8 ms·
IBM swallows Red Hat storage products
- LinuxBender 4y agoCeph is not becoming Spectrum Ceph. Along with ODF, it will remain 100 percent open source. IBM said it will assume Premier Sponsorship of the Ceph Foundation, whose members collaborate on the Ceph open source project. That is the key take-away for me that I hope remains true and does not go the route of Sequent. Should that be the case I also hope the Ceph Foundation keep Ceph alive and independent from IBM perhaps by forking it in the same manor that was done with MySQL (MariaDB and others) when Oracle acquired it.
- ThaDood 4y agoWhat would be the ramifications? IBM now has a forked version of ODF and Ceph with enterprise support? Ceph and ODF get abandoned?
- 0xF2 4y agoRed Hat Ceph Storage and ODF continue. The same team will continue to develop newer releases, now with dual IBM and RHT corporate access. Open Source commitment, upstream first, and foundation continue as before. I am a member of the team, and while we are certainly adjusting to the news, we are also pretty excited. Red Hat has been generous to Ceph, but it could not take Ceph beyond platform storage for OpenStack and Kubernetes — we want to reach for the full “Linux of Storage” original vision.
- jjtheblunt 4y agogo the route of Sequent?
- tyingq 4y agoMakes me curious what the internal politics is like. IBM does seem to have mostly let RedHat continue working as it did before, not meddling on a broad scale. Now we have some RedHat employees getting the news they are being transferred to an IBM area. I wonder how that's viewed from the RedHat side.
- capableweb 4y ago> Now we have some RedHat employees getting the news they are being transferred to an IBM area. I wonder how that's viewed from the RedHat side. Shocking absolutely no one. Every acquisition comes with the promise of "X will let Y operate exactly like it always has been, and we'll never steer their direction" and it has never been true.
- tyingq 4y agoIn this case, I had asked some RH folks about it when the acquisition happened. There was a lot of bravado that IBM would leave it be. This is small in relative terms, but appears to be the first crack. Thus, I'm curious if it's a hot topic there.
- jhickok 4y agoThis is for sure the biggest crack in the divide. Red Hatters have had multiple occasions for pause, however, beginning with IBM obtaining the list of Red Hat customers and trying to upsell OpenShift/IBM Software customers to Cloud Paks (IBM's embedded software solutions on OpenShift).
- stuff4ben 4y agoWhy would that give anyone pause? They're IBM customers now and it makes sense to sell as much as you can I would think.
- mogwire 4y agoWas it a crack when ACM came over from IBM to Red Hat? Or Hypershift came over from IBM to Red Hat? You align software to where it works best. IBM is better suited to develop and sell Software Defined Storage than Red Hat.
- tyingq 4y agoWell the presumption is that the culture at RedHat is preferable to the one at IBM. So, no, those two moves didn't cause me to wonder about whether those teams had concern about the move.
- Nexxius 4y agoThey'd best hope they aren't assigned to the games grid, I hear its pretty brutal.
- 0xbadcafebee 4y ago"NooBaa" ? The hell? Sounds like a magic spell to get rid of evil sheep. I would be embarrassed to put out press releases at RH about this thing. Ah, here we go... https://blog.noobaa.com/blog/the-noobaa-brand-brilliant-founderly-craftwork https://blog.noobaa.com/blog/the-noobaa-brand-brilliant-foun... "We did in fact have high hopes for words like “Nubes”, amazingly the latin word for cloud, also a play on words with “newb” reflecting our introduction of a new architecture for reliably retaining data. So then it’s time to lock in your domain name. GoDaddy had nubes.com on sale for $800, of course wayyy beyond the budget of this self-funded entrepreneur (and BTW still available. Fortunately GoDaddy’s algorithm sensed our cheapness, suggested alternative “NooBaa.com” for $3.99 per year, and the mouse went 'click! But....NooBaa didn’t mean anything. Nobody spelled it right. Everybody asked us what it means. We invented creative facts about African tribes. Then we observed that it’s attention-getting. It’s intriguing." It's baaaaaad. Technical founders are really a special bunch.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoFor some reason, technical founders (like me) really love Latin and Greek names for companies. It is such a trap: nobody knows what your company does just from the etymology, and literally all of the URLs for common Latin words are already registered.
- washadjeffmad 4y agoI'm certain many are very grateful they didn't lock down "Nubes" since it would definitely have ended up being conflated with a very different market in searches. It's almost the real life equivalent of Tobias Funke's "A Nu Start".
- trasz 4y agoWhich ones of the "swallowed" were not helloworldware/marketingware?
- trufas 4y agoCeph is the big one
- netfortius 4y agoI sure hope Ceph stays "untouched"
- Nursie 4y agoOh wow, an odd convergence of two of my IBM careers... Dennis Kennelly was in charge of the part of Tivoli I worked for for a while about 15 years ago and then about 7 years ago I consulted for a year with the Storwize storage folks... Well, it'll happen, unfortunately. Everything that Big Blue buys will eventually be assimilated. Unfortunately the next phase is usually a few years of tightening budgets, then beyond that 'buying another thing to replace it'.
- yourapostasy 4y agoBlue Washing never ceases to amuse me. > Unfortunately the next phase is usually a few years of tightening budgets... This happens because post-Blue Washing, execs want to quickly drive cash towards shareholders and bonuses towards themselves, and the easiest way to do that is to slash budgets. This translates into losing the best and brightest, and... > ...then beyond that 'buying another thing to replace it'. This doesn't happen at 1:1 product granularity as much as many think it does. It is more a big swap of strategic focus, which happens to include large, splashy purchases of other assets that gets lots of attention while existing steady revenue generators get metaphorically tossed aside if not budget-wise, then management focus-wise.
- spookierookie 4y agoSo it seems that the entrenched powers in IBM are winning over. Sad but expected TBH.
- supernovae 4y agonah. Storage will do better at IBM.
- nimbius 4y agochrist the IBM acquisition is turning out to be the WORST timeline. - Redhat kneecaps centos because some mid manager was worried he might not get this years bonus - Redhat kneecaps Ansible by making ansible-core and forcing everyone to re-install community plugins they were using from EPEL, or buy the shiny Redhat version of ansible. - Redhat decides to turn Ceph into yet another garbage storage product with the same exorbitant support fees and contract payments that were the original motivation for an open source storage solution in the first place. All this is being done under the guise that "oh its not proprietary, its enterprise grade now!" like the very same devsecops engineers and SRE's who made this shit work in the first place arent wholly capable of running it in production without forking over most of their $round of investment to the same company that turned softlayer into a swirling vortex of DDoS gangs spam relays and double extortion rings. to date it feels like all IBM wants to do with Redhat is turn it into IBM so if thtas all these juggernaut dinosaurs can do im quietly waiting to see Microsoft acquire Ubuntu and quietly turn it into a teams plugin the same way they acquired github and turned it into an outage response simulator for developers.
- zxspectrum1982 4y agoRed Hat Process Automation Manager and Decision Manager have also moved from RH to IBM recently https://access.redhat.com/articles/6968468 https://access.redhat.com/articles/6968468
- acomjean 4y agoI was at IBM (research) at the turn of the century after the Lotus acquisition. IBM was all in on Notes and I was developing notes applications for a department. (I actually came to appreciate Notes, and understand that Notes was being sold for mail, when mail is just another notes database, which is why it isn't great...) But it was clear later when I met from people from Lotus there was tension between the Lotus division which IBM had bought. The cultures didn't mesh well and they resented everything being IBMified. Though from the IBM side it seemed they really were all in on Notes. Really pushing it hard. Lotus's "smart suite" of desktop application not as much. Another friends company got bought by IBM a couple years ago. It seems they didn't really want it as they let half the people go (core people, not just overhead). Its kinda sad really. It seems its better after an acquisition to let the company keep doing what it was doing, with minimal changes (excepting removing the corporate overhead stuff).
- cptnapalm 4y agoSo the hope was that IBM would become Big Red, but instead we're getting Blue Hat.
- AtlasBarfed 4y agoRed hat was a THIRTY FOUR BILLION DOLLAR acquisition. For a company that dresses up free software for enterprises. No way Red Hat is staying like some gilded ivory tower of open source purity. They are a brand name for selling services and licenses, so if Red Hat still looks after ... wait that was only 3 years ago? Well anyway if Red Hat is still recognizable after that acquisition in some non-IBM way then IBM is showing enormous restraint. The previous 10 years at IBM were "buy company, attach Websphere to the front of their product names, sell, abandon product". Still better than Computer Associates software, but not much better.
- supernovae 4y agowe don’t sell licenses, we sell subscriptions :) IBM has left us alone. I don’t get paid by IBM, my benefits are Red Hat, My CEO is Red Hat’s CEO and funny enough when we work with IBM we lead the calls because IBM is letting us do what we do best. I could sense storage was changing. We had product delays, we kept pushing things out to future releases to expand ODF to our managed services. Evrything was always next quarter. Now it makes sense. I wouldn’t be surprised if Jboss is next.
- KaiserPro 4y agoIf you're going to buy storage from redhat/ibm you might as well skip all the pain and just use GPFS (which is currently branded as spectrum scale) Ceph is fine, but its a toy. You can slam hooks into everything, and the raid replacement (which is probably only allow on IBM tin, the bastards.) is brilliant. (rebuilding stuff doesn't take 24 hours) Want to have a global filsystem, no problem, want to mange wrote clashes? no problem, everything is based on rules. Want to have a storage array in the US, but a copy in the EU, no problems. just set your rules and you're away. and its all posix and really rather scalable.
- neverartful 4y ago"Ceph is fine, but its a toy." Because?
- KaiserPro 4y agoCeph started out as an object storage system with vaguely universal front end slammed on top. It is a good object store, but it's not a file system, and this shows. It has Forward Error Correction scheme that dealt with underlying hardware failure. so your blocks that you store are reasonably safe. But thats the point, its a blockstore/object store. Thats the easy part. allowing concurrent access to the same block, managing write clashes, decent cacheing are hard. Even harder when you are doing it with posix semantics. The main issue with Ceph is that the filesystem is an addon and required a huge amount of resources to make it work properly. (search out the ceph plan for gitlab, before they were bought out by a company that insisted on bringing in sysadmins to sort infra out) the big and largest elephant is that cephfs is still not really "stable" by that I mean supported fully by a large support company. This means that if something goes wrong, you need to figure it out yourself.
- yencabulator 4y ago> Ceph started out as an object storage system with vaguely universal front end slammed on top. The opposite. Ceph started out with the underlying load balancing algorithm (May 2004), then with the plan for the filesystem metadata management (Nov 2004). The block storage was created to support the filesystem, virtual block devices were an afterthought to enable private clouds, object storage was an afterthought in a world where S3 got popular. See https://www.ssrc.ucsc.edu/person/sage.html https://www.ssrc.ucsc.edu/person/sage.html for the chronological order. Of course, stabilizing the most complex part of the stack, depending on almost everything else already being stable (everything except RBD and the S3-compatible gateway, which both are relatively slim layers on top of RADOS), takes the longest. Meanwhile, business users were very keen on getting the benefits of RBD for "private clouds" and the object storage, so the filesystem was on the back burner. [Disclaimer: I worked on Ceph pre-RedHat]
- linuxftw 4y agoI've had the misfortune of using ceph both supported and unsupported. IMO, it's a nightmare to use, it constantly has problems, there's tons of bugs in every release. We're currently several releases behind because there's some kind of major problem with each of the newer versions. It's sad, because there's a lot of genius level people that work on Ceph. But the project as a whole is not high enough quality to be reliable. I imagine most people that work on ceph (eg, the code, not the rest of the org) will want to move to greener pastures soon. Anyone that wants to work for IBM pretty much already did.
- jandrusk 4y agoEverything IBM touches turns to shit.
- jjtheblunt 4y agoIBM touched the personal computer market in 1981, and here we are.
- qwertyuiop_ 4y ago> It's 10x cheaper to build your own infrastructure than use AWS on-demand instances It’s always cheaper on the bill of materials. Who is going to build and maintain the complex infrastructure. It would be interesting to see the TCO over 5 years.
- GekkePrutser 4y agoThis depends so much on your usecases. In our company it certainly is not cheaper. But what they do is ridiculous. They just moved from physical datacenters to AWS instances. Every "server" instance is running 24/7 independent of load, and you have to fill in an excel of 10 tabs to get permission to fire up an instance. In fact, the only thing they changed is the physical rack location tab to an AWS zone one :P So now we are "in the cloud" but we have almost none of the benefits said cloud offers. And we're using it in such an inefficient way that we're wasting money by the millions. And we kept all the internal overhead we already had when we managed the datacenters itself (that's what that excel is for). Once we actually start dynamically spinning up instances based on load and shutting them down when not needed, then yeah I could see it being cheaper than having a bunch of metal in a rack somewhere. But I guess we won't get there in the next 10 years or so. We'll probably be all-in on cloud by the time everyone has already gone on to edge computing or whatever the next big thing is, lol.
- qwertyuiop_ 4y agoMay I ask you what industry you are in ?
- GekkePrutser 4y agoManufacturing, multinational.
- mroche 4y agoIf anyone wants to read the Red Hat statement on the matter: https://www.redhat.com/en/blog/red-hat-storage-strategy-update https://www.redhat.com/en/blog/red-hat-storage-strategy-upda...