7 ms·
AT&T to pay $23M fine for bribing lawmaker’s ally in exchange for vote
- KingOfCoders 4y agoThis stops when CEOs go to jail not when companies pay the fines.
- washmyelbows 4y agoisn't this kind of thing common in US politics? what makes this specifically actionable?
- bdw5204 4y agoIf the bribe is paid as a "campaign contribution" to a politician or to a group that runs ads to get a politician elected, it is "free speech" according to SCOTUS in Citizens United v. FEC. If it is paid directly to a politician or to a politician's friend, it is illegal bribery. It would also be perfectly legal to hire a politician or regulator who advanced your interests once he's no longer in office. There is, in fact, a revolving door between many industries and the agencies that regulate them. But you can't explicitly promise these individuals a job while they're still in office or you committed illegal bribery. A politician also can't sell a Senate appointment (as the governor of Illinois infamously tried to do after Obama was elected president) but he can give it to one of his political allies as a favor and reasonably expect that the favor will be repaid in the future. Of course, these differences aren't particularly meaningful in reality but they're very important under the law and anybody who is stupid enough to execute their bribes the wrong way will probably be punished for bribery even though it would have been perfectly legal if they'd done it the right way.
- dvt 4y agoThis is an incredibly reductive take. Campaign contributions are carefully monitored. So you can't, like, buy yourself a house in Martha's Vineyard with campaign contributions. In fact, it's illegal for a politician to even be in contact with a super PAC (even though they may be campaigning for them). There have been many lawsuits that have settled this. Citizens United is problematic not because "money is free speech" (which, frankly, it is, as we live in a capitalist society) but rather because corporations (specifically when donating to Super PACs) have no caps on donation sizes. Fun fact: that money is not taxable income, by the way. So they can (in a roundabout way) essentially fill a friendly politician's coffers "for free."
- maerF0x0 4y agoAnd that's why Citizens united should have focused on citizens, not corporations. Corporations have not votes. Citizens do. A step forward could be to bar corporations from any action in the voting process (their constituent citizens like employees, owners, board etc can do what they wish as citizens, if they're citizens) .
- Zircom 4y agoThis is an incredibly naive take. There's countless ways and examples of how to get campaign funds into your own pocket. Speaking fees, books, your campaign hiring family members or friends, buying goods and services for your campaign from your own companies, etc. It happens all the time.
- dvt 4y ago> There's countless ways and examples of how to get campaign funds into your own pocket. I mean, while this is technically true, it's also a bit silly to think it's untraceable--many people that attempt to do this get in trouble for it[1]. As someone that owns a Super PAC, while I don't consider myself some kind of absolute authority, I do know some of the regulatory hurdles one must go through. I get it, you watched John Oliver do his little song and dance, but reality is a bit more complicated. [1] Just to cite a famous-ish case: read about Conservative Strikeforce Super PAC.
- Zircom 4y agoIf you could point to exactly where I said it was untraceable or that people don't get caught doing it....? Yeah. Please don't put words in my mouth. I'm fully aware it's by no means a risk free or foolproof venture, but you're the one being silly if you think the amount of cases where people are caught committing crimes is anything but a small percentage of people actually committing said crimes, especially white collar crimes like this. They're just the ones that were unlucky and/or not smart enough to get away with it. And honestly you're being more than a bit condescending and not really arguing in good faith, so not interested in continuing this conversation. You have a nice day though :)
- dvt 4y agoAre you trying to say that bribery is common in US politics? I can't tell if you're being sarcastic or not, but no, bribery is not common nor is it legal. People like to meme about lobbyists and PACs and all that. And, while it may be true that the system might need tweaks, all of that money is required to be reported through the FEC in the case of campaign contributions, or via D-2 forms in the case of lobbying. The problem with under-the-table bribes is that you can't "follow the money" so to speak.
- noworriesnate 4y agoLobbying is legalized bribery, and it's not just companies doing the lobbying/bribing, it's foreign countries doing it as well[1]. Also, lobbyists don't just influence policy, they also influence who gets elected in the first place[2]. The most common issue that lobbyist money is spent on has to do with the appropriating money from the federal budget[3], so in many cases it's likely that the money spent lobbying is used to redirect taxpayer funds to pay for more lobbying. In other words lobbying is so corrupt that it's easy for any citizen to see the corruption--yet people say, "Nah, it's fine because it's legal." This is blatantly anti-democratic. It's a huge mess of conflicts of interest. It should not be legal. [1] https://www.opensecrets.org/fara https://www.opensecrets.org/fara [2] https://www.opensecrets.org/federal-lobbying/top-recipients https://www.opensecrets.org/federal-lobbying/top-recipients [3] https://www.opensecrets.org/federal-lobbying/top-issues https://www.opensecrets.org/federal-lobbying/top-issues
- crazygringo 4y ago> Lobbying is legalized bribery That's an unhelpful take. Bribery as defined by law is inherently illegal, and lobbying is defined by law as legal, so legalized bribery is nonsensical. It can't exist. On the other hand, there are certainly arguments to be made for why lobbying can feel anti-democratic. But they come smack up against rights to freedom of speech, association, etc. It's incredibly difficult to draw the lines here for what is "democratic" and "anti-democratic", where "legitimate democratic politics" turns into "corruption". All of democracy is about individuals and groups trying to influence candidates and politicians, and providing or withholding support to do so, and candidates and politicians actively seeking support of individuals and groups via policy. Fortunately, we've decided that some lines are relatively easy to draw: politicians can solicit/receive contributions for campaigns, but not personally. But what you're arguing against doesn't have any kind of clear line. Federal money and tax breaks go to lots of different groups, and lots of different groups lobby. It's hard to see how that either of those should be illegal, or how tying them together could be made illegal, without the end result being even more anti-democratic.
- jeremynixon 4y agoAre these fines close to the business value gained from getting this legislation passed over the last 5 years? Seems unlikely. Nobody is going to jail. So where is the disincentive?
- f-securus 4y agoCost of doing business. Seems like this had positive ROI. I’d like for companies that do illegal things to have repercussions in line with what an individual would face for doing the same thing. Whoever signs off on it at the highest level should pay the price.
- schnebbau 4y agoAgreed. When a company does something illegal, the "company" is liable. But it was actually a person within the company who made the decision to do this; companies are not sentient. Why are the decision makers not held liable instead?
- duped 4y agoTo hell with monetary gain. It should be prison time for executives and board members.
- jcampbell1 4y agoThe head of AT&T Illinois is very much going to do time in federal prison and AT&T provided the evidence to the feds to send him there.
- rayiner 4y agoThe former President of AT&T Illinois has been charged and may go to prison: https://www.justice.gov/usao-ndil/pr/former-president-att-illinois-charged-conspiracy-unlawfully-influence-former-illinois-0 https://www.justice.gov/usao-ndil/pr/former-president-att-il...
- revlolz 4y ago"Under the agreement with AT&T, "the government will defer prosecution on the charge for two years and then seek to dismiss it if AT&T Illinois abides by certain conditions..." Slap on the wrist and no real punishment for the largest American telecom/ISP.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoATT shareholders have been punished quite a bit by the executives they have chosen. T-Mobile market cap is $165B, Verizon $152B, and ATT at $106B. Not that the government punishment should not be worse, but kind of breathtaking how badly managed ATT is.
- pcurve 4y agoI didn't realize Tmobile exceeded Verizon in market cap. wow. VZ has taken major beating in share price lately because of its high debt load. Looking at Tmobile's plan, https://www.t-mobile.com/cell-phone-plans https://www.t-mobile.com/cell-phone-plans I'm shocked at how low their price is for 3 phonelines. $90 essential plan is all I need. Similar plan on ATT would cost me at least 30%+ more.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoNote that for now and up until now, it is widely considered that coverage wise, Verizon > ATT > T-Mobile, and so mobile network pricing still reflects that. I doubt T-Mobile would be selling its services for less if it had the same coverage Verizon and ATT did, so effectively T-Mobile is selling an inferior product. Both Verizon and ATT tried to pull off a Comcast and tried to go vertical by acquiring content makers to avoid being just a dumb pipe, but they both failed miserably and ended up with a ton of debt. ATT failed much worse though. They paid $50B for a satellite TV broadcaster in 2015. It was already obvious that streaming was the future. Either extreme corruption or astounding incompetence.
- webinvest 4y agoVerizon has made a number of stupid decisions. Like buying and mismanaging Yahoo to buying and mismanaging Tumblr. Meanwhile TMobile bought Sprint and benefited significantly since it increased their coverage from just GSM to CDMA as well making them the only dual radio technology company in the country.
- giardini 4y agoI think they should pursue the indictments instead. Others' thoughts?
- rtanks 4y agoI agree
- dave78 4y agoThey are - they added additional charges to the former lawmaker (Madigan) who took the bribes[0]. He was already criminally charged for similar bribery by the local power company (ComEd). Makes me wonder if Comcast or Nicor will be next. I almost feel sorry for AT&T here. It's hard to overstate just how powerful Mike Madigan was in Illinois politics (and he's still very influential). He was undoubtedly more powerful than the governor. His corruption was legendary and well known by everyone, yet hardly anyone seemed to care and people voted for him anyway. He acted like a mob boss in the legislature, ensuring that all his colleagues would continue to vote him into the Speaker position year after year. Any Democrats who voted against him as speaker were very publicly punished, since he controlled most of the Democratic party money in the state. In a state that almost always has a Democratic supermajority, there were basically zero checks to his power. Companies like AT&T may have been in a bad situation of having no choice but to play ball with him just to be able to function in the state. Everyone in Illinois knew that you didn't say no to Mike Madigan. [0] https://chicago.suntimes.com/2022/10/14/23404193/mike-madigan-att-illinois-fined-sway-springfield-legislation https://chicago.suntimes.com/2022/10/14/23404193/mike-madiga...
- shkkmo 4y agoIt isn't clear, but I think only the indictment against the company itself is being put on hold. The CEO, the lawmaker and the intermediary are still being prosecuted?
- robswc 4y ago$20k is such a small amount (to bribe a politician at least). I'm constantly shocked at how small these bribes always seem to turn out. Unless the big ones are just better hidden, haha.
- lordnacho 4y agoMaybe they are so low risk it's a better business model to accept a large number of small bribes rather than a few large ones
- robswc 4y agoMakes sense actually. I guess small bribes are about the limit of what they can realistically get so they take anything.
- bogomipz 4y agoYes but this is only a single special interest. A corrupt politician makes up for this in volume.
- pessimizer 4y ago> $20k is such a small amount (to bribe a politician at least). I'm constantly shocked at how small these bribes always seem to turn out. I used to be shocked by this, but at some point I realized how expensive it must be to get a dollar to a politician. Getting $20K to Madigan involves meetings, planning, lawyers, accountants, and bagmen. I'm sure the total expense was closer to $100-$200K. Spent badly in this case because they still got caught, but spent well in the hundreds of cases we don't talk about. It's also capitalism; if Madigan weren't cheap and effective, he wouldn't have lasted as long as he did. He might have gotten a dozen AT&T-sized bribes that month from different sources.
- jackmott 4y ago
- pcurve 4y ago"The bill ended AT&T's obligation to provide landline phone service to all state residents" All that for a $22,500 payment. Talk about leverage.
- largbae 4y agoI don't get it, what is the difference between what was done here and paying a lobbyist?
- DannyBee 4y agoThey made the payment through a lobbyist if I read this right. In any case, lobbyists are paid to talk at people, not bribe them.
- daniel-cussen 4y ago
- bluefirebrand 4y agoCynically, lobbyists are paid to find ways of bribing people without getting caught, or inventing forms of bribery that aren't illegal yet.
- rayiner 4y agoIf by “cynically” you mean “inaccurately.” Lobbying involves making Power Points for staffers and doing their homework for them by drafting proposed legislation.
- ofer2 4y agoLobbyists probably also tend to hire ex-politicians as a form of (perfectly legal) delayed bribery; and hire family members of politicians (https://youtu.be/jXf04bhcjbg?t=1493 https://youtu.be/jXf04bhcjbg?t=1493).
- davidhyde 4y agoHow is the line between lobbying and bribery argued in court? There seems to be a large grey area between the two. This seems like lobbying to me. A corporation gives money to a politician (or party) in return for favourable legislation yet this particular incident is deemed illegal. Does the flow of money have to be more transparent to the public for it to be legal?
- jjulius 4y agoIANAL, this is probably way off, but at a basic level... Lobbying = "Hi, I'm a representative for [large donor]. I'd like to speak with you about how they feel about an upcoming piece of legislation, carefully using my words so that I'm just pushing our position on the issue and hoping you'll 'see our side' and vote in our favor, even though you and I both know what I really mean here." Bribery: "I will give you $[amount] if you vote [this way]."
- maerF0x0 4y agoaddendum to Lobbying: 4 years pass ... "<Name>! long time no see? oh you're out of office? Great! we have a cushy consulting position you should apply for, you're a shoe in!"
- didgetmaster 4y agoAlso..."Hey we are holding a conference and we would love to have you come speak for a half hour at <Big Event>. How does a $100K speaking fee sound to you?"
- chiefalchemist 4y agoMoi? That's more akin to veiled bribery. In the immediate they're promised an extremely lucrative *completely legal* payoff later. There's little actaul work, the pay is ridiculous, expenses covered, children get internships, etc. All legal...if you vote for hamburger today.
- mysterydip 4y agoThis, but replace lobbyist -> military contractor politician -> high ranking military officer out of office -> retired from active service and you now know why some contractors seem to continually get ludicrous purchases despite poor performance.
- zzzeek 4y ago$23M is a parking ticket for AT&T, subverting democracy might warrant a little more pinch maybe?
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoMargaret Cho has a great comedy bit about how being in a relationship turned her into a "low-priced hooker" (her words): "If you do the dishes, we can have sex." It's pretty stunning to me how low-priced these political hookers are. $22.5k to end a requirement for AT&T that is surely worth many, many millions? I have a difficult time believing the $23M is more than the annual savings they get from this bill. Companies will just rack this up as the cost of doing business.
- willcipriano 4y agoThe problem with your assumption is that corrupt politicians are rare and thus valuable, but the low prices indicate a oversupply of corrupt politicians all competing on price.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoEven if what you say were true, in any particular government there are only a few politicians that can move the needle. Some low ranking representative wouldn't be able to do squat in most cases. There is a reason AT&T specifically tried to court favor with the man who was Illinois Speaker of the House for nearly 2 decades.
- cosmodisk 4y agoI'm not an American, but the situation is very much the same in Europe. I always imagined big fat bribes that would buy a corrupt politicians or some official big house on an exotic island, etc. The reality is most are cheaper than an average prostitute on a street. It's shocking what <100K can buy in most cases. The ROI is insane.
- maerF0x0 4y ago> Madigan and McClain were previously indicted on racketeering and bribery Jail time and bans from operating. This is the only thing that will fix broken America. Jail time for those involved. and Lifetime bans from operating in the respective spaces. The person doing the bribing should be banned from a mgmt position, the the law maker should be banned from any political office at all levels, the lobby firm should be banned from operating in the US.
- chiefalchemist 4y agoAgreed. Fines are simply a cost of doing business in cases such as these. Commit a "blue collar" crime, you or I go to jail. But do a white collar crime and it's a slap on the wrists. Time - separated from family, etc. - has value. Money, for the amounts these people play with might as well be Monopoly money.
- rgrieselhuber 4y agoAnd a reversal of any legislation / actions taken.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pessimizer 4y ago> Jail time and bans from operating. You can't get that for an indictment unless you're indicting a poor person. In the US we ostensibly punish people when they're convicted. What we need to do is to punish the appearance of impropriety when it comes to politics, and be very specific about what appears to be impropriety. As it is, we can only stop dumb or lazy corruption, the kind that people talk about over the phone and write in emails.
- Kudotap 4y ago
- FpUser 4y ago
- perardi 4y ago“powerful lawmaker” Ever heard, vaguely, of Chicago-style politics? Well that’s the “powerful” guy here: Michael Madigan. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Madigan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Madigan https://www.chicagomag.com/chicago-magazine/december-2013/michael-madigan/ https://www.chicagomag.com/chicago-magazine/december-2013/mi... The longest-serving leader of any level of government in the country. He was old-school. No emails. Ran a foot soldier get-out-the-vote ground game. Massive conflicts of interest. Possibly torpedoed his own daughter’s run for governor. Never gave interviews.
- cosmodisk 4y agoThe Wikipedia entry alone reads like a script for a new Ozark season.
- faeriechangling 4y agoIt’s funny how I think of criminals who refuse to use modern technologies like emails as masters of technology. He would have been stopped years earlier had he not stuck to his old school ways and started using evidence-mail most likely. Reading about this man is fascinating. He’s a sort of a composed, calculated, competent evil.
- jjtheblunt 4y ago>longest-serving leader Longer than Secretary of State Jesse White in Illinois?
- blockwriter 4y agoMadigan is the Darth Vader of Illinois politics. He was speaker of the Illinois House from 97' until 21', when another scandal involving ComEd, if I recall correctly, finally forced him to resign. His other hustle is lowering the property tax rate of insiders - http://www.madigetz.com http://www.madigetz.com. Illinois politics is filled with the most ludicrously corrupt characters you can find. One interesting case from my neck of the woods is the Stephens family of Rosemont, who are, nominally, Republicans, but work with downstate Democrats to pass red light camera legislation, after receiving bribes from the companies that stand to gain - https://chicago.suntimes.com/politics/2020/10/18/21516422/red-light-camera-illinois-democrats-donations-michael-madigan-rosemont-brad-stephens-safespeed https://chicago.suntimes.com/politics/2020/10/18/21516422/re.... Rosemont is one of the weirdest places I've ever encountered. It's essentially family-run for-profit operation that caters to the corporate clientele of O'Hare airport.
- onetimeusename 4y agodon't forget that as far as I know, Illinois must hold the record for governors who have gone to jail for corruption. 4 out of the last 10 went to prison.
- grapescheesee 4y agoA real life Gotham city.
- dave78 4y agoThat number could increase soon too. The current governor is under federal tax fraud investigation. He bought the mansion next door to his, purposely removed the toilets, and then declared it uninhabitable to avoid paying hundreds of thousands of dollars in taxes.
- Mathnerd314 4y agoAFAICT that was settled in 2020 when Pritzker paid the extra taxes. I think if there were any charges they would have been announced by now. But it does seem Pritzker has some connections to Madigan (https://patch.com/illinois/chicago/pritzkers-7m-connection-madigan-elephant-room https://patch.com/illinois/chicago/pritzkers-7m-connection-m...), which might sink his re-election campaign. But so far he's doing well in the polls.
- swayvil 4y agoAh Illinois. That's where I live. We have the #1 highest taxes in the USA. Yes! And billions more in taxes gained from a vast legal marijuana industry. And our many prisons. And abortion tourism. And incredibly expensive rest homes for the elderly. All that tax money disappears like magic. Where'd it go?? We are famous for our corrupt politicians and soft-minded citizens.
- lotsofpulp 4y ago> Where'd it go?? Previously unaccounted for labor costs. Bought x amount of labor yesterday by paying y > x tomorrow, but not acknowledging y > x in any official reports. And, of course, there was most likely some loss due to corrupt investments. Note that federal laws exempted taxpayer funded deferred compensation schemes from laws such as ERISA 1974 and PPA 2006 specifically because taxes can be increased in the future, so why bother preventing future taxpayers from having to pay for previous generations of taxpayers?
- gautamdivgi 4y agoThe story allegedly is that it goes down the government pensions sink hole. That pension thing is crazy in and of itself. They put a commitment to fund pensions in the constitution. It’s nuts.
- swayvil 4y agoOh what a tasty bit of propagandistic argumentation that is. The reaction : everybody with a pension, or expecting a pension, fearful of losing their nestegg, rallys to defend the high taxes. And wailing fills the air, obscuring further discussion.
- pessimizer 4y agoThe government pensions sink hole was investing the cash with insiders who lost and stole it all, so it became a constant drain to pay out. They put a commitment to fund pensions in the constitution because the retirees who worked for bad salaries in exchange for these pensions deserve not to have to continue to fight for them. I would ask you to research John Filan for more details, but you'll find very little because this kind of history gets erased and substituted for angry rants about some appointee retiring at 45 on 3x his salary, to his own consulting company whose only client is the state, or a lobbying firm. As a reaction to those rants, it's retired teachers, DMV clerks, and garbagemen that get shit on. edit: this is absurdly detailed, although it glosses over a lot of stuff that Crain's ideologically approves of https://www.chicagobusiness.com/static/section/pensions.html https://www.chicagobusiness.com/static/section/pensions.html
- humaniania 4y agoEnd their capacity to "lobby" for a long time.
- bogomipz 4y agoCorporations are people in the US except when they commit crimes, then they're just corporations.
- yalogin 4y agoWow why is it possible to negotiate a criminal charge down to a fine? I can understand if it's a civil charge, but it should not be possible to do that for a criminal charge. One more example of "a corporation can do anything" rule we have in this country.
- jonhohle 4y agoEspecially one where a public servant is advancing its own interest at the expense of their constituents. IMHO, the penalties for such behavior should be harsh for both parties and prevent either from holding office again (and lobbying as well). Of the things that have had “zero tolerance” enforcement in the past, it’s egregious that crimes by politicians, law enforcement, and revenue agencies haven’t been included. Of course the laws and prosecutors are managed by the individuals involved in the crimes, so what will change?
- hairofadog 4y agoI wondered this as well. AT&T didn’t bribe anyone; executives at AT&T did. They should be facing the criminal penalty.
- userabchn 4y agoI think the solution is not to ban lobbying, etc., but rather to reduce the power of politicians so that there is no motivation to lobby or bribe them. For example, in my country the taxi drivers got politicians to ban Uber through protesting by blocking roads and probably pressuring their connections. I don't think politicians should have the power to be able to tell people that they are not allowed to pick up paying passengers if they want to, so there would have been no reason for the taxi drivers to gridlock the country as there would have been no potential benefit for them in doing so.
- Pulcinella 4y agoThe article says the bribe was for $22,500. Some how I am both insulted and encouraged by how low that amount is. I didn’t realize that my local PTA could abolish No Child Left Behind standardized testing for a few $100 bribes and a coupon to the local salad bar!
- victor106 4y agoCompanies commit a crime and pay fines, Individuals commit the same crime and go to prison.
- eyeareque 4y agoDoes this mean the vote that was made will be over turned? (If it turned out a single vote passed it)
- CyberDildonics 4y agoDon't forget that corporations are people, except when it comes to three strike laws and being put in prison for life.
- barbariangrunge 4y agoIs 23M more or less than the benefit that they got for this bribe?
- rayiner 4y agoWhat explains the corruption in Illinois? It seems disproportionately more corrupt than other parts of the US.
- tptacek 4y agoDoes it? Support that argument with evidence, not about the presence of corruption in Illinois, but about the corruption relative to other states.
- rayiner 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corruption_in_Illinois https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corruption_in_Illinois https://pols.uic.edu/chicago-politics/anti-corruption-reports/ https://pols.uic.edu/chicago-politics/anti-corruption-report... > The Department of Justice (DOJ) statistics on public corruption show, that since the department began collecting the data in 1976, the Northern District of Illinois, which includes Chicago, is the most corrupt federal judicial district in the nation, and that Illinois, on a per capita basis, is the third most corrupt state.
- tptacek 4y agoThe metric you're citing is followed by a table that shows they reached the ranking only by taking all public corruption cases from 1976-2020; if you look only at recent cases, we're behind Florida and California. The real issue is that this is an analysis that mostly just tracks population (it's not weighted by population). Look, for what it's worth, I'm not trying to argue that public corruption isn't a problem in Chicagoland. It obviously is. Hopefully the fall of Madigan does something about it; really, until we get a viable Illinois Republic Party, we're going to be stuck with a political machine, just like very non-competitive state has. But people are glib about this stuff.