3 ms·
Honestly, I find it really hard to get worked up about cell phone e-waste in the grand scheme of environmental issues. People seem to confuse the cost of somet
by crazygringo 4y ago
Honestly, I find it really hard to get worked up about cell phone e-waste in the grand scheme of environmental issues.
People seem to confuse the cost of something new with the harm in throwing it away -- they get upset about $250 AirPods not getting recycled, while they don't give a second thought to throwing away a couple pairs of $1 AAA batteries, when it's about the same level of landfill impact.
Or in this case, they think there's something wrong with throwing away a 5 oz (140 g) cell phone, but don't feel particularly bad when they finally dispose of an old 50 lb (22 kg) air conditioner -- or a 3,000 lb (1,360 kg) car. (Using these numbers, one car is the same mass of material as almost 10,000 phones.)
Putting it into perspective, cell phones are nothing. There's more glass used to make a jar of peanut butter, and you throw away more plastic after a family-sized Chinese takeout meal.
And yes if there are precious metals inside that can be recovered, then let's recover those -- but only if it's economical. Because that's a pure question of economics. We don't need to be "virtuous" -- if markets really think the metal is going to be that valuable because we're going to run out, then they will pay you accordingly handsomely for your old broken phones. But it doesn't seem like we've reached that point yet, because nobody's paying anything.
- plzbo 4y agoTo me this seems to be a case of whataboutism. Just because there are worse things to do environmentally speaking does not mean that this is not a problem.
- tormeh 4y agoWe should focus our efforts where the impact:effort ratio is the most favourable. This doesn't seem particularly productive.
- plzbo 4y agoThis is true of course, but we shouldn't discard any attempt to improve the situation, just because there are bigger fish to try.
- xvector 4y agoActually, we should, when the energy spent improving the situation could be spent on things with magnitude more impact. The whole phone e-waste discussion is virtue signaling in its worst form.
- plzbo 4y agoIt may well be, but the dismissal of it just because you could do more is even worse without action.
- palata 4y agoSure, but not everyone has the same opportunities. So I'd say we should focus on the best we _can_ do personally. It's better for me to focus on recycling my electronics than focusing on the ecological impact of the modern commercial satellites madness. Because I cannot do anything about Starlink and the likes, but I can recycle my phone.
- vlunkr 4y agoI disagree. the point is that if you're concerned about e-waste, start somewhere besides cellphones.
- paulcole 4y agoIf you care about the environment start somewhere other than e-waste.
- permo-w 4y agoI don’t mean this to be facetious, but they pointed out that this is whataboutism, and you, in more or less words, disagreed and said ‘what about this other e-waste that should be dealt with?’ besides this, how many people do you know that don’t have a phone? how often on average do you think people replace their phones? compare those answers to other tech/machinery that you may be thinking of starting with. also, finally, the top-level comment here takes a really shallow view of how the world economy works. yes if there was a shortage of these materials, there would be an economic incentive to recycle them properly, but that doesn’t mean that the obtaining of these materials doesn’t have a huge human or environmental cost. just because you can get a material cheaply doesn’t mean there’s nothing wrong with doing it
- dymk 4y ago"Whataboutism" is not always a fallacy. Sometimes it's economic fact.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- thrown_22 4y agoIt's called triage. If you have a paper cut and a heart attack one will be prioritized over the other. To equate the two is idiocy.
- permo-w 4y agothere are enough people in the world to deal with both. it’s whataboutism pure and simple
- thrown_22 4y ago[[citation needed]] If you feel so strongly about phone waste feel free to go live in the third world as a e-waste recycler.
- plzbo 4y ago
- thrown_22 4y agoI wasn't aware that the third world had a single race. Do you per chance also think that poor kids are just as smart as white kids like the current president? >It's on all of us to make a difference, however small. Great, so why aren't you an e-waste recycler?
- permo-w 4y agoif you think there should be less crime and a better police force, you don’t go and fight crime on the streets, do you? in the same way, sure you can go off to Bangladesh to sort through e-waste, but the real issue is how our governments regulate industry saying “why don’t you go and be the batman of e-waste?” just poisons the debate and helps no one. throwaway accounts are for sensitive information, not so you can be rude to people you disagree with without damaging your credibility
- ocbyc 4y agoActually, from an economic perspective, you should tackle the lowest hanging fruit. Assuming we can only tackle a non-unlimited amount of issues at any given time. I'm assuming this article hits the dopamine because everyone has a phone, and it's a very personal item and everyone upgrades / replaces them eventually. A window A/C on the other hand, not so much.
- Gigachad 4y agoUsually I don’t like this argument because it shifts the discussion from something you can control to something you can’t which justifies doing nothing. But in this case, talking about the difference between multiple consumer goods makes sense because you are in control of all of them. Simply not buying an oversized car does more than a lifetime of using phones for longer.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tuatoru 4y agoYeah, the article isn't great, talking about hazardous substances and such. Phones are moving to "chip scale" components: resistors, inductors, capacitors less than 0.25mm in size. And the chips themselves are getting smaller and smaller. The quantity of "hazardous" stuff outside of the battery is plummeting. Making the battery removable and replaceable and having fully-reticulated battery collection networks would be nice. On cost, though: there is the concept of "embodied energy". The AirPods cost $250 while the peanut butter jar costs less than $1, in part because a lot of energy is used to make the small components in the AirPods. (Not corresponding to the price difference, of course, but more energy.) Lots more steps in the production chain of AirPods, each with their own energy losses. So buying new AirPods does have a bigger environmental impact than buying a peanut butter jar. > you throw away more plastic after a family-sized Chinese takeout meal. Flying from one side of the country to the other and back uses more carbon than several years' worth of Chinese takeout containers.
- Gigachad 4y agoWould be interesting to have a breakdown of why the AirPods cost so much. I suspect a large chunk of it is research and development. As well as the wages of the top talent in the world required to develop and manufacture them. A jar is a mostly once off cost, you build the jar making machine and it works until it breaks. While AirPods are under constant innovation. So the initial cost has to be repaid fast.
- barsonme 4y agoAlso because we’ll pay that much :)
- 1123581321 4y agoManufacture cost is estimated to be roughly $30. Retail price of no-name, little-margin AirPods knockoffs corroborate this. I wouldn’t know where to begin with research and engineering, since all their products benefit from audio research and testing, iCloud, device inter-connectivity, etc. AirPods wouldn’t be any good without years of prior work on iOS. But they reportedly assign development costs roughly equal to manufacturing costs, which would put them at $60 and $100 of margin. This would make them contribute more to Apple’s target margin than the average product. This value is possible because of the state of the market, for whatever reason.
- permo-w 4y agoother things are bad -> bad thing isn’t bad? going on your estimate of 140g, 5 billion phones is 700,000 metric tonnes. that is an insane amount of waste, and not to be sniffed at besides this, phones are also massively more complex than a glass jar, and much more often replaced than a car or air conditioner there are genuine malevolent economic factors at play here. these companies want you to get a new phone and throw away your old one, so they can extract more wealth from you. and they have admitted to acting in ways that encourage this
- Retric 4y agoNo, 700,000 metric tons per year globally is nothing and we aren’t manufacturing 5 billion phones a year so we aren’t throwing that many away per year. We have more waste from TV remote batteries and nobody singles them out. As to lifespan, in a lifetime I might have say 20 cellphones and 4 cars but that’s nowhere close to being equivalent waste or environmental impact.
- paulryanrogers 4y agoDoesn't it require like half a ton of material to produce one modern phone? (Including all the mining and manufacturing to get one from the earth to ones hand.) If so then 2.5 billion tons is worth some attention, in addition to other ecological challenges.
- crazygringo 4y agoI can't find any data on anything like that. But quick googling reveals an iPhone contains 0.034 g of gold. Another stat says one ounce of gold requires 100,000 oz of ore, so the 0.034 g of gold would require 3.4 kg of ore. Nowhere even remotely close to half a ton. I can't find similar stats for e.g. palladium ore used to extract palladium, but remember that the amounts of precious metals in phones are truly tiny. The news reports I'm finding about "cell phones" and "tons" refer to water -- one report says 13 tons of water per phone. While a pair of leather boots is 25 tons of water, for comparison. But water is recyclable, and it doesn't seem like a concern particularly specific to electronics.
- jamroom 4y agoYeah but what about the resources that go into making a phone? The phone is just the end result of a long line of processes that create waste. So while the phone may be much smaller in size, "throwing it away" could result in a larger impact to the environment than it may seem.
- proffeatur8 4y ago
- recycledmatt 4y agoEPA has done a good job quantifying this with their WARM standards. We think of recycling impact by the ton and recycling a ton of phones is an order of magnitude better than recycling cars, and reusing/refurbishing phones is multiple orders of magnitude better
- fyvhbhn 4y agoI don't think we should restrict us to what's economical since the economy doesn't really care about sustainability
- xnx 4y agoI'm proportionately less concerned about the final "R" as I am about the first 4: Refuse, Reduce, Reuse, Repurpose, Recycle
- economism 4y agoWhat you're describing is called economism and is the reason we're in this mess. Preservation of the environment can not be reduced to an economic calculation.
- warner25 4y agoIt's just that my car has given me 15 years of service and will, I expect, give me ten more. Many large household appliances can last even longer than that. Meanwhile, my phone is only two years old, looks and works perfectly fine, but no longer receives security updates. I just posted an "Ask HN" on Thursday about how to handle this, because it feels ridiculous to replace the phone at this point, but the alternative options seem to suck too. It just seems like there's so much room to improve the situation. You're right about the economics, though. I remember filling out a form on the Best Buy website to see what they'd pay me to recycle a three year-old laptop, and it quoted me $5... So clearly whatever can be recycled from these machines isn't all that valuable.