3 ms·
This doesn't answer the question considering NTSC isn't used anymore. Why not 60 fps considering it's the standard refresh rate of practically all displays that
by charcircuit 4y ago
This doesn't answer the question considering NTSC isn't used anymore. Why not 60 fps considering it's the standard refresh rate of practically all displays that are in use?
- CharlesW 4y agoIf you're asking why movies aren't shot at 60 fps instead of 24/23.976 fps, there are "HFR" movies shot at higher frame rates: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_films_with_high_frame_rates https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_films_with_high_frame_... From what I can find as I write this, the only movies distributed at high-framerates on Blu-ray are Gemini Man and Billy Lynn’s Long Halftime Walk. Although HFR is technically an improvement, not everyone's a fan of the "feel". Relevant HN thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14616930 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14616930
- williamcotton 4y ago24fps has an aesthetic that "looks cinematic" because we have all watched decades of cinematic films at 24fps. From jump cuts, montage and flashbacks to the color saturation and frames per second of film, you've learned an entire visual language over all of these years of watching moving pictures!
- Mountain_Skies 4y agoIn the 1970s it seemed common for tv shows to be shot on video in the studio but on film outside, perhaps because video cameras were too large or sensitive for outdoor use. The audience simply became accustomed to the large difference in appearance between indoors and outdoors in tv shows. IIRC, Doctor Who and Benny Hill went through this change during episodes frequently. It also reminds me of the first time I went over to a friend's house who had a large tube standard def tv after I had switched to HD. The scanlines that had always been invisible to my brain were suddenly very obvious. Funny how we adjust.
- retrac 4y agoApparently, many people are so used to 24 fps that films shot at higher framerates are slightly unsettling (even if they don't realize why), and have even been, ironically, described as unnatural. I've noticed it myself; I watched a YouTube video recently that was at 60 fps and my attention kept going to the hands of the person talking as he waved them around. The motion was too fluid. Slightly distracting. I guess my brain is used to interpolating what it would have looked like from a blur at 24 fps, rather than actually seeing the fine details. Though I'm sure we'll get used to it soon enough.
- Gigachad 4y agoIt's also kind of happened for audio quality where when someone is being interviewed, its natural for the host to be in crisp quality while the guest has crappy airpods mic quality. And how games show black bars on the top and bottom for cut scenes. It's beyond just limitations and now part of your expectation. I will say that seeing 60fps video on youtube is very very noticeable, much more than the resolution. I personally much prefer it but I can see how others don't since it is such a difference to the normal.
- dontlaugh 4y agoI have the opposite. Panning shots at low frame rate look odd and make my head hurt, especially with 3:2 pull-down. The first time I saw a film at 48 fps it finally felt so natural and immersive.
- cameronh90 4y agoI know what you mean about the panning. If you've never looked into it, film shutter angles are an interesting topic. Conventionally, the shutter is open for 50% of the frame. At 24fps, that does create a noticeable judder, but also makes movement less blurry. You can reduce or increase the angle, but it's a trade-off either way at 24fps. 48+fps makes motion both a lot smoother and less blurry, however for me, it makes their costumes look a lot more like... costumes. For example when I watched The Hobbit in 48fps, it felt more like a LOTR themed fancy dress party than a film. I suspect, in time, most people will get used to high frame rates as it becomes more common and learn to suspend disbelief the same way they do at low frame rates. Objectively, it looks fantastic.
- TheRealPomax 4y agoBecause the cinematic feel of 24 fps is extremely different from the video feel of 30fps, which in turn is completely different from the reality TV show feel of 60 fps.
- rasz 4y agoThats old people talk. Young dont even know what reality tv is, they hardly know what TV is in the first place. Tiktok is 30 (well, 29.97), most of YT and twitch already 60, games >60.
- bni 4y ago"Billy Lynn's Long Halftime Walk" was shot at 120fps and displayed in cinema and at home on 120fps or 60fps. This is a drama film. Both critics and viewers hated the look of it. Marvel comic book films should def be shot at 60/120 though. Why haven't anyone tried this with audiences?
- TheRealPomax 4y agoEven if YT lets you play back at 1080p60 (or higher), any channel with videos that have cinematic looking segments (even something as simple as product review channel) have that look because those segments weren't actually shot at 60fps. The temporal smoothing of 24fps is critically important to get that look. And people still notice them and comment on how insanely good those segments are =)
- wsh 4y agoNTSC may be gone now, but to avoid the need for frame rate conversion during simultaneous analog and digital broadcasts, and for compatibility with older equipment and recordings, the U.S. broadcasters all adopted (and continue to use) SD and HD digital formats with 30/1.001 or 60/1.001 frame rates. (See also: drop frame time code.)
- axiolite 4y ago> Why not 60 fps considering it's the standard refresh rate of practically all displays that are in use? Actually, I'd say 50fields/sec is the most popular frame-rate in-use around the world. Theatres still use 24fps or perhaps 48fps. Shooting at 1200fps would make everybody happy. But 24fps works pretty well.
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoBecause ATSC inherited the NTSC frame rate.
- thrdbndndn 4y agoNTSC at this point is just a blanket term for any standard/tech stemmed from NTSC. NTSC's components, including framerates, are still widely used in various (previously NTSC) countries.