15 ms·
Did a little more reading on Wikipedia, and found this bit of "oof"[0]: > Cost overruns at Vogtle and the cancellation of Summer [Nuclear Generating Station in
by kelnos 4y ago
Did a little more reading on Wikipedia, and found this bit of "oof"[0]:
> Cost overruns at Vogtle and the cancellation of Summer [Nuclear Generating Station in South Carolina] led to Westinghouse's bankruptcy in 2017.
This raises a somewhat-scary question: in this case, Westinghouse's bankrupt remains were bought out by a private equity firm, and they presumably took on Westinghouse's obligations toward in-progress nuclear plant construction, but... what if that hadn't been the case? What if Westinghouse had just completely failed and ceased operations? Who would support the remainder of projects like Vogtle 3 & 4, and ongoing maintenance for the next however-many decades?
I guess a company in a heavily-regulated sector like this must have some sort of succession plan, but it's not clear to me how this would work, in the case of e.g. the company going bankrupt, and all the staff with institutional knowledge about a reactor design dispersing to various other companies. Hell, that could have even happened in Westinghouse's case.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AP1000 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AP1000
- bombcar 4y agoIf nobody wants take it over, the government steps in and tries to find a buyer (basically read: promises to subsidize someone who will take it on hand). If that fails, the government sometimes will setup its own company to take it in hand either at the state or federal level (this would almost certainly be federal). Failing that, the projects would cease.
- kelnos 4y agoAh, good to know there are a couple layers of fallbacks. I guess there's still one failure mode: project is completed and plant is running, and then the manufacturer goes out of business. I guess in that case the government would have to act as a backstop no matter what, and worst-case they would just operate until the plant could be decommissioned.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> What if Westinghouse had just completely failed and ceased operations? Who would support the remainder of projects like Vogtle 3 & 4, and ongoing maintenance for the next however-many decades? For maintaining and decommissioning built plants, there are reserve and bonding requirements [1]. For new developments, that's a risk inherent to every construction project. Some hold that risk on their books, others sell it to an insurer. (One of the many reasons fuel is loaded last.) [1] https://www.nrc.gov/reading-rm/doc-collections/cfr/part030/part030-0035.html https://www.nrc.gov/reading-rm/doc-collections/cfr/part030/p...
- TaylorAlexander 4y ago> For new developments, that's a risk inherent to every construction project. Yes but I would argue that the level of risk involved is different between different energy options. $20B worth of solar and wind plus energy storage (including subsidies for home solar/storage and EVs with V2G capability) would carry less risk for this scenario than a single nuclear power plant. I still think based on my back of the napkin calculations that solar + wind + storage (with the above mentioned subsidies) can be a compelling alternative to nuclear. It can be built faster, avoids the risk of a single large terrorist attack target, provides more energy independence for those who receive the subsidy for their own solar and storage, diversifies the grid, and avoids the need for a powerful government to control risky nuclear production facilities. You can do a quick calculation and see that $10B of solar and $10B of storage will produce similar continuous base load power as the $20B Vogtle system.
- kelnos 4y agoAnd in addition, there are tons of companies who could likely take over maintenance and repair for any particular solar grid if the original company went out of business. The tech is not particularly different when going from manufacturer to manufacturer for panels, inverters, etc., and many parts can be swapped out for new versions, made by a different manufacturer, if they break down and can't be repaired. In contrast, there is exactly one company that fully understands a particular nuclear reactor design. If that company disappears, it will take a lot of specialized knowledge transfer (likely requiring the continued employment of many of the original designers and builders) to allow another company or the government to take on that maintenance burden. Still, I'm not convinced solar + wind + storage will come along soon enough at scale to eliminate enough fossil-fuel burning in order to dig us out of our climate change hole without things getting so much worse first. Then again, if it takes 16 years from permit application time to get a nuclear plant project completed in the US, maybe we're screwed either way.
- TaylorAlexander 4y agoYeah it’s the long production time for nuclear that makes a big difference. Solar/wind/storage can roll out today and start producing energy tomorrow. We’d have 16 years to match the scale required which I think would only be a challenge for storage (wind and solar seem relatively simple to scale). In that time we can immediately begin producing clean power at least during the day, supplementing clean power for dirty at night for 5-10 years until more storage is available. This seems better than continuing with dirty power for 16 years until nuclear comes online. We are, generally, pretty screwed though yes.
- dirtsoc 4y agoI live in Georgia and this whole thing has been a cluster. All Georgia Power customers have a rate increase that goes into effect once the plants start producing power for the grid. Westinghouse went bankrupt due to incompetent contractors and under-the-table deals and Georgia Power customers are having to foot the bill. Not to mention that Georgia has a multi billion dollar government budget surplus. Personally they should use that to keep power rates low. With the additional rate increases being requested by Georgia Power the citizens of Georgia are looking at a 40% rate increase in the next couple of years.
- fshbbdssbbgdd 4y agoSubsidizing energy use during an energy shortage is good for winning elections, but counterproductive.
- trasz 4y ago>What if Westinghouse had just completely failed and ceased operations? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_Nuclear_Power_Technology_Corporation#CAP1400_(Guohe_One) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_Nuclear_Power_Technolo...