4 ms·
> I do worry that my kids won’t be diverse enough to be able to get into a decent school or get a good job like I was able to when they’re older. 1. A single p
by nonethewiser 4y ago
> I do worry that my kids won’t be diverse enough to be able to get into a decent school or get a good job like I was able to when they’re older.
1. A single person cannot be diverse or not diverse.
2. There is nothing wrong with your kids being in a majority demographic. It sounds like you're more worried about the world discriminating based off race and other traits.
I suspect you agree with all of this but it's a little scary how insidious these policies are. Even in your dissent you're seeing things from their perspective.
- PKop 4y agoIt is always useful and prudent to see things from the perspective of those attacking you. "Know your enemy.." You can argue over definitions and terms as much as you want, but the uniform you wear is often defined by your opposition. In other words, it may not be completely relevant what you or OP think diverse is or isn't. It is very relevant what the power structures and people implementing these policies think it means, no? If someone has a kid that potentially is going to be quota'ed out of jobs or education, why wouldn't they worry about it?
- nonethewiser 4y agoI don't mean they shouldn't worry. I mean they shouldn't use language that puts blame on their kid for not being "diverse" (which is also a non-sensical description of 1 person).
- PKop 4y agoI'm sorry but you're just missing the point. You're taking the term literally, but it is very simple in practical terms how this actually plays out: diverse is code word for non straight White male. Slightly more diverse would be straight White female. Obviously OP is simply saying, as a White man, he worries his children through no fault of their own by virtue of birth would be excluded or limited by these cultural trends. Blame on their kid? What sense does this make? He's blaming the system.
- giantg2 4y ago"A single person cannot be diverse or not diverse." There's a manager/HR somewhere saying "hold my beer"...
- uup 4y agoA single person can be diverse relative to a group, though. Like a black woman would add diversity to a group of white men, for instance. When we talk about diversity in recruiting, usually we mean diversity of the candidate relative to the makeup of the company.
- massinstall 4y agoOptically maybe, if that’s what you’re aiming for. Just assuming that the “group of white men” are “all the same” is not very deep. The truth is that they’re all individuals with individual stories strangers who judge them by their looks know nothing about. It used to be understood as a good thing to not judge people based on their gender or skin color, including the nowadays declared “evil” white men.
- slt2021 4y agoright words, but it is not what's happening in real world in hiring
- nonethewiser 4y agoDIE initiatives achieve extremely poor diversity of beliefs. The type of diversity that matters. It is outright hostile to it.
- ParetoOptimal 4y ago> Optically maybe, if that’s what you’re aiming for. Just assuming that the “group of white men” are “all the same” is not very deep. Not just optically. Even slightly different cultures can result in novel ways of thinking or world views that bring something new.
- randomdata 4y agoThat's what the parent is saying. The aforementioned black woman may have more in common with the white men on the team than other white men. If you were striving for true diversity, it is quite possible that yet another white man with a different background would provide the greatest diversity, but if you are only optimizing for optical diversity then those considerations go out the window.
- bloak 4y ago> 1. A single person cannot be diverse or not diverse. Compare and contrast with people saying "neurodiverse" when they mean "neurodivergent". I think there is general agreement that a single person should be described as "neurodivergent" rather than "neurodiverse". Some people say the wrong word just because the two words are so similar and are happy to be corrected. On the other hand, if we're talking about other kinds of diversity then I don't think there's a similar pair of terms. "The addition of this gender-divergent person increases the gender-diversity of the team"? I don't think so!
- lupire 4y ago"underrepresented" is pretty close to the word you need, but is a slightly miscast type.
- account42 4y agoWell yeah, calling something divergent implies that there is a "normal". For ways of thinking and personalities people are fine with calling others not normal. For races and genders that is currently very not politically correct.
- philwelch 4y ago> A single person cannot be diverse or not diverse. According to the plain old-fashioned definition, this is true. According to the modern political definition, “diverse” is approximately a synonym for “non-white”.