4 ms·
The _Asian_ gang that kidnaps Asians. If we're going to make this racial then dont mess it up.
by nonethewiser 4y ago
The _Asian_ gang that kidnaps Asians. If we're going to make this racial then dont mess it up.
- EdwardDiego 4y agoIt is a very weird way to phrase that headline. I'd rather they specified the Chinese gangs that kidnap Cambodians/Burmese. It's especially relevant (to me, anyway) because of the ongoing exploitation of Cambodia by Chinese interests who have Cambodian officials in their pockets because, well, money. Sihanoukville is something a friend had highlighted to me previously - it's seen massive development - by Chinese developers for a market comprised of Chinese tourists and expats. So the development hasn't exactly poured money into the economy, unless you count the minimal wages paid to local labourers, or the bribes to officials. And the development has seen locals being displaced by obliging Cambodian officials when they were seen as getting in the way of "progress", as well as the Cambodians displaced because they've been priced out of their own town. Mind you, economic colonialism is nothing new, and the countries that a lot of HNers hail from, myself included, have done exactly the same in the past (and, being fair, are probably still doing so now to some extent), but I feel it highlights the risks of the "Belt and Road" strategy as much as the ports in Sri Lanka et al that are now owned by Chinese interests because of loan terms that couldn't be met. Right now China is offering up lots of money for influence in the Pacific, and lots of "development" loans, and the eventual cost is going to be massive for the entire planet - a lot of those small Pacific nations have very large EEZs, and the ability to fish in an absolutely unsustainable manner in those EEZs is often what China asks for in return. There's also been worrying suggestions of Chinese military bases as a form of quid for the quo. (I say worrying because of China's aggressive tendencies in Biển Đông/West Phillipine Sea/North Natuna Sea/South China Sea).
- dirtyid 4y ago>weird way to phrase that headline It's Economist / western MSM evading the fact that Taiwan also plays huge part in criminal syndicate human trafficking schemes for telco scams targetting PRC&TW (but particularly PRC) nationals. It's one of the few criminal issues with formal joint PRC/TW coordination. I remember a few years ago they arrested ~8,000 such telco scammers from around the world (ASEAN/Pacific Islands/African) and 60% were TWnese. Maybe "Ethnically" Chinese gangs, but that has it's own layer of insinuations/omissions. As for rest of your analysis, that's just the cost of rapid development. Same story in Laos and Vietnam, and PRC herself during hayday. As for with resource exploitation and military cooperation. Countries with less $2000 and shit prospects has few options for growth, and TBH the fact that Cambodia's per capita GDP is less than landlocked Laos is startling.
- cellis 4y agoAgree, title should be worded “gangs in Asia kidnap and force crimes to be committed”
- thaumasiotes 4y agoThis seems to follow the standard practice of ascribing race to victims but not to criminals.
- woodruffw 4y agoI also found it confusing, but I don't think the Economist was trying to "make it racial." I think they were trying (and not succeeding) to succinctly express this sentence, in TFA: > The schemes are organised by ethnic-Chinese gangs, which sometimes collaborate with their local counterparts, says Jeremy Douglas of the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime.
- SanjayMehta 4y agoThe Economist's propaganda is usually much more subtle than this particular instance. Despite their neutral style, it occasionally leaks out, as in this instance. More often, it leaks out in their podcast, where the tone of voice used conveys their bias.
- sateesh 4y agoWhat is their propoganda and bias , curious to know.
- sofixa 4y agoThey have an obvious pro-business, neoliberal (economic) bias, and they've never hidden it. Calling it propaganda and implying it's some nefarious tricking is too much. It's in their freaking name what they are!
- hulitu 4y ago>Calling it propaganda and implying it's some nefarious tricking is too much. But it is still propaganda.
- SanjayMehta 4y agoThe usual sly British games with the English language. I first noticed it when they were ranting (very politely, of course) about some Indian policy change. They never said "the Indian government;" it was always "Modi's nationalist party." There was another example where their podcast was playing the sounds of various religions. For church bells, the speaker said "who'd want to live next to that," and for other demographics, he'd say "ah lovely."
- jldugger 4y agoI mean, you're the one who made it racial. Asia is a location, and the English language demonym for people who live there is "Asian."
- libpcap 4y agoThe PRC gangs to be exact.
- sofixa 4y agoEthnically Chinese could very well mean Taiwan too, the main ethnic group there is also Han, same as mainland China.
- eyelidlessness 4y agoYou made it “racial”. Until I saw this comment I thought it was a story local to some Asian communities.