7 ms·
How does the Russo-Ukrainian War end?
- asdfqwertzxcv 4y agoInteresting analysis and a level headed reasoning about the nuclear threat potentially being overblown.
- iammjm 4y ago[flagged]
- cplusplusfellow 4y agoLegitimate question : how does the Russian regime meet the definition of fascism?
- warinukraine 4y agoLet's see the definition of fascism, from Wikipedia > Fascism is a far-right, authoritarian, ultranationalist political ideology and movement, characterized by a dictatorial leader, centralized autocracy, militarism, forcible suppression of opposition, belief in a natural social hierarchy, subordination of individual interests for the perceived good of the nation and race, and strong regimentation of society and the economy. So, except for "far right", the Russian regime meets ever point.
- AussieWog93 4y agoDefinitions aside, there is definitely a qualitative difference between Putin and Mussolini/Hitler.
- voltaireodactyl 4y agoThat may be so, but I do not find this difference to be as obvious as it is to you, and would hesitate before assuming it’s self evident. For example, I see very little difference in terms of character; the variations between essentially boil down to respective levels of access to effective weaponry, geographical access to their enemies, and specific “enemy” groups.
- simonh 4y agoHitler maybe, but I don't see all that much to separate Mussolini from Putin. As others have pointed out Putin doesn't have a personal political movement the same way, but that's really the only significant difference IMHO. I personally wouldn't describe it a fascism, but there's not a big difference. I can see where people who do call it fascism are coming from so I'm not inclined to quibble with them on it.
- poorlyknit 4y agoThere sure is, however "fascism" as a concept can be seperated from its instances.
- warinukraine 4y agoPutin isn't even in the same league as Mussolini and Hitler, and anyone who says otherwise is either ignorant or lying. However, there's a spectrum. And Putin is definitely farther along towards authoritarian than any present day liberal democracy.
- yetihehe 4y agoLet's see the definition of "far right" > [...] far-right politics now include neo-fascism, neo-Nazism, the Third Position, the alt-right, racial supremacism, National Bolshevism (culturally only) and other ideologies or organizations that feature aspects of authoritarian, ultra-nationalist, chauvinist, xenophobic, theocratic, racist, homophobic, transphobic, and/or reactionary views." Look like Russian regime meets that point too.
- parineum 4y agoI think it makes a lot more sense to just categorize them as authoritarian. The rest of those qualifications certainly exist in Russia but I don't think it's to the extent where it's a characteristic of the regime. Fascism seems to be a "I know it when I see it" thing and I just don't see Putin as any more than a strong man ala Saddam Hussein. Somehow I feel like somewhat of a cult of personality is a key aspect of fascism and an much more oppressive suppression of subversive ideas, more like North Korea. In Russia, we hear about Pussy Riot rather than them dissapearing before we do.
- yetihehe 4y ago> feel like somewhat of a cult of personality is a key aspect of fascism Hmm, there is definitely a cult of personality in Russia, but maybe not directly started by Putin, I think it's organic. Otherwise I fully agree with you, it's not really fascism because there is no "belief in a natural social hierarchy, subordination of individual interests for the perceived good of the nation and race, and strong regimentation of society and the economy." All those examples of "far-right politics" look very similar from my point of view, so I think it's normal for people to get confused to the detriment of discussion.
- floor2 4y agoOn the internet, it's impossible to know who is knowingly spreading propaganda and who actually believes what they're saying, but... does anyone actually believe that's a reasonable definition of "far right"? Like, this just reads like a "far left" person wrote a long list of negative slander to throw at their opponents. I don't think anyone on the right would agree with essentially any of it. The "ultra-nationalist" I guess maybe sort of works, if hyperbolic, in that I think you would get right-wing people to agree that they would prioritize their nation over others, but I think if you asked a random right-wing person on the street "do you support ____" for anything else on your list, they'd say no. I'm solidly on the left by contemporary American standards, but I just wish we'd actually have honest discussions about what people believe and want, rather than slinging insults that our opponents are evil, vile people who intentionally want bad things because they're bad.
- rvz 4y agoSo just more 'authoritarian' then.
- jonathanstrange 4y agoRead Umberto Eco's seminal essay [1], it contains 14 characteristics of fascism. They are what you'd call soft criteria, which make sense because fascism has always been ideologically and theoretically weak. It's explained in the essay. If you check Putin's regime and public statements by government officials against these points, you will find that all 14 characteristics are matched quite well. The only difference is that Putin did not have to found a movement to seize power, but you can see the corresponding elements in Kremlin-supported pro-Russian groups and parties outside of Russia. [1] https://sites.evergreen.edu/politicalshakespeares/wp-content/uploads/sites/226/2015/12/Eco-urfascism.pdf https://sites.evergreen.edu/politicalshakespeares/wp-content...
- DiogenesKynikos 4y agoIt doesn't. The word is being used as part of a general rhetorical escalation. That's why the word "genocide" is also being bandied about, as if Russian war crimes were comparable to the Holocaust. It's insane, but people with no historical knowledge fall for it.
- impendia 4y agoHere is an article laying out why some call Putin's actions a genocide (and why some don't). https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-61017352 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-61017352 No one is saying the situation is as bad as the Holocaust. However, among other war crimes, large numbers of Ukrainian children have allegedly been abducted and forcibly transported to Russia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allegations_of_child_abductions_in_the_2022_Russian_invasion_of_Ukraine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allegations_of_child_abduction... According to the United Nations, that is a form of genocide. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genocide_Convention https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genocide_Convention
- DiogenesKynikos 4y agoThis is a classic example of a Motte-and-Bailey argument. Everyone knows what "genocide" means. It means an attempt to murder an entire group of people. That's why the word ends in "-cide," like "homicide," "suicide," "regicide," "fratricide" and other words that have to do with killing. When you say that Russia is committing genocide, everyone thinks you're saying that Russia is attempting to kill every single person in Ukraine. That's what the word means in the English language, as understood by the gobal community of native speakers. The people using the word "genocide" are doing so precisely because the word has such a strong connotation. They want people to make the connection to the Holocaust, Rwanda, and other cases of mass murder of an entire people. However, that comparison is obviously absurd, because Russia isn't trying to wipe out the Ukrainian population. So when pressed, defenders of the use of the term "genocide" retreat to a much narrower argument. They argue that according to a particular reading of the Genocide Convention, Russian actions fall into some technical definition of "genocide" - a definition that has absolutely nothing to do with how normal people understand the term. Now, that reading of the Genocide Convention is an enormous stretch, but people who want to use the word "genocide" fall back to it. But of course, nobody is interested in a highly tendentious, dubious reading of the Genocide Convention. People are interested in whether Russia is committing "genocide" as the word is actually understood by real people. I'll also add that even going by the Genocide Convention, the claim that Russia is committing genocide is still absurd. I don't want to get into it in detail, because it's a technical argument that's unrelated to what people actually care about. However, I'll just point out that the Ukrainian government is claiming that literally every Ukrainian child in Russia is abducted. Anyone who knows anything about Ukraine and Russia knows how absurd that claim is. There are very tight familial connections between Russians and Ukrainians (they were part of the same country for most of the last 400 years, after all). Because of that, Russia is the #1 destination for Ukrainian refugees. A lot of people escaping the violence have gone to live with family in Russia. Using that to accuse Russia of genocide is a really bold rhetorical gambit.
- Bayart 4y agoI wouldn't exclude seeing something worse come out of Russia.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ChuckNorris89 4y agoRussian soldiers are lacking even basic supplies like winter clothing, boots and sleeping bags, let alone fancy stuff like radiation or chemical suits.
- type0 4y agoNot a problem for Russians, their commandeers will tell them to loot that from the local civilians. Radiation or chemical suits are hardly needed when they don't even have field medicine and don't collect wounded.
- yetihehe 4y agoThey apparently did collect soldiers irradiated after digging trenches in Chernobyl.
- hackandthink 4y agoSee also: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33101131 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33101131
- therealrealblah 4y agoPutin uses tactical nukes or a nuclear disaster to create a buffer zone in between his newly acquired territories and the rest of Ukraine. No nuclear retaliation will happen and if there is any retaliation on his newly acquired territories, he will nuke those too, to create an even bigger buffer zone. This was all about buffer zones and lack of missiles close to their border.
- dustymcp 4y agoThen the cat is out of the box and they will be the first ones to ever have done so, we simply dont know how that will play out, will Nato do nothing (i doubt that) or will they move into Ukraine and mop up all the russians, we dont know.
- the_gipsy 4y ago*since the nuking of japanese cities by the USA
- idontwantthis 4y agoThe “buffer zone” would be inside his own territories already because that’s where the front line is.
- jonathanstrange 4y agoThat would not work because it would render the newly acquired territories fairly useless (you can't sell radiated crops). Moreover, dropping one or two tactical nuclear bombs may not substantially change the situation on the battlefield. On the contrary, there are reasons to assume that with Western help Ukrainian troops could deal with the radiation hazards much better and with better equipment than Russia. Putin would end up having to nuke the new territories themselves if the Ukrainian army continues to advance. However, that's not realistic either. What's realistic is a sort of showing-off gesture, a nuclear attack on a city in Western Ukraine. The political consequences for Russia would devastating, though, and it would serve almost no military purpose.
- deleted 4y ago
- pvaldes 4y agoOne thing is sure. They will found more mass burials like those found in Lyman yesterday
- simonh 4y agoI can imagine Russia conducting as 'nuclear test' in or near Ukraine, but I think the consequences for Russia would be dire, and I hope the Russian leadership realise that. Ive been following the author's currently ongoing Yale course on the history of the Ukrainian state on youtube, it's excellent. The latest lecture dropped yesterday and I just finished it a few minutes ago, so it seems weird to see his name again here so soon. Here's a link to the first of them. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bJczLlwp-d8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bJczLlwp-d8
- scotty79 4y agoIt ends hopefully with Ukrainian and NATO forces parading on the Red Square to celebrate victory, denuclearization, demilitarization and denzification of Russia, prosecution of war criminals and internationally organized democratic elections to find new legitimate leadership for Russia and possibly regional referenda to find out which parts of Russia still want to be Russia. And of course Russian citizenship for every Ukrainian that would like to trade Ukrainian citizenship for Russian citizenship.
- DiogenesKynikos 4y agoThe war would go nuclear long before that ever happened.
- scotty79 4y agoIf all of the winning was done by Ukraine then Russia wouldn't know who to nuke efficiently and nuking itself or almost itselt (Ukraine) wouldn't stop the process of loosing and could even accelerate the process. Not to mention the fact that Russia probably is just as inept when it comes to maintenance of nuclear forces as it seems to be for conventional ones. And nuclear devices are very complex and precise.
- the_gipsy 4y ago...and to live happily ever after.
- nalaz 4y ago
- trasz 4y agoUkraine has no reason to invade Russia back. There is nothing of value there.
- scotty79 4y agoNot sure how and why this comment got duplicated but I encourage you to read the second version and my clarifications in response to similar concerns that are raised by other users in response to this comment.
- scotty79 4y agoIt ends hopefully with Ukrainian and NATO forces parading on the Red Square in Moscow to celebrate victory, denuclearization, demilitarization and denzification of Russia, prosecution of war criminals and internationally organized democratic elections to find new legitimate leadership for Russia and possibly regional referenda to find out which parts of Russia still want to be Russia. And of course Russian citizenship for every Ukrainian that would like to trade Ukrainian citizenship for Russian citizenship.
- simonh 4y agoRussian propagandists might say so in order to stir up anti-Ukrainian and anti-NATO sentiment, based on the narrative that this whole conflict was engineered by NATO in order to create a pretext to attack Russia, but it's absurd. It would also mean Putin and the pro-war faction in Russia were idiots manipulated by the west. NATO forces haven't fought in this war so there would be nothing for them to parade about. Ukraine has no interest in going further than the internationally recognised borders, and nothing to gain from doing so. There has never been any military threat against Russia itself, except for the harm Russia has foolishly exposed itself to by going to war.
- scotty79 4y agoI have exactly zero doubts that Russia incited this war. I just described my prefered ending of it. The parade is necessary because the lack of a parade after Russia lost the cold war was what created Putin. Just like the lack of a parade in Berlin after the WWI spawned Hitler decades later. Russians just didn't understand how hard they lost. On the parade I'd see NATO represented as it fought. So just few few officials and NATO equipment. Operated purely by Ukrainian soldiers. They might be NATO soldiers at this point or just soon to be NATO soldiers (as Ukraine should be admitted into NATO in a blink of an eye after the victory). I'm fully aware that this ending might not happen because Ukraine doesn't have much to gain from pushing Russian army to Moskov not just to the borders but one might be hopeful. This war showed that Russia is dangerously rotten and talking about military threat to Russia is completely out of place. It's a saying that a garbage dump might be threatened by a possible hostile takeover by Amazon. Getting in there would be a charity mission not a threat.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lakomen 4y ago[flagged]
- elzbardico 4y ago
- Huh1337 4y agoYou somehow forgot about this: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budapest_Memorandum https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budapest_Memorandum
- mquarks 4y agoWhat's worrying, even if Putin is removed from power, who's there to replace him that is fit for the job? Most if not all opposition has been either imprisoned or killed.
- chriselles 4y agoThis ends, or escalates further, with the use of nuclear weapons by Russia. People can debate all day on whether Putin is a genuinely and popularly elected President, a totalitarian dictator, or a mafia boss. But what’s not up for debate is Putin’s absolute consistency. Putin does what he says, and says what he does. If Putin threatens to use nuclear weapons, he likely will, the only debate is when. The real threat of Putin using nuclear weapons shouldn’t stop efforts to shape the desired end-state. A realistic hope may be HOW nuclear weapons are deployed. An atmospheric test display over remote Russsian territory that disrupts the test ban treaty and global markets suffer some temporary disruption. A high altitude atmospheric detonation over Ukraine that disrupts Ukrainian communications, western military support for Ukraine, and global markets suffer longer lasting disruption. A tactical nuclear weapon detonation over Ukrainian combat units that disrupts Ukrainian offensive, western military support for Ukraine, and global markets suffer lasting disruption. Western coalitions have disrupted the Russian economy with sanctions, but China/India provide two major energy export customers. The west is most prone to economic disruption in Q4 Oct-Dec. In consumer-led discretionary income dependent sectors, Q4 can be 50% of annual revenue with 25% of annual revenue coming from just mid-Nov to mid-Dec. If I was Putin I would create and amplify tension targeting western markets and consume sentiment from now until Mid-Dec. Personally, I don’t worry about a Cold War era Cuban Missile Crisis or 80’s Threads/Day After threat of total nuclear annihilation. But I do strongly believe we are at greater risk of a limited nuclear display or tactical detonation than at any time since August 1945. Ukrainian forces have a lot of offensive momentum and high morale, which leaves them vulnerable to hubris. I am sympathetic and in 100% agreement with Ukraine to defend its sovereignty. But Ukraine attempting to recover 100% of its pre-2014 territory will likely result in nuclear weapons being used. My hope it that such a nuclear exchange is limited and that the global economic impact is only 1-3x the ‘20-‘22 COVID disruption.
- simonh 4y ago>A tactical nuclear weapon detonation over Ukrainian combat units that disrupts Ukrainian offensive, western military support for Ukraine, and global markets suffer lasting disruption. A single tactical nuke would have virtually no impact on Ukrainian military operations. It would only affect a few square km, maybe a battalion strength unit. To decisively influence a significant front like Kherson would take at least a handful of them. To relieve pressure along the whole front would take dozens. Strategic warheads used on the front would do more, but then the radiation and fallout effects would also impact Russian units, and Russia itself. there's also no way to use and EMP pulse to impair Ukrainian front line units without also impairing Russian front line units. >Western coalitions have disrupted the Russian economy with sanctions, but China/India provide two major energy export customers. Using nukes would remove all the remaining support Russia has, including that from China and India in terms of trade. It's likely the west would impose a total blockade and interdiction of all Russian ports, sea traffic and air transport anyway.
- pjmlp 4y agoMost likely with the start of the end of modern civilization, hope it isn't that painful when it comes to be.
- aaron695 4y ago
- elzbardico 4y agoThe Royal United Services Institute wrote a nice little paper in mid-June 2022; it is NATO/US that has the insufficient productive (and logistic) capacity to match the Russian ‘operational tempo’. The paper is called “The Return of Industrial War,” and it’s quite good, as it befits a person in a ‘think tank’ founded by the Duke of Wellington in the 1830s. https://rusi.org/explore-our-research/publications/commentary/return-industrial-warfare https://rusi.org/explore-our-research/publications/commentar...
- shapefrog 4y agoNATO/US has the insufficient productive (and logistic) capacity to match the Russian ‘operational tempo’ who in turn has the insufficient productive (and logistic) capacity to match the Ukraine ‘operational tempo’.
- danielvf 4y agoThis article points to the threat to Putin from both pro-war social media leaders and from those in power with their own militaries. And shortly after this was published, security forces publicly (dramatically) arrested Wagner Group's social media guy, who would fit both criteria: https://twitter.com/igorsushko/status/1577797361014669313 https://twitter.com/igorsushko/status/1577797361014669313
- stevefan1999 4y agoI know this is gonna be controversal but technically speaking, there are no Russo-Ukrainian War, but Russo-Ukrainian Conflict since Russia did not declare war on Ukraine. It has a scale of a war but it is not officially a war yet.
- popilewiz 4y ago
- regularjack 4y agoSo you can murder someone, and say it wasn't murder, and then it's not murder?
- davidgh 4y agoIf it looks like a duck, swims like a duck, and quacks like a duck, then it probably is a duck.
- delta_p_delta_x 4y agoDuck-typing for a war.
- tpoacher 4y agoIt's a special ornithological operation
- cafard 4y agoIn how many of the US's armed conflicts was war declared? To the best of my recollection, the US never declared war against any Indian tribes, but spent more than a hundred years periodically fighting against them. Then there were overseas engagements. I have never heard the fighting in Korea called anything but "the Korean War", but at the time the US line was that it was "a police action". The US had a lot of troops in Vietnam and dropped plenty of bombs on the north, without ever declaring war.
- thesuperbigfrog 4y ago
- euroderf 4y agoThis article is a useful reminder that to understand what Russia will do, think less about our politics (like, how will we react to Russian action A or Russian action B) and think more about Russia's politics. Any Russian actor that has been cultivating an independent power center within Russia (e.g. Wagner) won't want to see it frittered it away in Ukraine. The 1990 revolution peeled away from the Russian imperium a thick layer of oppressed non-Russian nationalities. A springtime for sovereignty. A new Russian internal power struggle, occurring in conjunction with the crippling of Russia's armed forces, might (just) enable the peeling away of another layer of oppressed non-Russian nationalities from the Russian imperial core. 'Twould be something to see.
- Viliam1234 4y agoThe idea of all oppressed non-Russian nationalities leaving is... too good to be true, I guess, but a nice dream anyway.
- Balgair 4y agoThe article points to an idea I had not considered: That the reason we see so many ancient pieces of gear and vehicles in Ukraine is not entirely due to shortages and the kleptocracy. Rather that the various elements (Prigozhin, Kadyrov, army officers, etc) are intentionally holding back the good stuff for the eventual knife-fight for power after Vlad. If true, then the collapse of the Russian Federation is much further along than I had realized. I would have thought that these consolidation moves would occur in the spring after the last gasp of Russian offensive power had been exhausted. That they may have been occurring this whole summer points that Vlad's doom may occur before the end of the year.
- wooque 4y agoIn a nuclear war. Move away from Europe/USA/Russia while you have time.
- oliwarner 4y agoTo? The Middle East, China depend on the West. If they become unstable, stop producing, the whole world falls apart. South America is consistently on the brink of revolution, and Africa (broadly) crawls along on the coattails of China. I don't think there's safe refuge anywhere.
- kobalsky 4y ago> At first, no one could imagine that the Russo-Ukrainian war could begin if by no one you mean the layman. https://www.csis.org/analysis/russias-possible-invasion-ukraine https://www.csis.org/analysis/russias-possible-invasion-ukra...