8 ms·
90% of US adults say the United States is experiencing a mental health crisis
- Bostonian 4y agoThe word "crisis" is overused. It is supposed to refer an urgent problem, not a chronic one such as the prevalence of mental illness.
- incomingpain 4y ago>The word "crisis" is overused. It is supposed to refer an urgent problem, not a chronic one such as the prevalence of mental illness. I feel like crisis is fair here. The 90% figure is quite shocking of a number until you realize it's CNN. It's not news though. https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/70/wr/mm7013e2.htm https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/70/wr/mm7013e2.htm Everyone knew lockdowns would cause this situation. The big question is how to deal with it. If you were emperor of your country, ordering or making mental health support free may be a long term excellent choice but there isn't the ability to handle it. There are not enough professionals to handle the demand. Even prior to covid, we had mental health awareness campaigns with significant consequences in convincing people they have mental health issues when they in reality did not. So the already scarce resource was already stretched beyond the limit. So we have reached a crisis point where people aren't able to get the help they need: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2847360/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2847360/
- autoexec 4y ago> Everyone knew lockdowns would cause this situation. Lockdowns didn't help, but they were just a small part of a very large collection of stressors covid brought the world which itself was just a small part of a larger ongoing breakdown of systems people have come to depend on for generations. Even if covid hadn't happened we'd be facing a mental health crisis right now.
- throwaway743 4y agoWord. They're using it to catch eyes for ads. Just like they do with "breaking news". It's overkill.
- amanaplanacanal 4y agoI think the crisis is not just the prevalence of mental illness, but the paucity of mental health care resources.
- Normille 4y agoThe other 10% said "I'm the Emperor Napoleon. I don't do surveys!"
- marginalia_nu 4y agoIt's usually 4%. https://slatestarcodex.com/2013/04/12/noisy-poll-results-and-reptilian-muslim-climatologists-from-mars/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2013/04/12/noisy-poll-results-and...
- aliswe 4y agoWhat kind of a headline is this? 90% of US adults say they are experiencing a mental health crisis? no! 90% of US adult say that the country is experiencing a mental health crisis. Why not ask experts instead???
- Slow_Hand 4y agoThat was my immediate thought as well. Most US adults are not experts on anyone’s mental health but their own and thus unsuited to comment on trends. When did the gut feelings of individuals about such matters become a stand-in for news reporting? I know journalists are also susceptible to writing about domains they don’t truly understand, but this kind of reporting is skipping right past the step of trying to engage with experts and proceeding to poll unqualified individuals about their gut feeling.
- klyrs 4y ago> Why not ask experts instead??? Because this is a story about public perception. While you may find it alarmist, a plain reading suggests that the people surveyed are alarmed.
- tanseydavid 4y agoRather than focus on the correctness (or incorrectness) of what 90% of US adults say or think about this matter -- why not notice how unusual it is for this many US adults to share a viewpoint? They might not be correct, but the fact that so many see it in the same way suggests to me that there is probably something worth examining more deeply.
- klondike_ 4y agoUnfortunately mental health services were gutted in the 1980s with little objection. There are few options for patients that require long term care. The community health services that were supposed to replace the asylums of old never materialized.
- everybodyknows 4y ago> community health services Was that Reagan's campaign line, to rationalize the money grab? Can anyone fill in the history here?
- derbOac 4y agoThe community mental health services movement actually started in the 60s, and coincided with a deinstitutionalization movement that you can tie to general social progressive policies during that time (civil rights etc). The idea (rightly so imho) was to destigmatize mental health, and to move to a model of reintegration, and not route people into institutionalization where they couldn't get out. This model declined during the 80s, and to a lesser extent 90s, for many many reasons. One is defunding, so you ended up in a situation where the institutions closed, but then as part of general government defunding (ala Reagan and post-Reagan trends), the community mental health services closed. Another issue that's probably less apparent is the neo-Kraepelinian movement in psychiatry that started in the 70s and accelerated during the 80s kind of was at odds with with the community services model. It allowed for treatments (think antipsychotics) that allowed people to leave institutions, but I think boxed in thinking about psychiatric care during subsequent decades. "Psychopathology as a medical illness" when it works in extreme cases is good at getting people out of residential institutions, but then is bound to a hospital-patient model that the US isn't very good at getting out of. So at the same time psychiatry was succeeding at getting people out of institutions through a biomedical model of psychiatry, it was kind of failing by neglecting the sociocultural side of psychiatry. So people get out of institutions because of effective medications, but then when they're out there, they're tied to hospitals for care and not community centers as they were originally envisioned. Basically, community-based care works, but requires a certain amount of infrastructure like anything, and it's been neglected to some extent because of biases in the healthcare system. It's also difficult once you recognize that psychiatric difficulties are bound up in very big socioeconomic structural issues that require a lot of political will to change, and if you don't, it incentivizes a head-in-the-sand kind of reaction. I wouldn't be surprised if there was a return to interest in these kinds of decentralized care models for various reasons in the coming decades, but it's hard to say. I think it's unfair to tie community mental health service trends to Reagan in particular, but I do think to the extent you attribute certain trends in public and government service funding to Reagan, it's accurate to say that Reagan-era trends were one contributor to problems. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3266763/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3266763/
- jasfi 4y agoHow can a mental health startup (non-profit or not) create revenue, reach a lot of people and not charge people too much money? From what I've seen, paid-for apps/SaaS is basically the only way to go. Unless you depend on donations, which seems like wishful thinking. There's B2B as well, but I think people without work need help the most.
- prewett 4y agoI don't think a mental health startup would be effective, revenue or no. Individual problems require customized help. Some things can only be addressed one person at a time.
- popularonion 4y ago“If you're not a part of the solution, there's good money to be made in prolonging the problem."
- nradov 4y agoThere are several mental health startups which connect individual patients to therapists. They provide the technology platform for finding a compatible therapist, online therapy sessions, and billing.
- tmpz22 4y ago> How can a mental health startup (non-profit or not) create revenue, reach a lot of people and not charge people too much money? By not taking VC money such that they exist to pay back their initial investors.
- bobkazamakis 4y ago>How can a mental health startup (non-profit or not) create revenue, reach a lot of people and not charge people too much money? How can the United States continue to pay more per capita for healthcare than any other nation in the world? hmmmmmm... maybe healthcare has direct consequences on our economic health.
- autoexec 4y ago
- ryandrake 4y agoJust like people's incorrect perception of crime: that it seems like it's going up while we are at historic lows, I wonder how much of this perception is just that mental health problems are more visible now. Homelessness (correlated with mental health trouble) is much more visible and in your face now. Social media has given everyone a megaphone, so the few crazies can now be as loud as they want and algorithmically drown out sensibility. You can go browse r/PublicFreakout and other "crazy videos" subreddits and watch unhinged people for hours. Political rhetoric paints "the other side" as insane rather than simply as opponents with differing views. All this combines to give the perception of a crisis, just like endless, breathless reporting about crime gives the perception that criminality is out of control.
- smt88 4y agoI take your point, but a lot of people are worn out from the pandemic, increasingly hopeless about climate change, and observing the decline of democracy in almost every influential country. Those are all justifiable things to be more depressed about now than people were in the past. People are smarter, wealthier, and more educated now than they were in the past, and that causes them to think further into the future (which is depressing).
- md2020 4y agoAs a 20-something, I see a lot of people my age that way, way overestimate the negative impacts of climate change, to the point where they admonish and make fun of people who want to have kids. I can’t help but think their media diet is somewhat to blame. Climate change is not going to be good, but there is good news on the technology front that you’d almost never hear if you got all your news from the big news outlets. For example, the IEA predictions for new solar additions have been terribly out of touch with reality for nearly a decade now [1], and before I saw this all I had seen was doom and gloom about how we could never scale up renewables fast enough. Seeing even the IEA be so wrong really makes me wonder what other good news I’m missing out on seeing. [1] https://www.visualcapitalist.com/experts-bad-forecasting-solar/ https://www.visualcapitalist.com/experts-bad-forecasting-sol...
- aaroninsf 4y ago[flagged]
- patrickthebold 4y agoI hate stats like this. What is the baseline? Maybe 90% of adults have always said the US is experiencing a mental health crisis. I'm interpreting this as some kind of increase because of COVID and social media and cell phones, but maybe the number is always high.
- nonch0n 4y agoI like how the nearly the same top comment, almost word-for-word, was posted in the recent thread called '50% of CEOs considering layoffs'... too many posts with numberspin lately.
- iinnPP 4y agoMy new personal favorite headline/intro (I have only ever heard it): "SCARY SOUNDING GOV'T AGENCY declined to comment on X" I heard this and read all the video comments (all 1000+). Not a single mention of the language. There is a serious problem here and it needs some rather forceful correction.
- systemvoltage 4y agoWe need a definition of 'mental health' first. Accurate, precise, quantitative and testable definition.
- righttoolforjob 4y ago[flagged]
- timcavel 4y ago
- paxys 4y agoI'd wager 90% of adults would say that at any point in history. There has never been a time and place where the average adult wouldn't go "everyone around me is crazy".
- oldsklgdfth 4y agoAs someone that struggles with stability regularly, I am concerned by this trend. Sure there are elements of our society that are adding stresses we did not have before. I'm not against that. The main concern I have is this becoming a fad and people become less resilient as a result.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rfwhyte 4y agoThe US, along with the rest of the world has a capitalism crisis, the mental health issues are just a symptom of the root disease. People broadly speaking, need connection and meaning in their lives, and the capitalist systems most of us are slaves to does not even come close to providing it. Heck it actively seeks to avoid providing those things, as if people had them they might not need / want to work so damn much. When your choices are spend 60+ hours a week working at one or more jobs where you could be laid off at a moments notice to protect the "Profits" of the already wealthy, or you know just fucking starve, it's no wonder so many people are stressed and depressed. The world these days for a heck of a lot of people is like an automatic hamster wheel that keeps spinning faster and faster, and if you can't keep up you die. Sounds like a surefire recipe for a "Mental health crisis" to me...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI think it is more of a consumerism crisis than a capitalism crisis. Like you said people need meaningful connections in their lives. This largely comes from interactions with your community. The average American watches 20 plus hours of television a week. I don't know how much doom scrolling and solitary gaming adds on top of this. Imagine how much happier they would be if they spent this time building and maintaining relationships with other human beings. If you look at the numbers for how many hours a week people work, they haven't really changed much over time. I think the big change is how people are spending their free time
- ryfia 4y agoNews outlets calling it a "mental health crisis" is just sleigh-of-hand, obscuring the root causes. It's natural to feel more stressed, anxious, or depressed if you're losing hope in life due to inflation, lagging pay, expensive healthcare, sky-high real estate costs, etc. Not to mention the general greedy nickel-and-diming that is present from most corporations, hedge funds, investors -- all of these small cuts and bruises add up to a very wounded animal. I recently read a NYT opinion piece that very eloquently laid out this idea: https://www.nytimes.com/2022/09/20/opinion/us-mental-health-politics.html https://www.nytimes.com/2022/09/20/opinion/us-mental-health-... Btw one favorite quote from that NYT article: > If someone is driving through a crowd, running people over, the smart move is not to declare an epidemic of people suffering from Got Run Over by a Car Syndrome and go searching for the underlying biological mechanism that must be causing it. You have to treat the very real suffering that is happening in the bodies of the people affected, obviously, but the key point is this: You’re going to have to stop the guy running over people with the car.
- kjs3 4y agoWhile I don't doubt many people are feeling this way, I can't shake the knee-jerk that these days we couldn't get 90% of US adults to agree the the sky is up.
- tanseydavid 4y ago"I like to think of the world-at-large as an Open Air Mental Institution. This helps me to see where I can be of assistance -- particularly to the other patients." - Les Visible (paraphrased)