3 ms·
An interesting article just under this one: https://mezha.media/en/2022/10/10/massive-attack-on-ukrainian-cities-air-defense-of-the-afu-shot-down-45-out-of-80-m
by viraptor 4y ago
An interesting article just under this one: https://mezha.media/en/2022/10/10/massive-attack-on-ukrainian-cities-air-defense-of-the-afu-shot-down-45-out-of-80-missiles/ https://mezha.media/en/2022/10/10/massive-attack-on-ukrainia...
45 out of 80 missiles shot down. I suspect they're not on a high alert right now away from the frontline, so that sounds like a good result. I wonder if I'm right or is the system mostly automated and "being ready" wouldn't make a difference.
- anovikov 4y agoThis "system" mostly consists of men on duty with MANPADS. They either shoot the missile down or, if they don't manage to because it flies overhead too quickly, call the next guy in the direction it flew to, informing them that a missile is incoming for that direction (it will be a short time, 1-2 minutes). So the next guy will be fully prepared and knows where to look. That simple. If missiles flew too high for MANPADS, they'd be very easily shot down by proper SAMs or fighters, they survive by flying under the radar.
- ISL 4y agoSounds like a pretty good system.
- anovikov 4y agoIt is. It's also one Russians can't probably do anything about.
- viraptor 4y agoWell "automated" deserves some quotes. The main point was "can they be more ready and more efficient the next time", whether "automated" means automatic response, or something beeping at a person with a launcher, or more people with MANPADs.
- anovikov 4y agoIt's not like "next time". This is not an unprecedented attack. Russians simply launched a week's worth of missiles in one hour. That's what they can produce + restore from Soviet stocks. There is no "escalation" in that sense, they simply caused "shock and awe" by concentrating everything they normally shoot in a week, in one salvo.
- rjtavares 4y agoHere's a good video with an example (from today, I think): https://twitter.com/IAPonomarenko/status/1579433935075147777 https://twitter.com/IAPonomarenko/status/1579433935075147777
- anovikov 4y agoYes that's about how it works. Around a 100 of these groups of 3-4 guys strategically placed all over Ukraine is enough to ensure ~50% losses of those missiles. Less if they are given a pickup truck so they can move ~10km laterally in ~10 min.
- manholio 4y agoIf so, provoking this Russian vengeance strike is the best feat of the Ukrainian army by a mile. If you can bleed 1 billion in military spending with the cost of a few deaths and an lorry filled with explosives, that's by far the most effective way to win a war: you will quickly bankrupt Russia while your own army is still able to fight. Sounds much like the V2 rocket program used by Hitler to punish the British for their continental bombing incursions; it was largely irrelevant militarily but very expensive.
- Moldoteck 4y agoDo you know how much money ru gets from fuels alone? From eu region alone? Billions... This means ru can shot for days these kind of rockets and they will still be at profit... I really doubt Ukr is wants this kind of terror. Loosing civilians can be sometimes much worse compared to loosing troops
- dragontamer 4y agoNo one wants to see civilians die. But killing civilians doesn't change Ukrainian military strength at all. That's why such an attack is stupid and barbaric. It changes nothing about the war and just manages to waste Russian money and kill innocent people. If Russia's best response is really just attacking Universities and parks, it means that the Ukrainian army is invisible to Russia and Russia has no ability to strike the troops. Russia seemingly just confirmed what we all were thinking, they have no ability to beat the Ukrainian army anymore, and have decided to simply attack civilians out of frustration. ------ In contrast, the destruction of the Crimean bridge destroys one of two railroads that are supplying the Russian army in the south. Logistics for troop supplies are ruined. The strategic implications are obvious, and Russia seemingly has no way to stop the Ukrainian southern counter-offensive... And now has roughly 1/2 of the military supplies moving forward.
- mamonster 4y agoExcept they haven't only destroyed universities and parks. They have also hit the power plants in most of the cities. Kharkov was out of electricity in the morning, so were parts of other major cities. Now imagine electricity being out but in winter.