8 ms·
Two recent books by historians explore the crisis in biological psychiatry
- nyc111 4y agoMental ilness is in your gut. That's where we should be looking at.
- BurningPenguin 4y agoHow about: Mental illness is a complex thing, that involves multiple parts of the body, and probably also the environment.
- marginalia_nu 4y agoAlmost as though the human body is one integrated system, rather than a set of individual components connected through well defined interfaces.
- serpix 4y agoI detect the sarcasm but others may not. As a thought experiment I present that any emotion can always be felt in the body. If you feel nothing, no emotion or no sensation in the body then that is also a felt emotion in the body as a lack of feeling.
- marginalia_nu 4y agoNo sarcasm intended. I genuinely don't think you can reduce the human body into parts without simplifying how it works. Humans design machines component-wise that way, but that is a methodology unknown to evolution.
- imoverclocked 4y agoThis. I think that people too often overemphasize one factor when it is many that can contribute to mental illness. The gut is definitely an integral part of mental health as has recently been popularized. Being in long-term social isolation or damaging relationships can also lead to mental illness. Having chronic stress (noise/chemical pollution/lack of good sleep/etc) can also lead to mental illness. All of these factors can be combined or work completely on their own.
- jvm___ 4y agoThe human system really has only three inputs your conscious brain has control over (and they're almost all 'loose' controls). Loose controls meaning imagine feeding birds, you don't feed the individual birds you just provide seeds and let them figure it out. Your inputs to your body are rarely localized, you just provide signals and your body figures it out. So, three inputs. Energy input as food/drink, how fast you breathe in. Energy output as what you do in the world and how much your muscles exert themselves. The third input to your body is your stress response as interrupted by your brain. Stress in this case can be pain and discomfort, but also any other input or thought from your senses. Your body doesn't know that a lion jumping out of the grass is terrifying, it just responds to your brain throwing terror seeds at it. Your body doesn't know that seeing "23 53 34 78 and bonus number 5" means you just won the Powerball lottery, it's just responds to the your brain throwing happiness seeds at it. Like you said, mental health can be systemic, but having bad inputs can stress you out as well. If your problem is mainly bad inputs, then you can control your response, just in a loose way rather than a tight way that we humans seem to prefer.
- nyc111 4y agoI don't agree. Our perception of the world is colored in the gut and served to the conscious mind. When I was living in New York, the jingle of the ice cream truck draw me crazy, it was torture. But for kids, it was happiness because the gut microbes feeding on sugar send a message to the conscsious mind to buy the sugary stuff and they created an irresistible desire for it. This is all done in the guts. Some people can remain cool under any adverse situation because they have a healthy gut.
- 50 4y agoNot "probably" but certainly. Mental illness not just as a psychological or even chemical problem but also as an ontologically-inflected political one.
- yibberish 4y agomy own mental illness exists in relation to the society I have grown up into. but you're still right, our own guts are what I had to look at in order to deal with this illness.
- zniturah 4y agoMaybe we rely on science here : it is genes + environment + head
- marginalia_nu 4y agoHow would you construct an experiment to verify that hypothesis?
- sinenomine 4y agoA twin study? https://www.nature.com/articles/ng.3285 https://www.nature.com/articles/ng.3285 The result TLDR: everything we measured about individuals is heritable.
- marginalia_nu 4y agoRight, but that contradicts the previous statement.
- WastingMyTime89 4y agoI don’t know if it’s relying on science. It’s a somewhat tautological statement. We are physical beings. All the processes happening inside us are mediated through chemicals. Most are assembled according to a building plans encoded in your genes and the building blocks come from your environment. Then obviously as the brain is the command centre of the body, it does involve the head. Still, it doesn’t tell us much. For all intents and purposes, we have shockingly little understanding of how the brain actually works. We know some chemicals have unexpected effects but we don’t always understand exactly how that happens. We don’t understand how memories are stored or recalled. We have some understanding of the feedback loops involved in emotion processing but that’s far from perfect. We are starting to realise that the processing happening in other organs like the digestive system have an effect on the brain but it’s not entirely clear which. I think people generally are not humble enough regarding the level of actual knowledge we have reached in psychology and medicine. I wouldn’t be surprised if we came to discover we had actually been missing something foundational at some point.
- 4y ago
- yibberish 4y agothis article reframes the recent trend in psychiatric into psychedelics in a bad light: > Understanding the undulating history of psychiatric hype and crisis is crucial today as the profession builds toward its next trend: psychedelics, already heralded as a “renaissance” and psychiatry’s “next frontier.” These two histories demonstrate that the academic and corporate pursuit of such hype [...] resulting in significant psychological and bodily harm. this articles ignores the unfounded claim: that the real purpose of the APA was not quite to heal, not after ww2. > We also have not had any significant breakthroughs in treatment. They even say this, which is as nazi social control as it gets. > psychiatrists in the 1970s who pathologized Black activism as “psychosis.” oh, and what Bush said in the 90s? I suppose all that went into marketing, and later on (i.e. nowadays) into 'engagement' metrics for online content and so on. so, as I said, they're not trying to heal you, they're trying to make a buck same as everybody else in a capitalist society/marketplace. now all that scientific progress is being used in an information war. as war crazy as it gets.
- mrxd 4y agoI wondered what is this “community-based” mental health care that the author advocates for, and how is it different from psychiatry. Are psychiatrists not part of the community? It turns out it refers to “dream-work, breathwork, herbalism, and meditation.”
- rustmachine 4y agoin what way did it turn out to refer to those things? Community-based health care seems to me like a way of saying that mental health is connected closely to the community you are a part of, and that this community therefore can play a big part of keeping your mind healthy. Which, I think, sounds very reasonable. If your work environment is toxic, the way to get better is to improve the work community, or find another community to be part of.
- newsmonkey5 4y agoCompare to community policing, in which crimes are created and solved by modifying the environment. It is a very good thing.
- mrxd 4y agoI clicked on the “soteria houses” link in the article
- jossclimb 4y agoIt is no measure of health to be well adjusted to a profoundly sick society. Jiddu Krishnamurti
- serpix 4y agoAnd the way to feel healthy, truly healthy, is to be connected to networks of society or communities that are safe, supportive and which have your back.
- Penyngton 4y agoSadly, that's not something easy to find if you're not born into one...
- tsol 4y agoWhich society in human history was not sick? Truth is that's the norm, not the exception
- jerojero 4y agoBut how many of the earlier societies had thousands of years of experience to look back to? Wouldn't you say in a society where we're capable of talking to anyone anywhere in the world at any moment we'd be able to at least try and solve these problems? We've solved so many problems that afflicted humanity for thousands of years in the past 200 years. So why not this one? I guess because, as the article says, to solve this problem we actually need to change society as a whole.
- Der_Einzige 4y agoNorthern Europe, right now.
- Bakary 4y agoTheir livelihoods are predicated as being part of a complex economic web and having good geopolitical conditions. Norway used to be one of the poorest European countries, now it is one of the wealthiest thanks to large oil reserves.
- carabiner 4y agoThe whole article is worth reading. It's a tortured history of the failures of psychiatry, least of which is the DSM and worst of which is mass incarceration of blacks engaged in activism due to "schizophrenia," similar to how homosexuality was once considered mental illness. It ends too early with: > "The fact is, if we didn’t have such a fucked-up society, I’d be out of a job." ... As historian Joanna Radin encouraged me to discuss in my undergraduate course on the History of Drugs, the question is not only, What is the right drug for me?, but also: What would the world have to look like for me not to need drugs at all? He stops short of really exploring this concept. I'll paraphrase an old comment of mine: Are you ready for me to diagnose your totally normal reaction to our shitty society as mental illness so I can get you addicted to mind altering drugs for the rest of your life? https://imgur.com/Jb1mJyx https://imgur.com/Jb1mJyx Or as the social critic Dr. Ted Kaczynski said, "Imagine a society that subjects people to conditions that make them terribly unhappy then gives them the drugs to take away their unhappiness. Science fiction? It is already happening to some extent in our own society. Instead of removing the conditions that make people depressed modern society gives them antidepressant drugs. In effect antidepressants are a means of modifying an individual's internal state in such a way as to enable him to tolerate social conditions that he would otherwise find intolerable." The problem is, this is the only life most of us have lived, and so we cannot imagine it otherwise, like a fish who cannot conceive of a world without water, or even that water is the medium surrounding it. If our entire society is causing this, then what can we do? Wage slavery, oligarchy, attention theft by tech companies, disintegration of community from various causes. Life for so many people is crawling through glass Monday through Friday, then getting shitfaced on the weekend. Is that happiness?
- automatic6131 4y agoIt's so easy to call this society "shitty" and "sick". It's much harder to articulate what it should be - and how it should be. Oh I know you can give a wishlist of things you want society to be; I bet you can't even begin to describe how you achieve it. No one ever does. The only method ever given is "revolution and then New Soviet Man". Every method is a restatement of those six words in longer format.
- 4y ago
- jokoon 4y agoEven a diagnosed bipolar woman started telling me my depression should not really affect my work. I'm tired of people. I feel the antiwork movement is starting to become the shelter of people with depression who are not being treated like they have a handicap. I'm glad I don't have a career, because my health would have crashed of I had one.
- tovej 4y agoI don't think it helps that working a lot of jobs it feels like I've had a negative contribution to human well-being and ecology. I cannot think of a large successful private company that is a net positive to society.
- feet 4y agoThis is one of the primary reasons I'm disgusted with private industry. It's BS, pointless at best and harmful at worst purely to make a couple people rich on the backs of others
- PicassoCTs 4y agoHonestly, if you travel around a bit as consultant, you don't even need to dig to know a "companys crimes". Just sit in the canteen and talk with some. The employee neurosis tells you all about it. Lots of vegan activism - grows animals on farms or trades in that sector. Pro-Peace and cultural sector activism. Produces weapons. Greenpeace? Usually chemical dumps or other environment damage. Virulent Patriotism? Usually exploits cheap labor & conditions abroad. List goes on. The more desperate the cooperate souls peddling their convictions to "outside strangers", the more morally rotten the business usually is. Just a observation.
- narrator 4y agoSuicides have been rising since 2000. I think we should go back to tricyclics antidepressants. They worked better than SSRIs.
- throwaway743 4y agoYears ago my doctor switched me to an SSRI as a one time trial to see if it would better help/could be tolerated... yeah never again. That shit straight up induced mania and suicidal thoughts. I cut that trial off real quick right after noticing. Everyone's different, but SSRIs are a hard no for me.
- jerojero 4y ago[flagged]
- fatneckbeardz 4y agoyeah that or 30 hour work week, walkable cities, free healthcare.
- rthomas6 4y agoThat's testable. That's already the case in some places, or close to it. Do those places also have rising suicide rates?
- eimrine 4y ago> The real crisis in academic psychiatry is that there is no crisis. I so love this words, especially I love to read that in the middle of my reading of Kuhn's "Structure of scientific revolutions" book because that book lets me clearly visualize of what crisis in psychiatry is being waited for.
- FailMore 4y agoI started writing a long comment in response to this article (more to respond to the original catchy headline this topic first went live with "Mental Illness Is Not in Your Head"). I decided I'd turn it into a blog post and have posted it for discussion here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33201781 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33201781 Here's it is as a comment: This is a response to an article currently being discussed on Hacker News [Two recent books by historians explore the crisis in biological psychiatry, originally titled Mental Illness Is Not in Your Head]. I believe that the, now replaced, catchy headline of the article is not correct. I believe mental health is in your head, but this does not mean that mental health is controllable through altering neurotransmitters (or in fact altering any specific biological process). ~All mental health issues use the same biological structures[1]. A structure which interprets the emotional dynamic of the situation you are currently in. Another structure which reactivates the emotional memory you have associated with that dynamic. Most likely the same mechanism is used for both happy and unhappy paths: # Happy paths: If you grew up with a loving (but not overwhelmingly loving) and calm family, your unconscious association between the emotional dynamic of a situation you are in, and the emotional memory associated with it are positive. These could range from: "Everyone is having fun right now, I can relax and have fun too!", to "That person did something that made me uncomfortable, I know it's safe to express my needs and feelings, so I can communicate calmly to the person who upset me how I their behaviour made me feel". # Unhappy paths: If you grew up with caregivers who were stressed by certain situations, your unconscious association between the emotional dynamic of a situation you are in, and the emotional memory/requirements associated with it will contain protective responses. These could range from: "Everyone seems to having fun right now... but everyone got so stressed out when I was anything other than calm and happy when I was young, I better keep all my stressed feelings hidden inside, and be act like I'm happy and having fun too - even if something is going on for me which means deep down I'm not feeling good", to "That person did something that made me uncomfortable. Everyone go angry so quickly when I was little, that I’m sure this person will get really angry too if I say anything to them. I will just pretend that I’m ok with what they did.” This list goes on and on, and will depend on the subtle dynamics of the relationships you were raised in. You will notice that in the happy paths there is not a separation between your external world and your internal worlds, whereas in the unhappy paths there is this split. This split is uncomfortable and it is lonely. It requires a tense form of control that the person on the happy path doesn’t need to apply to themselves. # Things get worse […before they get better?] I’m sure a bit of you related to the unhappy paths that I described. That is because we all have them. One of the biological survival mechanisms we have as highly dependent infants is to bend our emotional responses into ones which mean we get what we need from our caregivers. This is such a common requirement for making it through infancy that the human is built to shed these leant emotional shackles. I am in a controversial minority within psychotherapy that believes that the precise diagnosis of these emotional shackles is the function of dreaming (https://psyarxiv.com/k6trz https://psyarxiv.com/k6trz). Getting rid of an emotional shackle is not complicated when it is clearly visible. It is not particularly pleasant, but you simply have to unlearn the fear by facing up to it. If you notice you keep your stressed feelings inside, you’ll need to find the courage to start opening up. If you are not setting boundaries when you feel yours are getting trodden on, you need to find the courage to start having those (initially) awkward conversations. The same is true for whatever unuseful emotional conditioning you are trying to get free from. The mechanism behind this approach is very simple. We are extremely scared of facing these learnt fears (the type and level of fear we typically[2] only know in infancy). When we repeatedly face these fears and survive they are very quickly unlearned from the brain. It is highly inefficient for the brain to keep a fear in place that we now know (at an experiential, not only cognitive, level) to be superfluous, and the brain does not seem to want to do this. But what happens if no one is there to help you work our your emotional shackles and you are left to suffer their isolating consequences on your own? Again, I am in a bit of a controversial minority of the mental health community, but I believe it is the useful response that mental health symptoms should worsen. If things worsen both you and others begin to notice that something is wrong. If they notice something is wrong, there is an increased likelihood that you will get the emotional care that might lead you to successfully removing your emotional shackles; reducing your stress and isolation. Many people start treating their mental health because things have gotten bad, but the treatment (the process of discovering and facing up to unconscious fears) doesn’t need to stop when you return to your base level. In summary, I think there is a strong component of mental illness that is very much within our own heads. Because the happy and unhappy paths of mental illness use the same structural processes we cannot force a change at the biological level. Instead we have to explore, challenge and ultimately change the underlying emotional memories that are elicited in the structural processes. From my personal experience, this causes the greatest improvement to our mental health/reduces our “mental illness”. [1] I'm aware that I am talking with one of two layers of abstraction. I'm not talking about the specific parts of the brain, but these processes are consistent in all of us. [2] Stressful situations we experience as adults that cause PTSD are ones where our emotional processing of the situation we are going through mimics our childlike experience. The experience is overwhelming.
- tkk23 4y ago>Others engage in therapy with an artificially intelligent (and usually feminized) chatbot. Disturbingly, these digital apps are largely unregulated and have questionable standards of care. What alternatives are there? Therapists don't scale. If half of society could improve their life with therapy, and a therapist can treat 30 people per month over 10 years, then 1% of society have to become therapists. More therapists than teachers would be needed. I believe that this is a huge opportunity. Like medicine, people will be willing to pay anything to be happy. The biggest problem apart from developing a cure will be getting heard. The market will be flooded with enticing apps and a most likely bitter medicine will be a tough sell.
- slfnflctd 4y agoThis has become much more clear in the last couple years. Demand shot way up and is far outstripping supply. Then you get into the issue of how so many patients aren't a good match for the first therapist they try, so they have to jump through all the hoops and fill out all the forms to try another one, which also may not be a good match (all while potentially on the edge of some kind of breakdown)... I went through at least five before I found one I felt was effective for me, and my experience is not uncommon. Personally, I think we need to lower the barrier of entry for people to become therapists, and streamline the whole patient intake process. It's not like the quality is all that great with existing barriers, there are PhDs out there actively harming patients-- one kept trying to push Jesus on me when part of what I was dealing with was childhood religious trauma and the difficulties of restructuring my world view as a nonbeliever, an absolute breach of ethics. We need to make it easier for people to try out multiple therapists until they find one that's a good match for them, and part of that is increasing the supply of therapists. Unfortunately I'm not sure a chatbot is ever going to quite do it except for in the simplest & most clear cut cases, the mental tangles we can get into really require general intelligence to grapple with.
- BeFlatXIII 4y agoNot to mention that the dating game of filling out all the paperwork for the third time may be what pushes someone from on-edge but stable for the day into a breakdown.
- lebuffon 4y agoMy thought experiment question around Psychiatry is: How would pre-electricity age people explain the operations of a digital computer? They would probably invent some theories that bore no resemblance to the actual underlying technology. They might be close and even create some relevant metaphors but the theory would never be "correct", I suspect. Is this analogous to Psychiatry? An old engineering axiom is: "If you can't build it, you don't really understand it" This leads me to ask, will we only understand the human mind after we learn how to build one or two? Notwithstanding the question, can a network with X neurons fully comprehend a network with X neurons?
- dmarchand90 4y agoThe mechanistic view of the universe is ancient and thinking of things as a set of motion induced cause/ effect dates back at least to Democritus. The ancient Greeks had mechanical computers for astronomy. And mechanical automata have been around for a long time. Depends on the definition of understand. If you mean complete and faithful reproduction then maybe not. At least in one mind. Definitely a set of N minds with X-1 neurons can together understand the whole of X neurons if each simulates under given conditions or subsets of the whole. The mind also probably has a degree of fractal self similarity in its structure and understanding a part gives a representation of the whole.
- IIAOPSW 4y agoA Turing machine can simulate the operation of any other Turing machine, so maybe there's hope for a ball of X neurons.
- Bakary 4y agoWe don't need to understand all of the workings of the human brain. We need to provide a way for patients to be able to deal with their psychological burdens and establish mental self-sufficience.
- photochemsyn 4y agoI think this section is worth emphasizing - mental disorders are as unlikely to be due primarily to underlying genetic issues as getting an infectious disease is: > "The oft-cited claim, for example, that schizophrenia has a genetic basis has failed to pass scientific muster. As Scull discusses, after failing to find a Mendelian set of genes that could explain schizophrenia, researchers in the 2000s pinned their hopes on new genome-wide association studies (GWAS) that could investigate hundreds of thousands of base pairs in the search for genetic linkages to psychiatric disorders. But GWAS studies have not revealed a clear genetic basis for schizophrenia (or bipolar disorder, for that matter). While combining hundreds of genetic sites can help explain, at best, 8 percent of the observed variance of schizophrenia, it is still possible for an individual to have many of these genetic variations without developing the disease." There might be some influence - for example, someone born with genetic immunological defects is likely to be more susceptible to various infectious diseases, and there might be some kind of brain development issue that means that some people are less able to cope with high levels of stress, disappointment, trauma and so on - but the claim that this outcome is somehow ordained at birth is nonsensical. All in all, the science of mental disorders today could be compared to the science of infectious disease in say, 1890 - they didn't have much in the way of understanding of core mechanisms, even if some approaches (surgical sterilization, rigorous post-operative hygiene, etc.) were being shown to reduce mortality. Probably the most promising tools in this regard are the use of psychedelics under controlled settings to improve outcomes, but even here, the research is basically in its infancy due to the socio-governmental paranoia over these substances.
- derbOac 4y agoI do research in this area, and that paragraph is misleading. GWAS was a mistake from the beginning -- it was overhyped and ridiculously oversimplified from an analytic-design perspective. No one should have expected genes of major effect to emerge, and everyone generally agrees with this now. To me it's fine to point to GWAS as a major failure, but it's a major failure with academic systems and how research foci and funding occur, not with the idea of genetics in psychiatric phenomena in general. What's more realistic to me -- and what I tried to get colleagues to do for years -- is a focus on polygenic risk, where numerous genes have small effect. This research has been more fruitful, but again, it's overhyped and oversimplified (the article mentions this too, briefly). The problem isn't with the idea of genetic influences on mental illness, especially severe mental illness, it's the way that academic research occurs in general. The truth is, the most likely genetic explanation (which will only be a small part of the pie) -- the one that's been the case all along -- is some combination of polygenic influence, involving some complex cascade of genetic effects, along with very rare mutations occurring within single individuals or families. There's also probably lots about genetics and genetic expression we are totally wrong about in general. I'm deeply sympathetic with the articles' arguments. Modern psychiatry has really lost its way and has neglected more psychosocial, systems-level explanations, along with things like chemical and microbiological exposures. I myself have written critiques of popular psychiatric genetic positions. However, I think the underlying problems stem from wanting to shoehorn behavioral science into to some model where it doesn't fit. Typically this is physics or chemistry, or molecular biology. It's not that. It's kind of like that, but not the same. It's also kinda like economics, and kind of like infectious disease science, and kinda like computer science, but not quite like any of those things. But people want to oversimplify it nonetheless, and it becomes this all-or-nothing argument, between the "brainless" and "mindless", and you're not allowed to take some integrative position. Then you get into people in say, physics, complaining that because it's not that it's not scientific, which is also not true. There's just a lot of politics and pendulums swinging back and forth. Combine this with academic fad-chasing and the funding nonsense that fuels that fire, and you have a recipe for disaster. It's like layers of people wanting to oversimplify things for attention, combined with some kind of narcissistic vulnerability with people wanting to prove they're "real scientists" or "real physicians" and in the end people with problems just end up becoming pawns in this political back-and-forth. I'm happy to see these articles, but also a little frustrated because although their underlying arguments are on-point, they kind of end up perpetuating the same problems. Yes, part of the problem is that genes just aren't the end-all-be-all explanation for behavior. But part of the problem is we just don't know very much right now. So what will happen is the biopsychiatrists will retort with some new method or R-squared that refutes the specific points, but not the underlying message. And the process will just go round and round. Some of this is maybe true of academics in general -- oversimplfying things to get attention -- but some of it is made worse by the field not having some consensual agreement that behavior is really complex and not likely to be reducible to anything simple.
- slfnflctd 4y agoYes, it's kind of a long article. It's also one of the best analyses I've ever read of our current mental health treatment situation, whether you agree with the final paragraph or not. Save it for later if you don't have time now. I was particularly drawn in by the idea of the Soteria approach [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soteria_(psychiatric_treatment) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soteria_(psychiatric_treatment...].
- boxmonster 4y ago"Before you diagnose yourself with depression or low self esteem, first make sure you are not, in fact, just surrounded by assholes." @debihope (Boosted by William Gibson)
- Mappotofu 4y ago
- brutusborn 4y agoIf that's the case, could we develop methods to ensure that communities we build have inclusion mechanisms to ensure all people (including mentally ill) participate and are valued? Sometimes I wonder if hyper-individualism in western society plays a big part in mental issues, since it is so easy to isolate oneself from any community. It is left up to the individual to find communities, there is no mechanism to stop people 'falling through the cracks' like there would be in a tribal community or even modern close-knit villages / country towns. I don't see how social life is a zero-sum game. Sure, some people gain status and popularity above others, but that does not preclude inclusion of all people. I.e just because Bob has 10 friends and Alice only has 2, doesn't mean that Alice can't be part of Bob's community.
- zdragnar 4y agoThis couldn't be more wrong for me, personally. I first started getting depression when I was, so to speak, at the top of my social game in high school. Now, it is more or less well managed, and doesn't really manifest except for periods of time when I'm under significant stress. Depression isn't a defense mechanism at all- it is purely destructive and aimed internally. Projection is a much better example of an unhealthy defense mechanism to social failure. How can you help? Depression and anxiety are both examples of self-reinforcing pathologies; the manifestation encourages the continued behavior in a repetitive cycle. Treatment focuses on breaking that cycle- medication for what we guess might be the underlying biological cause on the one hand, and therapy to build up more resilient behaviors that don't lead to spiraling on the other (i.e. if you get too anxious at work, methods to handle the anxiety that don't put your job in jeopardy by feeding the flight response and causing more anxiety). Social life being zero sum is also, I think, a fundamentally wrong statement, but I'd rather keep the discussion focused on the medical side as it is more relevant to the rest of the thread.
- theGnuMe 4y agoIn what way is social life zero sum?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- chatterhead 4y agoHumpty Dumpty sat on a wall, Humpty Dumpty had a great fall. All the king’s horses and all the king’s men Couldn’t put Humpty together again. Not even with drugs. That's how the mind works. Build something new in your head; don't try to reclaim what's lost with chemical glue.
- _yb2s 4y agoInteresting how the two most promising "new" therapies are CBT (basically ancient Greek Stoicism) and psychedelics (which predates our species most likely)
- rapjr9 4y agoThe article linked here seems like a big clue that at least some psychological disorders have a biological basis: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33186046 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33186046 as does the fact that some drugs show benefit. That Big Pharma perverted the research goals does not mean this is no longer a good avenue to explore.