8 ms·
Mud boosts the immune system
- tigen 4y agoIt's all fun and games until you get the brain-eating amoeba. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naegleria_fowleri https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naegleria_fowleri
- rpastuszak 4y agoNot for the amoeba!
- dqpb 4y agoOr lead
- 4gotunameagain 4y ago
- kibwen 4y agoI grew up in the countryside and the article's conclusion of "let your kids eat some dirt" has always been rather anecdotally obvious to me; I tromped through a lot of mud and unwisely put a lot of weird things in my mouth and I seem to have a much more robust immune system than my peers who didn't. That said, "growing up in the countryside" isn't itself necessary. You just need to grow up with some decent nature within walking distance. Yes, many urban environments have unwisely paved over all their green spaces with parking lots and high rises. But that's not a necessary feature of a city; look for cities that value green spaces, e.g. Pittsburgh's Frick Park/Schenley Park/Hazelwood Greenway triangle provides ample opportunity for getting lost in unmanicured woods. Part of what gets my goat is the idea that humans only evolved to live in bucolic, pastoral locales. Humans have been banding together in cities for 6,000 years now; we have plenty of adaptations for urban living (such as, ironically, disease resistance; the notion that city living is cleaner than country living is a modern phenomenon).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- starkd 4y agoI think it was Steven Pinker who claimed that we were best evolved for life on the savanah, bucolic pastoral type settings with wide open fields. Settings that are easy on the eyes and provide a good line of sight while also providing corners to duck for cover. A setting which has mostly been replicated by the suburbs. True that we have adapted to live in cities fairly well, but even a few thousand years I would think would be too short for evolution.
- not2b 4y agoWhile this may or may not be the case, Pinker is a linguist and has neither the expertise nor evidence to back up this assertion. I don't think modern American suburbs resemble the African savanna. But the chaparral terrain on much of the California coast where I often hike is a lot closer to it.
- starkd 4y agoHe is a psycho-linguist and his field is evolutionary psychology. He never claimed a complete resemblance between the savannah and suburbia, but just that both contain many of the key features which would make it highly suitable for the species, at least from an evolutionary perspective. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steven_Pinker https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steven_Pinker
- oldcigarette 4y agoTo your point every creek in pittsburgh is still "shit creek" or loaded with amd in the spring. I wouldn't eat any mud - maybe some dirt up on a hill.
- MichaelCollins 4y ago> That said, "growing up in the countryside" isn't itself necessary. You just need to grow up with some decent nature within walking distance. Yes, many urban environments have unwisely paved over all their green spaces with parking lots and high rises. But that's not a necessary feature of a city; look for cities that value green spaces, e.g. Pittsburgh's Frick Park/Schenley Park/Hazelwood Greenway triangle provides ample opportunity for getting lost in unmanicured woods. I can scarcely imagine city parks providing the country upbringing experience of running off into the woods after breakfast and not coming home until dinner, every day of summer until school season started again. Visiting the park for a few hours once or twice a week just isn't the same.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- richardhod 4y agoAnd in other news, bears seen defecating in silvan locations /s This is definitely true, but not exactly news to most people
- shultays 4y agoIt is probably not as known to as you think. Lots of parents out there would put their kids in sterile rooms if they were able to. Idea of their kids playing in mud would faint a couple parents out there. Most uses antibiotics on their kids with slightest fever
- roflc0ptic 4y ago> Most uses antibiotics on their kids with slightest fever People in my vicinity generally understand that antibiotics don't help viral infections. What doctors are they getting these antibiotics from? I doubt this claim.
- pdpi 4y agoI’m not sure it’s as true now as it was 20 years ago, but I do remember seeing several campaigns raising awareness of the risks of antibiotic abuse. At any rate, you’re not necessarily contradicting GP. You can both know that antibiotics don’t help with viral infections and also believe that antibiotic use is harmless. Put the two together, and giving your kids antibiotics “just in case” seems perfectly reasonable.
- roflc0ptic 4y agoBut in the US at least antibiotics require a prescription from doctors. So you need the doctors to play along, too, and in my own experience I’ve never received antibiotics unnecessarily
- pdpi 4y agoYou can easily end up with leftovers from a prescription if stop taking them midway through the course once you're feeling better. Those left overs can then be used to self-medicate. I could speculate on how else it happens, but the important part is that it does happen, and e.g. the Mayo clinic says: > According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, about one-third of antibiotic use in people is not needed nor appropriate. https://www.mayoclinic.org/healthy-lifestyle/consumer-health/in-depth/antibiotics/art-20045720 https://www.mayoclinic.org/healthy-lifestyle/consumer-health...
- PaulKeeble 4y agoThere are various bacteria that stay within our gut and help us process fibre that comes from mud and nature generally, we have a symbiotic relationship with at least thousands of bacteria. The more interesting and potentially very medically relevant presence in mud is Phages, viruses for Bacteria. There are various bacteria our body can not clear and that are also antibiotic resistant and a treatment for them would be immensely beneficial. Yet nature has a phage for all of them, millions of different ones and they are very effective if you can find the right one.
- robk 4y agoReally fascinating area of science. They were ignored in lieu of antibiotics in the post war forming of big Pharma (except for pockets like France and Russia). Startups are working in this space now https://www.phagos.org/ https://www.phagos.org/
- Raydovsky 4y agoYou forgot Georgia. They are way ahead of Russia when it comes to phages
- ch4s3 4y agoWe’ll phages present their own issues. Antibiotics were cheap and easy to mass produce.
- manmal 4y agoAre you talking about bacteriophages? What issues do they present?
- CatWChainsaw 4y agoI'm guessing that once the research into a particular phage reaches a level equivalent to research in a particular antibiotic, the cost to manufacture that phage might be higher. In order to mass-produce phage you need a population of vulnerable bacteria kept alive long enough and in high enough number to keep your phage replicating since they rely on cellular machinery, and that takes large bioreactors. And that's if you're lucky. Some bacteria replicate under extremely obnoxious conditions, and sometimes the phages will only generate double-digit levels of virion particles each generation as opposed to the triple-digit target you want, and all your attempts to optimize the system hit a brick wall. Ask me how I know? :)
- mush_room 4y agoI'm not providing a reference with this comment but I've heard numerous times that at the time of the polio epidemic it was a common observation that kids raised in "rough" conditions, i.e. on the streets and exposed to all the insalubrity that goes with it, were handling polio infections much better than kids raised with modern hygiene. The so-called "hygiene hypothesis"...
- 323 4y agoI think the "hygiene hypothesis" is mostly related to allergies, not infections per se. Kids in countries with "rough" conditions have a much higher mortality than kids in the developed world. I think it's pretty well accepted that the hygiene revolution decreased child (and adult) mortality a lot. That's not to say it didn't create other problems, but surely on net a "cleaner" world is better. Nobody is advocating not washing your hands before you eat. So while "tougher raised" kids probably have a better immune system, the risk associated with pathogen exposure grow even more dramatically, such that they surpass the benefit.
- mush_room 4y agoI think both can be true, question of balance. Concerning kids exposed to those pathogens in the developing world, we have to consider that malnutrition is a major contributor.
- generalizations 4y agoOr, said another way - it was harder to survive being raised in those 'rough' conditions, but if you did, you were tougher. Survival of the fittest.
- Klinky 4y agoOne of the failings of the simple concept of "survival of the fittest" is that survival just means you pass on genes, your quality of life might be poor up til then or you die shortly after, and fitness is towards the environment you grew up in, you may fail completely at adapting to an environmental shift later on. The concept only goes so far, and people need to be wary of it being used to potentially justify that harsh living conditions are okay or "better". It can come off as an appeal to nature.
- tiku 4y agoWalk barefoot more. There was an article on here a while back that also claimed it helped. Because you get in contact with dirt/ground.
- j-bos 4y agoBut do be careful of domedtic fecal matter.
- chihuahua 4y agoDomestic fecal matter? Someone shits on the floor in my house, and I step into it? Yes that could present some problems, such as slipping on the stairs.
- ch4s3 4y agoWhat’s the mechanism here? Doesn’t the thick skin on the bottoms of your feet prevent and microorganisms from entering your body? That’s what it’s for after all.
- RosanaAnaDana 4y agoIn at least one case, worms. https://www.science.org/content/article/parasitic-worms-may-prevent-crohn-s-disease-altering-bacterial-balance https://www.science.org/content/article/parasitic-worms-may-...
- ch4s3 4y agoHemlinths enter the body through contaminated food and water, not through the feet. They’re also pretty bad for you, and can make you very sick for years.
- rekrsiv 4y agoElectrons: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3265077/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3265077/
- heynowheynow 4y agoSomehow, I suspect a mud resort is behind this.
- starkd 4y agoPerhaps. Sort of makes you want to go out and dig a hole.
- heynowheynow 4y agoSeriously. Claim Elvis, Madonna, and Oprah visited. And it has indescribable cleansing properties. Wellness is the easiest place to make money because it's selling sweet little lies people want to hear.
- starkd 4y agoPlus who doesn't like digging a good hole in the ground.
- photochemsyn 4y agoThis article has a blind spot large enough to drive a truck through, related to the author's apparent belief that we all live in some kind of bucolic pre-industrial society. Take this claim: > "People who grow up on farms are generally less likely to develop asthma, allergies, or auto-immune disorders like Crohn's disease – thanks, apparently, to their childhood exposure to a more diverse range of organisms in the rural environment that had encouraged more effective regulation of the immune system." The vast majority of farming in the USA and Britain is industrialized and relies heavily on regular application of pesticides and herbicides in the fields. Animal farming is centered on factory farms where animals are kept in close quarters and given antibiotics and hormones to prevent disease outbreaks and increase growth rates. The fecese and urine from these operations stink for miles around. Childhood exposure to such environments results in everything from asthma to neurological damage - see Parkinsons relationship to organophosphorous pesticides, say. Another concrete example: methyl bromide in the strawberry fields of California: https://www.ewg.org/research/heavy-methyl-bromide-use-near-california-schools https://www.ewg.org/research/heavy-methyl-bromide-use-near-c... That's the industrial agriculture reality, so packing your kids off to such farms to get their dose of 'good natural microbes' is inadvisable. It's just half the equation, however, as other kinds of industrial activity have loaded up soils with all kinds of chemical contaminants, from heavy metals (sometimes radioactive) to persistent organics with negative health effects. For example, anyone living downwind of an oil refinery or coal power plant, or around a uranium mine etc., should thing twice about galavanting through the local mudholes. Richmond, in California downwind from Chevron and other refineries, is a case example: https://www.ehn.org/pollution-poverty-richmond-2645503359.html https://www.ehn.org/pollution-poverty-richmond-2645503359.ht... Even without the modern industrial-related issues, historically animal farming has been linked to all kinds of parasite issues, such as the hookworm pandemic that afflicted the American South for many decades (linked to pig farms). The 'get in touch with nature on a nice organic farm' theme should be tempered by such realities, i.e.: https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/article/how-a-worm-gave-the-south-a-bad-name/ https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/article/how-a-worm-gave-the-so... However, direct interactions with relatively pristine natural environments are likely great for kids (and adults), and the notion that ultra-sterile equals ultra-healthy doesn't make any sense either.
- 4y ago
- DOsinga 4y agoNot the game then
- mr_mitm 4y ago> According to recent research, the dirt outside is teaming with friendly microorganisms that can train the immune system and build resilience to a range of illnesses, including allergies, asthma and even depression and anxiety. In that light, does it make sense to speak of "boosting the immune system"? If I understand correctly, allergies and asthma are the result of overly active immune system. Depression and anxiety are completely unrelated to the immune system as far as I know. So if anything, playing in mud dampens the immune system of children, albeit in a good way. Also, the title of the article neglects to mention that this only applies to children.
- jetbooster 4y agoIt was my understanding that in those cases the immune system overreacts because it hasn't been correctly calibrated by being properly challenged. It's not that it's too strong, it's that it lashes out at things that aren't actually threats because it's ability to recognise what is and isn't a threat is diminished
- mr_mitm 4y agoYes, "calibrating" is the word that also just jumped into my mind. That would have been a much better fit than "boosting".
- xeromal 4y agoAn additional datapoint I remember reading is that humans for so long has worms and other parasites that dulled the immune system that our immune system is actually hyperactive because we no longer have those parasites to repress it.
- NickM 4y agoDepression and anxiety are completely unrelated to the immune system as far as I know. They are definitely related. Many studies have found links between inflammation and both anxiety and depression. There's even a Wikipedia page about the depression/inflammation link: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Depression_and_immune_function https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Depression_and_immune_function
- Kudotap 4y agoAnd hence the reason why kids who grow up in urban areas, tend to have considerably lower than immunity kids raised in rural environments. Urbanism negatively affects us in a lot more ways than we're currently even aware of
- mustafabisic1 4y agoThis explains a lot about my childhood when my parents would just let me be outside all the time. Also it reminds me of an interesting conclusion somebody had here on HN that it's weird how we insctinctively know how each thing around us would taste. Like if I told you do you know how the door would taste if you licked it. A taste would come in your mind. Fascinating stuff. This article is definitely going into my next week's newsletter for remote working parents (https://thursdaydigest.com/ https://thursdaydigest.com/). Even though most of my subscribers are from HN.
- tzs 4y agoBabies offered free choice from a variety of foods seem to automatically know how to pick in a way to get a good balanced diet [1]. [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1626509/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1626509/
- logicalmonster 4y agoThis seems to be a unique period in history to test the idea with a large sample size. I'm not sure how this could easily be measured while taking into account every variable, but I'd love to see good studies done over the long-term based on how people are reacting to living with Covid-19. Due to a high state of fear, a portion of people seem resigned to living the rest of their lives wearing masks/gloves/face shields everywhere in public, very frequently cleaning themselves and their living environments to kill every possible germ, washing their hands more frequently than might be reasonably necessary, avoiding many public interactions, etc. If humans are better off with some reasonable amount of exposure to the normal bacteria in nature, the fearful people might end up with worse off immune systems due to this lack of normal exposure.
- palata 4y agoThe whole point of the covid measures was/is not to avoid getting covid, but to slow it down. Because if everyone is sick at the same time, it's extremely bad. There is a balance to find between living the rest of your life with a mask and refusing to help slowing the pandemic down by doing a small effort, because YOLO. But that's far from being globally understood.
- viridian 4y agoon the other hand, if this mostly applies to childhood behaviors, I doubt we'll see much of an effect. My kid was still chewing grass and tasting dirt clods in the middle of covid.
- 29athrowaway 4y agoIt was all healthy until polyfluoroalkyl contamination spread around the globe, and now rainwater is toxic and so is the soil.
- yboris 4y agoWhen you visit the page, the title is "How mud boosts your immune system" -- but isn't all the evidence and discussion about children? As far as I understand, this exposure to mud / bacteria is particularly beneficial during the first three years (maybe a few more years; probably not much consensus there) and there isn't evidence to think people over 18 would benefit from continued exposure (though gardening seems to benefit health; and perhaps those who have gone through antibiotic treatment might benefit - though I know of no such evidence, never looked). Could anyone who has more familiarity with the topic comment? :)
- pessimizer 4y ago> When you visit the page, the title is "How mud boosts your immune system" -- but isn't all the evidence and discussion about children? You wouldn't be able to find enough people to test if you focused on adults who played in the dirt and mud now, but didn't when they were children. I don't think there's any reason to doubt that it would work on adults, although I wouldn't assume it would, either.
- m3047 4y agoAll I have is anecdata. Early years were extremely urban; still have allergies; learned some things about managing them as an adult. Had a resurgence in autoimmune issues a few years ago (triggered by an initial misdiagnosis); declined doing allergy shots again, absolutely no doubt in my mind that my improvement since would be claimed as a win by allopathic practitioners if I'd gone that route. I used to spend a lot of time in the woods doing extreme stuff; I've bled all over the place, even got some nasty puncture wounds, never got infected; scuffed my hand in an urban park and got blood poisoning. I eat produce and fruit from my own grounds. I hug chickens. I pick up and dispose of dead things (carefully). Yes, I've had a tetanus shot in recent memory. Pretty sure I had COVID early on, barely noticed it. Or it could have been the lisinopril (blood pressure issue also stemming from the misdiagnosis, although it too is improving). I can only say "pretty sure" because I've asked repeatedly for an antibody test and the doctors have refused. Worked for biotechs, had safety training. Wore N95s throughout COVID indoors most places, taking care when removing them; sanitize my hands; wash them when I get home; avoid public restrooms if at all possible; have only eaten at restaurants twice since COVID started. In summary, I take measures which are probably half-assed, but I'm very consistent. Haven't had the "flu" either. Moved my annual physical to June starting this year, which is the yearly minimum for ILI around here; the physician had a studied "no comment" about this. When I was at the clinic in February to set this up, while I was sitting in the waiting room the linen service employee came to pick up the wash wearing dirty work gloves and nobody paid attention; after five minutes I got up and took some sani wipes to the door handles; then they noticed.
- dmix 4y agoIs the point of your comment that exposure and being active outdoors helps build your resistance. Also you sound a bit over cautious. Are you over 50? Otherwise you don’t really need a yearly physical. At least according to my doctor.
- m3047 4y ago> helps build your resistance I think "resilience" is more poetic than "resistance". Kind of like "modulation" instead of "moderation". Basically yes, but a lot of it is mental attitude and being willing and able to learn lessons from that activity. > Also you sound a bit over cautious. [...] See previous point about mental attitude. I clearly said I do a "half-assed" job, but do it consistently so that I can judge the effect. Do you need a yearly physical? Can you afford one? Is the risk vs benefit different at different points in the ILI (influenza like illness) cycle? Is it different depending on the general quality of medical care in your community? Is it different if the linen service comes through the front door of the clinic, or if the staff bothers to wipe the door handles? I think you need to be observant to develop answers to those questions and have any confidence in your reasoned judgement concerning related ones. Finally, I consider myself fortunate to have gotten out of the urban core and embraced a little of the "hard" part of life.
- chrischen 4y agoWhen I was a kid (in China), before boarding my flight to the US, my relatives packed some balls of dirt in my carry on for me to make “tea” from.
- andrekandre 4y agowhat kind of tea could that be?
- chrischen 4y agoI just put the ball of dirt in water and drink it.
- jvican 4y agoA relevant article arguing the opposite can be found in Elizabeth's blog: "Eating Dirt is Basically Made Up" https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/JzJcgsKBf35FeuZSD/eating-dirt-benefits-kids-is-basically-made-up https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/JzJcgsKBf35FeuZSD/eating-dir...
- pessimizer 4y agoNot really. Your reference is against "eating dirt" which seems to have become a popular pop-sci article shorthand for other stuff about sanitation that she says has plenty of backing. I was a filthy kid, but I didn't intentionally eat dirt (that would be weird), I ate with dirty hands.
- chihuahua 4y agoI'm told I used to eat dirt (sand, soil, etc) as a child, which upset my brother. It seems to have worked out for me - I have no allergies and can digest anything and everything, in contrast with people who proclaim that carbs make them bloat, they get tired after eating sugar, etc. I still get a good dose of dirt from frequent bike rides on dusty logging roads, where the occasional passing car stirs up dust clouds that end up in my mouth and nose.
- tartoran 4y agoBack in Eastern europe, usually in the summer and by the seaside or in an usual sunbathing setting, older people with various ailments such as rheumatism cover themselves in black mud and keep it on for hours then wash it off. Some of them are also practicing nudism as well, this part is quite funny. I never knew if there was an actual benefit from it, and still am somewhat skeptical though I’d give it a try if I had the chance and need. Could as well be a bucket list item. At the same time I think we’ve lost some ancient treatments this way and when it comes to the immune system, seems to me it’s on the better side if it’s stimulated rather than overprotected by isolation from exposure sources. I have a kid in preK and they’re sick quite frequently and it’s quite a normal thing.
- voisin 4y agoDoes the length of time it covers you matter? It would seem to me that leaving it on for shorter periods but getting more diversity by having more applications of new mud would be more effective. Babies are born from a sterile environment and apparently passing through the birth canal and then immediately being placed on the mother for skin-to-skin contact, even if only for a few minutes, is sufficient to populate the microbiome. But perhaps that’s because it is a clean slate being populated.
- tartoran 4y agoI actually found its more widespread in use, here’s the wiki entry for mud bathing: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mud_bath https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mud_bath
- noduerme 4y agoI love to hear about dirt "teaming" with microorganisms. They make a great pair!