushing rock works very slowly - that part of the carbon cycle takes ages. Any significant speedup of that would also be an environmental disaster - again too much rock crushing, and it would have to be spread over large areas. Even worse, this will all need to be done in an already deteriorated planet, with almost assuredly worse political stability and real economic output than we have now.
- twawaaay 4y ago> You're describing small systems being scaled up millions of times. What you are describing is how technological progress works usually. We first typically learn to do something at small scale, then learn to solve problems that are necessary to scale it up. The problem isn't really whether we can do it but whether we can get people to be willing to do it. > The crushing rock works very slowly Yes, it does. But once you crush the rock the rest happens on its own while you are crushing even more of it. Which means after some time the removal will asymptotically reach the speed at which you are able to crush the rock (and supply the air).
- mjhay 4y agoI don't think you are grasping the full, physical scale here. This is a lot of CO2, and you need a lot of crushed rock. This is not like integrated circuits or anything - it would be an enormous heavy industrial operation the likes of which the world has never seen. The main problems aren't really even technological - but economic, physical, and ecological. This isn't an area where Silicon Valley can invent some magic silver hammer that they always think is around the corner.
- twawaaay 4y agoI did not say crushed rock is the solution. I just used it as an example that solution may not require us to supply the amount energy from the grid that we would normally get from emitting the CO2 in the first place. Also, I think you are just flat wrong about how unprecedented this operation would be. Digging oil and coal from under the sea or thousands of meters below ground is certainly more difficult than crushing rock that is readily available on the surface basically everywhere. I think the bigger issue is figuring out what to do with that crushed rock so that it has contact with air so that it can actually perform the reactions we want (this might not be solvable). We can use crushed rock to some extent. For example, I use powdered basalt in my garden. It improves the soil and provides nutrients over long periods of time. But I think we would quickly run out of agricultural soil to fertilise this way.
- mjhay 4y ago"Negative-emissions" carbon-capture technologies have essentially intractable problems scaling up, including basic thermodynamics; that isn't even talking about the massive resource inputs to build a system capable of meaningfully reducing CO2. It's a lot easier to to not emit as much in the first place. Even barring these severe problems, the precautionary principle is the right thing to apply here. If "negative emission" tech has even a 90% chance of working, we still should focus on reducing emissions, because that tail risk is bad. It's like why people have fire insurance even though most people's houses never catch on fire.
- 11235813213455 4y agothe solutions are not technological, they are just about people reducing each drastically their footprint, and creating more natural super efficient carbon sinks, also called forests, permacultures, and more vegetation overall
- 11235813213455 4y agoI expected downvotes in a place where Elon Musk must be considered a god / savior against global warming (while cars with 500kg of batteries can't certainly be a good idea) but that's still the truth that someone highly knowledgable like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jean-Marc_Jancovici https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jean-Marc_Jancovici would explain in more details, there are many aspects, not just carbon
- potsandpans 4y agoand what are your qualifications?
- THENATHE 4y agoIf this, hypothetically, isn’t the solution, then what is? It is literally not possible to get everyone to stop emissions. If reducing emissions by planting trees and building carbon banks isn’t enough, will anything be enough? Seems kinda fatalist to just say “ah, we’re fucked”
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hulitu 4y agoWho cares ? /s
- captainthrow 4y ago
- 11235813213455 4y agoWho acts? Who reduced their footprint under 2 Tonnes equivalent CO2 / year? Not many of us, though that's definitely something with many other benefits than environmental
- hedora 4y agoThere are many direct air carbon capture technologies under development. Most should cost between $50-200 per ton of CO2 they capture. That translates to $1 to "undo" a gallon of gasoline.
- 11235813213455 4y agoIt's worth trying but it's also essential that people pollute less (and not just with CO2, plastic littering, batteries, ..), also note that those air carbon capture companies has received funds from gas companies (https://www.facebook.com/jeanmarc.jancovici/posts/353945709422318/ https://www.facebook.com/jeanmarc.jancovici/posts/3539457094...)
- onos 4y agoPerhaps we should build an arc to help these species survive the anticipated hot period.
- rdtwo 4y agoHate you break it to you but we’re going to overshoot and probably not temporarily
- rongopo 4y agoObvious to me. Why are there doubts? I hope for a non-political discussion.
- marstall 4y agobecause people have an overwhelming tendency to believe what the want to believe.
- rumpelstinkin 4y agohonest question, is it so bad if we go extinct? why bother going through all this effort and anxiety for someone we'll never even meet? taking an honest look at my own life, I'm just a sophisticated robot that eats, poops and labors just so I can continue to eat, poop and labor yet another day...
- ncr100 4y agoYes. It'd be a waste of effort. Feel free to disagree.
- magic_hamster 4y agoAs it appears, a whole lot of people prefer not to die.
- rumpelstinkin 4y agobut what about all this obsession about ensuring that there are still humans in say 200 years, when anyone who might exist is a complete stranger to us?
- stjohnswarts 4y agoBecause humans like other humans? humans want a legacy? humans want the species to persist and even excel? Not everyone is a nihilist.
- rumpelstinkin 4y agoand yet most humans continue pursuing a lifestyle that is simple not sustainable at an 8 billion people scale, and don't want to give it up. Doesn't sound like they care much about the consequences of their actions on others. Haven't made the calculations, but I'm quite sure we could keep the current technological pillars of well-being (food, health, heating) without much issue to the environment if we gave up all the other superfluous crap (private cars, gadgets, plastics toys, 3d videogames, etc). And we'd probably be much less depressed too.
- mrtri 4y ago
- nuancebydefault 4y agoAll these extrapolation attempts need to be taken with a grain of salt. One thing we know: * carbon and methane that we release en masse in the atmosphere causes the temperature to rise globally, it has been known for decades. It has a negative impact on the stability of climate and thus food/safety. Things we don't know: * exactly how big is the impact of temperature on the habitibility of earth. * how many degrees of increase is needed to be a danger to mankind's existence? Or how many people (even give or take) will suffer or die? * how fast will science find applicable solutions and what speed is necessary to keep the harmful effects limited? So we can keep on repeating that we are not doing enough to mitigate, or even that it is already too late, but that speculating does not solve anything. Bottom line, we should keep trying to keep temperature increase as low as possible, on multiple fronts: more efficient usage of resources, less inequality between poor and rich, investing in technology, persuade people not to waste resources, thinking about alternative types of economies,... Only future will tell if it were enough.