3 ms·
The only problem: becoming root doesn't mean you now control the device (you paid for).
by amelius 4y ago
The only problem: becoming root doesn't mean you now control the device (you paid for).
- pjmlp 4y agoBasically just like container based distributions and cloud infrastructure. :)
- spijdar 4y agoWe've sort of been at this point for a long time, though, the abstraction bar is just being shifted up. Previously, the bar was at the firmware level, where you will never fully control the black boxes governing the security chips, DRM implementations and real time OSes running on the microcontrollers inside the CPU. Now the OS (especially on Apple devices) is almost becoming like the firmware layer itself, so deeply integrated and locked to the machine, but with the freedom to run other OSes/environments on top. At least you can (usually) still unlock the OS level...
- amelius 4y agoI was sort of OK with the firmware being inaccessible when it couldn't talk to the internet. But times changed.
- ribit 4y agoI feel like I pretty much have full control over my Mac laptop. Why would you expect to fully control a machine from inside a VM anyway? Sounds like a massive security risk too.
- amelius 4y agoSecurity is entirely orthogonal here. It's like saying you're ok with not being able to enter your own house because of security.
- ribit 4y agoIf I lose the key, sure, getting inside the house will be more difficult, isn’t that the entire point? Still, I don’t understand the relevance of the analogy. I have access to the entire system and can pretty much tweak things as I want. I also happen to prefer the default macOS security model with the sealed system volume. Where exactly is control taken away from me?
- fsflover 4y ago> I feel like I pretty much have full control over my Mac laptop. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25074959 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25074959
- ribit 4y agoOh please. You are quoting an issue that happened two years ago and Apple has already acknowledged that their algorithms were crappy and promised to reengineer this stuff. This is like claiming that Linux does not allow you to install software because a repository happens to be down.
- saagarjha 4y ago(Which they failed to follow up on.)
- fsflover 4y agoSo where is the redesign? This is like saying that a repository is down for two years, but it's fine, since they promised to fix that. Also, it's much worse, because Apple knows every app you run, including, e.g., Tor Browser. Do you think it's good for your privacy? Can you yourself fix that on "your" computer, which you "control"?
- ribit 4y agoApple since implemented encryption for the OCSP protocol they were using (addressing privacy concerns) and most likely improved the infrastructure to avoid similar outages. They also promised that users could opt out of certificate revocation checking, but so far they have not delivered, this much is true. I am not at all concerned about the privacy of Apple occasionally verifying the developer certificates I use on my computer. I think they have much better things to do then log this information and try to link it back to me. I mean, if they want to know which software I run they have many more — and much better — options to collect my private data than using OCSP. In the end, this is about trust more than about anything else. A Linux software repository could also be collecting data about which packages you download. Second, OCSP is a standard protocol for certificate checking in the web. I mean, Firefox is using it. So is Firefox bad for privacy now? Besides, I think it's entirely silly to be concerned about OCSP privacy when we have things like unencrypted DNS lookup still being the normality. Look, I fully understand that some people dislike the idea of their OS periodically checking certificates on their computer. Fortunately, there are plenty of systems on the market that can cater to different needs and expectations. You decide what is a concern for you and what not. If you are privacy-oriented to the fault, you probably want to use some secure version of Linux with IP anonymisers, manually installed software and of course everything strictly audited. Most people don't care about this stuff.
- 58028641 4y agoYou can install Asahi Linux on an Apple Silicon Mac. What control do you feel you lack?