3 ms·
Wow. AFAIK, that's as strong a paper as you will get on the social sciences. With also as strong claims as you will get. The title is not the same as the paper
by marcosdumay 4y ago
Wow. AFAIK, that's as strong a paper as you will get on the social sciences. With also as strong claims as you will get.
The title is not the same as the paper's (for obvious reasons), and it's also wrong. The paper finds that the business people increase profits. More precisely, they are able to turn about half of the salary cuts into profits in a 5 years window. (There is no analysis of anything long term, except that employee turnover skyrockets.)
Of course, the always present disclaimer applies, that this is a single work, and any kind of certainty requires replication. But well, the claims aren't any extraordinary.
- Arrath 4y ago> More precisely, they are able to turn about half of the salary cuts into profits in a 5 years window. Isn't that just...how it works? If you now pay $x less, that $x doesn't leave the company accounts and is counted as pure profits? I've not yet had a chance to get into the article, but will soon.
- marcosdumay 4y ago> Isn't that just...how it works? Hum... No. They are saving $x, and getting $x/2 as extra profits. But anyway, management is supposed to impact a company's revenue. As a rule, profits and salary should be correlated.
- yamtaddle 4y agoCutting salaries or jobs can incur other costs. Lost productivity (worse morale, you fired the person who knew the thing and now everyone else has to try to figure it out, whatever), overtime pay for those who remain, that kind of thing. It's like if you're spending money on ineffective ads that only produce a return of 50% of what you put in. You notice this and stop the spending. You're only saving half your spending, because the other half was offset by the extra sales already. [EDIT] Point is, it's conceivable that cutting spending could, even, reduce profit—it's not a given that spending less means greater profit, and certainly not that it means greater profit in the amount of the cut spending.
- Arrath 4y agoRight, yeah, duh. I was thinking too abstractly as in "the perfect spherical cow salesman in a frictionless vacuum"
- dbingham 4y agoCan't read the paper, but the abstract seems to claim profits don't increase: > But consistent with our first set of results, these business managers show no greater ability to increase sales or profits in response to exporting opportunities.
- marcosdumay 4y agoProfits do not increase in response to exporting opportunities. Business people don't bring any market opportunity on average. Instead, they do increase solely as a consequence of salary cuts. (It's also not clear where the other half of the salary cuts ends up.)