3 ms·
A question for you. Imagine you're a doctor and after extensive research and your own medical experience and praxis, you conclude that, for instance, vaccinatio
by somenameforme 4y ago
A question for you. Imagine you're a doctor and after extensive research and your own medical experience and praxis, you conclude that, for instance, vaccination is probably a less than optimal choice for individuals under the age of 40. How comfortable would you feel publicly expressing this?
One of the biggest problems when a society starts to become intolerant towards dissenting views is that consensus itself starts to become impossible, or at least meaningless.
Most people don't care that much about most issues. Make it sting enough to dissent, and you'll eliminate dissent from all but those willing to choose this hill to die on. But in such a case the lack of dissent becomes meaningless.
- staticman2 4y agoI assume by "publically expressing" you mean not saying things to friends over a beer but posting things online or that will go online in some fashion. If I was a doctor it's unlikely I would be publically expressing anything. As far as I know I've never been treated by a doctor who goes around publically expressing things on any topic. When I see a specialist it's usually because I got a referral from a family doctor not because "This doctor has an exciting Twitter feed". I would guess my doctors have no public twitter feeds at all, not that I've ever checked. But your question is too vague. In this scenario am I a random "doctor" or am I a nationally regarded expert in the relevant field? And did I run my views past respected colleagues and did they recieve it well or tell me I'm being an idiot? I think the job of practicing medicine is generally about going to conferences and basing your practice on what the doctors regarded as being in the top of their field suggest. Just like the job of becoming a doctor is about answering the questions on medical school exams in line with what the teacher told you is true, not "sharing your original views" on how the teacher is wrong. I was born before social networks existed and reject the implicit framing society works better when everybody debates everything on social media all day. Some things might work well being debated on social media, but not everything.
- artificialLimbs 4y agoDoctors shouldn’t be sharing their opinions online is your hot take?
- staticman2 4y agoDoctors are supposed to be providing the public with medical advise in line with the standards of their profession, not sharing "opinions" on medical matters whatever the hell that is supposed to mean. If you can't convince your colleagues that your "opinions" have value and you have such a high opinion of your judgement relative to the rest of your profession that you insist on broadcasting these "opinions" to the world anyway, chances are you have a high level of confidence and a low level of competence and you aren't a very good doctor. Especially if these "opinions" are outside your specialty. I know the notion that a doctor should show intellectual humility may offend autodidactics who doesn't even think a layperson should show intellectual humility, but so it goes.
- artificialLimbs 4y agoTo attempt to force a populace to discard their own intellect and intuition in favor of simply listening to the 'experts' (who are always self appointed) is the dream of every psychopathic authoritarian who has lived.
- staticman2 4y agoMedical experts aren't self appointed but I can see how that belief might correlate with a belief in a number of other things.
- artificialLimbs 4y agoSo, medical experts don’t appoint medical experts?
- staticman2 4y ago