4 ms·
This is why I favor a libertarian Marxist analysis of economic change over UBI strategies. What I mean by libertarian Marxism is essentially what Richard Wolff
by SequoiaHope 4y ago
This is why I favor a libertarian Marxist analysis of economic change over UBI strategies. What I mean by libertarian Marxism is essentially what Richard Wolff advocates - that instead of an economy comprised primarily of top-down managed firms, we transition to an economy of worker owned cooperatives (still within a free market). This moves real economic decision making power to a broad base of the population rather than in minority hands. This fulfills the goal of worker ownership of the means of production in a fully voluntary system.
The problem with UBI is that economic decision making stays within the hands of a small minority, who then tilt the whole economy in their favor. This is why worker ownership of the means of production (or as I like to say, community ownership of the means of production) is so important. What’s important to understand is that this is a mechanistic choice for how to run an economy. We can choose to do this voluntary because we recognize the value this arrangement offers to most people. It does not need to be done by force as attempted by autocrats in the 20th century. In any case, it requires less force than UBI!
- harlequinn77 4y ago
- fghfhgfhmmem 4y agoHas any country done this successfully? Marxism has led to mass famine and death
- stjohnswarts 4y agoYou're getting downvoted, but look at what happened over and over all over central and South America. I'm not saying that you have to be capitalistic as the USA, but social democracy seems like a reasonable solution in the middle.
- SequoiaHope 4y agoNo, authoritarianism has lead to mass famine and death. Marxism is just a way to operate an economy. If you implement changes to an economy by force, you’re probably going to hurt people. But we can still make voluntary changes to our world based on things we think are a good idea. Like advocating for and participating in worker cooperatives. And being a purely voluntary concept I’m suggesting, you don’t really need “a country” to do this. You could have just some groups within a country do this and they would see some benefits.