6 ms·
Do McKinsey and other consultants do anything useful?
- k__ 4y agoThey create plausible deniability for higher ups.
- Ladioss 4y agoAn unavoidable, essential and expensive evolution with the rise (and the domination) of the managerial civilization.
- conductr 4y ago“Decision support” and “strategic (blank)” are how this is often messaged In a regulated space, I have found we usually bring them in initially just to find out how our competition is dealing with a new requirement. We may not even engage longer with them on the bigger project. This is actually useful because they have insights to so many companies.
- lupire 4y agoRight. It's corporate espionage.
- chrischattin 4y agoYep. Consultants are compensated very well to take the blame if the thing executives wanted to do anyway doesn’t work out.
- ryan93 4y agoThis gets said so much im now becoming skeptical. Third rate CEOs are keeping their jobs as long as they hired mckinsey?
- juve1996 4y agoI don't buy this argument very much. Higher ups are responsible for the company. You can blame consultants all you want but the board is still going to want heads to roll if you're underperforming.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoThe plausible deniability does not have to be just from shareholders. It can also be from the courts, or even other employees in the company. Also, the plausible deniability is for the person in the company doing the head rolling, so that they do not get caught up in it. Of course, some things can get so big that board members and CEO can get caught up in it, but not always.
- juve1996 4y agoI still don't buy it. Consultancies give recommendations and explain them. These things are well documented. McKinsey and Purdue worked together on opioids. Both were sued and both had to pay for their strategy which resulted in addiction and death.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoI would qualify that under: > Of course, some things can get so big that board members and CEO can get caught up in it, but not always.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- juve1996 4y agoSo let me get this straight - it's for plausible deniability, but it doesn't work in the case you would want it to the most?
- _pmf_ 4y agoResponsibility sink.
- raisin_churn 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headlines https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headline...
- Bakary 4y agoParadoxically, an article titled "Is Betteridge's law helpful?" would buck the trend
- raisin_churn 4y agoOr, since Betteridge's Law, like Moore's and Poe's, is a physical constant of the universe, it could implode in on itself and create a supermassive black hole.
- osipov 4y agoIn a broader economic context, they take profitable but unpredictable companies and make them boring. Google is the more recent example. Apple (pre-return of Job) is another. Here's a good article: https://www.inc.com/justin-bariso/apple-googlemckinsey-how-an-old-school-company-is-changing-the-world-of-digital-.html https://www.inc.com/justin-bariso/apple-googlemckinsey-how-a...
- yrgulation 4y agoI know Accenture does more harm than good. If a company brings in any of these types of “consultants” it means they are on a race to the bottom and this is their last attempt at turning things around. And at that stage the environment tends to be toxic.
- lbbenjohnston 4y agoHas anyone joined a project where Accenture developers are building a new solution that's gone well? ... asking for a friend.
- balabaster 4y agoI will tell you, having been approached by Accenture a number of times that the rates they offer their consultants are far below what a decent consultant expects to get paid. You get what you pay for. You're mileage may vary.
- simonh 4y agoThe opposite. Also I actually went to a job interview at Accenture once, their pay rates for IT people are terrible. Why anyone competent would work there I have no idea.
- agentwiggles 4y agoI was briefly employed by Accenture after an acquisition. It was exactly the corporate hellscape you'd expect, and at the end of the day you can't escape that. But a lot of the day to day experience depended on what team you were on. If you had good leads on your team, you could be protected from a lot of bullshit and focus on getting work done. The only "good" projects I'm aware of were projects that the acquired company had sold before the acquisition. For lower level employees (especially offshore), the corporate bullshit is impossible to escape, but depending on where you fall on the ladder, there are some good opportunities for advancement. If you're a ladder climber, you can make a lot of money in a Managing Director position or above. I didn't enjoy my time with them and would never work with them again, but I guess my point is that it's possible to have good experiences working there. Maybe this post will make it just a little bit less baffling that some folks choose to work there.
- mugivarra69 4y agono
- harha 4y agoNo, but let’s not overestimate what the rest of us are doing. I studied engineering at a prestigious school, I don’t think any of my jobs was particularly useful and this applies to most people I’ve met in my professional life. Something’s severely broken but I can’t really point to what it is.
- ryandvm 4y agoI like this vibe. I too am at the "nobody knows what they're doing and nothing really matters" stage of life.
- harha 4y agoYeah and at least in tech you get to play with: technology. So it’s fun, but I have this constant feeling that I could actually create value and also earn more. All the paths seem to be closed though whenever I dig a bit deeper. I was optimistic with decentralization for a while because that would let you operate outside of established firms that all seem to have the issues a sibling poster describes [1], unfortunately it didn’t take off for many notable non-financial use-cases. [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33214646 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33214646 Edit: added link
- lagrange77 4y ago> at least in tech you get to play with: technology. So it’s fun Right, without this fact, the tech landscape would look like a lot different.
- giardini 4y agoI too am in that stage of life. Why, even the other day I wondered "Do those 'bypass all authorization" buttons on the ICBM launch console (@ our hole in North Dakota) actually work?" To my surprise they do! Fortunately the "Shutdown engines" button also works! But it got me out of my funk. Well, got to do some cleaning: seems Minuteman-III silo vibrations cause bowel evacuations in most people.
- mush_room 4y ago
- altdataseller 4y agoShort answer: no. Long answer: no, not really.
- ghaff 4y agoMy one direct experience with McKinsey was mixed. We were making a fairly big bet on a new product line so the CEO brought in McKinsey. The consultants were a bit of a mixed bag. The partner and one of the associates were sharp. The other associate less so. They basically just confirmed that what we were planning made sense. But that was useful in and of itself. And they provided our business planning people with complicated spreadsheets that kept them out of otherwise getting in the way. (Only somewhat /s.)
- chasd00 4y agoA good team of consultants is worth their weight in gold but, like everyone else, a good team is rare.
- balabaster 4y agoAgreed!
- poxwole 4y agoThe Economist is the most morally bankrupt media outlet
- jen20 4y agoThe New York Post would like a word.
- simonh 4y agoThere are some specific cases where consultancies can be very useful. If you'e going through pretty much any on-time transition where you don't have internal expertise, bringing in outside expertise can be worthwhile. Things like opening an offshore office for the first time, buying another company and doing a merger, turning around a failing department or division. Clearly defined time bounded activities that require specific skills you don't have. Too often though companies use consultants to manage core activities of the company. If it's a core activity, and you can't do it yourself, what are you even doing in business?
- the_lonely_road 4y agoConsultants bread and butter are long standing regulations. Healthcare, banking, environmental and probably some others I am less familiar with. You find yourself on the other side of a government regulator action and what do you do? Stumble your way though it for the first time while redirecting business critical assets to an unfamiliar one time project or hire a group of people who have been standing on the other side of these regulators twice a year for the last 20 years?
- ethbr0 4y agoAbsolutely agreed! I think where so many of us have seen this go awry is when companies think IT isn't a core activity. And I also see companies consistently screw up defining their deliverables and by not building in a draft review process (early enough for feedback to be actioned on). If you have nebulous deliverables and a single project end date... of course consultancies are going to throw together what they think the minimal acceptable product is, at the last minute. We don't build software that way anymore, and for good reason.
- acdha 4y ago> If it's a core activity, and you can't do it yourself, what are you even doing in business? The most value I’ve ever seen was at a large, well-known organization where the 24 year-olds in $2k suits met with the actual staff and gave the C-level an honest report about all of the problems which had been getting buried for years by the mid-level management. That worked but so many things are just broken for that to be useful. Nobody wanted to deal with that, so unsurprisingly a lot of people left after a year or two.
- orangepurple 4y agoAs a subcontractor which was embedded into a BCG team in Virginia on a procurement overhaul project I have had nothing but a positive experience with that crew. They provided an actual real useful very detailed plan on how to reach the desired end state after spending weeks pitching their plan to the client. Maybe it's just the two partners I work with. Nothing shady or unethical happened. The client screwed themselves up so badly there is so much room for big money proposals to fix things the client already did to themselves. The leadership goes out of their way to stop both real and perceived corruption. e.g., no gifts or expensed dinners for clients. My team only needs reputation to get more work. And they are good at getting themselves out there and putting out good work. Just my observation.
- asplake 4y agoI was disappointed by this article, expected better. Although it acknowledges wrongdoing, it does little to explain why it happens as often as it does.
- ghaff 4y agoI think you wanted a different article. While pretty short, I pretty much agree with the two reasons they give for bringing in consultants.
- oneplane 4y agoNot really, because even if it were that simple (get some people from "over there" and bring them "here" so things are now "better"), it's not in their best interest. Just like with politics, it's not about doing something, it's about making sure with the next round of "who do we pick", you're the one that gets chosen.
- blueboo 4y agoThey’re change agents in organisations that find themselves unable to change. Are they effective?…often not, but juicing meaningful decision making is the underlying spirit of deploying them.
- hurrell 4y agohttps://archive.ph/RULym https://archive.ph/RULym
- spaceman_2020 4y agoThey do at least one thing useful: assume blame. That in itself is worth the price tag for senior execs seeking cover for their ideas.
- bell-cot 4y agoMcKinsey and other consultants are the modern equivalent of counselors to medieval kings. A strong, competent king would still have counselors - but he'd make sure they were competent, loyal, and deriving only modest and honest profits from the arrangement. A less-strong but passably competent king would often need more & better-paid counselors - if only to provide coverage and a chorus of arguments, when he needed to do things that weren't so popular or familiar. A weak or incompetent king often fell victim to Evil Counselors - who more-or-less ended up ruling the kingdom, for their own enjoyment and profit. Back in medieval times - when insulting the king could literally get your head chopped off - it was quite reasonable to blame "evil counselors" whenever the kingdom wasn't doing so well. But now? Why the h*ell can't people see and say the obvious, when craptastic managers, bureaucrats, and politicians need to be dethroned & defenestrated?
- Aeolun 4y agoIt’s like saying the emperor is not wearing any clothes. Everyone can see it and thinks it’s crazy, but all emperors (and emperor hopefulls) wear no clothes, so they’re disinclined to make an issue of it.
- bell-cot 4y agoNo. There is a very wide range of competence & honesty in managers, bureaucrats, and politicians. And you'll accomplish d*mn little if you replace or remove the consultants who gather around the crappy ones.
- paultopia 4y agoI always thought the point of consultants was to manage internal politics by giving management cover to do things that everyone knows needs to be done but nobody wants to do
- rufius 4y agoNo. If you see them show up at your company, run. It will be hell. My mother, a nurse for 40 years, knows first hand what a bunch of consultants know about patient care
- shp0ngle 4y agoI have good experience with McK and bad experience with everyone else. But it’s just anecdotal. So I don’t know
- balabaster 4y agoThere are plenty of use cases for consultants: 1. Experts in their field often reach a point in their career where they've run into enough road blocks and solved enough major problems in their field that they can see some benefit in helping others avoid/solve said problems on fast track. [This is where I'm at] 2. Companies often have need for on-tap expertise to solve problems on fast track without being required to commit for the long haul. And here is the intersection of consulting. I've solved about a million problems at this point in my career. Many of them solved the hard way - the way I'd like you not to have to solve them. I've spotted patterns that allow you to predict what kind of behaviours and working processes will cause what kinds of problems and I've formed patterns and processes that allow clients to sidestep issues before they become issues. Wouldn't it be useful to benefit from that? Many major consultancies, sadly, hire a ton of people that haven't put in the time and built the skills to be as effective as you may like - which is reflected by the fact that every time I've been approached by Accenture they've offered rates that only a junior or intermediate level consultant would go for. This explains why a lot of customers part ways with consultancies with a bad taste in their mouth. This isn't the grade of "expertise" you expect when you hire a consultancy. You expect senior or principal level resources for the rates you pay - people who have done the time, solved the problems and come armed with the solutions; not juniors and intermediates who may be great bums in seats, but not what you hire big expensive consultancies to provide.
- blablabla123 4y agoI've also been on a team with a technical consultant. Finding someone with that specific expertise and fitting into the environment would have been really difficult and probably more expensive, also considering the risk of a bad hire.
- kkfx 4y agoAnytime someone say "useful", "good", "bad" etc MUST precise for who. McKinsey sure and certainly do something useful for it's shareholders, for the rest of the world.............
- heynowheynow 4y agoSadly, yes. There are managers who refuse to listen to their own people. This is where MBB consultants come in: talk to everyone, listen, and deliver fancy brochure-level template presentations with data and input from their own employees. It's the same or variations of recommendations that are listened-to because they cost more. Also, an ignorant of the politics and business generalist business expert can more easily notice if there is anything amiss by entering as a novice with fewer vested interests.
- refurb 4y agoI've worked with the major consulting firms, including McKinsey and their "usefulness" really depends on what you're asking them to do. My general rule is if you ask them to work on something external - say, a summary of a market you're looking to enter, they can be quite useful. You're basically hiring a team to work pretty much full time on a specific topic. They usually have a good network of experts to tap and can do the grunt work of talking to a wide range of people, access major data sources, and approach the analysis methodically. That can be sometimes tough to do internally if you have limited time, internal expertise and limited accesses to sources of info. Plus you can avoid internal bias in the analysis. If they are working on something internal to your company? Say org structure, new processes or policies? You may be disappointed. You as the internal person will know way more then they'll ever know and despite internal interviews and data collection, they'll have such limited visibility they'll likely give you some cookie-cutter answer. But if that's the cookie cutter answer you want to sell internally, have an outside, independent perspective is maybe exactly what you want.
- oneoff786 4y ago> Though hated, they often provide a valuable service to the economy I’m current McKinsey and I’ll be honest, I’ve never seen anyone echo the “hated” thing outside a few random individual contributors. Most people have no idea who we are. But whatever. Can answer questions if people have them
- atty 4y agoI worked at a Kroger (grocery store chain) for 7 years, and each time they brought in consultants to modify workflows they made our lives (stockers and baggers) worse, with no measurable improvement in efficiency. Needless to say, I am not a fan of consultants. Only time you should use them is when you’re doing something you have zero competency in. A grocery store should not be using them to design their stocking workflows.
- Overtonwindow 4y agoDogbert has given us key insight into this powerful question: https://www.teerondesign.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/Dilbert-Dogbert-Consultant.jpg https://www.teerondesign.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/Dilb...