2 ms·
This isn't eugenics. People are allowed to choose their mates for their phenotypes, and we don't sterilize (except in very rare, extreme circumstances, with le
by dekhn 4y ago
This isn't eugenics. People are allowed to choose their mates for their phenotypes, and we don't sterilize (except in very rare, extreme circumstances, with legal approvals) people who don't have specific phenotypes.
It's a gedanken experiment, but I would expect that people who measure low on IQ tests but are raised immersed in an technical or artistic environment have as much potential to become masters as people with higher IQ, or very nearly so. Further, I think that by increasing the quality of the education system in a country, you can massively increase the intellectual output. There are probably enormous amounts of untapped potential never matched to an equivalent supply of knowledge and skill.
- orangecat 4y agobut I would expect that people who measure low on IQ tests but are raised immersed in an technical or artistic environment have as much potential to become masters as people with higher IQ, or very nearly so. I would strongly expect the opposite. But I agree it would be beneficial to figure out which of us is right.
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 4y agoAccording to the latest studies, IQ is largely determined by early exposure to abstract thought. This is the main reason IQ is still rising in first-world nations where malnutrition hasn't been an issue for generations. If you rob a grade school kid of playground time and learning to share toys, and instead force them to grind out math lessons and computer science problems, their adult IQ will be significantly higher. They might end up tremendously unhappy, of course. It just goes to show how raw IQ is a silly measure to value, let alone optimize for.
- desmosxxx 4y agoDo you have any links to these latest studies that I can take a look at? If you're just talking about the Flynn effect, then your conclusion is overreaching. IQ is still very highly heritable and adjusted for the Flynn effect has very little to do with early exposure to abstract reasoning AFAIK (but would love to see those studies).
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> This isn't eugenics. People are allowed to choose their mates for their phenotypes The fact that something is allowed doesn't make it not eugenics. Choosing your mate for their phenotype is eugenics.
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 4y agoNo - eugenics is by definition arranged. If a government nudged you to pair up with someone, that would be eugenics, but if you choose a mate of your own free will, it's not.
- dmurray 4y agoHow much nudging do you need before it's eugenics? Would it be eugenics if you were to take young men and women, separate them roughly by area of interest and level of intellectual achievement, remove them from the chaperoning influence of their families, and put them in an institution for four years at the perfect time of their life to form pair bonds? What if you additionally supplied them with easy access to alcohol?
- misterprime 4y agoInteresting new take: "College: the hidden eugenics program." This sort of makes sense to me.
- matheusmoreira 4y ago> if you choose a mate of your own free will, it's not If you're choosing mates at all, it means you're judging the value of other human beings. You're accepting some and rejecting others based on what you think or feel is best. It's just eugenics practiced by the general population according to highly variable personal criteria. This is not inherently superior to some explicit eugenics program. It's about the principle of individual autonomy.
- dekhn 4y agoits not eugenics because it's not population scale, it's individual. Your interpretation does not correspond to any mainstream understanding.