8 ms·
Are hospitals overtreating patients nearing the end?
- ThinkBeat 4y agoThe answer to this in my opinion is "Yes". It is not a trivial topic, however. We now have the technology and medicine that can extend life far beyond what I find ethically defensible. Assisted suicide / mercy is not legal in most places but it does happen every day when a doctor in good conscious cannot inflict further suffering. My grandmother, after being in hospital for weeks, wanted to check out. She refused to eat. The doctors gave her morphine to make it easier. Having to go on a hunger strike to be allowed to die sounds awful way to go. At least in the west where I have spent most of my time we are far too "afraid" of death. Death is as natural as birth. "whereas there is obviously nothing in the world over which every man has such an indisputable right as his own person and life” (Schopenhauer, 1851, 1974: p. 306)
- ProllyInfamous 4y agoIn unrelated news, helium/nitrogen sales increase to all time highs..!
- uslic001 4y agoOf course they are as they get paid more if they do more.
- yboris 4y agoAn awesome book that points out the hidden motives behind what people do: Elephant in the Brain by Robin Hanson sheds some light on this phenomenon. It seems like one of the ways people try to show their love for others is by acting like "money is not an issue when your life is on the line" which results in a tremendous amount of spending per healthy day of life generated (poor QALY trade off). https://www.amazon.com/Elephant-Brain-Hidden-Motives-Everyday/dp/0190495995 https://www.amazon.com/Elephant-Brain-Hidden-Motives-Everyda...
- mrec 4y agoFor anyone who hasn't already seen it, Scott Alexander's Who By Very Slow Decay [1] (2013) is a classic on the subject. Please take the trigger warning seriously. [1] https://slatestarcodex.com/2013/07/17/who-by-very-slow-decay/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2013/07/17/who-by-very-slow-decay...
- srvmshr 4y agoI read this in its entirety last year and sat quietly for a long time knowing many of these observations will one day be true for me too. Its sad, depressing and really harsh truth.
- Waterluvian 4y agoAfter years of declining health my grandfather ended up with some sort of flesh eating infection. My aunt and grandmother wanted to keep fighting. I remember being in the room with extended family and the doctor double checking that everyone wanted to stay for the discussion. He then discussed, …in detail, how they would treat it and what his life would be like after. The decision makers in my family quickly came to a consensus. What I remember most is that it didn’t feel like manipulation. The way the doctor laid out the situation felt like he was informing everyone. Equipping us to understand the situation almost as well as the doctors might. I remember that making it far easier on my aunt and grandma afterwards.
- purplerabbit 4y agoThe overmedicalization of death is a giant ethical problem that we haven’t developed the culture to healthily deal with. If you haven’t read the book “Being Mortal”, I would highly recommend it. It addresses how to approach death from a perspective that combines existential and medical issues. It’s one of a very small set of books that should probably be required reading for all of humanity
- jgurewitz 4y agoInformed, decision making away from the pulse of the emotion is essential here. High quality physicians with the time and space to guide a family are immensely impactful but sadly both the time and space are becoming increasingly limited. Having a trusted advocate by your side who is not as connected is becoming a significant trend.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoHence the need for everyone to have advanced health directives.
- jgurewitz 4y agoAdvanced health directives are great. Sadly most of the time they're placed in a box somewhere and it's not the first thing you think of when something critical is happening.
- Silverback_VII 4y agoAll your vitality and youth eaten up on the hamster wheel to get 10 miserable years surrounded by medical equipment at the end of your life consuming the rest of your fortune. And why exactly? to move the doomsday clock an inch closer to midnight?
- k__ 4y agoI didn't buy into that. I wanna live while I still can.
- daniel-cussen 4y ago
- sangnoir 4y ago[flagged]
- mensetmanusman 4y agoThe entire system seems somewhat incentivized to harvest as much cash out of situation as possible…
- t00ny 4y agoNot in Canada.
- stevenwoo 4y agoThe last few paragraphs detail specialized long term ICU centers in the USA that treat such patients where the survival rate is low compared to non patients and the medical technology is utilized to fullest so as many patients as possible reach the one year point so the statistics look great, and then it is withdrawn after the 365 day mark (because that is the only measurement used for funding) so the care can be used on the next customer. There's one near me where any time I pass by there is usually an ambulance taking away a patient or delivering a patient (the lights and siren are never used).
- s1artibartfast 4y agoFor the most part, doctors and hospitals don't want to do it. This is a patient and family driven phenomenon for the most part
- mywacaday 4y agoThis was a discussion that stuck with me: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28463482 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28463482
- _qua 4y agoI haven't had a chance to read the article yet but as a physician--yes we often overtreat at the end of life. I have had horrible experiences basically torturing patients with repeated invasive procedures and disease-focused treatments who have designated their decision making to a family member who is unable to accept a recommendation for hospice care from the treating physicians. In some cases this is motivated by religious beliefs that "everything must be done" to save a life no matter how much pain or suffering is causes. It's morally distressing.
- oski 4y agoYeah, it’s very distressing. It seems that there is often a correlation between religious thinking and hoping for a miracle that defies reason.
- sokoloff 4y agoThat’s hardly surprising, given the treatments of miracles in the Bible. If you believe in those, why think that no more miracles are forthcoming?
- candiddevmike 4y agoYou'd think they'd be pro-death and look forward to meeting them again in whatever afterlife they believe in. Or does faith falter in the face of the fragility of life?
- refurb 4y agoNo, I wouldn't assume the religious are "pro-death".
- denton-scratch 4y agoThere's a correlation between being religious and being "pro-life". Even the dimmest pro-lifer can see that it's hypocritical to insist on saving the life of a foetus that has never seen daylight, at the risk of the mother, while allowing an old, sick person to die naturally. So they are forced into an "all lives matter" posture.
- Something1234 4y agoI've been trying to figure out how to define a living will that is actually quantified, but I just can't come up with anything. Everything I can think of has exceptions in it, and I'm sure I won't cover all the holes.
- bittercynic 4y agoI think making a reasonable effort to cover likely scenarios is a good way to communicate your intent, and if a situation comes that you didn't cover, a trustworthy reader has a good chance of taking the action you would have wanted. At some point you have to accept that you're going to have diminishing control over things.
- denton-scratch 4y agoMine is very simple; I don't want people struggling to keep me alive, if the chances are that I'm going to die soon anyway. But this kind of thing can only work if the medical staff are trustworthy, and use common sense. My GP knows my attitudes, but in an emergency it might be any old jobsworth that has to interpret my wishes.
- theow7384iri 4y agoHospital has to make money somewhere! Procedures done on corpse are financing ER and other departments!
- Waterluvian 4y agoNot really how it works in Canada.
- kennend3 4y agoYour post makes no sense. Given this is posted on a Canadian site, and discusses Ontario.... Hospitals don't "make money" in Canada, they are all owned and funded by the government.
- photochemsyn 4y agoI think it's a bit more complicated than that, because in most socialized medicine systems, the suppliers are not owned by the government, so there's a lot of private industry billing (pharmaceuticals, medical devices and implants. etc.) It's comparable to the USA's freeway system - yes the roads are publicly owned, but road repairs and material procurement are contracted out to private industry, and there's always the possibility of things like a government employee getting a kickback from a construction company for signing off on unnecessary work requests, etc.
- kennend3 4y ago> the suppliers are not owned by the government Correct..but pretty much any "medical supplier" requires a doctors note to provide services. "blood testing labs" for example might want to blood test everyone in the country for everything imaginable..Without a doctors note they are prohibited from taking blood. Doctors (effectively government employees) do control the gates. Kickback schemes are possible (and have been uncovered), but this is a pretty big tangent to "over-treating those near death" isnt it? Most "medial fraud" in canada tends to focus on "services charged but not rendered".
- refurb 4y ago
- swayvil 4y agoBeing the fantasy-loving creatures that we are, theater always replaces reality, sooner or later. The costumes. The magic language. The shiny apparatus. The heroic striving. All necessary props in the drama. Ticket sales are good.
- Consultant32452 4y agoWe over-medicalize life too.
- inglor_cz 4y agoSomeone downvoted you for no reason. Yes, we over-medicalize life, too. Death is but the end stage of life, so it suffers from the same problem.
- lbriner 4y agoOne of the problems is that we think that we deserve to have everything done to save us, even if futile and families think they get the next priority in deciding what the hospitals will spend. How does a Government/Medical Profession agree to what is considered acceptable or not acceptable without incurring the expense of legal action? It seems like the "easy" answer is to be seen to do everything you possibly could. The article did mention, however, how the communication of the medical staff can be instrumental in coneying the graveness of the situation, although it's a lot to take in if everything has happened in the last 30 minutes and you are suddenly staring death in the face.
- debacle 4y agoMy least favorite statistic is that roughly 50% of an individual's lifetime medical costs come in the last few weeks of life. This is seriously problematic. Families need to learn to let go and doctors need to be more honest about outcomes. My mother was facing multiple organ failure and she was still given a feeding tube against her stated wishes and my family's protests.
- denton-scratch 4y ago> she was still given a feeding tube against her stated wishes and my family's protests. How did that happen? That sounds like assault. Did they not know her express wishes?
- lotsofpulp 4y agoThere is a very complex calculation of liability going on in medical decisions, and they depend on various interpretations of the jurisdiction’s laws.
- mjevans 4y agoThe forms they make families fill out are often given too late; and don't offer an affordance of nuance. My dad had dementia before anyone realized, and even if he had been of sound mind, the forms tend to be all or none, rather than reflecting the range of outcomes that are remotely likely. The discussions that are suddenly forced onto family at the end of life are an extra level of pain on top of the inevitable loss.
- bberenberg 4y agoBeing Mortal by Atul Gawande has an interesting look into this topic.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- andrewl 4y agoI thought this story in “comic book” form of end of life in a hospital was very powerful: https://www.acpjournals.org/doi/10.7326/G14-0009 https://www.acpjournals.org/doi/10.7326/G14-0009
- wpietri 4y agoTwo points: One, this barely touches on the opposite side, when doctors give up too soon. When my mom had a brain tumor that had a high 5-year mortality rate but still had plenty of time left, a number of doctors we encountered either gave us premature "time to give up" speeches or were just lackadaisical about treating her symptoms. (None of those doctors were her neuro-oncologist, and my mom was a fighter who would not give up on the time left to her.) Had I and my brother not been there to push back on the medical system, we would have had months less with her. Should we minimize the suffering when there's no hope? Definitely. But not until that point unless the patient clearly chooses otherwise. Two, I think the much bigger problem on either side is not doctor attitudes, but cultural attitudes towards death. It's something a lot of Americans avoid talking about, avoid thinking about. My mom was a fighter, but because she had run an adult foster care home with an elderly wing, she was was also a realist. She had a DNR on file and we had all talked about what we wanted years before she got sick. We knew she wanted as much of a good life as possible, and then she wanted to be done. So when the neuro-oncologist said we couldn't do any more, that was it, and we transitioned to hospice. But from what I understand, that's not the common reaction. I hear stories from friends of dying patients dragged through all sorts of unwanted treatment because the adult children of the patient are unable to deal with their emotions enough to honor the patient's wishes, tend to the patient's needs. So I ask everybody to talk with your family about what you each want. One framework I've used is Five Wishes, which has forms you fill out and material to help a family discussion along: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Five_Wishes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Five_Wishes https://www.fivewishes.org/for-myself/ https://www.fivewishes.org/for-myself/ This is the most important thing you can do to minimize overtreatment: talk about it with family and get something written down. That way when the doctor turns to you and asks what the patient wants, you can answer with confidence.
- Waterluvian 4y ago> Get something written down. Important advice. I think it’s also true the other way. Write down what doctors say. Far too often what doctors said and what people heard or can recall do not line up. That’s just human nature. A physician friend of mine prints out what she is going to say in serious moments and then hands it over after the conversation. She said this was because of how many times, “in cases like this, the x year survival is y percent” being later repeated as “doctor said Z only had x years to live.”
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Animatronio 4y agoLots of people here are willing to let others die so as to not "overburden" the medical system - financially or otherwise. I for one would like be overtreated to the max, because then what's the point of having EOL care if not to prevent death. Also, I'm a religious person, and I don't think it's in any way conflicting with my beliefs.
- wl 4y agoYou might want to talk with some of the healthcare workers that are performing these treatments. Most of them will say things along the lines of, "I don't want the last moments of my life to be someone breaking my ribs" or "there are fates worse than death."
- Animatronio 4y agoI don't think healtcare workers are more qualified than anyone to say there are fates worse than death, besides I don't think it's true.
- sethammons 4y agoWas it bad for you before being born?
- Animatronio 4y agoHow would I know?! Might have been a terrible time for me, but I have no memory of it. So I'd rather err on the side of caution.
- cpsns 4y agoIt’s definitely true, though I’m glad you’ve not had to whiteness such fates. I’ve seen it first hand with family members and it’s traumatic for all involved.
- throwaway6734 4y agoJust don't expect others to pay for it
- gsatic 4y agoOfcourse they are. Having spent a whole lot of time in hospitals with elderly family members over the last couple years its pure madness. One doc told me its like watching farmers keep entire fields of mostly dead plants alive.
- Silverback_VII 4y agoIt is not very ethical to spend hundreds of thousands to minimally extend the lives of people who will use this new gained time to watch a little more television. Someone has to pay the bill.
- Animatronio 4y agoHow does it compare to spending hundreds of billions to continuously prepare for war? Ethically speaking, of course!
- inglor_cz 4y agoEthically speaking, Ukraine would now be toast (which means: occupied, enslaved, tortured and raped) if the Western powers didn't spend enough money on their war readiness. World peace requires unanimity. Absent that, there is nothing principially unethical to prepare for future wars. And that has to be done continuously, because technology evolves.
- Animatronio 4y agoI wasn't referring to Ukraine at all. Let's not make this about current affairs please. Whenever there's a new billion dollar plane or ship or whatnot there's plenty of money for it. When someone requires half a mil for some procedure suddenly it's a big no-no.
- sokoloff 4y agoYou can’t cite war preparations as wasteful and then hand-wave away an argument that they’re being used to good effect right this minute. The problem isn’t that one person in total needs $500K; if that was it, we’d be done talking about it. The problem is that a lot of people need $500K and if some of those are spent on people with literally hours to live, then people who could enjoy years of benefit if treated are at risk of not being treated.
- nradov 4y ago
- the-printer 4y agoI suspect that people are more likely to want their loved ones to be treated in spite of glaring suggestions toward the end of their love one’s life when they fear that death will approach within the hospital walls. It’s likely that many people would prefer their loved one to die at home than elsewhere. Which I suppose is a natural feeling. But they then catch themselves in the dilemma of choosing between what they feel is an environment of care medically and an environment of care, well, “familial-ly”? It’s easy to make faith or religion a target for phenomenons such as as this. But which faith (or whose, rather) are we talking here?
- SkipperCat 4y agoI can't stress this enough. Get a living will and end of life directives. Your family will do everything to keep you alive because they'll feel awful if they don't. Their guilt about not doing enough will override common sense.
- civilized 4y agoSoon we can expect an article criticizing Canada as inhumane for putting limits on overtreatment at the end of life.
- VancouverMan 4y agoIn Canada, both situations are just symptoms of the same underlying problem: the various public health care systems in Canada are quite inefficient, including when it comes to the allocation of resources. This should be expected, though, since socialist systems tend to remove, or lack, the balancing factors that can encourage improved efficiency. There is little incentive for Canadian medical practitioners to do better. The artificially restrictive and anti-competitive nature of these health care ecosystems, from education, to funding, to providing service, helps ensure that the situation doesn't improve over time.
- civilized 4y agoThat's interesting. I've seen a table that said Canada's health system has the among the lowest percent admin overhead of any developed country, so I had the impression it was relatively efficient.
- inglor_cz 4y agoAdministration costs are just one of many possible inefficiencies. Choosing what to spend on is a very different can of worms. You can be very efficient in building bridges, but if you choose to build bridges to nowhere, the entire system is far from efficient.
- civilized 4y agoSure, but what specifically? Do they have bad doctors? Do they test your reflexes too many times, time which would be better spent looking in the ears? What is actually happening that's a waste of time?
- 4y ago
- denton-scratch 4y agoI've prepared a "living will" - basically a signed directive that I don't want anyone to strive officiously to save my life, a.k.a. "Do Not Resuscitate". I gave a copy to my GP, and I sent another to my health trust. There's a copy in my desk-drawer. My kids know my intentions. But I'm afraid that if a paramedic attends me in an emergency, she won't know about these documents, and will be in too much of a hurry to search. Also, if I get in trouble outside the area of my health trust, they won't have this document at all.
- ejb999 4y agoNot sure where you live, but in my state (and states around me) EMT/Paramedics know to check the fridge door for a MOLST form that is usually brightly colored (easy to see) and contains your wishes - i.e. no CPR or no intubation etc; usually these are filled out in conjunction with your doctor, they keep a copy and you put a copy on your fridge where it is easy to find - more common for very elderly folks and those with terminal illnesses - but I supposed anyone could have one.
- denton-scratch 4y ago> and those with terminal illnesses My terminal illness is called "life". I have COPD, which is supposedly incurable, and there's a fair chance that's what will kill me; but what guarantees that I'll die is the fact I'm alive.
- denton-scratch 4y agoYeah, that only works well if I carry my fridge around with me! /s I could carry the note, of course; but the chances are I'd forget to pin it back on the fridge. Perhaps I should stick a colourful note to my fridge, saying "Paramedics: instructions in desk drawer".
- _qua 4y agoA living will is only as good as your designated power of attorney when push comes to shove. It’s just as important to have these discussions with you power of attorney repeatedly and in depth before the time comes.
- TomMasz 4y agoI had to make the decision to stop medical intervention and start palliative care for my 92-year-old father. He had developed an infection, exacerbated by poor circulation and a reluctance to seek medical care. He was hospitalized, given massive amounts of antibiotics, and rallied it a bit. They told us he might be able to go home if he could get around on his own. He was sent to a rehab center but soon declined without the hospital's level of care and was re-hospitalized. This happened a few times, the rally was less each time. Finally, it was impossible to ignore the reality of what was happening despite the doctors' willingness to keep going. He had explicit instructions regarding end-of-life care but my mom couldn't make the decision so I had to. The hospital set up a quiet private room for him and he slipped away quietly in the night before he could be moved to hospice. I totally understand families not wanting to give up but you have to ask "who are you doing it for, yourselves or them?"
- nradov 4y agoFrom what I've seen, the next-of-kin sometimes agree to overtreatment due to fear of criticism from other family members. Some random cousin will make accusations of giving up too soon. This kind of dispute destroys families.
- scarab92 4y agoFor sure. It's also hard to know what giving up too soon even is. The family making these decisions rarely have complete information about the situation, the options, the prospects, nor time to carefully consider these options.
- andromaton 4y agoMust read: Being Mortal Illness, Medicine and What Matters in the End (Atul Gawande). Summary: quality not quantity. It gave me hope while helping family members and hope for when it's my turn.
- voakbasda 4y agoThe cost of care at end of life is unsustainable in its current form. The graphs of average cost per patient as a function of age are all shaped like hockey sticks. As a civilization, we cannot afford to spend like this. It will catch up to us, and then everyone will suffer.
- fuzzfactor 4y agoThis is the time when all parties already do expect to expend more resources.
- cityzen 4y agoGreat book called The Conspiracy Against the Human Race: A Contrivance of Horror touches on this… the fact that everyone is so obsessed with keeping people alive whether the patient wants it or not. Some people may just want to die… and that’s ok.
- mumblemumble 4y agoA few years back, my partner and I made the decision to take our own child off of life support. We knew his death was inevitable for a good long while before the decision came, and still, it was excruciating. Not because we weren't ready to let go. We knew we would never be ready, so, in some grim way, that just wasn't a factor. No, what we came to realize is that it was because we somehow didn't feel we were at liberty to do so. Legally, sure. But it seemed like everyone around us was pushing us to fight fight fight, and, even in such an extreme situation, peer pressure is one of the most powerful forces in nature. But I also know that, when we finally did say the words, everyone on the care team took turns hugging us and reassuring us that we were making the right choice. I think, in retrospect, that it must have been terribly heartbreaking for them to watch our situation and know what we were thinking, and themselves not feel at liberty to give voice to what we all were thinking, too. We call them heroes for saving lives, and yet they are perhaps at their most heroic when they can't save a life, but still manage to go back to work the next day. Even more so now that it has become customary to remove the proverbial band-aid as slowly as possible. I think that our only real regret is that we didn't let him go sooner, and instead stupidly, futilely let things drag out long past the point where it could do him or anyone else any good. I think about that a lot, now. And I make sure that the people who might some day have to make end of life care decisions for me know how much I think about it. Perhaps, when the time comes, it will help to fractionally reduce the amount of anguish they experience as they take care of me. I certainly hope so. And I think that the time to talk to your loved ones about these things is now. It's comforting to think that end of life care only happens to old people, but it can happen to anyone at any age.
- chrisandchips 4y agoWow, thank you for sharing that. Most of us don’t like to discus death and we do our absolute best to pretend like it will never happen. It really pains me to read this and I hope you and your partner find some peace.
- magicalhippo 4y agoMy dad's cancer had spread to the lungs, and one day he got pneumonia. After a day at the hospital, he'd asked the doc if he'd ever get home again if he survived the pneumonia. Unlikely, was the reply. The next day he asked them to stop the oxygen supply, and he passed away some hours later. It was really hard losing him that abruptly, even though we knew it could happen. And at that time I was surprised they had done what he asked. I was under the impression they'd do anything to extend the life of the patient. But at the same time I was, and still am, so grateful that he got to make that choice, and not have to suffer for months in a hospital bed before reaching the same outcome.