5 ms·
With seemingly endless data storage, people are 'digital hoarding'
- anthropodie 4y agoAttachment is the mother of all suffering. Let go people! We take nothing with us when we leave this world.
- tenebrisalietum 4y agoWhat about the people we leave behind? Let's leave something for them?
- pieterhg 4y agoReality is probably nobody cares about your backups with old files. Except maybe photos/videos. But even that's to be debated. You're not that important.
- tenebrisalietum 4y agoYet, we treasure discoveries of such trivial things of absolute nobodies in thousands-years-old civilizations that are gone. Example: https://www.livescience.com/pompeii-slave-room-uncovered https://www.livescience.com/pompeii-slave-room-uncovered
- biggerChris 4y agoThis is sad. The cake is a lie. Life has no meaning. Lol. Jokes aside. Memories are the only thing of value we have to ourselves.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoLooks at iCloud photos… 26k family photos 5k family videos Every year for birthdays we print out the top 100 and make a hardcover keepsake in case digital worlds come crashing down some day.
- hazrmard 4y agohttps://www.reddit.com/r/DataHoarder/ https://www.reddit.com/r/DataHoarder/ Their subreddit blurb (jokingly) is quite relevant to the article: "It's a Digital Disease!" I feel like it's a balance between keeping redundant digital possessions (duplicates, outdated files, unidentifiable artifacts), having a healthy distrust of things persisting in the cloud, and a desire to keep a digital legacy.
- loonster 4y agoDo you mean delete? (This is a joke of old reddit vs new reddit.) https://old.reddit.com/r/DataHoarder/ https://old.reddit.com/r/DataHoarder/
- toastedwedge 4y ago> In our research sample, some people had gathered more than 40 terabytes (TB) of digital content over time. Good lord. I need to step up! Jokes aside, I, like others here, realize the surprisingly fragile nature of digital storage, even in the "cloud". I don't hoard things I don't need, I hoard things I know I won't find again in 10-15 years due to algorithm optimization, or a change in public opinion. This also applies to family photos and videos that I will cherish and, had I not taken the time and effort, would gravely regret not having.
- causi 4y agochange in public opinion Oh man, I wish there was more written about this. There's quite a lot of content I may be the only remaining possessor of thanks to my (probably tism-related) need to not repeatedly waste bandwidth on things I may as well keep on local storage. There are huge swaths of content that creators have taken offline because it doesn't math their current branding or it had one too many "gamer words" in it. One look through your "Liked" videos on Youtube is enough to turn anybody into a data hoarder.
- peteforde 4y ago> In our survey of 846 respondents representing the general population, we found that digital hoarding can lead to higher levels of anxiety. Statistically, 37% of one's total level of anxiety, measured using an established depression, anxiety, and stress scale, was explained by digital hoarding. I'm sorry: if there is a human who can attribute 37% of their total life anxiety to having too many files stored, they probably own a yacht. What a fantastically stupid sentence.
- sidewndr46 4y agoWe'd need to dig through the study itself and whatever information was available about it. But typically what you'll find what was that responders to the survey answered a series of questions about storage & anxiety. The researchers then concluded 37% of their total anxiety came from the data stored. How this was reached is missing from this report it seems. Also there should be some sort of uncertainty or confidence interval associated with it.
- Root_Denied 4y agoI think it's worded poorly and that the implication is that people are experiencing anxiety thinking about their files due to concern about losing those files, not from having them in the first place.
- frou_dh 4y agoI don't think it's a particularly good example that the article keeps talking about smartphone photos, because taking even mundane photos is at least a creative act. Digital hoarding would be more like acquiring masses of TV shows and Music that you never watch. Or saving hundreds of articles to Read-it-Later lists (ahem).
- im3w1l 4y ago> Some people had gathered more than 40 terabytes (TB) of digital content over time. With a quick search I was able to find 16TB harddrives for sale, so you could easily fit more than 40TB in a single tower. Doesn't sound like their hoarding rises to the level of dysfunctional.
- kkfx 4y agoThe issue is not for you but for those who want to have all users data on their systems, let's say "the big of cloud" who start having scalability issues...
- unstatusthequo 4y ago22 TB drives also exist. Slam 10 of those into a NAS and you’re good for a while.
- sekh60 4y agoYou can fit 40TB in a tower no problem, however you have to remember to add disks for parity, and your backups should at least be a separate box. Doing it right adds up quick in terms of cost.
- adrian_b 4y agoYou can have 240 TB in a suitcase with 20 LTO magnetic tape cartridges. The volume is about the same as it would be with hard disks of 24 to 30 TB per HDD, but the weight and cost is much less.
- arnaudsm 4y agoIndeed photos are the gateway drug to data hoarding. I'm at 128 TB myself, I now have Wikipedia dumps, millions of books, thousands of YouTube videos, papers, everything I can download pretty much. You'd be surprised how ephemeral the web is. My favorite YouTube videos from 2010 are all gone, I'm glad I kept a copy.
- LorenPechtel 4y agoFor most people it comes down to not being worth taking the time to prune. Without attempting to shop around I'm seeing something like $25/TB for large drives. A photo and it's corresponding .RAW (for those of us who shoot cameras that record such) takes maybe 20MB unless you have some pretty high end gear. 50,000 photos per terabyte. 0.05 cent per photo. If you work at minimum wage that's about a quarter second of your time. You're much better off working and buying a bigger drive than in pruning unwanted photos.
- fmajid 4y agoThe cost is in retrieval if you have to sift through the dross. Technologies like facial recognition and GPS geotagging can help a little, but ultimately you need curation.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- haunter 4y agoStarted downloading my Youtube liked videos back in 2009 (and keeping it updated ever since). +10k videos ~1.5 TB. It's pretty much nothing and a huge chunk of them gone forever from the site, especially pre-2010 ones.
- scyzoryk_xyz 4y agoThat is something that I would love to browse
- sfvegandude 4y agoHow long until there's a torrent tracker for removed YouTube videos?
- djsavvy 4y agoDo you have an automatic setup to do this, or is it a manual process?
- haunter 4y agoyt-dlp Automatically you can only download the most recent 100 liked videos. So if you have a huge library first download the list (even Google Takeout supports that), you just need the video IDs then feed it to yt-dlp. The rest, like quality, are personal preference. Like I usually max at 1080p and never download DASH videos. When you are up to date you can still automate it. For example download once a week but I pretty much download everything asap even manually because I know Google can remove it quick or even sometimes the uploader.
- tomschwarze 4y ago> even sometimes the uploader. Yeah, that happened to a channel I loved several years ago [0]. I've been scouring the internet ever since then, looking for mirrors of the channel, and one video in particular [1]. It's a long shot, but maybe you or someone else reading this could help, so I'll leave the links here: [0]: https://web.archive.org/web/20151129103353/https://www.youtube.com/user/nimber/featured https://web.archive.org/web/20151129103353/https://www.youtu... [1]: https://web.archive.org/web/20151130132704/https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PzUvNL1dSns https://web.archive.org/web/20151130132704/https://www.youtu...
- xnx 4y agoWe're probably not more than 10 years off from 360 HD video of every minute of our waking lives being easy to capture, store, and analyze.
- foundart 4y agoOriginal article: https://theconversation.com/with-seemingly-endless-data-storage-at-our-fingertips-digital-hoarding-could-be-an-increasing-problem-190356 https://theconversation.com/with-seemingly-endless-data-stor...
- kkfx 4y agoThe real issue IMVHO is that people do not know how to damn manage their own data. Most are still stuck at dealing with files and directories. Most can't even manage their craphone photos. As a result the pile up rubbish on rubbish not know what to do, it's a bit different than 'digital hoarding' IMVHO...
- shrubble 4y agoSome are hoarding because they have seen how entire sites or groups of videos or books (even a Dr. Suess children's book) can be removed... so if it is digital you need to store it yourself.
- LorenPechtel 4y agoYup. I mirrored a website with hiking information because I wanted it available offline. I'm glad I did because not too long after that I found it gone. I'm guessing the guy was afraid of being blamed because some moron got in over his head. Hey, if you're going off the beaten track you better have a good understanding of your limits! I'll admit he was writing expecting a fair amount of scrambling skill (more than once I found spots that made me turn back that he barely mentioned at all) but nothing about it was deceptive and it had a perfectly good warning that much of it wasn't just a walk in the park.
- alkonaut 4y agoUnpopular take: life is ephemeral, the web too. That video you liked from YouTube that has since been deleted: it doesn’t matter. You weren’t going to watch it again. Content you didn’t create yourself has two categories only: so important it matters to other people so you don’t have to store it, and not important even to yourself. Yes there is a risk of an item falling in between (being important to you and lost). Don’t worry. There’s other content.
- Rygian 4y agoJust this morning I downloaded a few videos from 2013, that i hadn't watched in years but felt like watching again, because i was concerned they would be removed some day. I have then spent the afternoon watching them again. Your point of view is yours and yours only, I believe. You don't have a magic ball to see what is important to others.
- karencarits 4y agoThere was a thread yesterday on M-DISCs and the longevity of DVDs etc (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33117813 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33117813). It's sad - and perhaps strange? - that we don't have good write-and-forget storage solutions, it would certainly reduce my stress around backuping and curation
- sfvegandude 4y agoWas this article written by the copyright lobby?