4 ms·

Would a toy manufacturer be sued in Brazil for selling toys without batteries? “Batteries not included” is such a common marketing phrase it was used as a major

Would a toy manufacturer be sued in Brazil for selling toys without batteries? “Batteries not included” is such a common marketing phrase it was used as a major movie title… in 1987. What if they required some “expensive” proprietary battery that was sold separately? (Power tools do this in the US) For me, I don’t know anything about Brazil, but this lawsuit only makes sense if they misled the public into believing there would be a cable included. Likely, it was very clear about was actually included and people just didn’t read it or care enough (already deciding they’d buy a knock-off). I remember this moment in time and it was pretty well known in the US from my recollection. Even my non-tech friends knew about it and were kind of upset that it would cost them more and all their existing cables and accessories would be obsolete.

felipelemos 4y ago
Let me fix that for you: > Would a toy manufacturer be sued in Brazil for selling toys without a charging cable? The answer is: Yes.
- conductr 4y ago
  Ok TIL. But still makes no sense to me if they informed you about what was in the box. I’m just stuck in that mental model I suppose. Also doesn’t quite make sense why charging cables is different than any other power source. Batteries for toys, fuel for cars, etc. Seems kind of arbitrary.
  - ncallaway 4y ago
    > Also doesn’t quite make sense why charging cables is different than any other power source. Batteries for toys, fuel for cars, etc. Seems kind of arbitrary. I mean, it seems pretty easy to distinguish between those two to me? One set are consumables ("batteries for toys", "fuel for cars"), while the other set are long-lived goods ("charging cables").
    - conductr 4y ago
      But why should one be included and the others can be excluded, the fact the cable was available for purchase should have been enough.
      - brahma-dev 4y ago
        The law has to draw a line somewhere. Cars have to come with wheels, even if wheels are available for purchase. Appliances have to come with power cable, even if wires are available for purchase.
- marcosdumay 4y ago
  To add it further. If it required some cable that could be considered standard enough so people can buy it anywhere from anyone, then the answer would be "no". AFAIK, technically nobody ever deemed any cable standard enough. I am confident (but IANAL) you would win the suit if you require a USB A to USB C cable, but you will probably get sued.
kodah 4y ago
I own a number of power tools, I've never seen one come without a necessary component for basic operation. Maybe you can link to some brands that bare costs similar to an iPhone that are sold without basic components. The problem is that you can't compare the US to other countries in this way. The salaries and what people take home are drastically different. Even inside the US, if anyone bothered to look, you'd probably find that most US citizens outside of wealthy areas give something up to get the next iPhone. Adding the charger on top of that likely has impact, just less so than a place like Brazil.
- datpiff 4y ago
  >I own a number of power tools, I've never seen one come without a necessary component for basic operation. it's very common for power tools to be sold "body only", i.e. without a battery or charger
  - _ktx2 4y ago
    I asked for links. I've never bought something like a drill or battery operated saw that didn't come with a battery. Did they come with drill bits or a blade? Not always, but I think a customer can expect a battery and a way to charge it.
    - conductr 4y ago
      You can usually buy it both ways, with or without the batteries.
  - shard 4y ago
    To add to this clarification, the reason is that the power tools from one company typically have interchangeable battery packs, therefore if you have purchased a few full sets with battery and charger, often you do not need more, therefore tools can be purchased "body only". Here is an example: https://www.homedepot.com/p/RYOBI-ONE-HP-18V-Brushless-Cordless-1-2-in-Drill-Driver-Tool-Only-PBLDD01B/314109432 https://www.homedepot.com/p/RYOBI-ONE-HP-18V-Brushless-Cordl... Edit: GP asked for link to tool that costs similar to an iPhone that is body only, here's one priced at $2500: https://www.homedepot.com/p/Makita-18V-LXT-Lithium-Ion-Cordless-5-16-in-Hole-Puncher-Tool-Only-XPP01ZK/312370609 https://www.homedepot.com/p/Makita-18V-LXT-Lithium-Ion-Cordl...
zekrioca 4y ago
Exactly because you do not know anything that you should refrain from basing your opinions by using only your own context of living.
- conductr 4y ago
  Except this whole thread is about trying to understand this lawsuit, which requires comparing the different contexts (Brazilian and not)
marcosdumay 4y ago
> What if they required some “expensive” proprietary battery that was sold separately? Yes, in that case they would be sued.

felipelemos 4y ago

Let me fix that for you: > Would a toy manufacturer be sued in Brazil for selling toys without a charging cable? The answer is: Yes.

conductr 4y ago
Ok TIL. But still makes no sense to me if they informed you about what was in the box. I’m just stuck in that mental model I suppose. Also doesn’t quite make sense why charging cables is different than any other power source. Batteries for toys, fuel for cars, etc. Seems kind of arbitrary.
- ncallaway 4y ago
  > Also doesn’t quite make sense why charging cables is different than any other power source. Batteries for toys, fuel for cars, etc. Seems kind of arbitrary. I mean, it seems pretty easy to distinguish between those two to me? One set are consumables ("batteries for toys", "fuel for cars"), while the other set are long-lived goods ("charging cables").
  - conductr 4y ago
    But why should one be included and the others can be excluded, the fact the cable was available for purchase should have been enough.
    - brahma-dev 4y ago
      The law has to draw a line somewhere. Cars have to come with wheels, even if wheels are available for purchase. Appliances have to come with power cable, even if wires are available for purchase.
marcosdumay 4y ago
To add it further. If it required some cable that could be considered standard enough so people can buy it anywhere from anyone, then the answer would be "no". AFAIK, technically nobody ever deemed any cable standard enough. I am confident (but IANAL) you would win the suit if you require a USB A to USB C cable, but you will probably get sued.

kodah 4y ago

I own a number of power tools, I've never seen one come without a necessary component for basic operation. Maybe you can link to some brands that bare costs similar to an iPhone that are sold without basic components. The problem is that you can't compare the US to other countries in this way. The salaries and what people take home are drastically different. Even inside the US, if anyone bothered to look, you'd probably find that most US citizens outside of wealthy areas give something up to get the next iPhone. Adding the charger on top of that likely has impact, just less so than a place like Brazil.

datpiff 4y ago
>I own a number of power tools, I've never seen one come without a necessary component for basic operation. it's very common for power tools to be sold "body only", i.e. without a battery or charger
- _ktx2 4y ago
  I asked for links. I've never bought something like a drill or battery operated saw that didn't come with a battery. Did they come with drill bits or a blade? Not always, but I think a customer can expect a battery and a way to charge it.
  - conductr 4y ago
    You can usually buy it both ways, with or without the batteries.
- shard 4y ago
  To add to this clarification, the reason is that the power tools from one company typically have interchangeable battery packs, therefore if you have purchased a few full sets with battery and charger, often you do not need more, therefore tools can be purchased "body only". Here is an example: https://www.homedepot.com/p/RYOBI-ONE-HP-18V-Brushless-Cordless-1-2-in-Drill-Driver-Tool-Only-PBLDD01B/314109432 https://www.homedepot.com/p/RYOBI-ONE-HP-18V-Brushless-Cordl... Edit: GP asked for link to tool that costs similar to an iPhone that is body only, here's one priced at $2500: https://www.homedepot.com/p/Makita-18V-LXT-Lithium-Ion-Cordless-5-16-in-Hole-Puncher-Tool-Only-XPP01ZK/312370609 https://www.homedepot.com/p/Makita-18V-LXT-Lithium-Ion-Cordl...

zekrioca 4y ago

Exactly because you do not know anything that you should refrain from basing your opinions by using only your own context of living.

conductr 4y ago
Except this whole thread is about trying to understand this lawsuit, which requires comparing the different contexts (Brazilian and not)

marcosdumay 4y ago

> What if they required some “expensive” proprietary battery that was sold separately? Yes, in that case they would be sued.