12 ms·
Commercial profitable nuclear fusion is a maybe by the end of the century. We really need to get nuclear fission capacity built out ASAP if we're serious about
by vlovich123 4y ago
Commercial profitable nuclear fusion is a maybe by the end of the century. We really need to get nuclear fission capacity built out ASAP if we're serious about global warming and the overall health of the planet. Renewables just won't get us there.
Moreover, we need to overbuild the amount of clean energy produced to the point where we can waste it on energy inefficient processes for carbon recapture that we know work. Fusion is important in terms of helping this to continue to scale / make it even more economical / reduce nuclear waste and weapons concerns. Ultimately though, it's an iterative step over fission for the problems the most urgent ecological problems the world is facing.
EDIT: Did some back of the envelope math. Nuclear energy is worst case ~ $200 USD / MWh. At 2,400 kWh/tCO2 for direct air capture, that's $14 trillion USD or ~16% of the world's GDP that would instantly get us to net 0 yearly emissions. We'd need to invest more than that to start reducing carbon levels. This wouldn't recover things since damage is already done in many places (e.g. coral reef deaths) but it would arrest the worsening of issues. Additionally, this has knock on effects that improves the economy overall (weaker storms = less money recovering from disasters).
- bpodgursky 4y agoDo you have any concept of how far away the end of the century is? That's 80 years. Think back to 1942. It's ridiculously arrogant to make predictions like this.
- vlovich123 4y agoThe most optimistic estimates by the commercial companies working in this space is the first commercial reactors coming online around ~2050. It takes time to build these reactors and integrate them into the existing power systems. I may have misstated my position which is that I don't think fusion will make up any meaningful part of power by the end of the century. The reason is a) requires fundamental engineering and materials breakthroughs b) funding for it is a pitiful amount compared to what it probably needs c) it's competing with other cheaper energy sources d) we don't have any net positive energy reactors yet. The basis of that prediction is just looking at how long it took fission to take off and there it was being driven by military needs (submarines) and not civilian.
- denton-scratch 4y ago> and there it was being driven by military needs (submarines) and not civilian. I'm surprised that support for fusion isn't part of US DoD policy; abundant, cheap, clean energy would be a huge military asset. Those explosives zooming back and forth in Ukraine are really just energy balls.
- ncmncm 4y agoThe necessarily super-expensive fusion would be a strict liability. It will, in consequence, not be built. All work toward that is pure waste. The DoD does spend a great deal of our tax money on fusion, but not for "abundant cheap clean energy". It is, rather, for uses like what is occurring in Ukraine: death and destruction; and for vaporizing cities and ports, distributing radioactive fallout over wide areas.
- tsimionescu 4y agoFusion would in no possible world be cheap. Whatever else they would be, fusion reactors will be the most expensive structures per unit of volume built by man.
- denton-scratch 4y agoWell, I guess I was talking about running costs. Pardon me if I'm talking out of my ass, but this is what I tought: * The main input to a fusion reactor is electrical power. * The main output of a fusion reactor is even more power. So that seems to me to mean that once you've incurred the capital cost, the machine produces free energy. My reasoning sounds naive and simplistic, because I don't know what I'm talking about. But what's wrong with my reasoning?
- ncmncm 4y ago1. A fusion plant would be extremely expensive to build. The most optimistic estimates are 10x per GW vs. fission. But we really don't know how to build one; nobody has identified a material that would work. 2. It is extremely expensive to operate. The most optimistic estimates are >10x fission. A thousand tons of lithium "blanket" would have to be sifted daily to get a few grams of tritium for the next day's operation. Nobody knows how this could be done. 3. It destroys itself with neutron irradiation in only a few years. At best, major parts of the structure would have to be replaced using robots because of the extreme radiation in the parts being replaced. Similarly, for repairs. Nobody has built such robots, so they are custom one-offs. The fuel cost of fission is a negligible part of its cost. The fuel cost of a fusion plant would be negligible, assuming enough tritium could be obtained at all. The ITER project expects to run out and does not know where they will get enough for future experimentation. Nothing about fusion is free, or even affordable.
- coldtea 4y agoYou could say it for 800 A.D. or 1200 A.D. too, and yet 880 A.D or 1280 A.D. wouldn't look too different. In fact, you could say it for 300 B.C. and 1300 A.D. - a whole millenium away - would still be quite similar technologically. Not all periods have 1942-2022 amount of innovation. In fact 1942-2022 is itself bimodal and front-loaded. By 1980 already most major innovation had already happened. The rest is mostly efficiency improvements and diminishing returns, but much much much less major inventions.
- m463 4y agoin 1942 there were no nuclear (fission) power plants, yet today there is probably one within driving distance of your house. additionally there are natural fission nuclear reactors that have been going for possibly billions of years... and one big fusion one within visual range :)
- ncmncm 4y agoThere are no natural fission reactors operating on Earth, and have not been any for billions of years.
- antonvs 4y agoIt's not arrogant at all, it's a rational, evidence-based prediction. I recommend https://thebulletin.org/2018/02/iter-is-a-showcase-for-the-drawbacks-of-fusion-energy/ https://thebulletin.org/2018/02/iter-is-a-showcase-for-the-d... for an initial introduction to why the idea of fusion by the end of the century is only a "maybe". As a sort of representative summary of the situation, the ITER project has been in progress since 1988 - 34 years - and hasn't yet achieved fusion for more than about 5 seconds. On top of that, by design, it will never be net energy positive - the tens of billions of dollars and decades spent on it are purely to produce a proof of concept for sustaining a fusion reaction. Turning that into something that can actually act as a source of energy is currently still at the "unsolved problem" stage. We can't even write a project plan for how a viable reactor could be developed, because we simply don't know. As such, there's no realistic scenario in which this situation somehow turns into viable fusion power before the end of the century, short of an unexpected major breakthrough. While such a breakthrough is conceivable, it's not something you can base a strategy on. The responsible position is to recognize that we can't rely on anything useful happening in fusion in this century. One other point about the "think back to 1942" comment is that extrapolation only works when you have relevant data points to extrapolate. The technological advances since 1942 have been nothing like the advances needed to exploit fusion. Fusion involves literally recreating the conditions in the heart of a star, but without the enormous mass of a star to provide the necessary pressure. There's no precedent for this in our technological history. Nuclear fission was trivial by comparison - nature does all the real work, all you have to do is arrange the fissile material appropriately. That's not the case for fusion. It's an incredible achievement that we can produce a fusion reaction for 5 seconds, but there's no guarantee that we're going to be able to turn this into something that can be sustained day in, day out, and that generates more energy than it consumes.
- kbelder 4y ago>I recommend https://thebulletin.org/2018/02/iter-is-a-showcase-for-the-d https://thebulletin.org/2018/02/iter-is-a-showcase-for-the-d... for an initial introduction to why the idea of fusion by the end of the century is only a "maybe". Sure, if you acknowledge that fusion in twenty years is also a "maybe". If you can't, then you're not handling your probability distributions properly.
- reidacdc 4y agoI've seen the scenario you describe as the "fission bridge to fusion" scenario, and as I understand it, a major problem is that it can't be done with existing pressurized light-water reactors. These systems just don't use Uranium very efficiently, they extract a small percentage of the energy from the fuel, and then need to be refueled. This doesn't mean the "fission bridge to fusion" is impossible by any means, but it does mean that significant work needs to be done in developing and commercializing next-generation fission reactors, including breeder reactors, which use much more of the available energy from fuel, and possibly novel reactor designs that can run on reprocessed fuel from LWRs. A political complication is that large-scale commercial nuclear fuel reprocessing represents a nuclear-weapons proliferation risk, and so might imply regulatory burdens, or require international agreements on use and control before it can go forward. Refs: Dim recollection from reading Walter C. Patterson's "Nuclear Power", and some discussion about peak Uranium (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peak_uranium https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peak_uranium).
- aidenn0 4y agoMy understanding is that breeder reactors are politically problematic because of proliferation concerns.
- Manuel_D 4y agoReprocessing increases net efficiency considerably [1]. Few people do it since uranium is very cheap relative to the amount of energy extracted from it, even without reprocessing. But if fuel ever becomes constrained, reprocessing would become competitive. Nuclear weapons proliferation isn't a risk among most countries that have nuclear generation programs. Heck, most of them already have nuclear weapons. The rest can contract out reprocessing to nuclear-armed countries. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_reprocessing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_reprocessing
- jhallenworld 4y agoAlso there are "near-breeder" CANDU heavy water moderated reactors: they are a proven technology that exists today and can use non-enriched uranium. They also in theory can use a plutonium/thorium mixture, so can burn thorium. They are cheaper as far as fuel, but it turns out that fuel didn't become as expensive as anticipated in the 1970s (when it was thought that there would be 1000s of reactors). They are physically larger, so have a higher construction cost that put them at a disadvantage compared to conventional LWRs. The tritium needed for fusion reactors comes from these CANDU reactors (some of the deuterium from the heavy water is converted to tritium, it is collected).
- fallingknife 4y agoNuclear is great as baseload, but it is more expensive than wind/solar when you just look at pure generation without storage. So we definitely need to get nuclear built out, but you want as much cheap renewables as you can get the grid to support, and as little expensive nuclear as possible. And it's not what you would use for CO2 capture. For that you would use renewables, because it doesn't matter what time of the day you do it, or for how long you do it continuously. So just direct excess renewable power into CO2 capture.
- vlovich123 4y agoThe problem with renewables is one of space and materials rather than energy production. Nuclear is drastically smaller in terms of the land footprint. Focusing on cost is misleading because the costs are because we haven’t invested in fission in many decades / regulations are fairly insane. For example, the cost argument would go the other way in the 90s when wind and solar were much more expensive. Also, solar provide energy when there’s typically peak demand so you can’t really load shift for DAC. Wind you might be able to do that.
- ncmncm 4y agoThere is in fact no problem of "footprint" of renewables for nukes to pretend to solve.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hackeraccount 4y agohttps://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2021-energy-land-use-economy/ https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2021-energy-land-use-econ... It seems like you need a fair amount of land devoted to wind or solar to go carbon neutral. Presumably much of this is dual use?
- ncmncm 4y ago
- greenthrow 4y agoNuclear takes way, way too long to get online to help with global warming. Renewables absolutely can and are "getting us there." It's a solved problem. Fusion is always some long period of time away. It is not close to being a viable source of power, and there are convincing arguments it never will be. And regardless, why do we need to waste so much money trying to turn into a viable source of power when we have solar and wind now and they are cheaper than any other form of power? By all means keep researching fusion for scientific reasons, but enough with the empty promises about it being the ultimate power source. And fission can die off as the existing reactors reach the end of their lives. It is too expensive, too environmentally dangerous and totally unnecessary.
- Raydovsky 4y agoRenewables are a solved problem, but storage of energy to combat the unreliability of renewables isn't. NPP's take about 7 years to build. The latest EPR builds are taking more due to an over complicated design.
- ncmncm 4y agoStorage is not, in fact, a problem. Numerous methods using century-old tech are cheap and practical, and only need to be built out. They are not being built out yet because there is not excess renewable generating capacity to charge them from.
- vlovich123 4y agoRenewables have yet to demonstrate the ability to replace fossil fuels in any meaningful way. They seem to top out at 10-20% of the energy mix. France achieved net 0 many decades ago because they went all in with nuclear whereas their neighbors that went with renewables haven’t gotten anywhere close to that. The best time to plant a tree is 20 years ago. The second best time is now.
- dieortin 4y agoFrance hasn’t achieved net 0, not even close. And there are several countries with more than 20% renewable energy in their grid.
- brightball 4y agoI’m curious about facilities like the one in NJ that produce power by burning trash. I wonder how viable they would be on a larger scale.
- ramesh31 4y ago> I’m curious about facilities like the one in NJ that produce power by burning trash. I wonder how viable they would be on a larger scale. Incinerating already sequestered carbon via burning hydrocarbons is a path to nowhere. It’s a profitable business for sure, but so is mining coal.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- godelski 4y agoBecause of comments below, I want to piggyback here. Climate is a pretty complicated topic that is often vastly overly simplified. To the point where major mistakes are made. Remember, first (and even second) order approximations are only useful in limited regimes. If you're in the camp of "net negative, regardless of costs" then it is silly to ignore nuclear. But people seem to confuse this as "nuclear VS renewables." We should ABSOLUTELY build as much renewable energy as possible. The issue is that the world/country/states aren't homogeneous. For example, Southern California and the entire Southwest probably needs little to zero nuclear power. There's more than enough sun and wind year around to exceed demand. But this isn't true everywhere. Where this isn't true (and where there isn't hydro availability) nuclear is a great option and it is silly to discard it as an option. You also can't just transport energy across the country without significant losses and drawbacks (e.g.s energy security, reduced priority). So I want to make it clear that you can think nuclear is expensive and too slow but still be in this camp. This camp is just believes that you shouldn't remove a zero carbon emitter from the table. Why tie a hand behind your back? You don't have to use that hand, but it may come in handy every once in awhile. As to carbon capture, again this is a complicated topic. Often it is overly simplified into "plant more trees." But we just can't plant enough trees and the scientific consensus is that this won't get us there. There's also plenty of natural ways to reduce carbon. Land management is broad term usually used. But soil restoration, bogs, and swamps are far less sexy than forests (which when young are actually carbon emitters). DCC still has a long way to go too, but again, why turn away from it? Use every tool at hand. Especially because we have to remember that zero emissions typically means "zero energy emissions" and that doesn't solve the other half of the problem that we have. I know everyone is passionate about this subject (I am too) but I also encourage everyone to recognize that we have more similarities and differences. We are mostly arguing about the most efficient way to reach the goal, but mind you that if we fight too much others can use this to divide us and make us overall less efficient. Complex problems require complex solutions. Very few people here are experts in climate and if you ever talk to climate scientists they will happily tell you that their expertise is limited to their niche. It is too complex of a problem for a singular person to understand. So let's keep that in mind when we're arguing with one another. It is good to have arguments and discussions, but turning into fights is unproductive and just demonstrates how naive we all are. I'll bastardize a Feynman quote: "I think I can safely say that no one understands Climate Change."
- bulbosaur123 4y ago>Commercial profitable nuclear fusion is a maybe by the end of the century. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GD8EdXuU9Ms https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GD8EdXuU9Ms 10-20 years max. Deep Mind will work on it.
- ncmncm 4y agoWill you believe Deep Mind when it tells you it cannot work?
- paulcole 4y ago> if we're serious about global warming and the overall health of the planet There’s a saying that when someone shows you who they are, believe them. It’s pretty clear that “we” as humanity are not serious about global warming and the overall health of the planet. Some of us are making gobs of money and think we’ll just be able to buy our kids the same great life we’ve had. Some of us are complacent and don’t worry too much about the future. Some of us are so desperate to survive today that we can’t think about tomorrow. Some of us realize it’s a lost cause. “Fixing” global warming just isn’t going to happen. We spent the money we didn’t have over the past few decades and the bill is coming due soon. At this point it’s all about how we cope with a world that’s going to be unimaginable to many of the people alive today.
- Apocryphon 4y ago> “Fixing” global warming just isn’t going to happen. There will be likely last-ditch efforts from desperate governments and technocratic industrialists to do geoengineering, with all of the expense and potential blowback that entails.
- paulcole 4y agoSome attempt to darken the skies probably won’t happen in my lifetime but I sure wouldn’t want to be alive in 200 years.
- Apocryphon 4y agoMaybe the O’Neill colonies will be ready by then.
- tsjackson 4y agoThere's a weird sociological phenomenon where people declare that "renewables won't get us there" without any real justification. A recently announced deal in California would build out solar for $20/MWh compared to your $200/MWh nuclear worst case. Renewables can and will get us 90% of the way there. I recognize that a renewables based grid will require massive investments in grid infrastructure, which are long overdue anyway, as well as eventually storage/batteries, which is still on an exponential cost reduction curve. Bbut given the massive cost difference of generation, that would still be a dramatic net benefit. Particularly when nuclear plants take a decade to build compared to a year for a solar plant. I get that nuclear is cool, particularly fusion, but I really don't understand this "renewables won't get us there" argument beyond that.
- nerbert 4y agoSeems like in 2022 renewables are getting us there: https://ember-climate.org/insights/research/global-electricity-mid-year-insights-2022/ https://ember-climate.org/insights/research/global-electrici...
- elevaet 4y ago> +389 Change in global electricity demand (TWh) > +416 Change in renewable generation (TWh) > +5 Change in fossil generation (TWh) I'm confused by this, it doesn't add up: change in renewables + fossil generation = +421TWh, so why does it say +389TWh for change in global electricity demand? Is 32TWh just going to waste?
- confidantlake 4y agoMaybe a third category (perhaps nuclear) went down? Just speculating, it isn't very clear.
- lm28469 4y agoAre they ? Seems like we're using just as much fossil fuel as previously, which is still waaaaaay too much for any kind of sustainability As always the rebound effect is kicking our ass, instead of producing the same and polluting less we pollute the same and produce more
- Gatsky 4y agoMmm I think renewables could cover it without the need for fusion. I think there is one potentially big issue with renewables though. The supply chain for panels, wind turbines and batteries involves China quite heavily.* This year has been a hard lesson in the essentiality of energy security. Depending on what plays out geopolitically, renewables could suffer from deglobalisation and increasing hostility between superpowers. The low cost per MW of renewables obviously makes some supply chain assumptions. * This issue also pertains to fossil fuels, particularly gas infrastructure. I also think that it is worth noting that renewables are a peaceful and ubiquitous energy source. Successful fusion would carry significant military advantages, which may cause a lot of disruption depending on who gets it first. This is always the way when someone develops a denser energy source.
- renewiltord 4y agoTakes too long. Remember it takes decades to build 1.7 miles of track. Renewables' innovation is in being small repeatable project.
- Euphorbium 4y agoYou will never overshoot production, if crypto mining can waste any amount of energy.