3 ms·
Seems like this challenges the underpinnings of the free market. So according to the article we can start taxing everyone 100% once their income is above a cer
by amelius 4y ago
Seems like this challenges the underpinnings of the free market.
So according to the article we can start taxing everyone 100% once their income is above a certain level.
And the output of the economy will be better.
- senko 4y agoCongrats, you've just invented communism: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/From_each_according_to_his_ability,_to_each_according_to_his_needs https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/From_each_according_to_his_a...
- lolinder 4y ago"The free market" is not synonymous with "money as the primary motivator". All that a free market means is that we let natural interactions between people and groups of people drive the economy. It doesn't rely on any particular framework for how people choose what they want or how behavior is actually motivated. As an example: I choose to work at a job that pays less than I could get elsewhere because there are intangible benefits that matter more to me. I'm able to do that because the market is free. Within the company, I fight to keep those intangible benefits prioritized because I know that they are a major selling point that will get us engineers when we can't afford to pay SV wages. That's the free market at work, but money and incentive schemes don't factor into it at all.
- amelius 4y ago> "The free market" is not synonymous with "money as the primary motivator" Of course it is not black/white like that. But people keep telling me that the free market is so much better than communism because there is an incentive to work (money). However, it seems, the truth is somewhere in the middle, and it seems closer to communism after a certain level of income has been attained. That is, according to the theory in this article.
- lolinder 4y agoYou or they misunderstand. The fundamental premise of the free market is that, in a large and complex system, attempts to exercise central control tend to go badly relative to just letting people figure out what they want and pursue that. It's not money specifically that is the incentive to work, it's self-interest in general. This is perfectly compatible with Alfie Kohn's idea that intrinsic motivation beats extrinsic motivation—intrinsic motivation is a form of self-interest. The primary ideological conflict between communism and the free market isn't over money, it's over whether it is possible for a centrally-organized economy to outperform one in which people are left to pursue their own self-interest as they see fit. The article doesn't address this question at all. (As an aside, central control versus free market is obviously not an either/or choice, and most countries' policies end up somewhere in the middle.)
- BOOSTERHIDROGEN 4y agoany books about this topics? thanks.
- zeroonetwothree 4y agoThis article argues against a particular form of compensation, not compensation in general. And in any case, "the free market" != "people are only motivated by money". All "free market" means is that voluntary exchanges are not regulated or restricted by the government. Indeed it has nothing inherently to do with money, if you want to trade your labor for a pile of corn that would be a perfectly fine free market transaction.