3 ms·
I mean, there used to be assylums. Of course those had their own problems/abuses too (as the article points out). "including the right to avoid the consequence
by giantg2 4y ago
I mean, there used to be assylums. Of course those had their own problems/abuses too (as the article points out).
"including the right to avoid the consequences of their behavior."
To me, this reeks of bias. They don't avoid consequences. The consequences are different (secure psychiatric facility vs prison). The main point of the punishment for a crime is to prevent it from happening again (and Gove the victim closure/recourse within the confines of the law). Stick a psychotic person in prison, they likely will be even worse when they come out. At least with treatment there's a chance at recovery and prevention.
There needs to be a balance between mandating treatments and freedom. Can we mandate testing, treatment, and restrictions in freedoms for infectious diseases in the name of protecting society? It seems like there's a lot of conflicting precedent on that (STIs, vs covid, vs flu, etc).
Also, if the state institutions shut down so long ago, is there any background information on the increase in the mentally ill in prison and on the street? Is there an overall increase in mental illness, or just a distribution issue? Or could it even be diagnostic sensitivity or scope creep of the definitions (likely what the ACLU and others are truly worried about, in addition to the Minority Report-esque pre-crime element)?
- orwin 4y agoWhen my country started removing asylums, it created at the same times community and youth/family centers where you can get pre-checked with certified nurses and mediators (i used that personally), and hospitals working as asylums for long-term treatments, but not as cut of society as asylums were. We also have psychologists available at 'formation centers' (messed up traduction : basically institutes mandated to find adapted formations to people on benefits (or stuck after their useless math bachelor degree... Hey, that's me again!) Granted, we probably the worse country in the world for that to happen, because most low-level mental healthcare workers are taught a lot of fraudulent and pseudoscientific theories like Young archetypes and other post-freud shenanigans, but it seems we are somehow better at taking care of our people than the country where most cutting-edge theories and treatments come from.