7 ms·
New research suggests eating early and within a 10-hour window is healthier
- j7ake 4y agoVery cool. I guess the takeaway is eating a big meal right before sleeping is not ideal for losing weight (but could be a good strategy for those looking to gain).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sdfhbdf 4y agoSeems like the thesis might be true for overweight individuals. This might be key information missing from the title. as per the article: “Researchers had 16 overweight patients…” I would suggest to suffix the title with “for overweight individuals”
- stevenwoo 4y agoThis article lists three studies, one with sixteen overweight, one with thirty overweight, and the 137 San Diego firefighters study that was posted within the last week.
- mmastrac 4y agoDoes anyone have a link to the paper? I found a similar study from 2020: https://www.cell.com/cell-metabolism/pdfExtended/S1550-4131(19)30611-4 https://www.cell.com/cell-metabolism/pdfExtended/S1550-4131(... EDIT: I _think_ https://www.cell.com/cell-metabolism/fulltext/S1550-4131(22)00397-7 https://www.cell.com/cell-metabolism/fulltext/S1550-4131(22)... is the paper, but this article is kind of blog-spammy. Paper Summary: Late eating has been linked to obesity risk. It is unclear whether this is caused by changes in hunger and appetite, energy expenditure, or both, and whether molecular pathways in adipose tissues are involved. Therefore, we conducted a randomized, controlled, crossover trial (ClinicalTrials.gov NCT02298790) to determine the effects of late versus early eating while rigorously controlling for nutrient intake, physical activity, sleep, and light exposure. Late eating increased hunger (p < 0.0001) and altered appetite-regulating hormones, increasing waketime and 24-h ghrelin:leptin ratio (p < 0.0001 and p = 0.006, respectively). Furthermore, late eating decreased waketime energy expenditure (p = 0.002) and 24-h core body temperature (p = 0.019). Adipose tissue gene expression analyses showed that late eating altered pathways involved in lipid metabolism, e.g., p38 MAPK signaling, TGF-β signaling, modulation of receptor tyrosine kinases, and autophagy, in a direction consistent with decreased lipolysis/increased adipogenesis. These findings show converging mechanisms by which late eating may result in positive energy balance and increased obesity risk. Highlights: "Specifically, late eating significantly increased the odds of a >50 response on the VAS scale of how much a participant would like to eat (p < 0.0001), of reporting a desire to eat starchy foods (p < 0.0001) or meat (p < 0.0001), and of reporting a strong desire to eat (p < 0.0007). There were also increases in reported desire for salty foods (p < 0.0051), dairy (p < 0.034), and vegetables (p < 0.036)." "During the 16-h wake episode, late eating decreased average leptin by 16% (p < 0.0001) and increased the ghrelin:leptin ratio by 34% (p < 0.0001), consistent with the increased hunger probability during that time, while during the 8-h sleep episode, late eating increased average leptin by 10% (p = 0.0028), decreased ghrelin by 13% (p = 0.0002), and decreased the ghrelin:leptin ratio by 18% (p < 0.0001)." "Taken together, our results suggest that late eating caused a decrease in energy expenditure across the 24-h cycle, although future studies are needed to verify this." "...late eating significantly increased waketime hunger, decreased 24-h leptin, had no significant effect on 24-h ghrelin, decreased waketime energy expenditure, and decreased 24-h CBT." (and lots more -- study is quite interesting)
- dustedcodes 4y agoAlthough new studies are always interesting to some extent I find it extremely surprising how some people are still very surprised by things which we already knew for a very long time. Since I was a wee boy I remember being told that the healthiest eating pattern is a substantial breakfast, a warm lunch and a light dinner and you shouldn’t eat before going to sleep, just like you shouldn’t eat before heavy exercise or going swimming. There are numerous health benefits to this and they have all been talked to death so why are we still researching something that we already have the answers to?
- the_doctah 4y agoA warm lunch? How does temperature have anything to do with it?
- simonmales 4y agoIt's more about cold dinner. Theory is you are more likely to over eat a warm meal. So if you are going to keep to having a warm meal a day. Make it lunch.
- copperx 4y ago> Theory is you are more likely to over eat a warm meal. Eating all your meals cold might be a reasonable approach to weight loss. Wait, did I just invent a new diet fad?
- aksss 4y agoYour body covers the energy overhead to break down food into usable energy supply, ideally ending with a net positive. Warmer food presumably makes the digestion a little less costly. Cooked meat is definitely more rewarding (energy-wise) than raw meat (because it costs less to digest), so maybe warm food is a heuristic for cooked food as well.
- chiefalchemist 4y agoUnfortunately, the wisdom of ages doesn't qualify as science. I'm not agreeing with that, only explaining how are modern paradigm is anything but humble. Another example is cultures with rituals involving psychedelics. Western-based values dismissed those practices. Until now. Now we have Western-based "proof" of the usefulness of mind-altering substances.
- candiddevmike 4y agoDoesn't mention anything about autophagy, does not align with my worldview. In all seriousness I'd love to have a big breakfast but I'm too lazy to do it most days. The days I go out to eat for breakfast I end up doing light snacking for the rest of the day because I am so satiated.
- beardyw 4y agoI found doing business in Spain ok except they don't seem to eat until about 10pm. That was a real struggle for me - 6pm is my choice.
- tenthirtyam 4y agoAnd interestingly, from personal experience, Spaniards are not a generally overweight population despite eating a late dinner plus a typical breakfast, lunch and even merienda (afternoon snack). What gives?
- PabloRobles 4y agoI guess this thread discusses 2nd order effects. The most important factors are still the food you eat (Mediterranean diet in this case) and the number of calories (portion sizes).
- jrajav 4y agoMostly the calories. Number of meals is a non sequitur, especially with the insane caloric density of the typical American meal.
- jotm 4y agoLol fork off, it highly depends on your schedule and type of work. I have a very unusual eating schedule right now and have lost nearly all the fat I gained when I was working from home and eating early.
- EGreg 4y agoPeople don’t seem to understand yet the far more powerful (and much more complex) mechanisms for weight loss and gain. 1) Gut microbiome - the flora and fauna can be affected by antibiotics and probiotics, and also when you travel. For example kids given antibiotics early on become more overweight throughout life. 2) Meat and factory farms - they overuse antibiotics, and the older the animals you eat, the more effect it has on your own aging process. 3) The brain’s ability to burn calories AND regulate the gut brain too, through neuron pathways, is still poorly understood. But it might be a factor of mind over matter: https://nypost.com/2022/09/01/the-secret-to-weight-loss-could-be-in-the-brain-study/ https://nypost.com/2022/09/01/the-secret-to-weight-loss-coul... 4) Cutting out processed sugars, bread/starches and a lot of other artificial bullshit. Check out Jordan Peterson opening up about his all-meat diet. He and his famoly had many things clear up that were considered incurable, including arthritis and depression. https://www.doctorkiltz.com/jordan-peterson-diet/ https://www.doctorkiltz.com/jordan-peterson-diet/
- gruez 4y ago>2) Meat and factory farms - [...] the older the animals you eat, the more effect it has on your own aging process. You're in luck because modern factory farming has made it possible to raise animals in record time. Chicken are slaughtered as early as 6-7 weeks old[1], and beef you get at the grocery store is probably slaughtered between 12 and 22 months[2]. [1] https://ask.usda.gov/s/article/How-old-are-chickens-used-for-meat https://ask.usda.gov/s/article/How-old-are-chickens-used-for... [2] https://beef-cattle.extension.org/what-is-the-age-range-for-butchering-steers-i-am-trying-for-prime/ https://beef-cattle.extension.org/what-is-the-age-range-for-...
- EGreg 4y agoWow, I didn't know this. Based on your second link, a large number of calves are grown on grass pastures. It seems that in other scenarios, though, they are held in tight conditions. How can we tell which is which when we buy the meat? https://www.americancattlemen.com/articles/backgrounding-calves https://www.americancattlemen.com/articles/backgrounding-cal... My main concern is that the calves live a comfortable life and get to do what they want in the grass, and when they're slaughtered it's all over quickly. It seems a high energy diet would give them a lot more energy and enjoyment, if they are allowed to be out in pasture. As opposed to, say, veal!
- lizardactivist 4y agoEating less (than the recommended 4 meals per day) seems beneficial too. Lunch at 12 and dinner at 18 seems to work very well.
- ReactiveJelly 4y ago4? Is "tea" its own meal where you live? I've only said "fourth meal" ironically as it's part of a Taco Bell marketing campaign. Breakfast, lunch, dinner, and then getting Taco Bell at 2 am on a weekend.
- copperx 4y agoDo people work until 2 am on weekends? I've done it only occasionally, but if it's becoming a common thing, we should look into solving it, and not by having a 4th meal.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- xboxnolifes 4y agoThird shift exists, yes. But also, work wasn't mentioned or implied, unless you mean the taco bell workers.
- copperx 4y agoI've always been perplexed by those hours. Having a good breakfast, then having lunch between 2 and 4 seems much better (you can easily stretch that to make it after work, at 5:30 pm or so), as they do in Latin America. Then dinner is optional.
- astura 4y agoIf I eat breakfast I'm ravenous by 2:00, if I don't eat breakfast I am only a bit peckish at 2 and proper hungry by 4. Eating breakfast regularly also has the downside of causing me to wake up hungry. No thanks.
- gnicholas 4y agoI've heard the "early" window is better than late. For me, this is very difficult because I want to eat dinner with my family (who all eat breakfast at different times). I still seem to have reasonable success with a 17/7 window that's roughly noon/1p to 7/8p. Does anyone else have experience with the differences between early and late windows? Or ways to make early windows feasible with a family?
- Mikeb85 4y agoI wouldn't trust it. Tons of Europeans eat early and very late and are perfectly healthy.
- copperx 4y agoVery late as in after midnight?
- Mikeb85 4y agoNo but like 9-10pm for dinner which is significantly later than North Americans typically eat and definitely far beyond a 10 hour window for all meals.
- stubish 4y agoUntil studies are reproduced in places like Spain, we won't know if they could be even healthier. And if studies cannot be replicated, that is interesting too as it could help narrow down why intermittent fasting approaches show benefits in other populations.
- pbronez 4y agoI’m in the same position. Need to eat dinner in the evenings for family reasons. Social elements of food are significant.
- copperx 4y ago> Social elements of food are significant. But easily changeable. Nothing stops you from sitting at the table and having a good conversation, all while eating an apple or two and a glass of water.
- mopeas908 4y agoI feel like a study like this comes out three times a year and still somehow gets a headline. Anyone have a link to a meta-analysis?
- stubish 4y agoYes, it is fantastic how people are reproducing scientific studies now, and even building on them. Just recently there was a study on firefighters and a question comes up about eating early or late in the window. And now, here is a study that looked at that exact question. It seems reasonably likely the next similar headline will be a meta-analysis, since we seem to have had a spate of studies recently.
- stoplying1 4y agoOof. I'm not sure this is an optimization I can go for. I feel good running a bit low during the day. I don't know how I could get enough calories in to stay sane, without having to eat too many of them early in the day or break my fast too soon when I inevitably get hungry at night. I guess it probably is psychological like everything else. Maybe a light breakfast at 7am, a healthy dinner at 4pm, that's still a decent fasting window? I prefer to fast throughout the day though (I'm still actively trying to lose another 20lbs).
- RDaneel0livaw 4y agoThis falls into the "safe to ignore useless new research" articles that are constantly spammed out all year every year forever: - battery technology - eating / nutrition - alcohol consumption trends
- dominotw 4y agoJust tired of this shit. I'll eat whenever I feel like. STFU.
- whateveracct 4y agoI encourage you to. HNers and SV tech bros have a generally disordered view of food from my perspective. I think I'm a little sensitive to it because many in my family and wife have had eating disorders. Food is for enjoyment as much as sustenance. Focus on learning to cook and having a joyous relationship with food of all types. If you start with rules and numbers, you're missing the forest through the trees imo.
- mgamache 4y agoNew headline. "Small underpowered study is published" This might mean something as part of a meta analysis, but means nothing here.
- e63f67dd-065b 4y ago> Researchers had 16 overweight patients eat the same exact meals on two schedules: one with meals earlier in the day and the other with meals about four hours later in the day. That’s all I need to know to stop reading. Drawing conclusions from n=16, on the latest edition of the journal of bogus research.
- TomJansen 4y agoIsn't this the classic working schedule? Breakfast at 8, lunch at 12:00 and dinner at 18:00. I think it minimizes snacking
- frxx 4y agoI think dinner times can vary a lot, based on the cultures in each country/region. Meal times in general, I suppose.