10 ms·
Banks are not repaying victims of Zelle scams
- skyzyx 4y agoFor as bad as education is (talking mostly about the US), cybersecurity education is so much worse. Also, since our lawmakers are so far behind the curve on technology which impacts daily life (also talking mostly about the US), if you are not proactively learning about and defending yourself against cyber threats, absolutely nobody else is going to do that for you. Cybersecurity experts have failed to educate at least three solid generations of human life on earth. We can bitch and moan about this post all day long, but the root problem is the societal education problem.
- antony565 4y ago
- antony565 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kylehotchkiss 4y agoFinancial Security/responsibility is getting wayyy too complex for the layperson: * Find a decent bank with 2FA. None of the big banks are decent, they have minimum balances, piles of fees. Credit unions are good, but you want one that isn't too local, which can limit you to credit unions specific to military/veterans/families * Have multiple checking accounts. Only one of these checking accounts has a debit card attached, or exposed account number anywhere. Never ever hold a balance in this account. Keep the balance in the other account. * Never use that debit card for anything but the ATM and bank teller authentication. In fact, don't even carry it with you, in case you lose your wallet or somebody tries to take it. Not every bank makes it easy to turn debit card off. * Only use ACH for rent and loan payments. Never hold a balance in the account used for this. Many rent companies and loan providers are not properly securing that number. Your account number can't easily be changed. * Keep the bank you use a secret from everybody including friends and family. Only the few payees and your payroll provider need to know. * For sending money to friends if everybody has iPhones, Apple's Cash functionality is good enough. * Get a respectable credit card with zero fraud liability. Use it for everything. Have a backup at home. Now your bank is insulated from the outside world. If somebody tries to take your wallet, just give it to them. It's easier to get a card reissued and transactions overturned in that scenario than it is to get drivers licence replaced. * Don't move outside the country or do a USPS address change to a PO Box. Banks have been known to just shut people's accounts down and mail the balance as a check in these scenarios. Patriot act something something. This is banking in USA. It was designed for a trust-based society 70 years ago that's still mostly trustful but needs to consider the culture has changed a bit. If the Fed would require member banks implement secure 2FA and the option to disable external ACH from accounts upon request, we wouldn't need to do all this.
- hervature 4y ago> Find a decent bank with 2FA. None of the big banks are decent, they have minimum balances, piles of fees. Can you clarify this. Are big banks not secure enough or are they not decent because of the minimum balance and "piles of fees"? I would rather pay something for security.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- cowtools 4y agoBeyond 2FA, some type of chaumian cash like https://taler.net/en/ https://taler.net/en/ might help too. But the problem is really downgrade attacks. There are multiple payment systems (bank wire, check, credit card ) and if there is one insecure way to make payments, then the whole system is broken.
- bittercynic 4y ago>...you want one that isn't too local... What's the problem with local credit unions?
- bombcar 4y agoBiggest issue is accessing your account if you move; I've never really had any other issue come up.
- smeej 4y agoEven a tiny local credit union is great if they're part of the co-op. The vast majority of credit unions in the U.S. are, and you can use any co-op branch or ATMs just like your home credit union's branches or ATMs. It's brilliant, and in my experience, so much more accessible than the giant banks who are often regionally concentrated.
- _23sd 4y ago
- loeg 4y agoThe article and headline are somewhat in disagreement. Or at least, the headline is an over simplification. From the article, most rejected fraud claims are for cases where the victim was deceived (social engineering) into sending a Zelle transfer to a fraudster, rather than in cases of account takeover. In fact, the majority of the article is about Zelle, rather than takeovers.
- hgsgm 4y ago
- bombcar 4y agoBanks should obviously do their best to prevent and revert fraudulent behavior, but there are points past which they can't do anything without just refunding out of the goodness of their (perhaps cold and small) hearts. If I convince you to withdraw thousands of dollars in cash and then skip town with it, do we expect the bank to make you whole?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- wewtyflakes 4y agoI would expect the banks to talk to each other in good faith and reverse the transaction.
- NovemberWhiskey 4y agoPlease re-read the hypothetical - there is no second bank; it involves giving cash to a fraudster.
- gtowey 4y agoI think the issue is that without regulations forcing banks to serve customers better, they will simply abandon all responsibility completely because it's cheaper for them. And since we see that with Zelle, banks will collude to all hose customers in the same way, the free market is not a solution. It would be trivial for banks to give customers better fraud protection tools and enable better recovery, but they clearly don't care. * For one, since you can't have a bank account anonymously the receiving bank knows exactly who stole the money. They should at least be able to refer them for criminal investigation. * Two, since they own the machinery of transferring the money, yes they can easily reverse fraudulent transactions -- the bank doesn't have to take a loss since the fraudster has to have an account with them. They know who to take it back from. * The fraudster withdrew the money and ran? ACH transfers have always taken up to 15 days to "clear" -- banks wouldn't let you withdraw money you just deposited exactly for this reason, to verify that the sending bank actually has the funds and there are no issues. Why can't Zelle let the sender specify a "hold" period so there is time to dispute the transfer and the funds can be recovered? Basically is seems to me that a modern digital payment systems must have a kind of escrow service built in. IMHO this is what we need the law to require banks to do. In combination there needs to be a payment dispute resolution system which would probably take the form of a kind of arbitration system not unlike the role small claims court plays. This is something the banks should lobby the government to provide since doing it themselves would clearly get complicated and expensive.
- kelthuzad 4y ago> When U.S. consumers have their online bank accounts hijacked and plundered by hackers, U.S. financial institutions are legally obligated to reverse any unauthorized transactions as long as the victim reports the fraud in a timely manner. But new data released this week suggests that for some of the nation’s largest banks, reimbursing account takeover victims has become more the exception than the rule. I always knew that some of the pro arguments for centralized systems were suspect, but it's good to have some evidence for it now. Now I wonder how many other cases that are touted as arguments for centralized systems don't hold up to any scrutiny.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 4y agoThe banks aren't going to make you whole when withdraw a thousand bucks from the ATM and send it to someone. These denied refunds follow the same principle. There are warnings all over every zelle implementation I've used saying that using zelle is like using cash, don't send it to someone you don't know, etc. But people still do it anyways. Btw crypto is worse on this in every way and there is no system that actually solves this problem. I wonder if it is even possible to solve.
- criddell 4y agoIs Zelle really like using cash? It seems closer to an electronic transfer than withdrawing dollar bills. With cash they have no way to know what I'm doing with the money but with a transfer, they know a little bit more and so they have more responsibilities (IMHO).
- asdfasgasdgasdg 4y agoIt is the intentional decision of zelle to be like using cash in terms of rollback guarantees. This is so that payees can accept it like cash. There's no way to balance the scales -- the payment system that can be rolled back has its own issues.
- criddell 4y ago
- hayst4ck 4y agoFor any of the types of people who are against taxes and regulation, that type of policy results in a world where outcomes of disputes are able to be dictated solely on the basis of who has more power or resources. I'd rather live in a world where banks are solely responsible for fraudulent withdrawals than one where banks can shirk responsibility to their patrons. That is only possible through regulation. That's why it's important to vote for people who aren't afraid to create regulations, and that's why it's important to question people who claim that "the free market will eventually result in reasonable outcomes."
- bobkazamakis 4y agoCorrect but you've gotten off the subway at chud station and the MBAs are going to be seething
- daveslash 4y agoYes. I agree. I grew up in a household that was extremely "Free Market is the Best Market; Regulation is for commies and baddies". It's taken me a long time to heal from that. I still prefer as much free market as is reasonable, but my sense for what is and is not reasonable has shifted a ton. I'm now a big advocate for sensible regulation. (Most is sensible in intent, but sometimes non-SME write huge swaths and it gets botched). These days, my biggest complaint about regulation is that the right people (SMEs) aren't consulted as much as they should be.
- hayst4ck 4y ago"Some regulation is bad, therefore all regulation is bad." is what I grew up with too.
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 4y ago> ... who has more power or resources. I imagine it's been said before but I recently had the thought that murder being illegal is a regulation of the market. The point being that even the most staunch proponent of "free markets" is probably going to draw the line somewhere that defines a "not completely free market" which opens the door to questioning where the line should be drawn. I think that's always been the case but then you'll encounter arguments that something should not be regulated because the market should be free.
- commandlinefan 4y agoMan I hate this. I'm terrified of Zelle (and, even worse, Venmo). There's no reason at all to use these things - except that everybody around me insists on using them. My kids Venmo with their friends all the time. My wife and her friends Venmo constantly. More and more services won't even take a check, they'll only take Zelle or Venmo. And every time I use these fragile services I'm opening myself to having my entire bank account wiped out with little recourse. (And, of course, the people I owe money to like the lienholder on my car and my mortgage broker will sure as hell still expect their money).
- teeray 4y agoWould good opsec for these services be to open another checking account for them to limit the blast radius?
- loeg 4y ago> And every time I use these fragile services I'm opening myself to having my entire bank account wiped out with little recourse. No. Sending money with Zelle does not expose you to having your account wiped out. Receiving money, there is a minute chance a transfer might be reversed. But that’s all. Don’t use Zelle to accept payment for goods/services.
- bombcar 4y agoOne defense is to just have two banks, one for "real bills" and one for Zelle/Venmo "play money" bills. Then at worst you're out the play money. Make sure it's set so the real money can only push into the play money account.
- 5d8767c68926 4y agoHow do I lock down my "real" account? For instance, I want to disable the ability for anybody to pull money, and I must manually push into a billing account which only maintains limited funds. I briefly looked into this at one point and as best as I could tell, Chase would only let you disable ACH on business accounts.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- trothamel 4y agoI've always found the Mitchell and Webb take on identity theft/bank robbery to be a very interesting take on who's responsible: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CS9ptA3Ya9E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CS9ptA3Ya9E
- spaetzleesser 4y agoIt’s a stroke of genius how the banks managed to make the victims of bad security practice at banks responsible for these problems.
- shadowgovt 4y agoYes. We really let creditors hoodwink us when we let them invent the idea of "identity theft" instead of what it is: "You trusted some fraudster's claim they were who they said they were." One puts the onus on the defrauded company to fix their house; the other puts it on a third-party with no involvement in the transaction to... Make it harder? For strangers to lie and tell other strangers they are the person with the "stolen identity?" We could have drastically changed the landscape on this if the first time a company came after someone whose identity was stolen for money not paid the government had responded with not only a "no" but a fine for using the law to harass a stranger.
- factsarelolz 4y ago>We really let creditors hoodwink us when we let them invent the idea of "identity theft" instead of what it is: "You trusted some fraudster's claim they were who they said they were." This pissed me off so much. Victim blaming and they get away with it.
- drdec 4y agoIt's not victim blaming. They (the creditors) are the victims and they expect you to make them whole.
- shadowgovt 4y ago
- shadowgovt 4y agoOof, that's bad news. Banking access is not actually very particularly secure. The only thing that keeps banking practically secure is the banks reversing fraud when it's discovered and the government sending fraudsters to jail. If the banks don't hold up their end of the bargain, the system begins to collapse because they certainly aren't technologically secure enough to guarantee security of customers' money, which is one of the primary functions of a bank.
- notch656a 4y agoThat's the story of society in general. You can easily walk into many (most) people's houses between 10a-3pm weekdays and just take their shit. I'm sure one could make 6 figures doing that. Of course most of us don't because we don't want to harm others, and because of the consequences. You really just have to make it enough of a hassle for thieves that they pick the next easier thing to do. Not create Ft. Knox.
- Retric 4y agoI suspect it’s hard to actually consistently make 500$/day breaking into peoples homes. Most used things aren’t worth much and would be difficult to sell in bulk at anything close to what they cost. That’s why people steal catalytic converters etc.
- ragona 4y agoI bet it's easy to make $500/day briefly, and hard to sustain it. Catalytic converters have the benefit of not requiring you to break into someone's house where risk of being caught or harmed is way higher.
- bombcar 4y agoThe key is to make nothing for months and then make $90k in one go.
- to11mtm 4y ago
- factsarelolz 4y agoI recently hired a contractor to do landscaping. We’re talking multiple trees to take down, redoing multiple flower beds, mulch, rock and some sod. I was quoted at ~9k$. I paid half (4500$) via Square using my platinum credit card issued by my CU. I took a picture of his business license, insurance, and I ended up getting pics of trucks when I took before pictures. The crew came and worked one day. Maybe completed 30% of the work. For the next two weeks my calls and texts were dodged/unanswered/sent directly to voicemail. Finally I had enough. I called the police, did a police report. Called the CU explained what happened and was sent an email on how to open a fraud report. I submitted all the before pictures and the “after 30% of work” pictures. I sent the police report, and social media posts of people who claimed to have their money stolen by the same person / company. 3 weeks later I get an email that my claim was denied due to “lack of information.” I spent a total of 31 hours on the phone attempting to get someone to tell me what information I needed to send them or what information they found lacking. I got absolutely no where. No answers. No one from fraud department. No one cared at all. Just denied. So I went the other route, filed a claim in small claims court. I provided the judge everything I sent to the credit union. Judgement was in my favor. Now he owes me the $4500. How do I collect? I probably will never see the money. I can’t legally garnish any wages. So I’m out 4500. I couldn’t really do anything else to protect myself more. Navy Federal Credit Union. I’ve been a member since 1991. 30 years with a credit union. I am a military veteran. Hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of transactions have passed through my account. I’ve had multiple home, auto and personal loans. I’m still trying to get over it.
- mixmastamyk 4y agoChargeback.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- NovemberWhiskey 4y ago>So I went the other route, filed a claim in small claims court. I provided the judge everything I sent to the credit union. Judgement was in my favor. Now he owes me the $4500. How do I collect? I can’t legally garnish any wages. Where I live, after 30 days of the debtor failing to pay the judgment, you'd make an appointment with the sheriff, bring a check for $35 and they'd attempt to enforce it for you; including garnishing wages, seizing property (real or personal) etc etc. I'm not surprised you didn't get far with police reports and fraud filings: breach of contract is not necessarily fraud.
- maztaim 4y agoI prefer NCUA insured credit unions. Banks have been historically bad in so many ways to me personally as a young person just starting out in life. I am sure there are many that hit the famous $25.00 service fee that magically gets charged the day your account goes to $30.00, causing subsequent charges to hit your "overdraft protection" that allows the bank to penalize you $25 for every transaction that drops you below a zero balance for that day. You now owe hundreds of dollars. I also had a horrible experience with Citizens Bank, of which they allowed $5000 to be fraudulently withdrawn from my account in two days. The second $5000 was withdrawn after I was told it shouldn't happen again. That day I learned an ACH hold request is just that. A request that takes 3 days. I should have been smart enough to know that the support agent really meant for me to drop everything and immediately get to a physical branch where they could put an all hold on my accounts instantly, because I cannot do that over the phone. I don't mean to say credit unions are always better, but I will say, I have been getting 2% interest earnings on my savings and 1.05% on my checking account. Most banks typically give you only a percentage of a percentage point in interest for either...
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoUnsurprising. This is exactly why banks are so eager to come up with payment systems that go directly to/from bank accounts, as opposed to credit cards. It's also why I don't use Zelle or Venmo.
- silexia 4y agoFrauds and scams should be solved with heavy jail time or death and policing across borders.
- Animats 4y agoThis is why, in the US, you want to use a credit card, not Zelle, for anything which might require reversal. The terms for credit cards are set by Federal law, and they favor the cardholder. Terms for debit systems such as Zelle are more like handing cash to someone.
- jcadam 4y agoI have an Amex Platinum card and the few times I've disputed a charge they've usually found in favor of the merchant (particularly if the merchant is a large company). The one notable time they actually found in my favor and refunded me was a recurring charge I'd repeatedly tried to cancel with the merchant and eventually I threatened to close my account with Amex. "Oh, really? Alright, I want to close my account." "Oh, hold on sir, let me try again..." Effing $800/year in annual fees for this crap.
- silisili 4y agoAmex went down the tubes about 10 or so years ago. Their CS is terrible now. Prices went up, perks went down. The only card even worth entertaining is their blue cash, for 6% grocery.
- snotrockets 4y agoZelle is also covered by federal regulation (Reg E). Banks just would very much like you to ignore that.
- thewebcount 4y agoI actually sent a payment via Zelle yesterday and saw something new. This was a small payment to a family member that I send payments to regularly for some work they're doing for me. When I was choosing the recipient, it said something like "Money transfers that happen in seconds," implying they'd have the money almost instantly (and that does appear to have been the case in the past). After completing the transfer, it had a note below the resulting screen that said, "This transfer will take 1-3 days to complete." It did complete the next day, but it was the first time I've seen this sort of thing happen. I wonder if it was due to some new security check or something else? Anyone else see anything like this?
- cityzen 4y agoSame banks that make, literally, billions off overdraft and other fees? Shocking.
- diebeforei485 4y agoI feel like screen-sharing apps on phones are a part of this problem. Apple goes out of their way to make sure you can't record video off the Netflix app or other apps that play copyrighted media. However, as far as I can tell, they do not make similar safeguards available (optionally) for financial apps.
- jabroni_salad 4y agoisnt that more the app dev's responsibility? Neither of the banking apps on my phone permit screenshots or even show a preview in recents.
- diebeforei485 4y agoIs there an API an app can use for this? Out of curiosity what apps are those?
- jabroni_salad 4y agoPNC and Fidelity. I'm not a phone dev so I dont really know what APIs are available.
- baby 4y agoBut blockchain payments can’t be reversed! /s
- mensetmanusman 4y agoAs we age, the likelihood we get scammed approaches unity. Hopefully we figure this out some day…
- missedthecue 4y agoIf banks repaid scam victims, couldn't you game the system, fake getting scammed, and get reimbursed, doubling your money?
- cuteboy19 4y agoI don't understand how zelle can be so bad both from a usability and security perspective. It's designed to be the worst of both worlds