7 ms·
> Konnech distributes and sells its proprietary PollChief software, which is an election worker management system that was utilized by the county in the last Ca
by ceejayoz 4y ago
> Konnech distributes and sells its proprietary PollChief software, which is an election worker management system that was utilized by the county in the last California election. The software assists with poll worker assignments, communications and payroll. PollChief requires that workers submit personal identifying information, which is retained by the Konnech.
I'm so very tired of proprietary software made by tiny little outfits being critical to elections.
- danielodievich 4y agoin my previous/previous/previous career I was heavily involved with various states election systems (juicily enough starting in hanging chads Florida). The field is full of tiny little outfits AND huge consultancies (Accenture in my personal example) doing stuff. The quality varies tremendously from amazing to amazingly atrocious. When I did all this work the cloud was not yet a big thing so no servers were provisioned in anything other than well known data centers, but it's you get what you pay for. Since it's secretaries of state paying for some, and then tons of random counties paying for some others, these are not incredibly lucrative contracts, and it does attract just random small software firms.
- pyuser583 4y agoIs “the cloud” really a good idea for high integrity software?
- hotpotamus 4y ago
- anonymousiam 4y agoFortunately, elections are managed by the states. Unfortunately, the Federal Government is trying to take them over. https://www.congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/senate-bill/2747 https://www.congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/senate-bill/274... https://www.congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/house-bill/1/text https://www.congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/house-bill/1/te...
- usernomdeguerre 4y agoThese seem to be altering rules around federal elections in particular. Can you detail where state elections are being 'taken over'?
- batch12 4y agoSome federal elections, like presidential elections are run by the states. With the current system, one doesn't vote directly for president, but instead who they would like their state (via the electoral college) to cast a vote for. As such they are state-run federal elections. Some people don't like this system. Not sure if this was where you were going with your comment. If not, my apologies.
- anonymousiam 4y agoPerhaps I wasn't clear enough. No elections are run by the Federal Government. They are all run by the states, per the US Constitution. The bills referenced above are "altering rules" as you put it, and that is a form of control.
- usernomdeguerre 4y agoHow does your statement align with the Constitution's Article 1 Section 4 which seems to explicitly allow for congress to alter federal rules at the federal level? "The Times, Places and Manner of holding Elections for Senators and Representatives, shall be prescribed in each State by the Legislature thereof; but the Congress may at any time by Law make or alter such Regulations, except as to the Places of chusing Senators."
- anon291 4y ago> "The Times, Places and Manner of holding Elections for Senators and Representatives, shall be prescribed in each State by the Legislature thereof; but the Congress may at any time by Law make or alter such Regulations, except as to the Places of chusing Senators Congress can regulate elections for representatives, but they cannot run them. The president or the executive of the federal government cannot run elections. Only state executives (governors, secretaries of state) can run an election. This is separation of powers.
- bushbaba 4y agoNational security wise better to avoid the risk of nation wide vote hacking by having many separate systems. Yes it increases the likelihood of a successful hacking event, but it decreases expected damage.
- bscphil 4y agoIf that was a concern, surely the only reasonable thing to do would be to move to a popular vote as soon as possible. As things stand, an entity that could reliably hack 2 or 3 states would have a better than even chance of controlling the election outcome.
- ejb999 4y agothat doesn't help at all, and in fact makes it worse - with a popular vote you can just hack one or two communities with very large populations (i.e. LA and NYC), and change or cast enough votes to cancel out about 30 other states in total.
- bscphil 4y agoYou can't trivially shift huge numbers of votes without getting caught. To get away with it, you'd have to shift small numbers of votes in specific locations. But with a popular votes, small numbers of votes don't make a difference. Reliably shifting 1% of the vote in Wisconsin, Michigan, Ohio, Arizona, would throw an election one way or another under the current system. Switching 1% of the vote in Los Angeles and New York wouldn't reliably change anything with a popular vote system.
- _-david-_ 4y agoThe most reliable way would be to do what some states used to do which is have the state legislatures vote instead of the individuals in the state. Dealing with a couple hundred (thousand?) people would be significantly more manageable than millions.
- bushbaba 4y ago
- ransom1538 4y agoThe feds are good at taxing and weapons. Anything else they screw up. Turns out you only need to be good at those two things anyway.
- pyuser583 4y agoThey’re not very good at taxing.
- cronix 4y agoThey do much better at taxing than collecting.
- basementcat 4y agoI never quite understood the "feds screw everything up" meme. It’s like a large company where are some incredibly talented people (NIST, NASA, etc) as well as some people who are "vested and rested". Unlike most large companies, policy makers are appointed every few years by shareholder vote, except each shareholder has the same voting power as every other shareholder and most shareholders decline to exercise their governance privileges. There is wide disagreement between factions of shareholders on the most appropriate policies so progress can sometimes appear slow and fitful.
- caycep 4y agorailing against the federal government in a response to an article saying a private company was at fault?
- hotpotamus 4y agoIf a private company can't do it, then what chance does the government have? I should also add, my comment about sarcasm should probably be taken into account.
- lern_too_spel 4y agoThey aren't run by the federal government. They are run by states and counties.
- adamrezich 4y agoI'm just tired of the rhetoric that 100% of such software is 100% unassailable and 100% utilized by 100% honest actors with 100% honest motives, 100% of the time, and anything else is a "conspiracy theory."
- zuminator 4y agoCan you point to a single person who has asserted even one prong of that supposed rhetoric? All anyone reasonable is saying, is if there's widespread or systemic wrongdoing, where's the evidence?
- narrator 4y agoSince you asked: http://www.hereistheevidence.com http://www.hereistheevidence.com Yup, this exact talking point has been made so many times in so many ways on so many forums that somebody made a site just to rebut it.
- woodruffw 4y agoMuch like lengthen-your-manhood.info, the domain name is not a seal of quality. In this case, the index appears to be a mash of conspiracy Twitter accounts, fringe blogs, and links to itself. Ho hum.
- batch12 4y ago~ $ whois lengthen-your-manhood.info Domain not found. YC23 anyone?
- narrator 4y agoMuch like cnn.com, the domain name is not a seal of quality. In this case, every source that has told you there was no fraud in the 2020 election appears to be a mash of conspiracy Twitter accounts, fringe blogs, or links to itself. Ho hum.
- 4y ago
- vkou 4y agoThis particular role of the software doesn't sound particularly critical, in the sense that if it caught fire tomorrow, elections would still happen in the same way, maybe with more human labour involved on the planning side. But sure, I agree that it's stupid to have every municipality and polity, down to the five mud farmers living in unincorporated East Mudsville, Nowhere figuring out how to do their elections in their own special way. Perhaps it would be good to look into how Elections Canada[1] does things? [1] It has the unfortunate side effect of providing federal oversight over elections, which is not something that republicans seem to be interested in this year.
- anon291 4y agoNo this is false. Imagine if tomorrow all GOP poll workers were 'dismissed' due to a technical glitch and lo and behold a democrat one a formerly red district. Or vice versa. This opens up the election to unnecessary allegations of fraud. Unnecessary because of how simple this is to manage.
- vkou 4y agoThen there would be procedures for redress and emergency injunctions that could be made, with enough time to do so.. The situation would have to be unfucked by hand. 'The computer said so' does not overturn election rules. This kind of scheduling is not critical, because it happens early enough that you can actually correct mistakes with it without compromising the election. That's the whole point of defense in depth. Compromising this layer does not actually break the system. Because any failures from it are both visible and redressable.
- anon291 4y agoIf we can do it by hand... then why not? This sort of thing just makes the elections seem haphazard.
- CobrastanJorji 4y agoI wonder what an ideal solution might look like. I kind of envision the Federal government funding a small organization overseeing an open source "election software" system, which would be run on some sort of well-defined stock hardware. The government would periodically pay for the hardware and software combination to be audited against a variety of attacks. The machines would produce standardized audit logs, published as openly as possible (someone smarter than me should figure out whether it's safe or good to publish the times or votes or the votes themselves. I'm leaning towards yes to both, but I'm concerned that you could figure out someone's vote if you knew the timestamps of the individual votes). Security researchers could purchase the hardware, install the software on it, and analyze it on their own. Then you'd do the same thing for the vote tabulators or whatever hardware and software exists asides from the voting machines themselves. Then I think about what might look like a nice halfway point. Voting machine software is still written by companies, but we require that all software running on a voting machine be published and hermetically reproducible. They don't have to take pull requests, they still own it, but we should be able to open one up and be 100% sure that the software running on it is exactly what they've documented.
- rgrieselhuber 4y agoPaper
- autoexec 4y agoPaper really is the best hardware platform for voting. Scantron results are nice because they are fast, so people can find out results quickly, but they are also able to be verified against the physical record which is far more important.
- pjmorris 4y agoPaper ballots counted in public is the strongest system we've found so far.
- hedora 4y agoIf you aren't convinced that paper is the right choice, look at exit poll vs official tally studies for US presidential elections starting in 2000. It turns out that the discrepancies are almost always in districts without paper trails, and always favor one party. Unsurprisingly, the discrepancies favor the party that keeps blocking federal voting machine standards.
- themitigating 4y agoIt's an HR system. Saying it's critical to elections is a manipulation technique to further other conspiracy theories that have no evidence